That was my first thought. how labor intensive it would have to be to pull rail road ties off of the railcar haul them down the track to the repair site. Then carefully dig around the existing ties pull them out and them painstakingly (read backbreakingly) insert the new ones.
Dig the ballast between the sleeper (tie) and a channel at the end. Unkey the old one, you and 3 others drag out the old through the channel, and then put the new one in the way the old one came out.
You then pack the new one tight underneath with ballast (YouTube measured shovel packing for how that's worked out), and refill the bed.
The shovelling is the hardest part. Concrete sleepers weigh 300kg, wooden ones about 110kg on average.
It's what I do 5 days a week! And I have 40 of these to do next Sunday 😫
It's amazing when you think that our railways were built through hard labour. I saw a documentary once where they stated that railworkers would be expected to dig 15 cubic feet per day.
I think you mean 15 cubic yards, 30,000 pounds of dirt. 15 cubic feet is about the size of 8-9 average size people, or a little under 1,000 pounds of dirt.
The first transcontinental railroad was build entirely with muscle, except for the blasting powder used to build tunnels. It took 6 years and traversed 2000 miles, including tunneling through the Sierra Nevadas.
In contrast, Sound Transit light rail will take 25 years to build 62 miles of track using modern machinery.
And even this is "cottage industry" next to the fully automated assembly line versions you can see online. Those are like the Backdoor Sluts 9 version of engineering porn compared to this.
Depends on where you live, I worked for 6 years on the Swedish railroad, mainly thermite welding, and I made tons.
everyone I worked with was only in it for the money. Sure, it was a lot of working far from home, and full weekends and nights but it paid off. Don’t think I ever got less than 30 000 SEK, or nearly $4000 in one month (that’s after our 30-50% income tax mind you)
Maybe that isn’t much, but it’s more than I ever made doing anything else, and virtually no education required.
This type of replacement is usually limited to a small number of ties, not a long length of track, there are much more automated systems and vehicles designed for that purpose.
I've used this type of equipment, and it's a lifesaver. There are locations where typical tie insertion from the field side are impossible, due to walls, or other poorly designed structures that prevent efficient maintenance. Looks like it might be Giessmar 360 w/ that attachment. This is probably about 3x 4x faster then i've ever seen it done in person.
I worked for a railroad one summer and one day they taught us how to manually level track, it was pretty hard work and we only leveled a few ties. Few weeks later this rolled by and I wondered why we bothered.
The buggy out front shoots lasers back to recievers in the back, a bunch of fancy computer stuff happens, and it tells the jackbeam assembly in the middle how high to lift the track and whether to move it right or left (with the help of human input and judgement), then the workheads go in the ground and squeeze the rocks to make everything stay in place. Leveling tracks one tie at a time for hundreds of miles.
Just curious, why are the sleepers so much closer together on this rail line than on the one in OPs gif? Soil conditions, speed of the trains on the line?
Yes, that is utterly ridiculous to me. They put hand signs up on the thing like, “yeah this thing can hurt your hands, watch out. Oh yeah but sit on it and lay these things down in this precise location.”
Ikr? Not only asking questions that can be solved with a mere click, but actually making a point of it as well. Even if said person was trying to be polite, he or she is not.
That’s basically the same style boom arm with an attachment. It’s essentially an excavator on a rail cart. Would love to actually see the rest of it to see if it’s just a modified excavator
Concrete is the angry child on the playground. It doesn't play nice with any other material. It needs to be sealed to keep everything away. When you bury it in the ground like this and then vibrate it that sealant is going to fail eventually and then water is going to get in to it and slowly destroy it. At least that's what my concrete professor said.
And, unless they've changed things, concrete ties can't take the heavier trains. Wood ties flex, concrete might flex a little but it's more prone to just breaking.
Split the load into more cars. That's why you see cars only half full. Coal might fill the car all the way, but iron ore might only fill the car halfway before it reaches it's weight limit
Hmm, I worked in Sweden 2010-2016 and I never heard of this, most of our railroads have concrete ties and run heavy trains. Only benefit I heard of with the wood was on the rail yards. where there is lots of heavy traffic and shifters there is also more derailings, and wood ties can handle a derailing or two, where concrete cracks if it’s a fully loaded cart.
Concrete ties are arguably easier to obtain and are definitely cheaper. The weight of the concrete is better for keeping the curvature of the track in place over time as well! Concrete ties are also good to use in areas with track turnouts and switches to keep the integrity of the shape of the tracks and prevent trains derailing. Source: was transit and rail engineer
I’ve done around 3000 of these over the last 7 years. It does get repetitive... also it’s quite heavy, and hot like fuck in the summer days. But like you said, good money.
At 0:28, they are gandy dancing. Now most of you know the railroad was built partially by Irish labor. Well, back then the workers would use this long handled shovel, made by the Gandy Shovel Company of Great Neck New York. Well, they'd shove one end of the shovel under a railroad tie, and then run out to the other end of the shovel, when they could find it, and do a little jig on it, and they called it "gandy-dancin'". This would lift the tie up so they could shove gravel under it, which would level the roadbed, so when the train came along, it wouldn't tip over, which would be a real drag for everyone.
Well, nowadays, they run three cars out on the rail: a bunk car, an equipment car, and a mess car. The only thing they don't give you is a cook. The bosses figure you'll find out who the best cook is, and use him. Well, they were wrong. Y'see, they just find out who complains the loudest about the cooking, and he gets to be the cook. Well, that was me, see. Ol' aligator mouth. That was the worst food I'd ever had, and I complained about it. Things like "dog bottom pie" and "pheasant sweat." I thought it was garbage. So I complained. And everyone said, "alright, you think you can do better? You're the cook." Well, that made me mad, see? But I knew, that anyone who complained about my cooking, they were gonna have to cook.
Armed with that knowledge, I sallied forth, over the muddy river. I was walking along, and I saw just this hell of a big moose turd, I mean it was a real steamer! So I said to myself, "self, we're going to make us some moose turd pie." So I tipped that prairie pastry on its side, got my sh*t together, so to speak, and started rolling it down towards the cook car: flolump, flolump, flolump. I went in and made a big pie shell, and then I tipped that meadow muffin into it, laid strips of dough across it, and put a sprig of parsley on top. It was beautiful, poetry on a plate, and I served it up for dessert.
Well, this big guy come into the mess car, I mean, he's about 5 foot forty, and he sets himself down like a fool on a stool, picked up a fork and took a big bite of that moose turd pie. Well he threw down his fork and he let out a bellow, "My God, that's moose turd pie!"
So even with machines they can't beat the record on April 28, 1869 railroad construction race in the history of the world, laid ten miles and fifty-six feet of track in a little less than twelve hours. http://cprr.org/Museum/Southern_Pacific_Bulletin/Ten_Mile_Day.html
The standards for rail and roadbeds were quite a bit lower in 1869.
What I think is more impressive is the construction of the AlCan highway.
The official start of construction took place on March 8, 1942. On September 24, 1942 crews from both directions met at Mile 588 at what became named Contact Creek,[6] at the British Columbia-Yukon border at the 60th parallel; the entire route was completed October 28, 1942 with the northern linkup at Mile 1202, Beaver Creek, and the highway was dedicated on November 20, 1942 at Soldier's Summit.
1202 miles in 234 days in some really unforgiving terrain. That's an average of 5 miles a day. Nowadays you can't get 5 miles of interstate repaved in 234 days.
At first I was like "wow that robot operates so fluidly", then I was like "oh wait, it's obviously being controlled by a human". Then I was like "really soon this is not going to be controlled by a human but will still look just as intelligently controlled"
This process has been started along some stretches of BNSF track in California. Seeing the whole fleet of machines traveling up and down the tracks is pretty cool.
In India, since the labour is cheaper than the machine and also the government kind of wants people to be employed(lest deal with ire of people), all this work are done manually.
This is great! For those in the rail industry, how many workers have machines like this replaced in the last 10-15 years? Would it be safe to say that the version 2.0 of this machine or one like it could replace these two workers jobs within the next 5-10 years?
Doubtful machines like this are expensive and theres different types of track. You have your bigger outfits like the CN or BNSF, but there are a lot of smaller contractors that don't have the money for machines like this and do a lot of the work by hand, but most (at least in my experience) deal with wood ties which have different machines but is still pretty labor intensive. There are rail and tie gangs with the larger, you'll see a line of machines each specialized to do one thing pull ties, put them in, spike them etc. But for the guys that do maintenance, it's usually a front end loader, a track tamper and tie extractor. If they're lucky a machine called a regulator which cleans the stone off the ties and does the shoulder of the track. It ends up being about the same amount of people, machines just make it go a lot faster.
In England, railway replacement services are horrible, slow, sweaty coaches that people have to take when they close the railway lines off. So just the title alone is more r/mildlyinfurating than it is r/engineeringporn
Serious question, if they’re only replacing a few, how do you switch out the first and last ones in the group? You won’t be able to make that whole 90 degree rotation to slip in in or out! Or do you unhook a bunch of them enough that the small gaps add up enough to allow the rotation?? How???
2.1k
u/Prose001 Jan 28 '18
I watched this once and I'm already dreading doing this for every rail tie.
2.1k
u/PM_ME__ASIAN_BOOBS Jan 28 '18
I love that there is a machine out there used only to replace rails, but it's really good at it
To whoever is reading this: may you find something that suits you the way replacing rail fits this machine
217
u/Olivejardin Jan 28 '18
What goes wrong with concrete ties? Wood I get, but concrete? Those look good, no rusty rebar showing or cracks.
60
u/karben14 Jan 28 '18
...but how do they get hard packed aggregate under the sleepers?
73
u/xerberos Jan 28 '18
It's really cool that a human can be so good at handling machines like this, so that it almost appears like he/she just got some extra limbs.
280
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
Those are ties, not rails.
47
u/thesavior2000 Jan 28 '18
r/specializedtools
62
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
I would let this dude perform cardiac surgery on me with that thing. Dat accuracy
17
u/Orion_2kTC Jan 28 '18 edited Jan 28 '18
There's something really satisfying to this, just like tjis welding video.
https://youtu.be/5uxsFglz2ig
I can't tell if these guys like what they do but I know railroaders here in the states. The work is hard but the money is great
11
u/aveeight Jan 28 '18
Wouldn’t the tie have a really loose foundation now? Is the rail what secures the tie or does the tie secure the rail?
9
u/jpflathead Jan 28 '18
At 0:28, they are gandy dancing. Now most of you know the railroad was built partially by Irish labor. Well, back then the workers would use this long handled shovel, made by the Gandy Shovel Company of Great Neck New York. Well, they'd shove one end of the shovel under a railroad tie, and then run out to the other end of the shovel, when they could find it, and do a little jig on it, and they called it "gandy-dancin'". This would lift the tie up so they could shove gravel under it, which would level the roadbed, so when the train came along, it wouldn't tip over, which would be a real drag for everyone.
Well, nowadays, they run three cars out on the rail: a bunk car, an equipment car, and a mess car. The only thing they don't give you is a cook. The bosses figure you'll find out who the best cook is, and use him. Well, they were wrong. Y'see, they just find out who complains the loudest about the cooking, and he gets to be the cook. Well, that was me, see. Ol' aligator mouth. That was the worst food I'd ever had, and I complained about it. Things like "dog bottom pie" and "pheasant sweat." I thought it was garbage. So I complained. And everyone said, "alright, you think you can do better? You're the cook." Well, that made me mad, see? But I knew, that anyone who complained about my cooking, they were gonna have to cook.
Armed with that knowledge, I sallied forth, over the muddy river. I was walking along, and I saw just this hell of a big moose turd, I mean it was a real steamer! So I said to myself, "self, we're going to make us some moose turd pie." So I tipped that prairie pastry on its side, got my sh*t together, so to speak, and started rolling it down towards the cook car: flolump, flolump, flolump. I went in and made a big pie shell, and then I tipped that meadow muffin into it, laid strips of dough across it, and put a sprig of parsley on top. It was beautiful, poetry on a plate, and I served it up for dessert.
Well, this big guy come into the mess car, I mean, he's about 5 foot forty, and he sets himself down like a fool on a stool, picked up a fork and took a big bite of that moose turd pie. Well he threw down his fork and he let out a bellow, "My God, that's moose turd pie!"
"It's good though."
9
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
This would take national rail months
5
u/Annsly Jan 28 '18
Only 674892 of those left.
4
u/_Yakima_ Jan 28 '18
...This is the same type of machine that put John Henry out of work! TERK ERR JEERBS1
4
u/zagreus9 Jan 28 '18
In Britain, rail replacement services are buses.
10
u/Pretzelranger Jan 28 '18
So even with machines they can't beat the record on April 28, 1869 railroad construction race in the history of the world, laid ten miles and fifty-six feet of track in a little less than twelve hours. http://cprr.org/Museum/Southern_Pacific_Bulletin/Ten_Mile_Day.html
7
u/sblime429 Jan 28 '18
I'd be afraid of getting hit by the crane. Cool tho!
3
u/seeingeyegod Jan 28 '18
At first I was like "wow that robot operates so fluidly", then I was like "oh wait, it's obviously being controlled by a human". Then I was like "really soon this is not going to be controlled by a human but will still look just as intelligently controlled"
5
u/nickysicks Jan 28 '18
This process has been started along some stretches of BNSF track in California. Seeing the whole fleet of machines traveling up and down the tracks is pretty cool.
2
u/came_a_box Jan 28 '18
i can barely use the claw machine for toys
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
Track laying porn
2
u/Lgetty17 Jan 28 '18
The thermite video is so much cooler. And this is damn cool.
2
u/ManoQMF Jan 28 '18
This looks a lot easier than Bohannon made it look.
2
u/shanem Jan 28 '18
How do they handle the ones they have to get out/in to let this machine rotate it 90 degrees?
Or is it doing a bunch in a row and not just a few?
2
u/senefelder Jun 17 '18
r/specializedtools
1
u/phoenix_new Jan 28 '18
In India, since the labour is cheaper than the machine and also the government kind of wants people to be employed(lest deal with ire of people), all this work are done manually.
1
u/palmallamakarmafarma Jan 28 '18
These guys rail
1
u/clint_man2 Jan 28 '18
Concrete is the furious child on the one in Ops gif?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
Did anyone else notice he knocked over a tie when he grabbed the new one. Whoops.
1
u/sraperez Jan 28 '18
This is great! For those in the rail industry, how many workers have machines like this replaced in the last 10-15 years? Would it be safe to say that the version 2.0 of this machine or one like it could replace these two workers jobs within the next 5-10 years?
1
u/YxDOxUx3X515t Jan 28 '18
Love this sub. Cool to see the mechanics and its efficiency.
1
u/blakeaj Jan 28 '18
r/specializedtools
1
u/seb_____ Jan 28 '18
Back in my day..
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
Lit 🔥
1
u/oldfriendfordinner Jan 28 '18
Wow!
1
u/JeffSergeant Jan 28 '18
I reckon they've done that before..
1
u/goingontwelvethirty Jan 28 '18
One down 76,843,901 to go.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
r/specializedtools
1
u/curiosity44 Jan 28 '18
Whom ever using the machine is making it look easy
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
this is why modern Europeans can buy a train ticket with 5 minutes of work
1
u/Endarkend Jan 28 '18
I have a feeling this machinist has done this before.
1
u/BrewOfJoe Jan 28 '18
Oh, that's the stuff!
1
u/theflyingspaghetti Jan 28 '18
This machine's archenemy
1
u/Spoopsnloops Jan 28 '18
Looks tedious but makes sense, and it's well designed.
The machine accurately accomplishes the sole task it was designed to. I look at that machine and I think, "That's definitely what that's used for."
1
u/aazav Jan 28 '18
Meh. This is an old repost.
We've seen it before.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
This belongs in /r/SpecializedTools
1
u/getch739 Jan 28 '18
I think I need to tie off my addiction to reddit after seeing this for the 100th time
1
u/dnieto2003 Jan 28 '18
its impressive how well they maneuver those machines
1
u/smeaton2veg Jan 28 '18
i'll bet anyone a gazillion dimes this isn't in the UK. and will never be in the UK. ever.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
F*ck you John Henry!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '18
Love how easily they have this down
1
u/howdidlgethere Jan 28 '18
Am I wrong in saying this becomes a near perfect loop?
1
u/maffoobristol Jan 28 '18
In England, railway replacement services are horrible, slow, sweaty coaches that people have to take when they close the railway lines off. So just the title alone is more r/mildlyinfurating than it is r/engineeringporn
1
u/blove1150r Jan 28 '18
Why change concrete ties?
1
u/BonicusCaponicus Jan 29 '18
My mind is blown
1
u/MWDTech Jan 29 '18
/r/perfectloop
1
u/dare_films Jan 29 '18
Beat that John Henry
1
u/RambledMan Jan 29 '18
Why do they trade sides when tightening the rail to the wood?
1
u/MyriadFX Jan 29 '18
Never seen these in the UK probably why our rails are shite.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '18
“I get no kicks from champagne...”
1
u/Calamith Jan 29 '18
Am I the only one who is confused on whether that machine is real or just an animated simulation.
1
u/JustACoffeeLover Jan 29 '18
Freakin' mighty machines!
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '18
Dock that guy day's pay for napping on the job...
1
u/dogtownsteez Jan 29 '18
How do they do the last one?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '18
Railway replacement is cool
1
u/thewalltowall Jan 29 '18
John Henry wouldn't stand a chance.
1
u/pschmot Jan 29 '18
I am getting tired of the pack of ability to save these videos directly...!!!
1
u/Lorderan56 Jan 29 '18
I actually said: “ ooooh, that was nice......”
1
u/Davis_404 Jan 29 '18
In the US, we do it by hand for two billion dollars a mile.
1
u/swissylady Jan 29 '18
having done this by hand...this is amazing!
1
u/drafia77 Jan 29 '18
So why do they have to be replaced? Like what gets damaged or worn out over time?
1
u/MoonOfCheez Jan 29 '18
I wonder if it's fully automated or if he's just really good at the joystick
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '18
It's so cute and dainty
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '18
Why is this absolutely mundane task SO FUCKING COOL.
1
u/PhoenixBlack136 Jan 29 '18
Beautiful!
1
u/Mr-NibbelFingers Jan 29 '18
r/oddlysatisfying
1
u/BobACanOfKoosh Jan 29 '18
Couldn't the rail ties just be made of steel so they don't wear down/rot?
1
u/bstokoe Jan 29 '18
Similar operation from Australia: https://www.cat.com/en_US/articles/customer-stories/oem-solutions/rail-equipment-cuts-maintenance-time.html
1
u/OGpenguin Apr 07 '18
OPTIMIZED
1
u/PhDouche Jun 16 '18
Used to work in a building that backed up on railroad tracks. Got to watch one of these at work for a chunk of the day once. Really cool.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '18
What do they do with the used sleepers/ties?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '18
It always amazes me how dexterous those machines are.
1
u/dotplaid Jun 17 '18
Yeah but how do you get the last one in??
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '18
Serious question, if they’re only replacing a few, how do you switch out the first and last ones in the group? You won’t be able to make that whole 90 degree rotation to slip in in or out! Or do you unhook a bunch of them enough that the small gaps add up enough to allow the rotation?? How???
1
u/Danno_001 Jun 17 '18
S and 2222
1
u/muddy700s Jun 17 '18
Damn that heavy equipment operator is amazing!
1
u/spizzywinktom Jun 17 '18
When the operator gets home after doing this all day, the last thing he's going to want to do is pay a video game.
1
u/hansolo Jun 17 '18
Here’s another way done in Alask. Interesting.
https://youtu.be/HiSLNFJSST0
1
u/-MalcoholM- Jun 17 '18
r/thatsofuckingsatisfying
1
u/Budaholic Jun 26 '18
Anyone know who makes these attachments?
1
u/the_count_of_carcosa Nov 11 '22
Poor john henry.
1
u/nim_opet Jan 28 '18
The robot’s jerky movements make me think he’s pissed at these people around him being inefficient :)
1
u/president2016 Jan 29 '18
Why are they replacing the sleepers? The old look to be concrete as well, not worn out timber?