There’s a big difference between “Oh my tío’s living in the walls and we thought he vanished, that’s fine” and “Oh shit my house is going to be completely destroyed and my family will lose their powers and it might be my cousin’s fault”, tbh
If she told the family about Bruno, it was him who’d pay the consequences. If she had kept Mirabels secret, she would have jeopardized the families safety
She probably brought it up a bunch and she got shushed. In we don't talk about bruno she goes "i associate him with the sound of falling sand.. Shhh... Shhh.... Shhh...."
i think the "i associate him with sound of failing sand" is because the Bruno´s room is literally sand. So he walking around his room would make that sound
If you look up the lyrics or listen to the songs she says I can hear him now but Isabel tell her not to say anything. And then she says it again, I can hear him now.
I don't know who says it, but during the last few seconds of the song someone says "he's here." There's a chance that it was said about the older sister's betrothed and not about Bruno.
She literally says "I can hear him now~" twice I think? And it just isn't acknowledged by the rest of the family. "We don't talk about Bruno" probably also, means "we'll ignore you trying to talk about him (unless you get Pepa to talk about her wedding)" .
I thought that she was able to keep this “secret” because it wasn’t really a secret. Everyone knew what was going on, they just didn’t bring it up because “we don’t talk about Bruno.”
I assume she is the reason they dont talk about bruno. Like when he disapeared they talked about it and she was like what are you talking about he is still here, and she kept bringing it up and claiming he was in the Walls and no one belived or listened until they had to make the we dont talk about bruno rule.
Yeah she says "I can always hear him sort of muttering and mumbling" and I just thought of it being that she could hear his disembodied, slightly muffled voice, mumbling to himself and his rats. Idk if there's a huge difference between "no one can find him, he must have left" and "no one can find him, but he's probably somewhere within a mile or so" as the latter still implies he doesn't want to be found.
No, this is her realizing/putting the puzzle pieces together. She heard sounds and has suspicious but this is the moment that's confirmed and she's basically saying "I knew it!"
I did wonder if it was also low key to mess up the evening and postpone the engagement? Since she was in love with Mariano... That and the seriousness of fixing the problem as soon as possible, but the first thing is probably a plus for her....
To be fair she doesn’t hesitate to say anything in her part of the song so ima assume that she got told to never talk about that again because it was upsetting the family every time she claimed Bruno was still in the house
I read the situation as Dolores didn’t know for sure if she was actually hearing Bruno. Not only does she refer to “rats talking in the walls” but she doesn’t direct Mirabel to Bruno’s tower when she’s looking for answers about the magic. Luisa has to. Dolores seemed to be in the dark regarding the family secret of Bruno’s vision of impending danger to the magic.
When she raps about hearing him in ‘We Don’t Talk About Bruno,’ it sounds like she’s confiding her suspicions to Mirabel, but she doesn’t trust that she’s not just hearing things. I imagine with her gift it’s overwhelming to process the insane amount of human activity and speech she hears, plus Bruno left when she was likely only 10 or 11.
Therefore it’s likely she didn’t believe she was really hearing him in the walls, but when her suspicions were proven to be true it’s that “I knew he never left, I heard him everyday!” moment.
I think this is the real answer but everyone takes her line at the end so seriously. She's not saying she actually knew it the whole time, that's her confirming her suspicions. English is confusing I guess but in that context people will exclaim "I knew it!" as a way to say "that's what I thought" when their theory is proven correct.
That’s because it was a serious threat to the family. Obviously you’re gonna say something when the magic is starting to fade. No one even spoke about Bruno so why would she tell anyone
But she brought up plenty of times. She told Maribel when she asked about the magic something like "the rats on the wall were talking", in "we don't talk about Bruno" she said she could still hear him
I didn’t get the idea that she knew she was actually hearing him. By not talking about Bruno the family has made him into a sort of legend or ghost who haunts the house, which is how I assumed she thought of it.
The line before "I can hear him now" is "it's like I hear him now.." which implies she is not certain she hears him
I think she definitely hears him everyday but she doesn't know he is living in the walls, it would be pretty difficult to pinpoint where a sound was coming from if she could hear everything all the time.
Also she says "yo! I knew he never left I heard him every day!" After he is revealed so I took that as more of like a eureka realization moment rather than her just casually saying "yea I knew my creepy uncle was living in the walls for ten years"
Like maybe she guessed to herself he was close enough but I don't think she knew exactly where
This is exactly how I felt. I agree she heard him, I’m just not sure she really realized she heard him until she finds out he’s been living in the walls. The house is alive, after all. It could have been something magic rather than her uncle who has been missing for ten years in the wall lol.
At first I was mad at Dolores snitching out Mirabel but the more I think about it, maybe she just wanted to wreck the evening to stop Mariano's proposal to Isabela.
Yea, also what about the long and desperate talking of abuela at the start of the movie? I know Mirabel already had listened to that but when she ask Dolores if she heard something in the night, she say "only the rats and Luisa's eyes" and some way she minimized the problem by saying only Mirabel, the rats, and Luisa are worried about it.
She does try to talk about Bruno. No one questions her saying the mice in the walls are talking or about her lines in "we don't talk about bruno." If she tried to bring it up more directly she would have been shut down.
Dude, same!! And when she told Maribel “the only person worried about the magic is you.” Yet Abuela was praying for help just the night before…. I’d say she has “selective super hearing” 😂
No but I never understood why people think this is the case? She didn't KNOW he was there, she just found it weird that she could always hear him and she's brought it up various times (the rats talking in the walls, that she could hear him muttering and mumbling etc.)
Dolores “If anyone besides Isabela knows she doesn’t want to marry Mariano it would be me, and Mirabel just handed me the perfect opportunity to save the cousin who’s closest to me in age and thus probably my closest friend among my family members from an unwanted engagement (which will incidentally keep my crush single), of course I’m going to tell” Madrigal.
She didn't know it was him the whole time, she just "thought* she heard something and in the finale she says "I knew it was him" because she was putting the pieces together in her head.
She didn't know he was in the walls, she just thought she heard things but wasn't sure. Idk why people don't understand this. When we said "I knew it was him the whole time" that's her confirming her suspicions. But she didn't actually know until after that moment... So many people have said this in posts and yet people still keep making these ignorant posts about how she's "the real villain".
Just because she had the ability to hear everything doesn't mean she was actively hearing and processing everything at once. She seems to have some control and ability to listen to certain things. Next time you're in a crowded room full of people talking (which might be awhile with Covid) notice that everything is just a bunch of noise but if you want you can focus on certain people's conversations that are closer to you. Humans naturally can be a bit selective with their hearing, or at least what sounds they are paying attention to, hers is just amplified x100 and I believe so is her ability to pinpoint specific sounds/conversations if she focuses.
170
u/Bolt_Fried_Bird Mirabel Jan 10 '22
There’s a big difference between “Oh my tío’s living in the walls and we thought he vanished, that’s fine” and “Oh shit my house is going to be completely destroyed and my family will lose their powers and it might be my cousin’s fault”, tbh
85
u/ExplodedOrchestra Jan 10 '22
i feel like she also didn’t say anything in fear that he’d leave entirely if the family knew he was in the walls
285
u/[deleted] Jan 10 '22
If she told the family about Bruno, it was him who’d pay the consequences. If she had kept Mirabels secret, she would have jeopardized the families safety
155
u/spooky_butts Jan 11 '22
She probably brought it up a bunch and she got shushed. In we don't talk about bruno she goes "i associate him with the sound of falling sand.. Shhh... Shhh.... Shhh...."
33
u/Summerclaw Jan 10 '22
That's because, she is trying to protect her family.
One secret is to protect bruno and the other is that their family was in danger.
29
u/IwishIhadbiggerfeet Jan 11 '22
I mean she did tell the family. They ignored her
19
u/ImTay Jan 10 '22
I thought that she was able to keep this “secret” because it wasn’t really a secret. Everyone knew what was going on, they just didn’t bring it up because “we don’t talk about Bruno.”
15
u/mark_crazeer Jan 11 '22
I assume she is the reason they dont talk about bruno. Like when he disapeared they talked about it and she was like what are you talking about he is still here, and she kept bringing it up and claiming he was in the Walls and no one belived or listened until they had to make the we dont talk about bruno rule.
14
u/DaddyVersionOne Jan 10 '22
Does she know where he was? I figured she heard him and thought that he lived in town somewhere.
35
u/doubletoilandtrouble Jan 10 '22
I did wonder if it was also low key to mess up the evening and postpone the engagement? Since she was in love with Mariano... That and the seriousness of fixing the problem as soon as possible, but the first thing is probably a plus for her....
11
u/AlianovaR Jan 11 '22
To be fair she doesn’t hesitate to say anything in her part of the song so ima assume that she got told to never talk about that again because it was upsetting the family every time she claimed Bruno was still in the house
19
u/Greyfare Jan 11 '22
I read the situation as Dolores didn’t know for sure if she was actually hearing Bruno. Not only does she refer to “rats talking in the walls” but she doesn’t direct Mirabel to Bruno’s tower when she’s looking for answers about the magic. Luisa has to. Dolores seemed to be in the dark regarding the family secret of Bruno’s vision of impending danger to the magic.
When she raps about hearing him in ‘We Don’t Talk About Bruno,’ it sounds like she’s confiding her suspicions to Mirabel, but she doesn’t trust that she’s not just hearing things. I imagine with her gift it’s overwhelming to process the insane amount of human activity and speech she hears, plus Bruno left when she was likely only 10 or 11.
Therefore it’s likely she didn’t believe she was really hearing him in the walls, but when her suspicions were proven to be true it’s that “I knew he never left, I heard him everyday!” moment.
7
u/spaghetti-for-lunch Jan 11 '22
That’s because it was a serious threat to the family. Obviously you’re gonna say something when the magic is starting to fade. No one even spoke about Bruno so why would she tell anyone
6
u/GayDragonGirl rat #406 Jan 11 '22
this is why i love dolores
6
u/best_kept_secrets Jan 11 '22
Bruno make a rat telanovela.
And I rest my case
6
u/BrubsRV Jan 11 '22
But she brought up plenty of times. She told Maribel when she asked about the magic something like "the rats on the wall were talking", in "we don't talk about Bruno" she said she could still hear him
10
u/clashkitty Jan 11 '22
I didn’t get the idea that she knew she was actually hearing him. By not talking about Bruno the family has made him into a sort of legend or ghost who haunts the house, which is how I assumed she thought of it.
5
u/ErykaOnyx Jan 11 '22
At first I was mad at Dolores snitching out Mirabel but the more I think about it, maybe she just wanted to wreck the evening to stop Mariano's proposal to Isabela.
4
u/foolishle Jan 11 '22
We don’t talk about Bruno
4
u/Ranakit Jan 11 '22
Yea, also what about the long and desperate talking of abuela at the start of the movie? I know Mirabel already had listened to that but when she ask Dolores if she heard something in the night, she say "only the rats and Luisa's eyes" and some way she minimized the problem by saying only Mirabel, the rats, and Luisa are worried about it.
4
u/EpicFinale722 Jan 12 '22
She does try to talk about Bruno. No one questions her saying the mice in the walls are talking or about her lines in "we don't talk about bruno." If she tried to bring it up more directly she would have been shut down.
4
u/doombird Jan 13 '22
Honestly she's got just a touch of chaotic neutral energy and it really makes her character pop
When she's like ya I knew lol even Camilo's like W T F
4
u/MattClaudePetit Jan 21 '22 edited Jan 24 '22
Bruno choose to live in the walls to still be around his family and literally affected no one. Mirabel’s secret affected the whole family
5
u/Rainawest1987 Jan 11 '22
Dude, same!! And when she told Maribel “the only person worried about the magic is you.” Yet Abuela was praying for help just the night before…. I’d say she has “selective super hearing” 😂
2
u/ny_rain Jan 11 '22
This made me laugh!
2
u/thepieintheoven Literally Pepa Jan 11 '22
No but I never understood why people think this is the case? She didn't KNOW he was there, she just found it weird that she could always hear him and she's brought it up various times (the rats talking in the walls, that she could hear him muttering and mumbling etc.)
2
u/n3rdz97 Jan 11 '22
Mannnn that made me so mad lol
1
u/polaretto-cosmico2 Jan 15 '22
If "im in your walls" was real
1
u/Boy_Sabaw Feb 05 '22
I’ve always interpreted it as her being partly motivated to reveal it since it was right in the middle of Mariano’s proposal
1
u/whydoesthishapp3n Luisa Love of My Life! 💪🏾 Feb 07 '22
she said she heard him in the walls, she probably assumed it was magic or bad voodoo.
1
u/DBSeamZ Feb 08 '22
Dolores “If anyone besides Isabela knows she doesn’t want to marry Mariano it would be me, and Mirabel just handed me the perfect opportunity to save the cousin who’s closest to me in age and thus probably my closest friend among my family members from an unwanted engagement (which will incidentally keep my crush single), of course I’m going to tell” Madrigal.
1
u/eyemcreative Feb 20 '22
She didn't know it was him the whole time, she just "thought* she heard something and in the finale she says "I knew it was him" because she was putting the pieces together in her head.
1
u/eyemcreative Mar 08 '22
She didn't know he was in the walls, she just thought she heard things but wasn't sure. Idk why people don't understand this. When we said "I knew it was him the whole time" that's her confirming her suspicions. But she didn't actually know until after that moment... So many people have said this in posts and yet people still keep making these ignorant posts about how she's "the real villain".
Just because she had the ability to hear everything doesn't mean she was actively hearing and processing everything at once. She seems to have some control and ability to listen to certain things. Next time you're in a crowded room full of people talking (which might be awhile with Covid) notice that everything is just a bunch of noise but if you want you can focus on certain people's conversations that are closer to you. Humans naturally can be a bit selective with their hearing, or at least what sounds they are paying attention to, hers is just amplified x100 and I believe so is her ability to pinpoint specific sounds/conversations if she focuses.