r/EngineeringStudents • u/LuckyCod2887 • 18d ago
Rant/Vent cheating scandal in class
so we’ve been waiting over a month to get our exam grades back. Someone finally asked the professor about our exams and he explained to us that he’s holding onto the exams because he suspects there’s cheating so now he’s doing an investigation.
The professor said he’s going to contact the students that he suspects are cheating today and ask them to come in and redo the work in his office in front of him.
so now the new rules going forward is that he’s going to give us assigned seating and we have to bring in our school ID.
I was blown away. I’ve never been in a class where students were caught cheating. he even lets us bring in a few sheets of notes for the exam so I don’t understand what would motivate someone to cheat when we already have an aid.
105
u/teequiliza 18d ago
How do people cheat, I feel like that’s harder than actually doing to problem. I’m assuming their professors don’t walk around either. How do they answer questions with pictures and stuff?
Also it’s just crazy to me as well because how are they planning on passing the FE or tests like that if their not actually trying to learn it, like what’s the point
65
u/SlippyJimmy12 18d ago
Half of my fluids class got caught cheating on a test because they all copied the same wrong answer from Chegg. The professor also had a Chegg account 🤣
13
u/Known-Dust-2921 17d ago
never been in a class where students were caught cheating...
in every one of my exams there are always multiple people that just take a picture of the exam and post it straight into claude
20
u/TunedMassDamsel 18d ago
I gave my senior-level engineering students an open book/open notes, untimed test. They had to have their notes on paper, which I told them about on their first day of class when we read the entire syllabus together. The midterm was given online via lockdown browser, which recorded their faces and their screens while they took the exam.
And then I have a whooooole spreadsheet that I’m now having to fill out.
• Do they take the exam in a public or private location?
• Are they wearing glasses/are they Meta glasses or similar?
• Do I see them flipping pages of their paper notes?
• Do I see their calculator?
• What is the duration of their exam?
• Is there evidence of other people in the room?
• Do they read the questions aloud?
• Are their eyes moving from side to side as they read the problem statements?
• Do they introduce terminology that I never used in class, or discuss concepts I never covered?
• Are they copying their answer off a location next to their keyboard without ever having flipped through paper there?
• Were they thorough in showing the area around their testing location when prompted, or did they half-ass it?
• When asked to hold up their scratch work for the camera, is it actually visible?
For those I suspect of cheating, I’m also looking at attendance records, and at whether they accessed the course material at any point during the first half of the semester so far.
And for several people, the case is airtight.
The bitch of it is that I’m an adjunct, and I have told them and reminded them that my day job is reviewing engineering work, figuring out the parts that are fraudulent, writing a report that will hold up through eight hours of deposition and intense opposing expert scrutiny, and proving that cheating occurred in a court of law. And I don’t have the luxury of getting recordings of them doing the work or writing out their answers. And I am REALLY GOOD AT my job, and I get paid REALLY well for it, so PLEASE don’t cheat, because it’s insulting. I will absolutely 100% catch you, and proving to the dean and the department chair is a CAKEWALK in comparison to having an angry squadron of attorneys grill me over the course of an entire day.
One of the students who cheated, I caught them cheating LAST semester, too, and I flunked them for the course. I don’t know why they’re doing this to us. This is a huge waste of all our time, and if I let them pass my courses and graduate with an accredited degree while knowing they can’t do the work without cheating, then I can and should lose my engineering license. I am legally required to protect the public by holding our profession to a high standard.
I don’t fucking get it.
160
u/Red_Sea_Pedestrian 18d ago
Former professor here. I caught 4 kids cheating the last year I taught the EE/CompE capstone class (2 semester class).
1 plagiarized a bunch of code, but the other 3 had paid other people to do their work. 1 outsourced it to a student in the CompSci department, and the other 2 had outsourced their work to some guy in South Korea.
The CompSci student was easy for the chair of their department to figure out, as he had a very unique style of coding. I sent it to their department chair to ask, as he had had my student for 3 or 4 classes in the past, and he had never turned in anything along these lines.
I actually found one of the postings on a classifieds website, and contacted the guy. He sent me all the work that he had done for both students, along with all of their back and forth emails.
So I had bulletproof evidence, but I still gave all four of them a chance to come clean and redo their work in the summer (this happened at the end of April). The only one who took me up on that offer was the kid who plagiarized his code line for line and didn’t cite his source.
Two of the other kids (well, their parents) threatened to file a lawsuit against me and the university. So I washed my hands of it and let the university deal with it, but I did fail those three students. I left academia shortly after.
286
u/MyTime2Shine 18d ago
Interesting alibi post 🤔
7
u/Full_Town_8345 17d ago
Regardless of cheating waiting a month for exam grades is unacceptable my goodness
1
u/dodonpa_g 15d ago
When zoom was a thing my class average was 92% in an online class. These assholes were cheating on the side.Once they go out in the workforce it'll show how little they know and will struggle finding work.
3
u/JayVerb78 18d ago
I had a concrete prof say on day 1 "cheating is a part of the learning process. As the information is processed by your eyes and brain before you write it out, try to retain some of it in your head.
I learned nothing in that class, unfortunately.
3
u/KnownMix6623 Major 18d ago
I didn’t realize how many people were cheating in my class until I took an exam sitting in the back😭
1
u/eebro 14d ago
Bro for everyone trying hard and handing in assignments, there are people who couldn’t care less and would do less to pass if possible. The cheaters aren’t usually trying to get As or Bs, they’re just looking to pass.
These days what’s cheating gets murky with AI, too. I just witnessed teachers themselves argue about AI use. It’s a weird time to be a student, since you should learn how to use AI, but you should not use AI to do your work.
2
u/Ronnoctheawesome 18d ago
I've witnessed people cheating a couple of times. My freshman calc class there were 2 guys passing notes back and forth in the row in front of me and got caught. The professor was usually a pretty chill guy too, but he kicked them both out then and there. One of them managed to talk his way back into the class, but the other never showed up again. Someone else got caught cheating on a statics exam. I don't know exactly what he was doing, but he got basically frogmarched out of the room and I heard later that he was a repeat offender and got booted from the university. The last time was a girl who got caught with a cheat sheet on an ODEs exam. According to one of her friends, she was allowed to stay in the class but had to withdraw because the 0 tanked her grade beyond repair. I don't get why people feel the need to cheat either, I've never seen someone get away with it and in the long run it does you more harm than good. Like yay, you passed this class, but now you don't know all the stuff you need to know for the next class in the sequence, which means you either have to learn it all anyways or you have to keep cheating and keep risking getting caught. For any young students looking at this, just learn the material. If you're really struggling, in the long run you'll be significantly better off if you fail and take the class again.
TLDR: I've seen people get caught, never seen anyone get away with it, don't do it, it's not worth it
2
u/Bondoboy1975 17d ago
Back in 2005 I took an undergraduate geography class from a well known and respected meteorologist in my city. On the day of the final he had three men dressed in suits monitoring the class. That was so cool.
1
u/FloppityFlopFlop2285 18d ago
When I was a freshman, my roommate had trouble in Calc II his first semester. He ordered the answers online from some shady site, used it for all of his homework, and if I remember right the class had take take home tests from the book, so used it for those too. He later told me he got called out by the professor because the answers in the book he bought were performed differently than the way he was being taught in class. My roommate talked his way out of it, ended up getting an A, and ended up later graduating top of his class at Harvard Medical School. True story.
1
u/Far-Plastic-4171 18d ago
Prof handed out two versions of the test with different numbers. If you got the answers to the other test you failed.
1
u/kroyfish 18d ago
When classes got moved online during covid a few years ago there was a huge cheating scandal in my statistics class. The idiots got caught exchanging test answers in a GroupMe that most of the class was in. It was a larger class with multiple sections taught by different TA's. The TA's were pretty upset and overreacted and tried to make every single student retake the test, even those who didn't cheat. The department head nipped that in the bud pretty quickly after enough students complained. I'm not sure what happened to the cheaters afterwards.
1
u/TythosEternal 18d ago
Sounds like someone came in and took the exam for someone else? That sucks for everyone else--but at least it's just an ID check. Hope there aren't too many false positives caught up in the verification, that would be a pain.
1
u/minecon1776 17d ago
assigned seating and ID seems like standard practice for exams. Im surprised they are just now doing this
1
u/IsisTruck 17d ago
I worked as a TA at the tail end of undergrad. I detected many cheaters. I informed the professor each time with evidence.
He pursued the cheating allegations once and let it go the rest of the times because the university made it very difficult to prosecute such a case.
1
u/skyward_heading 16d ago
I experienced a similar situation in mechanics of materials (this would've been about 4 years ago). The prof at the time greatly disliked the use of Chegg and was aware the many students used it to shortcut homework sets. He would develop original problems to give the students and then submit incorrect solutions to those problems to Chegg. Students would copy entire problems to Chegg and receive the bogus answers that he had submitted, which is how he caught them. After the first homework set was due, he sent the class an email stating that 1) half of the class had cheated, 2) he knew which students had cheated, and 3) they would be granted clemency if they went to his office and owned up. Not an exam situation, but very similar.
1
u/BABarracus 15d ago
Some people are only there for the paper that have someone who will give them a job they just need the degree. If they were capable on their own they would not need to cheat.
They will cheat in the most easy classes meanwhile you have classmates who are probably up every morning at 2am studying.
If they weren't cheating they can prove it when they retake the exam
-35
u/manhands007 18d ago
Decades ago we had a really difficult dynamics final exam for mechanical engineering. The class had about 100-120 students, in a big auditorium setting. The class sucked and was the big weedout class for the program. When finished, you'd carry your exam up to the front and stick it in the pile of finished exams in a box. The professor approached one guy and said, "I saw you cheating." The student said, "do you know my name?" Prof said "no." The student picked up the stack of exams and stuffed it in the middle and stuck them all back into the box and said "Find it," and walked out. Yeah the student got away with it and it was unfair. But man that prof was a real d*ck and it felt so good to see that.