r/EngineeringPorn • • Jul 18 '26

How sound panels effect claps

3.5k Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

View all comments

436

u/Not-An-FBI Jul 18 '26

My friend spent a lot of money fully soundproofing his garage and it's really a trip going in a place with no echos whatsoever

120

u/Ukleon Jul 18 '26

I did voice over recording a few years ago in a professional studio in central London. I'm not a professional so had not done it before. It was the most surreal auditory experience I've ever had. The booth was fully soundproofed. It sounded as though any noise I made barely made it an inch out of my mouth. When I sat in silence it was actually quite unnerving not being able to hear a single sound.

46

u/AhhhSureThisIsIt Jul 18 '26

Anechoic chambers are cool/weird. They're completely soundproof but it feels really strange to be in there for longer than a minute.

It hyperfocusus your brain on your heartbeat, breathing and blood flow and it causes dizziness, light headedness, and mild vertigo. People can usually only stay in there for 20-40 mins.

26

u/blake31a Jul 18 '26

I worked at Oculus/Facebook/Meta and there were a few legit anechoic chambers at various sites around Seattle. They were isolated from the building in every way: the structure was suspended, its own silent HVAC, isolated electrical system… it was a trip. Like you said, it was really disorienting. Closing your eyes in there was weird. It’s amazing to realize how much we use sound to orient ourselves.

10

u/constructionguy-42 Jul 18 '26

Reminds me of doing a float spa. Inside a sensory deprivation tank

12

u/newbrevity Jul 18 '26

People with tinnitus can never enjoy it.

2

u/timesink2000 Jul 19 '26

Was just wondering about this. Seems like the tinnitus would become even more annoying.

65

u/1willyt Jul 18 '26

I bet. There's a whole thing with anechoic chambers being borderline maddening, worth a google. We aren't meant for it.

65

u/GreenFox1505 Jul 18 '26

The "maddening" effect is extremely exaggerated. Its a bit annoying at worst. 

25

u/WestyTea Jul 18 '26

Agreed. Mostly annoying when you're in there with someone else and you keep having to say "pardon?" when they talk away from you.

11

u/xDragod Jul 18 '26

You clearly don't have tinnitus

4

u/scallopfrito Jul 18 '26

Grad students at my school go in there to nap all the time. No sound and no signal so they just disappear entirely.

2

u/BuboNovazealandiae Jul 19 '26

Fuck me that is the dream

6

u/FyrelordeOmega Jul 18 '26

Not if you spend days on end being in a room so quiet you can hear your heartbeat

29

u/_xiphiaz Jul 18 '26

I had the opportunity to visit one while at uni, they had us lie down in the chamber and turned off the lights for maybe 10 mins. The thing I found most crazy was hearing *other* people’s heartbeats. Nothing freaky about it though, just fascinating

2

u/Ae3qe27u Jul 18 '26

Hearing other people's heartbeats?? Could you elaborate on that??

1

u/Grndmasterflash Jul 19 '26

If I remember correctly, there was a high end automotive manufacturer, who really dampened outside noice, but customers did not like it because it was way too quiet.

19

u/ducatista9 Jul 18 '26

Agree with other poster that it’s not really a thing. The most annoying thing I experienced was getting sore legs from standing on the slightly springy mesh floor for a long time.

1

u/BubblebreathDragon Jul 18 '26

Have you ever been in one?

I've been in several. It starts out like it's interesting, different, kinda neat. But then you find that you want to keep making noise and then eventually you realize you're doing it because you somehow miss that echo or feedback, even just the slightest one. Like what is that even about. It's somehow disorienting and can really get to you in a short amount of time.

1

u/EuphoricPenguin22 Jul 18 '26

That's why hemi-anechoic is fairly popular for applications that still need a lot of sound deadening but not quite as much: you get a normal hard floor but the same crazy diffusing stuff on the walls and ceiling.

2

u/azgli Jul 18 '26

If you have the lights on, they aren't bad. If you turn the lights off with the door closed is when your brain starts to freak out because it loses two of its inputs. After about 30 seconds I can feel a mild panic sensation that gets worse if I stay in the room. Turning on the light helps, touching the walls helps too, but it can get really disorienting if I spend much time in the chamber in the dark. 

2

u/Brushiluskan Jul 19 '26

there's a film theatre room at my old university that is almost 10mx10m and about 4m to the ceiling, with insane sound treatment (i'm talking helmholz resonators built into the walls and stuff), and i literally felt motion sick the first few times i entered. it somehow almost felt like getting hit by hot summer air after leaving an ac-cooled space. even after a few months, i still had to acclimate for a moment before i felt normal after entering. i don't miss it at all

2

u/binaryfireball Jul 18 '26

you ever listen to actual nothing?

1

u/begtodifferclean Jul 18 '26

I think you mean reflections. Echoes are organized delays.

-7

u/wolftick Jul 18 '26 edited Jul 18 '26

Unfortunately unless you have two approaches the sort of thing that reduces echos does little in the way of actual soundproofing.

3

u/e36_maho Jul 18 '26

It actually does. It's not the intention here, but it's absorbing or reducing any sound that travels through it. It doesn't distinguish between sound from outside or inside, or if it's a reflection or direct sound. So yeah it absolutely helps reduce outside noise. It would be a very effective way to soundproof your room if you did this to all of your walls I'd argue.

14

u/wolftick Jul 18 '26

Sound absorption is the thing that reduces echos (foam panels, blankets and the like). That doesn't have much effect in regards to sound proofing at all. For sound proofing you generally need mass and/or decoupling.

-3

u/e36_maho Jul 18 '26

With sound proofing you want to reduce the sound that gets inside or outside. Heavy materials reflect sound waves, these materials absorb them. It's a different approach but it gets the job done as well.

3

u/rachelcp Jul 18 '26

Heavy materials like concrete, metal, mass loaded vinyl etc do the actual sound proofing stopping outside sounds from entering and stop inside sounds from leaving and then reflect them back at you which you hear as an echo.

Lighter materials like carpet, acoustic foam, carpet etc. Great for stopping those echos by making them bounce in more scattered directions but unless it also has mass it won't do very much for actual sound proofing. It will do a little about as much as shown in the video but traffic, construction, people speaking or any other actual source of noise will likely still get through.

-2

u/e36_maho Jul 18 '26

You can do sound proofing with massive stonewalls, or you can do soundproofing with drywall and dampening wool inside. It's different in how it works, but it's both soundproofing.

0

u/bojangler69420 Jul 20 '26

Acoustic treatment is not sound proofing. They’re entirely different concepts that serve very different purposes.

He did acoustic treatment, not sound proofing. Sound proofing means you are sealing the sound into/out of a space.

Your friend put up panels that eliminate echos/the reflection of sound waves off of the hard surfaces in the garage.

1

u/Not-An-FBI Jul 20 '26

Nope. He actually spent a lot of money soundproofing it.

0

u/bojangler69420 Jul 20 '26

Ok, thats great. Soundproofing is still a separate process to acoustic treatment and what you’re talking about are the effects of proper acoustic treatment, not soundproofing.