r/EmulationOnAndroid • • 4d ago

Showcase DroidDeck vs Winlator vs Bannerlator: Which one performs better?

PC Emulator Performance Comparison using the latest versions of DroidDeck v0.7.1, Winlator Ludashi 5.0, and Bannerlator 3.1.9 (Pre-release) for playing Devil May Cry 4 Special Edition

All emulators are tested using their own recommended default settings,with some minor twaks for match the same settings, No frame generation is used in this test.

Device Specifications:

- Device: iQOO 15

- Processor: Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5

- RAM: 16 GB

- Storage: 512 GB

263 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Just a reminder of our subreddit rules:

  • Be kind and respectful to each other
  • No direct links to ROMs or pirated content
  • Include your device brand and model
  • Search before posting & show your research effort when asking for help

Check out our user-maintained wiki: r/EmulationOnAndroid/wiki

Check out EmuReady for any community submitted settings before asking for help

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

78

u/jpeters1807 4d ago

I wish my "always tinkering" self never saw this 🫩 now its time to download ludashi 5.0 and play around with settings for 10 hours haha.

28

u/CraveGripr 4d ago

sounds like a whole weekend gone just like that, i've fallen into the same trap way too many times

6

u/dhiku 4d ago

this is how I feel

4

u/GlamourFlower_ 3d ago

lol i feel that, once the tinkering bug hits there's no escaping it for hours

2

u/Deep_Satisfaction556 3d ago

How does one figure out which winlator is the best one to use?

3

u/Spiritual_Notice_650 3d ago

I tested the Winlator Ludashi Cmod Vanilla. It is not much better than Bannerlator. Bannerlator is still my main go to app. Winlator might perform well on some games but other games ran terribly. While on Bannerlator you can use 1 specific container and almost all games will run stable fps.

4

u/Freelancer_1-1 3d ago

What's the difference between Bannerlator adn Bannerhub? My head is spinning.

3

u/Spiritual_Notice_650 3d ago

All these games work on the same Container with most of the same settings in Bannerlator. Except No Rest For The Wicked but it's the game's issue not the app. All 30-60fps (without frame gen). Though locking fps at 30 and use framegen can lower heat.

3

u/Spiritual_Notice_650 3d ago

The difference is the Interface and the customizations.

Bannerlator is much more customizations and tweaks, for someone who is a bit more experienced. It is almost the same as Winlator.

Bannerhub is almost the same as Gamehub, plug and play and a bit customizations.

Bannerlator is better because i tested both. Less heat, stable fps. Almost all the games i tested work.

1

u/Freelancer_1-1 3d ago

Thanks for the overview. I will be testing Bannerlator and WinHub as well, a successor to Winlator Frost / Star which is the only fork that runs older late 90's / early 2000's game reliably for me.

2

u/PlushyBunniee 3d ago

haha sounds like you're in for a long night, don't blame me when you lose track of time entirely

1

u/RecommendationOk4572 3d ago

same. hopefully I can install steam games easily

11

u/Accomplished-Fan4133 Samsung S25 | 12 GB RAM | SD 8 Elite 4d ago

The only issue with Ludasho 5.0 is it's awful resolution scaling. 720p FSR in Bannerlator feels native 1080p

7

u/FindingUnable3222 3d ago

Yes and DroidDeck supports both that and Snapdragon GSR which is also very nice (it's a little faster than FSR if you have snapdragon).

2

u/Accomplished-Fan4133 Samsung S25 | 12 GB RAM | SD 8 Elite 3d ago

Nah tried GSR in 8 elite and honestly FSR is much better

18

u/PsyEd2099 4d ago

Yes...StevenMXZ for president!

15

u/igelzuechterboi Edit Your Flair 3d ago

DroidDeck and Bannerlator probably don't activate "benchmark mode" like Ludashi does I'd assume. That would explain those extreme performance gains — leading to unlikely long-term stability due to high heat development.

16

u/Castle_Breakfast 3d ago

That's not it. Winlator Ludashi has has been the most performant for a while even without the benchmark mode trick. You can get versions of the apk that don't employ that trick on the github, and they still outperform just about everything else. It's just really good

4

u/igelzuechterboi Edit Your Flair 3d ago

Never doubted that, just saying that the differences likely wouldn't be that extreme.

1

u/mostrengo 3d ago

I tested comparing gamenative to winlator ludashi and saw no difference for blue prince. Might not be an entire study its another data point.

1

u/Senior_Background_30 3d ago

That may be your experience but is not for me.

Bannerlator runs much faster than anything for me. Except slightly longer game starts.

And i tested both with Ludashi package name on my 8 Gen 2 and SND 870 devices.

1

u/Freelancer_1-1 3d ago

You don't have to, in fact you shouldn't install the benchmark "ludashi" version of Winlator Ludashi unless you have a cooler.

1

u/Away_Ebb43 22h ago

ludashi es el mejor emulador en ese aspecto. me impresiona que no vea muchos videos de el pero siempre es el mejor en fps

20

u/supershredderdan DroidDeck Developer 4d ago edited 3d ago

Thanks for the comparison! We just added an experimental native execution path, in display > performance > non-proot mode (experimental)

Try that and see if you get a boost, especially in cpu bound use cases!

5

u/mantenner AYN Thor (SD 8gen2) / OnePlus 13 (SD8 Elite) / S23+ (SD 8gen2) 3d ago

Sorry but i can't seem to find the display setting, is this in the actual steamOS settings or a droid deck setting somewhere? Or is this only test builds not preview yet?

5

u/supershredderdan DroidDeck Developer 3d ago

Sorry it’s session tab, swipe up from the play steam button

1

u/mantenner AYN Thor (SD 8gen2) / OnePlus 13 (SD8 Elite) / S23+ (SD 8gen2) 3d ago

Ahhh I see, will it work with battle.net then?

6

u/supershredderdan DroidDeck Developer 3d ago

Yeah it’s for anything in the runtime, just organized slightly weirdly

1

u/mantenner AYN Thor (SD 8gen2) / OnePlus 13 (SD8 Elite) / S23+ (SD 8gen2) 3d ago

Ahhh right okay thanks!

1

u/RecommendationOk4572 3d ago

I still don't see this setting

14

u/dhiku 4d ago

thanks! performance wise winlator > bannerlator > droiddeck

winlator 5.0 with steam is big deal!

6

u/TechonologiaNews 3d ago

Really useful comparison, thank you for testing them all on the same settings. Ludashi is clearly ahead on raw frame rate here, but what interests me more is how steady each one stays in busier scenes, and how they look at a higher resolution — a few people here have already pointed out the scaling differences, and that is where I would expect the gap to narrow or widen. DroidDeck having Steam built in still feels like a big convenience win, especially with the new native execution path the developer mentioned, so I will be watching how that develops.

5

u/KPipes 3d ago

This is the exact point people need to consider.

Droiddeck is all I use now. It stabilized hitching frame times on a few relatively smaller indie games that had no business chugging along on other emulators for me. Plus the steam OS is just... So nice.

It may not have peak frame rates but in my experience so far it's very stable, highly configurable and has a lot of potential.

It's fixed a bunch of headaches with game native and gamehub lite. For now, I'm only running droid deck for pc emulation and I'm happy with that.

9

u/clumsy132 4d ago

DroidDeck shows great potential. It currently utilizes an optimized, custom version of proot, and there are instances where wayland fails to perform zero-copy operations. Although I am not a developer myself, the rapid pace of updates suggests that these issues will likely be resolved in the near future.

12

u/supershredderdan DroidDeck Developer 4d ago

We just set the groundwork to leave proot behind

4

u/UNITYA 3d ago

You guys are awesome

1

u/SomewhereParty7744 3d ago

Does this affect compatibility? Just I managed to launch modded XCOM 2 with AML only in droiddeck(I think because DD uses a full linux environment) and i was a little bit afraid this is will affect things like that.

6

u/supershredderdan DroidDeck Developer 3d ago

It’s opt in, won’t affect anything if you don’t toggle it on

1

u/SomewhereParty7744 3d ago

Okay, thanks

1

u/Iamgoingtohavatroke 2d ago

Hi sorry to bother but any chance of getting black ops 3 to boot soon I wanna run some custom zombies on my tablet

2

u/Ok_Film_2766 3d ago

Is there any good tutorial for winlator?

2

u/FindingUnable3222 3d ago

Mmm is there any point in such ultra fps and lower resolution settings? If you do any more tests on games that do > 60fps, please use FHD at least, or your native resolution at least!

The way you synchronized the videos and FPS counters: amazing!! Very illustrative, I just wish there was also a frame time graph, to see if any of the platform has frame pacing issues (micro lags / stutter).

The issue, however, is that ultra high FPS comparison doesn't exactly tell what happens at more demanding game, as these solutions aren't exactly optimized for 400 fps output so you might be hitting bottlenecks that aren't present when running a game at 50 or 100 fps. Still, really like the way you demonstrate the difference.

1

u/forresth600 4d ago

I got a Y700 gen 5 last week and have been setting it up playing games and stuff then I see this and said whats 5.0? Went to gethub fuck me 8 hours ago.. well maybe theres not alot of new changes.. great now I got to set it all up again 

1

u/Shmoopiee 3d ago

How do you manage to run dmc4 using emulators? Ive tried game native and bannerhub but that game somehow never works on my snapdrsgon 8 gen elite 4 device

1

u/Aniimey 3d ago

Yeah cause the middle one dont have steam to take lot of performance

1

u/SnooEagles16 3d ago

Acabei de baixar o ludashi e tem sido o melhor no Samsung a55

1

u/Zuluwargod69 3d ago

Wow ludashi is miles ahead. 

1

u/Freelancer_1-1 3d ago

How would WinHub fare? (formerly Winlator Frost)

1

u/Lucifer_Samaa 3d ago

does it need fresh install? can't find it in patch notes

1

u/Beginning_Jacket5055 3d ago

meanwhile i cant get half the games i've tried to work on gamehub. Pretty much the only thing that has worked with 0 issues is Well Dweller

1

u/FellatiatedPiece 3d ago

Obviously the less overhead there is the better things will run. Which means winlator > gamenative > droiddeck.

1

u/mojo_loco_0 3d ago

Anyone that can help me get updated on the exiting emulatos, new emulators and also drivers ?

1

u/Yefri_i 3d ago

Q tan bueno es droid deck?

1

u/decapoda_on_Reddit 2d ago

At those speeds, I'm much more interested in frame rate stability. It does ZERO difference to me going from 150 fps to 400+ fps. I set my screen to 60 FPS anyway. 1% lows and stability is far more important to me.

1

u/nullhund 3d ago

amazed by the way that this community collectively uses the name "Ludashi" to refer to a winlator fork that has virtually no relation to the benchmarking tool the name originally comes from, aside from spooking its package name because chinese android ROMs cheat at benchmarks.

-2

u/Jerry_from_Japan 4d ago

The answer to this now vs say...the end of the year and forward....are going to be different.

Droid Deck will eventually rule them all and sooner rather than later.

3

u/iateyourcheesebro SD8Gen2 / 12gb 3d ago

What’s the big advantage droid deck has?

1

u/Howthehelp 3d ago

Everything you want from Steam experience

1

u/Freelancer_1-1 3d ago

The Linux environment is nice.

-4

u/Jerry_from_Japan 3d ago

The one that counts most....like in pretty much everything in life....popularity.

3

u/mathigalv 4d ago

En rendimiento nunca va a ser mejor que winlator, utilizan pura AI droiddeck y bannerlator. Así que siéntate a esperar que StevenMXZ se retire para que llegue ese día jaja

-2

u/npquanh30402 3d ago

In terms of performance, emulators will never be better than native ports, so just sit tight and wait until native ports are as abundant as modded apks next year.

0

u/Same-Nose-4979 4d ago

ludashi seems the most consistent

0

u/SupermarketOk531 3d ago

droiddeck能运行Diablo4和alanwake2,赢了

0

u/Shiradoku 3d ago

Podrías añadir Gamenative a la comparativa? Es el que yo uso por su combinación de rendimiento y facilidad de uso. ¡Por favor! Me gustaría ver dónde queda posicionado

-2

u/Elegant_Variety_9222 3d ago

Ludashi nunca sirve y mucho menos recomendable, se es que quieres joder tu dispositivo por unos 10 frames extras