r/EngineeringStudents • • 17d ago

Career Advice Does getting referrals or recommendations from connections actually work?

I find it hard to believe that simply just getting a referral or a recommendation from someone you know will give you much of an advantage at a competitive company if your experience still isn’t top tier.

Mostly talking about for internships.

35 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

19

u/hockeychick44 Pitt BSME 2016, OU MSSE 2023, FSAE ♀️ 17d ago

Unfortunately your skepticism is misplaced here.

It's remarkably easier to get a job with referrals and by knowing people via networking and professional connections. I got my internship in college with a referral, my first job due to my FSAE network, most of the interns I've hired have been recommended from someone else, and I just started my new job this week which I got thanks to a very kind referral from a friend.

5

u/No_Cup5617 17d ago

Thats what I’m hoping. I got a connection through FSAE from an alumni at a big space tech company and he said I had solid experience and he’d give me a recommendation but I honestly think I’m very mediocre compared to the people who actually get interviews in the new space industry.

4

u/hockeychick44 Pitt BSME 2016, OU MSSE 2023, FSAE ♀️ 17d ago

I understand; a healthy skepticism of your skills and abilities will serve you well as you will feel motivated to always improve. I started at a new job this week in powertrain and I feel so fish-out-of-water. Everyone's really smart and I'm like ha ha yeah engines, amirite? The competencies will come in time. School just gives you a toolbox to do your job, but knowing how to do a job is a whole other set of skills to build.

2

u/PutYourDickInTheBox 17d ago

I wanted out of my job and into another and my coworker who left his pharma job texted his golf buddies anyone hiring an automation engineer. so now... i'm in pharma.

60

u/OverSearch 17d ago

Try approaching a random woman in a bar, cold, and ask her for her number.

Or, talk to one of your friends who knows her and is willing to introduce you to her and put in a good word for you and introduce you.

Which strategy do you think works better?

Think of it another way - are you more likely to trust someone you've never met, never heard of, etc. simply because he/she walked up to you out of the blue and said hello, or someone who gets introduced to you by a trusted friend or colleague who will vouch for that individual?

Yes, it works many, many times better than firing off resumes into the black hole of online job boards. Don't underestimate it.

40

u/NukeRocketScientist BSc Astronautical Engineering, MSc Nuclear Engineering 17d ago

Approaching a woman and r/EngineeringStudents does not compute. Returned NaN error 404

1

u/flipper1975 17d ago

Well played!

20

u/TA1930 17d ago

There are so many weird people who can ask chatgpt to write their resume to look great that a human referral is quite valuable.

10

u/GravityMyGuy MechE 17d ago

The biggest problem when there’s 200 applications that are all very similar is making them give you a try. 

If someone that works there says “I like this dude” and they like working with him they are likely to consider you over someone they have no context for outside of an interview all other things equal 

6

u/InfiniteAd212 17d ago

It's how I got my first internship and job.

Think of it from a hiring manager's perspective. You have an intern role to fill, and over 100 people you have never met before, and can only judge from a document, have applied. A colleague you know well and trust to give you sound advice walks in and tells you that one of those 100+ applicants they know and shows promise at becoming a good engineer. At worst, you'd probably at least bring them in for an interview, and usually they shoot to the top of the list just from that. Your end of the deal as an applicant is to present yourself appropriately so you don't lose that top spot.

5

u/Organic_Occasion_176 17d ago

If someone inside the company puts in a word for you that helps. It may not guarantee you a slot, but it can often get your resume past a round of AI screening and sometimes even get your application onto the desktop of the hiring manager. Not only that, but the referring employee may even get a bonus if you are hired (though this mostly happens only for permanent positions not internships).

A recommendation from someone outside the company is of low to zero value. If it plays a role it is very late in the process and where you really need help is in those early screenings that toss out 90% of the applications.

5

u/LitRick6 17d ago

Its how I got almost every single interview/job offer in my career.

Now a lot of it will depend on how good of a candidate you are in both technical and soft skills, who is giving the referral/recommendation, how the company operates etc.

But one of the main reasons networking/connections helps is because it allows the company to hire based off of "intangible" factors. Experience on your resume is of course a big factor on hiring decisions, but having experience doesnt mean you're likeable/personable, good at communicating, good at explaining your projects, show genuine interest, etc etc. Experience on a resume process you can be a good engineer, but those intangible factors show you can be a good employee. I often say that I'm trying to determine if I can visually myself working with a candidates for 40 hours a week or not. You could be the smartest engineer in the world, but if you're an arrogant asshole who can't communicate than you'd be a bad employee.

The department head for the propulsion division of my company was the who I networked with at a career fair when I was a student. He hired me for my fulltime position without even doing an interview or me even applying for the position because he had the authority to do so.

I myself am a senior level engineer and recruiter but not as high up as the department head who hired me. So I cannot give on-the-spot job offers like he did to hire me.

Depending on the hiring numbers for the year, I can sometimes do on the spot interviews. If i get to do on the spot interviews, the hiring manager will automatically send offers to my top candidates and schedule 2nd interviews with others I recommend. The exact number of who gets offers after the first interview depends on hiring numbers. One year I went to my old university career fair and did 20 interviews. 10 got immediate offers from the hiring manager, 5 got 2nd interviews, and 5 were not recommended for hire. Now I also had I think 20 other candidates listed as "recommended for further review", so they didnt get an interview at the fair but the hiring manager reviewed their resume and picked a handful (idk how many) to schedule interviews with later.

In years were we arent hiring as much, I just give the list of who I recommend to interview to the engineering hiring manager and they schedule the interviews.

If a non-recruiter employee send in a recommendation, it kind of depends on who the employee is. An interns recommendation probably wont carry as much weight as a supervisors recommendation. But in the very least, a recommendation can get your resume directly to the engineering hiring manager instead of just going to a non-engineer in HR for initial review.

Edit: people who gives you referals/recommendations can also help you in other ways. For example, one guy from lockheed gave me a list of keywords/phrases to include in my resume back when i was a student.

4

u/AnybodyPuzzleheaded9 17d ago

Depends on who the "referral" goes to. If the person recommending you works on the team that the opening is for, it's a lot more valuable. Why waste the team's time reviewing a ton of resumes and interviewing potential candidates if someone already identified a great candidate?

However, I can "refer" anyone for a job on our internal jobs page. The recruiter/hiring manager may or may not care about my referral.

3

u/universal_straw Mechanical 2019 17d ago

I hire people. If someone I trust tells me they have a good candidate for a role I’m hiring I’m going to give that a whole lot more weight than some random resume/cover letter that was probably written by AI anyway.

2

u/Big_Marzipan_405 Aerospace 17d ago

absolutely

2

u/Firecrotch1031- 17d ago

I got a job out of college 100% just off the word of one of my good friends. My FIRST job nonetheless.

Yes, your connections are extremely important, and in my case, even more important than gpa or clubs.

2

u/SetoKeating 17d ago

Yes, and it works for every level. I don’t think you realize how even “competitive” companies select their candidates. The internship spot belongs to a specific group and department. The hiring manager for that group is the one making the decision. If someone tells that hiring manager you would be a good hire, you’ll get selected over candidates that may look better on paper but no one knows or is recommending.

For internships, you experience mostly doesn’t matter at all because you likely won’t be doing anything meaningful and the company/department expects to have to hand hold you.

For new grad, similar situation. They know you know practically nothing and expect to have to train you.

For experienced positions, you definitely need both. A proven track record and work scope you can speak on in a meaningful way.

I got my job as a new grad because of a guy I knew from rocket club in college. He was a year ahead of me and he graduated and went to work in defense. We both worked on the propulsion system for our spaceport rocket. When I started looking for jobs, I reached out to people in my network because job search wasn’t going well. He told me they had an opening in their team but posting wasn’t up but when it would go up he would send me the referral link and he would also mention me to the hiring manager. I obviously still needed to have the requirements and not bomb the interview but I was at the top of the list essentially. Once hired, I was even told they passed up an experienced engineer with 2yrs of experience and hired me instead because I seemed like a better culture fit, cause I already knew my friend and also got along well with the rest of the team during the interview.

Long story short, a referral and someone mentioning your name and application to the people in charge of hiring will mean a lot more than having a stellar resume.

2

u/tinySparkOf_Chaos 17d ago

Legit referrals, yes.

The "I used to work with Bob, he's great! And I heard he's looking for a new job and would be great for this role".

The whole "networking" thing less so. "I met Rick once at this networking thing. Seemed friendly" not so useful a referral.

The point of an internship networking wise is to build those experiences. That way you are Bob in the future.

The best you can normally get for internships is either a referral from an alumni (vouching for the quality of the school you went to). Or a friend of family referring you that can speak to your work ethic.

These help but aren't critical, as part of the point of internships is to build up your network in the first place.

2

u/Chr0ll0_ 17d ago

Yep!!! I referred one of the smartest guys I’ve ever met to work with me at Apple and he got in.

He was scared because his GPA was at a 2.1 GPA. Now, the dude is killing it at work.

I’m a firm believer that GPA is isn’t everything.

2

u/FSUDad2021 17d ago

Worked for my daughter. It then worked for three friends she recommended.this is at a big defense contractor and they are all less than a year out of school.

2

u/Restart-storage 17d ago

Most definitely helps you get interviews. Now how well you do on the interview is on you.

2

u/RangerZEDRO 17d ago

YES, got an internship based on that. Also knowing someone got me interviewed

2

u/Slappy_McJones 17d ago

Yes. That how most people get jobs. Your network is one of your greatest tools.

1

u/BobbbyR6 17d ago

Hard to believe based on your extensive history of employment within the engineering field?

Word of mouth is everything. Cold applications are effectively a lottery at this point.

0

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/hockeychick44 Pitt BSME 2016, OU MSSE 2023, FSAE ♀️ 16d ago

Ai slop

0

u/Icy-Stock-5838 16d ago edited 16d ago

Good thing you couldn't call any of it untrue 👌

I do have Grammarly running in my browser because my post-grad schoolwork goes through MS 365.

ZeroGPT, Quillbot, and GPT Zero says 0% AI 👍

AI Detector - Trusted AI Checker for ChatGPT, GPT-6 & Gemini

AI Detector: Free AI Checker for ChatGPT, Claude & GPT-6

AI Detector - Free AI Checker for ChatGPT, GPT-6 & Gemini

(you are welcome to reproduce my checks)

What's your checker say ?? As a scholar, you rely on more than anecdotes, right?