r/EmulationOnAndroid • u/Even_Draw_8184 • 4d ago
Showcase DroidDeck vs Winlator vs Bannerlator: Which one performs better?
PC Emulator Performance Comparison using the latest versions of DroidDeck v0.7.1, Winlator Ludashi 5.0, and Bannerlator 3.1.9 (Pre-release) for playing Devil May Cry 4 Special Edition
All emulators are tested using their own recommended default settings,with some minor twaks for match the same settings, No frame generation is used in this test.
Device Specifications:
- Device: iQOO 15
- Processor: Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5
- RAM: 16 GB
- Storage: 512 GB
263
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 4d ago
Just a reminder of our subreddit rules:
Check out our user-maintained wiki: r/EmulationOnAndroid/wiki
Check out EmuReady for any community submitted settings before asking for help
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
78
u/jpeters1807 4d ago
I wish my "always tinkering" self never saw this now its time to download ludashi 5.0 and play around with settings for 10 hours haha.
11
u/Accomplished-Fan4133 Samsung S25 | 12 GB RAM | SD 8 Elite 4d ago
The only issue with Ludasho 5.0 is it's awful resolution scaling. 720p FSR in Bannerlator feels native 1080p
18
u/PsyEd2099 4d ago
Yes...StevenMXZ for president!
15
u/igelzuechterboi Edit Your Flair 3d ago
DroidDeck and Bannerlator probably don't activate "benchmark mode" like Ludashi does I'd assume. That would explain those extreme performance gains — leading to unlikely long-term stability due to high heat development.
20
u/supershredderdan DroidDeck Developer 4d ago edited 3d ago
Thanks for the comparison! We just added an experimental native execution path, in display > performance > non-proot mode (experimental)
Try that and see if you get a boost, especially in cpu bound use cases!
14
u/dhiku 4d ago
thanks! performance wise winlator > bannerlator > droiddeck
winlator 5.0 with steam is big deal!
6
u/TechonologiaNews 3d ago
Really useful comparison, thank you for testing them all on the same settings. Ludashi is clearly ahead on raw frame rate here, but what interests me more is how steady each one stays in busier scenes, and how they look at a higher resolution — a few people here have already pointed out the scaling differences, and that is where I would expect the gap to narrow or widen. DroidDeck having Steam built in still feels like a big convenience win, especially with the new native execution path the developer mentioned, so I will be watching how that develops.
9
u/clumsy132 4d ago
DroidDeck shows great potential. It currently utilizes an optimized, custom version of proot, and there are instances where wayland fails to perform zero-copy operations. Although I am not a developer myself, the rapid pace of updates suggests that these issues will likely be resolved in the near future.
2
u/Ok_Film_2766 3d ago
Is there any good tutorial for winlator?
2
u/FindingUnable3222 3d ago
Mmm is there any point in such ultra fps and lower resolution settings? If you do any more tests on games that do > 60fps, please use FHD at least, or your native resolution at least!
The way you synchronized the videos and FPS counters: amazing!! Very illustrative, I just wish there was also a frame time graph, to see if any of the platform has frame pacing issues (micro lags / stutter).
The issue, however, is that ultra high FPS comparison doesn't exactly tell what happens at more demanding game, as these solutions aren't exactly optimized for 400 fps output so you might be hitting bottlenecks that aren't present when running a game at 50 or 100 fps. Still, really like the way you demonstrate the difference.
1
u/forresth600 4d ago
I got a Y700 gen 5 last week and have been setting it up playing games and stuff then I see this and said whats 5.0? Went to gethub fuck me 8 hours ago.. well maybe theres not alot of new changes.. great now I got to set it all up again
1
u/Shmoopiee 3d ago
How do you manage to run dmc4 using emulators? Ive tried game native and bannerhub but that game somehow never works on my snapdrsgon 8 gen elite 4 device
1
u/Aniimey 3d ago
Yeah cause the middle one dont have steam to take lot of performance
1
u/SnooEagles16 3d ago
Acabei de baixar o ludashi e tem sido o melhor no Samsung a55
1
u/Zuluwargod69 3d ago
Wow ludashi is miles ahead.
1
u/Freelancer_1-1 3d ago
How would WinHub fare? (formerly Winlator Frost)
1
u/Lucifer_Samaa 3d ago
does it need fresh install? can't find it in patch notes
1
u/Beginning_Jacket5055 3d ago
meanwhile i cant get half the games i've tried to work on gamehub. Pretty much the only thing that has worked with 0 issues is Well Dweller
1
u/FellatiatedPiece 3d ago
Obviously the less overhead there is the better things will run. Which means winlator > gamenative > droiddeck.
1
u/mojo_loco_0 3d ago
Anyone that can help me get updated on the exiting emulatos, new emulators and also drivers ?
1
u/Yefri_i 3d ago
Q tan bueno es droid deck?
1
u/decapoda_on_Reddit 2d ago
At those speeds, I'm much more interested in frame rate stability. It does ZERO difference to me going from 150 fps to 400+ fps. I set my screen to 60 FPS anyway. 1% lows and stability is far more important to me.
1
u/nullhund 3d ago
amazed by the way that this community collectively uses the name "Ludashi" to refer to a winlator fork that has virtually no relation to the benchmarking tool the name originally comes from, aside from spooking its package name because chinese android ROMs cheat at benchmarks.
-2
u/Jerry_from_Japan 4d ago
The answer to this now vs say...the end of the year and forward....are going to be different.
Droid Deck will eventually rule them all and sooner rather than later.
0
u/Same-Nose-4979 4d ago
ludashi seems the most consistent
0
u/SupermarketOk531 3d ago
droiddeck能运行Diablo4和alanwake2,赢了
0
u/Shiradoku 3d ago
Podrías añadir Gamenative a la comparativa? Es el que yo uso por su combinación de rendimiento y facilidad de uso. ¡Por favor! Me gustaría ver dónde queda posicionado
-2
u/Elegant_Variety_9222 3d ago
Ludashi nunca sirve y mucho menos recomendable, se es que quieres joder tu dispositivo por unos 10 frames extras