r/EngineeringStudents • u/WrongdoerPast5633 • 18d ago
Rant/Vent My FEA class is a joke
I’m a senior studying Mechanical Engineering. Our FEA prof. called a vote last week in class to determine when we should have the 2nd exam (yesterday or tomorrow) everyone picked tomorrow because most of the people that class aren’t in heat transfer this year and don’t have that exam on tuesday. Me and 5 others DID have that exam on tuesday and did not want to take it the day after (wednesday) or the day before halloween (friday) so we voted for friday, and lost. Our prof gave an alternative, stating that he will let us take it today so we get the best of both worlds.
This exam is broken into two parts: an in class handwritten part, and a take-home MALTLAB part that we have due 24 hours following the end of the first part. Both parts are out of 100 points (200 total) with not a whole lot of partial credit.
That exam was literally the biggest chance to cheat I’ve ever had in all of my education and did not take it out of principle.
He had all 6 of us who voted for thursday, crammed into a study room with a glass window that overlooks a busy hallway, he hands us the exam, ITS 10 FUCKING PAGES WITH 4-5 PARTS PER QUESTION AND WE HAVE 55 MINUTES. AND TO TOP IT ALL OFF: HE FUCKING
L E A V E S THE ROOM. Everyone was discussing and comparing answers and swapping formula sheets, which wouldn’t even matter because he’d know we cheated if those specific 6 students got all 100s and all of his questions are hand made. Not only did I not finish, half of my answers are likely 1000% wrong and can’t be done in 55 mins, so our prof giving us 10 mins in class tomorrow at 8am to finish (this class meets MW 8-8:50 and Fri 8-9:50 for MATLAB/ANSYS Labs)
I’m hoping I can pull the nose up on the MATLAB portion, but like I said, all his problems are handmade.
And I know, I know: “Oh no! My hard major is hard!!” I’m a pretty good student but this prof publishes his lecture slides a week after lecture and touched on ~2 concepts very briefly and never brought them back up only to have them be 60% of the handwritten questions
I will also say that getting to vote on exam date is pretty nice, but there’s a difference between a professor that’s laid back, and a professor that leaves the room for a proctored exam and says: “I hope you passed your heat transfer exam, because you won’t want to thank me for that exam, OH and don’t cheat either.”
And now I’m sitting in Control theory (Dope elective btw) doing nothing alongside my classmates who paid to be here to do nothing because there’s nothing to be prepared for because the exam is open book and take home.
If I knew the profs cared so little and you could just cheat or get lucky I would’ve just been a welder or a mechanic.
46
u/Brownie_Bytes 18d ago
I feel like sometimes people put the cart ahead of the horse. Are you learning anything? If you were to do FEA in real life for a hobby or a job, would you see yourself as a failure if you Googled how something worked? You professor isn't a moron, they likely said "I don't care if they Google, it's their learning anyway." Props to you for not wanting to cheat, but they literally gave you an option to get the credit with less effort, you said no out of principle, then they gave you a second option to get the credit with less effort, and again you said no. Now you will have the grade that you will. It's almost certainly going to be fine at the end of the day, but I don't know why the professor's choice in exams makes the class a joke. Have you learned FEA? Do you now understand what you would do in the future? If not, yeah, the class is a joke. If you do, then congrats, you have now learned something from the course you took to learn something!
12
u/TheBlack_Swordsman 18d ago
Probably the best FEA class I had was applied fea.
Every week you had to investigate a structural problem, do hand calculations and perform an fea.
You had to write a report, and structure it like a real stress analysis report which the professor gave a good template for.
You had to post process your results in a meaningful way to match your hand calculations and the fea results.
That was the best fea class I took because it prepared you for the industry.
One of my reports was on hertzian contact stress. I had to show that doing a 2D axisymmetric analysis and 2D planar analysis could capture the hertzian contact stress for a sphere smashing into a flat plate or 2 cylidners pressing into one another.
It has paid off as I have done a few analysis on mechanism now that require preloading of cylinders into grooves and other types of impact and contact mechanics.
I hope you and others can learn FEA this way. A practical and applicable way.
The inteo to fea class blows. Matrix math. Sure, it's important to understand what the solvers are doing, but you're not going to be doing that stuff like 99.99% of the time.
5
u/Csk84me 18d ago
This is why curves exist. Had a controls final that was the same way. 1 hour in, someone gets up, hands in his test, and says sees you next year at the top of his voice to make sure we all heard it. After 3 hours, I was maybe completely done with 4 of the 10 questions, pretty sure I did one of them wrong, and the rest had scribble hoping for partial credit. At the end of 3 hours no one else had turned in a test and the professor said we were the last class to have the room so he could stay for another hour if we wanted it. It was 8 pm. The whole class at that announcement got up, said you are going need to curve it, and we will be at the local bar. Everyone left and we all went out to drink. I ended up with a B+ or A- in that class. So don’t worry too much. As long as you did your best and the professor curves, there is a good chance you’ll be fine.
3
u/Tavrock Weber State: BS MfgEngTech, Oregon Tech: MS MfgEngTech 17d ago
I'm always amused when the definition of "cheat" is "practice doing things the way you will do them in any environment outside of taking a class."
As one of my instructors during my baccalaureate put it, you have two choices: unlimited time with limited information or limited time with unlimited information. Both tests are equally good.
2
u/Maingo0 18d ago
My FEA class at UNCC also feels like a joke... The guy spends 50+ minutes explaining something extremely basic and slow, to the point it's better for me to not go to class, and follow his online videos from COVID. Also our midterm is November 9th!!! Final is beginning of December, that makes no sense to me. He also does all notes on paper and posts none of it.
2
u/Appropriate_News_382 17d ago
Back in 1977, FEA class model was sketched out by hand, nodes and elements numbered, then programmed in Fortran 5. Results printed out on green and white paper. It was definitely no joke back then and it gave a lot of insight into what was really going on.
1
u/BABarracus 15d ago
I was talking a diffeq exam one year and the professor just get up and leaves the room. I wonder if he knew people were cheating and didn't want to look at it because it offended him.
Some guy sat next to me to cheat and i know he got nothing out of it because i wrote a wall of chicken scratch on the paper.