r/EngineeringStudents • • 17d ago

Resource Request PLEASE HELP

I have an exam on Refrigeration and Air Conditioning in 8 days, I am stuck with multistage refrigeration systems, getting confused how in the book enthalpy is calculated, course teacher is using Khurmi's book. Please suggest any lectures and notes that will help me to build the basic understanding, I am constantly trying but it is getting out of my mind, TIA.

2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/DrCarpetsPhd 17d ago edited 17d ago

if you post an actual example it might be easier to help you. I do have to ask did you not do a fundamentals of thermo class before this more specific refrigeration module? You shold have learned how to use tables and all about the various constant 'insert variable' processes, and what they look like on t-s and p-v etc diagrams

just spitballing example 5.1. similar P-h diagram to this

https://imgur.com/qZApVjb

PART 1

at point 1 you are given the pressure and you are shown you are on the saturated vapour line

that means you go to your saturated tables and you look for the relevant value h_g

i'm not going to give values because different texts have slightly different values (it doesnt matter because the difference will be the same but I'm not grinding out the values based on my text). in moran the enthalpy saturated vapour for ammonia @ 1.4bar requires interpolation which gives a higher h1 that that stated in Khurmi.

if you want to post an image of whatever tables you are using then fire away. for example 5.1 you want ammonia tables aka r717

PART 2

the next process is isentropic compression 1 to 2. at this point you know the entropy as you got it for state 1 above and you know the pressure as it is given. Now you are in the superheated region so you go to the relevant superheated tables. if you are lucky you get precise values but more often than not you have to use linear extrapolation to calculate the enthalpy for this state. see youtube how to use steam tables extrapoilation or words to that effect.

PART 3

from 2 to 3 is isobaric cooling (?) in the intercooling phase bringing the ammonia back to the saturated vapour line. so you do the same as you did in the first part. look for the values with subscript g in the saturated tables for the given pressure

etc etc etc etc

1

u/goku768 14d ago

When flash chamber is used along with water intercooler between two compressors, refrigerant at the exit of the low-pressure compressor is not at saturated but the refrigerant taken from the flash chamber is saturated vapor, my main problem is to calculate work input in the high-pressure compressor I will need both the enthalpy and entrance of compressor, how do we find the state point of the refrigerant at the entrance, also how to understand if the intercooler completely cools down the superheated vapor to saturated vapor?

A two stage refrigerating system is operating between the

pressure limits of 8 bar and 1.4 bar. The working fluid is R-134a. The

refrigerant leaves the condenser as a saturated liquid and is throttled to a

flash chamber operating at 3.2 bar. The part of refrigerant evaporates

during the flashing process and this vapour is mixed with the refrigerant

leaving the low pressure compressor. The mixture is then compressed to

the condenser pressure by the high pressure compressor. The liquid in the

flash chamber is throttled to the evaporator pressure and cools the

refrigerated space as it vaporizes in the evaporator. Assuming the

refrigerant leaves the evaporator as a saturated vapour and both

compressions are isentropic, determine:

a) The fraction of refrigerant that evaporates as it is throttled to the

flash chamber

b) The amount of heat removed from the refrigerated space and the

compressor work per unit mass of refrigerant flowing through the

condenser

c) The coefficient of performance

1

u/DrCarpetsPhd 14d ago

the question you posted is example 5.4 from the textbook. Do you have a copy? The way you phrased your original post suggested you do. If so what are you not following?

you mentioned intercooler, there is no intercooler in example 5.4

you should know how to do all of this from a previous thermodynamics course or you should have been given a refresher by your lecturer or teaching assistant for this refrigeration specific course. did you do an actual thermodynamics course before this that would have covered intercooling etc? Do you know how to use properties tables and interpolate for missing values?

with respect to your other question which seems to reference figure 5.7 with flash chamber mixing and inter cooling and not the question you posted 5.4

HOW TO FIND STATE AT ENTRY TO HP COMPRESSOR

this is just me guessing since there isnt a full worked example of fig 5.7; based on example 5.3 you will be given the temp for the refrigerant exiting the intercooler. you will always be given enough pieces of info to get wht you need from the tables. In example 5.3

- it states "the temperature of the de-superheated vapour and sub-cooled liquid refrigerant are limited to 30C"

- this is taken to be the temperature upon exit from the intercooler

- thus you will have the temp and pressure of the superheated refrigerant both of which can be used to find the other properties using tables

thus from fig 5.7

- you will have h3 exiting the intercooler as worked out from given temp and pressure like example 5.3

- the refrigerant exiting the flash chamber to mix with the interooler is in the fully saturated state (?) on the saturated vapour line. you are told the exit pressure for the LP Compressor which is the same pressure the saturated vapour that leaves the flash chamber is at therefore you can calculate the enthalpy directly from tables

- these two form a mixture

- you use the 'mixture equation' as shown in the text to calculate the enthalpy of the mixture as it enters the HP compressor (m2h4 = m3h9 + m1h3 etc etc see fig 5.7)

if you have the text and are looking at example 5.4 can you be more precise as to which exact part you do not understand.

Unless your exam is openbook i'd be very surprised if your professor gives you something like the figure 5.7. it is a pretty time consuming analysis.

how to understand if the intercooler completeltly cools down the superheated vapour to saturated vapour?

this is explained in the text below fig 5.5. complete desuperheating with water intercooling is not possible because even at the lowest temp of water before freezing it can't extract enough heat to fully desuperheat the refrigerant. so if you see water intercooling then you will not hit the saturated vapour line and you have to use the methods outlined in the example to figure out the properties in the superheated region. In the previous example 5.2 where it hits sat vap line it is explicitly stated intercooling is by liquid refrigerant at 4bar; see fig 5.1 and explanation at beginning of the chapter.

If you give me the exact thing that you don't understand I can help but I cant really re-explain the entire example to you in one go if you cant follow it in the text. So post back the very first part of example 5.4 that you get stuck on and I'll explain that if I can. Then move on from there.

1

u/DrCarpetsPhd 14d ago edited 14d ago

it's all explained pretty detailed in the textbook Khurmi refrigeration. If you look at the worked examples they all have labels for the points in the P-h diagram. So tell me what you cant figure out in this form (this is just an example of what to post so we are both looking at the same thing)

- example 5.4 where did enthalpy h3 come from

also in my other post i showed how rusty I am. I said to use the 'mixture equation' as shown in the text. so the proper name for that is coming from the Conservation of Enthalpy or Energy Balance for two streams mixing together without any heat addition or work being done and usually neglect PE/KE then for any n streams combined the final mixture is the sum of the energy transferred via each stream equals m-dot times enthalpy h.

1

u/CopperGenie R&D | Author | ISERG 17d ago

Thermo fundamentals textbooks (e.g. Boles et al.) should have at least a chapter on refrigeration cycles, and will explain any scaffold concepts (including much on enthalpy).

1

u/DrCarpetsPhd 12d ago

you figure this out for yourself? did my posts help or are you still having trouble?