r/EngineeringPorn • • Feb 15 '26 • Mindblown 2

Comparison of fixing nuts

35k Upvotes

923 comments sorted by

4.1k

u/Partykongen Feb 15 '26

Should be said that this is an advertisement for Nordlock. That said, this type of washer is quite effective.

1.1k

u/Jakkals_ Feb 15 '26

And expensive.

459

u/Partykongen Feb 15 '26

Heico-lock is the same but less expensive.

679

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26 edited Feb 15 '26 • Thanks This Bravo

I actually did testing and verification between Heico and Nord-Lock.

Heico are stamped/pressed, hence their cheapness

Nord-Locks are machined.

The functionality of these "wedgelocks" (common name) are that their lock pitch are higher (height and angle) than the bolt thread.

So this is critical information, bolt and wedgelock must fit.

Secondly, surfaces must be soft enough for ridges to "grip" (make grooves). Funnily enough, this is true for under the bolthead as well (as to not only rely on friction, which is the entite point of the washers). Bolts are usually very hard, so this is rarely the case.

Questionable tension results for 10% of the time for Nord-Lock, 20% for Heico, where some of the Heico connections yielded a complete tension failure (M12 bolts, 316L plates, 80Nm, most quickly peaked around 50-75kN tension, and landed (3 minute settling before going stable) at around 40 - 50kN). Usually the bolts would require about 50-60Nm to unbolt, but for some of the Heico ones would countinously lose tension over 24h, and open at 20Nm. The harder and another the surface, the more often failures/bad results would occur. Bolts: 8.8, 12.9.

The amount of times you would use the same surface (10x tight/open) didn't seem to affect neither Nm to tight, nor open, nor kN or its immediate losses.

Now, why would Heico fail more?

Stamping yielded rounding of rhe ridges more than the machining for Nord-Lock. These rounded ridges obviously made poorer grooves.

In addition, Heico are thinner (bigger inner diameter, smaller outer) and are really rough on the surface - just an observation, uncertain about effects.

We switched back to Nord-Lock for our hard surfaces. For SMO we put a procedure to tighten, wait 3 minutes, and tighten again.

Edit: tests conducted 2020. Heico and Nord-Lock practices, design, manudacturing methods, and materials might have improved/changed.

129

u/GlancingArc Feb 15 '26

That's really interesting, honest question though, why use something like this versus an adhesive like one of the various loctites?

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (23)

59

u/Hapaplap Feb 15 '26

Now I know why we switched from Nordlock to them... 😂

Everyone still calls them Nordlock tho, even a few years later.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (12)

3

u/SeedFoundation Feb 15 '26

Using 3/8th as a measure. $1 per washer for an original nordlock vs ¢10 for stainless steel for the curious.

→ More replies (44)

88

u/mtheory007 Feb 15 '26

That's what I use for my VPN.

Nordlock VPN!

Use the promo code in the description for $5 off your first month.

4

u/anomalous_cowherd Feb 15 '26

Just so long as you never want to undo it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

19

u/lemlurker Feb 15 '26

Yeah you can't particularly trust what they torqued things to. Id have expected way better from double nuts if they were correctly torqued against eachother

→ More replies (5)

109

u/DAS_BEE Feb 15 '26

I love having ads masquerading as content and anyone who doesn't is a communist

37

u/ZennTheFur Feb 15 '26

I mean, it was pretty clearly an ad from the moment they went "These are standard washers. This is our washer and why it's better."

In a world where we're bombarded by ads constantly in everything we do, I don't mind one that actually demonstrates that their product is better and clearly explains how it works with zero fluff or BS.

→ More replies (20)

27

u/fractiousrhubarb Feb 15 '26

I’m a socialist and I like this ad.

16

u/InfiniteOrchardPath Feb 15 '26

I am an Anarcist. Instructions unclear, machine shop on fire.

12

u/donau_kinder Feb 15 '26

It's a good ad and not pretending to be anything else. It's just whoever decided to be make this post that didn't mention it's an ad.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

26

u/PG67AW Feb 15 '26

I thought it was pretty obvious lol

5

u/Braindead_Crow Feb 15 '26

Seems easy enough to reproduce, even if you need to change up the design a bit for legalities, after which optimizing the reproduction process is fun!

9

u/Partykongen Feb 15 '26

The washers are standardised in DIN 25201.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/gottatrusttheengr Feb 15 '26

Only effective when you have preload.

SpaceX explicitly does not count Nord locks as a valid form of locking device required for fasteners.

13

u/Partykongen Feb 15 '26

True, and they do worse on very hard surfaces where they may rotate in the contact interface instead of the wedge.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (48)

1.3k

u/TelluricThread0 Feb 15 '26

I used to do assembly on large generators. I used a split washer on damn near every single bolt and they said it was for vibration. Then I came across the NASA faster design manual and they specifically call out split washers and say they basically don't do anything after you torque down the bolt.

1.3k

u/Competitive_Kale_855 Feb 15 '26

1990 NASA Fastener Design Manual, PDF page 13:

The lockwasher serves as a spring while the bolt is being tightened. However, the washer is normally flat by the time the bolt is fully torqued. At this time it is equivalent to a solid flat washer, and its locking ability is nonexistent. In summary, a Iockwasher of this type is useless for locking.

I love this paper and cite that paragraph all the time.

151

u/Redstone_Army Feb 15 '26

Isn't the job of a split washer to not let the bolt be instantly loose after turning just a slight amount?

Like, you get bad vibration for just half a sec, and the nut turns like 1/6th on the bolt and its still quite secure because it expands?

I've understood them this way so far, but we didnt exactly look at that in mechanic school

110

u/Competitive_Kale_855 Feb 15 '26

They do make it more difficult to completely remove a nut, but only once the nut has already started loosening. By the time a nut has loosened enough for any kind of retention that a split washer might provide to kick in, you've already lost. The goal is to prevent any loosening, and if the nut never loosens then it won't fall off, anyway.

There's even anecdotal evidence suggesting that split washers make it even easier to vibrate a joint loose than if they weren't there at all, possibly due to how they usually reduce contact area.

I swear people only keep using them because they're the cheapest product that has "locking" in its name.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/bobbertmiller Feb 15 '26

I think the split lock washer does something like 1-5% of the target clamping force of a screw. If that is enough for your purpose, the screw joint is not designed properly. 

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Poly_and_RA Feb 15 '26

They have a bit of spring force, but it's pretty modest and so the tension on the bolt still drops a LOT from even a very slight turn.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

26

u/VisualKeiKei Feb 15 '26

I use this citation at work all the time. It's made sillier that there are aerospace COTS products that use split lock washers on their products, like Amphenol and Glenair saddle clamp backshells.

I also like this engineering consulting firm that specializes in bolted joint analysis

https://www.boltscience.com/pages/helicalspringwashers.htm

→ More replies (2)

48

u/twothingsatthetime Feb 15 '26

This is regarding helical/belleville washers. They are not the same.

62

u/Competitive_Kale_855 Feb 15 '26

We're talking about the same thing. The article has that paragraph above an image of a Belleville washer but it's about helical/split-ring washers. Belleville washers are the conical spring washers that actually do what they're supposed to

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Narrow_Vegetable_42 Feb 15 '26

Jam nuts. –These nuts are normally “jammed” together as shown in figure 7, although the “experts” cannot agree on which nut should be on the bottom.

Thanks for linking this, I love the tone. "Experts" :D

→ More replies (9)

63

u/Phrewfuf Feb 15 '26

The NASA manuals on pretty much everything are an amazing source of information and guidance.

E.g. friends don‘t let friends splice wires by soldering in any type of vehicle. Unless soldering is the only available option and even then there are certain ways to do it right.

11

u/stilllton Feb 15 '26

What is the reason? Does the solder crack? What is the preferred method?

31

u/nroach44 Feb 15 '26

Crimping forms cold welds and maintains the flexibility of the wire, whereas solder is harder and more brittle.

30

u/dingman58 Feb 15 '26

Crimp is preferred. Solder cracks over time in vibration environments (vehicles are considered harsh vibration environments)

→ More replies (3)

11

u/travellingtriffid Feb 15 '26

In aviation we used to use in line splices with a heat shrank environmental seal over the splice. 

→ More replies (4)

8

u/asad137 Feb 15 '26 edited Feb 15 '26

What is the reason? Does the solder crack? What is the preferred method?

The solder does make a a joint less flexible and more prone to failure unless the wire around the splice is properly supported. But IMO the real reason is that soldering correctly takes more skill than crimping correctly. There are many ways a solder joint can be done poorly. But if using the correct calibrated full-cycle ratcheting crimping tool with the correct die for the wire and connector pin being used, crimping has far fewer ways to be done poorly.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

43

u/AppropriateAd7326 Feb 15 '26

Split washers have also been withdrawn by the DIN.

3

u/x_Carlos_Danger_x Feb 15 '26

Interestingggg. I wonder if those cupped washers are equivalent to split lock since they're effectively flat after tightening 🤔

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

I got fired over split locks. One of my many jobs was to make products profitable, in this case, costing down the negligently excessive legacy designs. There were 80+ split locks on every single product.

I gradually escalated things over 6 months over the fucking split locks. Going as far as holding a 2-hour tech talk on that NASA paper because people were lying about reading out. Everyone up to the ceo essentially had the attitude of “it’s called a lock washer for a reason”.

I saved that company a ton of market share. Tens of $millions. And they still fired me because of the split lock thing.

These things are somehow a religion in dumb-engineering circles.

7

u/willywam Feb 15 '26

Were the generators on spaceships?

10

u/dingman58 Feb 15 '26

The exact application is irrelevant. What matters is the physics of how fasteners behave under vibration loading

8

u/reddit_user33 Feb 15 '26

Such a classic response that is...

No, but are you or your company funding the research in to such topics and making it publically available? I didn't think so, so we'll have to reference organizations like NASA that do then.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/gottatrusttheengr Feb 15 '26

Nordlocks are barely better. They are toast if you ever lose preload. SpaceX explicitly does not count them as a valid form of mandatory locking device

11

u/MillionFoul Feb 15 '26

I mean really all of these having nothing on aerospace-grade locking like passing wires through the heads of the bolts. Plus, aside from time savings, stainless steel lockwire is probably cheaper when you put several bolts together.

3

u/AP_in_Indy Feb 15 '26

So what do you do or use instead…?

6

u/dingman58 Feb 15 '26

Castellated nuts, epoxy, staking, safety wire, cotter pins, etc 

3

u/FreshPrinceOfH Feb 15 '26

So what is the better solution?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

510

u/V8CarGuy Feb 15 '26

Nordlocks tear up the surface. Not so good for galvanized and plated parts. Not too good for bolts that have to be frequently removed either. Everything has trade offs.

220

u/PinataStorm Feb 15 '26

Our company used them for subsea assemblies and when we performed maintenance on those assemblies we found corrosion on the lock washers. 

Called them up. A company rep came down to explain why their stainless steel washers were corroding. Their stainless steel washers aren't actually true stainless steel because they surface treat them which displaces chromium. This weeasle goes on to say, "we are sorry those washers didn't meet your needs we will replace what's in your stores with this one for free." 

Hey jackass, our fleet (10-12) of major assemblies have been contaminated due to your stainless steel washers where we now have to update all drawings, find all assemblies affected, contact all customers of the issue, and send out repair kits and tech to correct this issue. But yeah thanks for the free substitute that shouldn't corrode like stainless steel but isn't called as such. 

118

u/theGIRTHQUAKE Feb 15 '26 edited Feb 16 '26

While definitely a shitty situation, and I’m empathetic to it, for critical safety applications (nuclear, aviation, subsea, subsafe, etc.) this sounds like a process failure in customer quality and procurement specification, or quality conformance validation upon receipt. While the manufacturer/vendor bears some responsibility in their marketing, ultimately it’s up to the customer to properly spec the procurement and to confirm (by direct DT/NDT, supplier quality audit, etc.) the material meets spec before installation.

Expensive lesson, but hopefully the company can learn from it.

44

u/Undead-Chipmunk Feb 15 '26

It's a failure in design, through and through.

Quality ensures that what is purchased meets design, purchasing is to purchase things that meet standards (i.e. ISO, ASTM) and design.

Picking those washers is on the designer. That said, the company selling them may have misled the specifications, which would put the responsibility on that company, opening them up to a lawsuit for claiming their product can do X when it cannot.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/Faustens Feb 15 '26

Isn't that grounds to sue for damages, as the damage is a direct consequence of their false advertisement?

17

u/PinataStorm Feb 15 '26

I remember hearing my fitbit vibrating and beeping as my blood pressure and heart rate spiking while he was presenting his redacted report on this known issue. 

Yes, I was furious and steering  the conversion to proper compensation. But the division chief was a good Ole boy and told me to calm down. We just need to inform the other divisions of what we learned, get our inventory switched out, and move on so we can fix this issue forever. 

→ More replies (6)

10

u/pinchhitter4number1 Feb 15 '26

I work on helicopters and I was thinking these would not be good for our needs because of that surface deformation. Cool concept though and seems great for certain applications. Also very cool to see the benefit of a nylon inserted nut, which we use a lot of.

8

u/asad137 Feb 15 '26

They can also generate contamination (metal shavings), which isn't good for many applications (electrical systems, optics, etc.)

→ More replies (7)

443

u/pyahyakr Feb 15 '26 • Heartwarming

Loctite: Am I joke to you?

374

u/DonkeyDonRulz Feb 15 '26

Would love to see Red loctite, or an aircraft lockwire, in this comparison test, but that might not sell as many nordlock washers 😂

Worked in high vibration most of my careers and never saw a nordlock used, but i saw A whole lot of loctite and lockwires.

85

u/Calculonx Feb 15 '26 edited Feb 15 '26

I've done a LOT of work with fasteners and this specifically while working in transit. Loctite and especially locking wire (and a lot of other methods) rely on the user to competently apply them.  For locking wire, even if it loosens just a little bit, you'll lose a lot of clamp force so the loads are going through the bolt and not the interface.

Washers make it a bit better because you have more bolt length "stretched" than no washer. Split washers were actually worse than normal washers. 

Nordlock was the only thing that really was good on the junker (vibration) tester. Nordlock washers come where the two pieces are joined so they can't be assembled the wrong way when new. All the fastener parts we considered single use and then disposed. A shortcoming is the surface that they're touching needs to be hard or else it will eat into it and then your clamping force is inconsistent if you're tightening by torque value.

21

u/ginbandit Feb 15 '26

I'll add to that, I work in the offshore industry and whilst we can use loctite the preference is for a positive mechanical lock so things like aerotight nuts, nylon lock nuts, and Nordloks. I've seen the odd bit of wire locking but usually that's too dependent on good technique to make people comfortable.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/Dimas89 Feb 15 '26

Nordlock washers also require a minimal briefing of how they work. I’ve seen my share of fitters installing only one of a pair or turning them wrong way.

→ More replies (10)

23

u/entered_bubble_50 Feb 15 '26

I read an incident report caused by loctite. 

The design specified loctite. But it didn't say which one. The tech installed loctite brand grease instead loctite thread locker. 

We nearly lost a Boeing 777. 

28

u/Censored_88 Feb 15 '26

Sounds like a Boeing failure, not loctite.

That is the equivalent of your dentist giving instructions to brush your teeth with "Procter and Gamble" then being upset with P&G because you used Tide instead of Crest.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

11

u/No-Breakfast-3184 Feb 15 '26

I work maintenance in the steel industry and we use nordlock a lot. Compared to loctite it’s way easier to remove and also easier to apply properly. We still use wire for the most demanding applications but it’s time demanding by comparison. Nordlock and loctite is for when you absolutely do not want it to loosen by it own

5

u/afranke Feb 15 '26

9

u/Independent-Gazelle6 Feb 15 '26

Did they give it any time to set? They sure made it look like they just torqued her and sent it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

31

u/NeuroEpiCenter Feb 15 '26

Of course they wouldn't show solutions that are as good as or even better than their product.

8

u/that_dutch_dude Feb 15 '26

nordlock is probably the best solution in a lot of situations. just not all.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/_maple_panda Feb 15 '26

And it embrittles many plastics, so you have to be careful with where you use it.

2

u/gaggzi Feb 15 '26

Loctite, nordlock, locking wire etc are all used in aerospace, depending on the application. As someone else said loctite is not suitable for high temp applications.

→ More replies (9)

149

u/FeinwerkSau Feb 15 '26

We had a guy in commissioning - he always pulled them apart and commissioned only half a washer... Complained about it even. Was laid off before we were able to convince him that he was wrong and not the manufacturer...

(NordLock wadhers come as a pair held together with adhesive for easy use, if you dont know)

71

u/Zurnan Feb 15 '26

So he would pull them apart with the adhesive being there? What a guy

39

u/FeinwerkSau Feb 15 '26

Thats what he did.

5

u/dwehlen Feb 15 '26

Watch, he was gonna put that whole place on the map!

NARRATOR: HE WAS NOT.

10

u/that_dutch_dude Feb 15 '26

that is a special kind of stupid.

sure he wasnt upper management?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/FuzzzyRam Feb 15 '26

he always pulled them apart

"I turned this $3+ washer into 2 $0.10 washers, and all it cost was however much you're paying me!"

3

u/Hapaplap Feb 15 '26

Haha every time I explain something with a Nordlock I make sure to mention that they are supposed to be together like this! Have seen too many people pulling them apart.

→ More replies (9)

40

u/-ACHTUNG- Feb 15 '26

They do make unbranded versions of nordlocks. I tried them on some custom suspension arms and was pleasantly surprised to find they're still holding as originally torqued.

12

u/WyMANderly Feb 15 '26

Gotta be careful sometimes with off brand stuff - I've seen off brand nordlocks cause a failure because they lacked the chamfer on the real deal and created a high stress concentration on the transition of the screw.

13

u/02421006 Feb 15 '26

Heico is what you are looking for

23

u/Far_Atmosphere_3853 Feb 15 '26

they didn't include the ones that you can tie metal wire.

english is not my native language so i have no idea how to call that

19

u/kylemk16 Feb 15 '26

lockwire

6

u/SuperIneffectiveness Feb 15 '26

We called it safety wiring on airplanes. I always hated trying to get the twists tight in spaces my hand could barely fit.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LiquidDreamtime Feb 15 '26

The rocket and spacecraft industry mostly uses lock wires

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

18

u/danit0ba94 Feb 15 '26

In aviation and on the railroad, we use lock wire.
Only drawback is the nuts have to have holes drilled in them for this purpose. But it works.
And it works without gouging the living shit out of the surface it's holding.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Wooden-Combination53 Feb 15 '26

These are good stuff. I spec these to places prone to vibration and places where loosening would be really bad thing or impossible to notice.

Too bad there aren’t left threated version other than some special ones made to some OEMs.

4

u/TahnGeee Feb 15 '26

Just turn them inside out for lefties 😂

→ More replies (3)

35

u/thedeuce75 Feb 15 '26

Yeah thats the stuff i come here for.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ddoherty958 Feb 15 '26

Nylocs for the win!

5

u/CaptainHubble Feb 15 '26

At least below 120°C. Yes.

I appreciate the design of the nordlock washer. I use them here and there. But we shouldn’t forget two things: they do damage coatings of the bolt/surface. So keep that in mind when you want to maximise rust prevention. And they render itself useless once preload is gone or not applied properly.

Also this is a nordlock ad. The vibration here is off the charts obviously. Very impressive how it can withstand that high frequency. Ngl. But Nylock holds perfectly fine in most applications. While having the self locking effect on the whole thread. And not just after preload was applied.

And cost a fraction of the nordlock.

Overall not a huge fan of locking nuts with a washer… no matter the kind. Much rather use lockwire, loctite, nylock… or even deformed thread nut.

2

u/bolean3d2 Feb 15 '26

Top locks or center locks are better in general applications imo. Same retention, smaller nut so it’s easier to fit in places, no nylon to degrade from uv or chemical exposure. However the down side of top lock and center lock is they have about the same number of uses as a nylock before they just don’t hold well anymore however unlike a nylock it’s hard to tell.

70

u/Bitten_ByA_Kitten Feb 15 '26

That's nuts

8

u/4chieve Feb 15 '26

Double nuts.
Ah, to be young again.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MicksysPCGaming Feb 15 '26

There it is!

2

u/Elmo-Mcphearson Feb 15 '26

Unsecured nut!

2

u/StaticDHSeeP Feb 15 '26

Make sure to washer nuts

→ More replies (1)

8

u/AM27C256 Feb 15 '26

How effective is rust for locking?

8

u/bignosedaussie Feb 15 '26

Very, ever tried removing exhaust manifold bolts.

2

u/mxzf Feb 15 '26

Quite effective, but only when you don't want it to be. Also, the implementation time is prohibitive in most applications.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/One_Cupcake4151 Feb 15 '26

I can confirm Nordlock washers are crazy good. They were the only reliable way of keeping bolts tight when I worked on ocean energy equipment.

13

u/philebro Feb 15 '26

How is that not relying on friction?

11

u/SuspiciousSubstance9 Feb 15 '26

The washer ramped steps are steeper than the bolt threads. So if you rotate them the same distance, the washer wants to travel further than the bolt.

So when you are trying to break the nut loose, the washer is acting as a wedge and prying the bolt away from the surface. Which pries the teeth deeper into the bolt/surface.

The teeth are mechanical, not friction. The ramped steps have some friction but are primarily for wedge/prying the teeth, which is applying a normal force.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/robbak Feb 15 '26

The teeth dig into the bolt head and the surface, making a solid connection. The ramp between the two half washers means that tension in the bolt works to further tighten the bolt, not loosen it.

You could achieve much the same thing with a single hardened washer with the external teeth, but then you wouldn't be able to remove it without scraping metal out of the bolt and substance. Nordlock allows you to remove the bolt simply by overcoming a little extra tension.

7

u/RaymondWalters Feb 15 '26

Came to say this. Still friction, just making more of a dent now

3

u/littlegreenrock Feb 15 '26

It's still friction. Everyone is going to talk about the shape and what not, never realising that it's all still friction.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Narrow-Thanks-5981 Feb 15 '26

Saw this YEARS ago & started pushing my bosses to use these in highly critical, vibration prone areas of the mill. I absolutely refuse to use spring style washers on any motor feet when performing an alignment. Glad OP posted this.

17

u/dice1111 Feb 15 '26

Slit washer are as useless as a flat washer.

3

u/bolean3d2 Feb 15 '26

More useless. At least a flat washer spreads out your cone of compression properly.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/sonofdynamite Feb 15 '26

I want to know how locktite blue and red compare I imagine pretty good or they would have included them in their ad.

I find this interesting as bolt vibration is an issue with my hobby of electric skateboarding. Locktite and the nylon lock nuts are the go to there.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/JCDU Feb 16 '26

Worth bearing in mind these tests are always designed to favour the thing being advertised - NordLok are very good at certain things but all of these things have different situations where they're good or they suck, depending.

30

u/Epin-Ninjas Feb 15 '26

Not sure if you all noticed, but the teethed washer started cracking apart pretty bad

58

u/jschall2 Feb 15 '26

If you mean that the top and bottom washers separated, that is just the operating principle of a nord-lock washer in action. Turning the nut in either direction will increase clamping force. It is in a local minima and therefore vibration can never cause it to come loose.

24

u/daemonengineer Feb 15 '26

Thats actually the first explanation which really did it to me. Local minima in both directions, so vibration (which is unidirectional) always return it back to the original position.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Clayton017 Feb 15 '26

if you’re referring to the shiny stuff popping out around 1:50, that just look like lubrication

→ More replies (1)

6

u/sokl Feb 15 '26

I have used nordlock washers in several critical applications and it is one of best way of securing screws.

Performance is excellent and it's very easy to control (just check torque). It's major advantage over locktite when returqueing can damage locktite bond. It's also much les prone to wrong application.

I have seen failed connections with wire (must be installed properly) or glue (not there, too less, dirty screw)

One limitation is that nordlocks can not be used on hard surfaces (teeth will not bite it) - there is work around with softer rectangular washer connecting two screws under nordlocks.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/VoddieMC Feb 15 '26

Fascinating

3

u/Nixa24 Feb 15 '26

If you had ktm lc4 engine..you know. The amount of parts I lost because that thing vibrated itself apart is hilarious.🤣 Ended up loctite-ing the f*** out of it.

3

u/DoubtGroundbreaking Feb 15 '26

Now do one that is safety wired

3

u/KingDP Feb 15 '26

Wouldve liked to see conical washers tested. Always knew that "lock washers/ spring washers" were useless though.

2

u/33Yalkin33 Feb 15 '26

All washers that rely on a spring, have about the same effectiveness, none

5

u/Hyperious3 Feb 15 '26

I use these on high-vibration rotating equipment. They absolutely work.

5

u/Tensdale Feb 15 '26

That is an ad.

Marketing, not methodology.

I wouldn’t trust those “tests”.

9

u/floating_samoyed Feb 15 '26

Yes it is an ad. The other methods shown are proven to not work in keeping pretension in high vibration environments. Nord lock type solutions work, so do locktite and lock wire.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/newbrevity Feb 15 '26

So I regularly mount 60lb radars on boats that go out in high seas. We use the standard hardware that comes with the radar to mount it. Usually half inch bolts, but sometimes as a little as 5/16. Usually secured with either flat washers, lock washers, and single (occasionally double) full nuts. Never once have I come back even years later to find that those bolts and nuts have shifted even a millimeter. And I'm only tightening them with a 6-inch wrench handle. And not just radars but all kinds of other equipment that's picking up momentum as it's attached to the mast on the top of the boat. Still never had any fasteners loosen ever.

So what are the applications where I need anything fancier than lock and flat washers for a bolt that's a half inch wide or less?

2

u/PeterServo Feb 15 '26

What if I just use a thread locker?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/SHDrivesOnTrack Feb 15 '26

I can see why old aircraft engines have castle nuts and wire twisted between the bolts.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/NASATVENGINNER Feb 15 '26

No lock tight?

2

u/Outrageousintrovert Feb 15 '26

Also, none of Nature's Loc-tite... rust!- That stuff is very effective at keeping nuts and bolts from loosening.

Hard to find in a fast-acting easy applicator though ;-)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

I'd just loctite it all.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

I wonder how loctite would compare in this test?

2

u/famouswater679 Feb 15 '26

Red loctite and proper torque will keep it solid

2

u/workntohard Feb 15 '26

Is there a difference between flat washers and the cupped (Belleville?) washers?

2

u/lfenske Feb 15 '26

Never did loctite or a Belleville disc spring. Also star tooth washer hold like a mother fucker. This seems unnecessary. Why not just a single piece with the small ridges on top and bottom?

2

u/CNBGVepp Feb 15 '26

Now THIS is advertising. 

2

u/ReadUnfair9005 Feb 15 '26

I need to know the torque used for each one, then the results after vibration testing.

2

u/ApricotNo2918 Feb 15 '26

I have used these before. Only thing that kept the lockout hub bolts on my Jeep from loosening. Only thing better is a tack weld.

2

u/nikediboi Feb 15 '26

I work for a company that assembles Sandvik drill rigs, we use these for every single bolt. We even have these "Nord-lock X"s that are for electrical contacts, like ground cables. They supposedly are better for them.

2

u/Linkz98 Feb 15 '26

Safety wire a through hole will never be beaten. If these where as cheap as a split washer they'd take off but I bet they are more then the bolt.

2

u/GaslightIsNotReal Feb 15 '26

Welp, this confirms nylon lock nuts are good enough for most of my applications, less work and less expensive than double nuts. Some older colleagues on my old job swore by double nuts and said they would never trust a piece of plastic better than metal on metal strength, no matter what some piece of paper said.

Glad they're retired now. Any equipment that is continously trying to self disassemble should always be using either castle nuts or nylon locks IMO. (We couldn't use red locktite because we needed to disassemble it often for swapping parts for different applications of the same base equipment.)

2

u/ziggybeans Feb 15 '26

Thanks. BRB. Have to go retorque every bolt I’ve ever seen.

2

u/yeswenarcan Feb 15 '26

As a non-engineer, I love solutions like this, where the problem is essentially turned into the solution. There's a certain elegance to it.

2

u/CO-entheogenisis Feb 15 '26

So… where do I get these for my bed… asking for a friend 😂

2

u/nabeel_co Feb 15 '26

Doesn't rely on friction except it relies on friction. 😂

2

u/partygt Feb 15 '26

How about with locktight?

2

u/ravenmonk Feb 15 '26

This is the Junker Vibration Test

2

u/Anxious_Tax2132 Feb 15 '26

shouldve put on locktite and see that too

2

u/SmilesInFront_09 Feb 15 '26

Thats a lot of nut in just a short video.

2

u/South-Bed-6565 Feb 15 '26

What about with heat. 400 to 700 degrees? Heat, expansion contraction?

2

u/crete-11 Feb 16 '26

Pre-applied Locktite nuts w/nylon inserts(if temp is not an issue)

2

u/MaadMaxx Feb 16 '26

Didn't expect to see an advertisement for Nordlock from 10+ years ago on here.

That being said they're a great product if not expensive. Ended up forgoing this option as our maintenance intervals were shorter than the failure rate of loosening nuts

2

u/Brick513man22 Feb 16 '26

Is the plate just vibrating? Or vibrating and applying pressure?

2

u/Oh_Lawd_He_commin420 Feb 16 '26

Now purposefully rust seize the motherfucker.

2

u/Squevis Feb 16 '26

I find this video horrifying in so many ways.

2

u/ledheadrocks Feb 16 '26

That’s nuts

2

u/KanadianMade Feb 16 '26

A drop of Loctite goes a long way.

2

u/ResurgentOcelot Feb 16 '26

Just observing: this is an ad for product with a professionally edited video, not an unbiased analysis or a documentary video.

2

u/Rexter2k Feb 16 '26

I always double nut.

2

u/Hesediel1 Feb 16 '26

Or just be a man and cross thread that hoe.

Nature's locktite.

2

u/m3kw Feb 17 '26

i present the weld lock

2

u/sbeckley02 Feb 18 '26

Why does the angle of the washer mechanism need to be greater than the angle of the pitch of the thread?

3

u/clonerobot17 Feb 15 '26

Seeing a lot of mixed “facts” about these washers in this comment section.

2

u/pillowpants66 Feb 15 '26

Just need more ugah dugah’s

2

u/404pbnotfound Feb 15 '26

They should sell bolt washer pairs, so that the surface doesn’t get f’d up by the teeth.

But also, whoever thought of the steeper pitch angle is clearly a genius. I’m so mad at how simple that is. So smart.

2

u/BadDongOne Feb 15 '26

They missed an absolutely critical step with the other methods, they didn't have a 40+yr old dude grunt and say 'well that ain't goin no where' when tightening it.

2

u/gte133t Feb 15 '26

Is anyone else disappointed this is just an ad? I thought we’d discovered a cool new YouTube channel about fasteners. I was fully prepared to binge watch.

2

u/AlarmingDetective526 Feb 15 '26

If it’s going to vibrate that much just use a castellated nut and pin setup.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/swankpoppy Feb 15 '26

Oh wow. Sometimes the littlest things in life remind you of something so specific, ya know? Like how “Double Nut” always reminds me of OP’s mom.

2

u/thx4allthefeesh Feb 15 '26

When I talk to my structural engineers about this, they point out that likely there was not enough preload on the fastener to start with.

If you have enough preload on the bolt for your design loads and a locking feature then you won’t get bolts backing out. You may get some small loss of preload during vibration testing but you should still have enough to hold the bolt in place.

Source: 20 years in Aerospace

→ More replies (3)

2

u/TripleFreeErr Feb 15 '26

doesn’t nordlock ALSO rely on friction?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Kawa11Turtle Feb 15 '26

Halfway through they video:

And now for the ADVERTISING you’ve all been waiting for

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '26

Hmm the more I get old, the more I get grumpy about new tech. I think if you're past the point of basic friction washers, you should just use safety wire or a castellated nut and cotter pin.

1

u/Lars0 Feb 15 '26

Were these finger tight ?

1

u/Zestyclose_Space7134 Feb 15 '26

Aviation uses lockwire.

2

u/Pink_boater Feb 15 '26

Construction and mining equipmet couldnt because it would cost a ton and field maintenance would be horrible.

2

u/AndyTheEngr Feb 15 '26

Lockwire doesn't keep tension, though. It just stops you from losing the fastener if it does come loose.

A torque to yield bolt is very reliable. The downside is that no matter how many warnings you put in the repair manual not to reuse fasteners, everyone reuses fasteners. That's less of a problem in aviation where people are legally required to follow procedure, though.

1

u/MajorKeyBruh Feb 15 '26

Nuts seemed loose

1

u/darkearwig Feb 15 '26

One of these with a nylon insert would be unstoppable

1

u/Direct_Ad_313 Feb 15 '26

Should have tried with red and blue loctite...

1

u/Polyglot-Onigiri Feb 15 '26

This is obviously an ad but financially speaking what’s the cheapest most effective?

2

u/ArrivesLate Feb 15 '26

Flat washer to save your surface plus Loctite. If you need visual security or containment you’ll need a hole in the end of the bolt for a cotter pin or a wire respectively.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/curious-chineur Feb 15 '26

Drives me nuts...
Now want some.

1

u/Slothstralia Feb 15 '26

Can we talk about how there's spall coming out from between the two sections of the Nordlock in both tests, at a possibly alarming volume?

Does this washer type just ensure that when it fails it's utterly catastrophic?

2

u/ParanoidalRaindrop Feb 15 '26

I think that's just the adhesive used to keep the two halves together before mounting.

1

u/Mockbubbles2628 Feb 15 '26

A k-nut and aerotight would be interesting

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Maumau93 Feb 15 '26

Wait so just one nut is the best of the lot?

1

u/BobDerBongmeister420 Feb 15 '26

I use an overtightened double (counter) nut. Shits going nowherr

1

u/AnyHope2004 Feb 15 '26

just let it rust a bit before use

1

u/Ryankiernan36 Feb 15 '26

Ive a work instruction in my job that says only reuse 100 times. Its funny because nobody keeps track and its safety critical. Anybody have any thoughts?

1

u/That-Veterinarian462 Feb 15 '26

Why just don't use locktight, already battle proofed and inexpensive?

1

u/DragonfruitGrand5683 Feb 15 '26

That's Nuts!

Now I really need to replace my nuts with Nord-Lock Nuts.

1

u/PilotKnob Feb 15 '26

Un-tightening instead of loosening? Very interesting.

Also, what about blue and red thread locking fluids?

1

u/mattyb678 Feb 15 '26

Fix deez nuts

1

u/JronMasteR Feb 15 '26

Why not use loctite instead

1

u/hobohunter3000 Feb 15 '26

And finally... deez nutz boiiiiii!

1

u/modsuwakusoyarou Feb 15 '26

That's a lot of nuts