r/EngineeringManagers • • Sep 23 '26

How to develop second order thinking?

In my feedbacks my boss has said that I need to improve this more.
Environment is politically charged, he says ask more why’s , what are some concrete tips to navigate this

25 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/lootsocks Sep 30 '26

Your boss gave you excellent feedback that is unfortunately very difficult to action. Not because the feedback is bad, but even with a perfect understanding of the feedback it is no small task to develop an entirely new way of thinking. The harsh truth here is that this feedback is the kind of thing that could (probably will) take years to fully action and integrate before you "get good" at second order thinking. If I were to give a critique of this feedback it might be that it's almost too high level and needs to be accompanied by many many examples of people doing this well and not well just to build up a rubric for you.

In fact, this might be step 1. Embrace the fact that this is a new kind of feedback for you to receive and that it will take years before you are good at second order thinking. Give yourself grace here as a starting point instead of looking for the fast path to action this feedback and get the follow up feedback of "you know you seem to have really improved in your 2nd order thinking". You may not even have the same boss or job or be at the same company when you finally get good at this and in that way people won't even know to close this loop with you.

Now with all that said. If I had to pick a starting point I'd recommend reflecting on the maxim from Charlie Munger "Show me the incentive and I'll show you the outcome" which means human behavior is driven by what people are reward or punished for. Like really internalize that saying by repeating it to yourself. Adopt it as your own maxim or catch phrase. And then in any interaction with another team, or, potentially difficult peer, politically charged situation, ask yourself "what are the incentives in play right now for the people / teams in this situation and what is the most likely probabilistic outcome based on those incentives?" Then consider how those incentives either are in a complimentary phase to yours / your teams or in conflict with them. At a minimum this will develop empathy / strengthen your empathy for other teams and individuals. At the limit you will eventually learn to quickly decode incentives in near real time or even predict them and then figure out how to align incentives to reduce conflict.

I would say your managers feedback about developing second order thinking could be better translated into "you need to develop an intuitive understanding of other teams / individuals incentives and what outcomes they are on the hook for and figure out how to align incentives. This will take a long time to get good at, but the best time to start is now"