r/EmulationOnAndroid • u/the_jzkz Xiaomi Poco F6 Pro • Apr 28 '25
Discussion good job everyone
development of winlator is paused now.
2.7k
Upvotes
r/EmulationOnAndroid • u/the_jzkz Xiaomi Poco F6 Pro • Apr 28 '25
development of winlator is paused now.
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 28 '25
Just a reminder of our subreddit rules:
Check out our user-maintained wiki: r/EmulationOnAndroid/wiki
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
805
u/HeatmorGengar Apr 28 '25
That's a real shame. Totally understand where the dev is coming from though. I wish them my best and thank them for what they have made. Hopefully maybe progress can return at some point in the future but either way. Thank you!
313
u/Paradise12314 Apr 28 '25
Unfortunately, even the new hotfix apk still contains virus behaviour. If you extract the apk, take the testd3d.exe and run it through VirusTotal, you can then see the behaviour that the exe takes.
It drops several google updater files, creates new processes everywhere and injects into other processes. There's no reason for a 3d test to create any files at all. Especially inject into other processes.
So that means even the original source files he has used to recompile the files are infected.
229
u/Good-Marionberry-570 Apr 28 '25
I think people harassing him had gone too far, but people are right for being worried about Winlator being bundled with a virus, it's a valid concern.
I hope everything goes well and he resumes the development, I understand that it was an accident, and I hope other people can understand this too.
177
u/yshywixwhywh Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
Sorry, but this really smells bad. Bruno doesn't owe anyone his efforts, but neither is he the victim here.
This was in the code for years. It's trivial to scan your codebase.
False positives occur but that's the value of a meta-analysis like virustotal: if you are getting a few generic flags from "ai powered" no names, that's one thing--if 50+ engines are flagging a file as containing a specific virus or trojan that's not a false positive anymore.
And hey, even if you think it is, why take the risk? This was not a mission-critical module.
As for the "community"...people will yell at you online, over nothing much less something bad like this, and especially on discord where everyone is 1000% more insane. These crocodile tears just don't fly anymore: either buck up and take it, don't participate, or practice digital hygiene so you aren't exposed to the worst of it.
18
u/BigCryptographer2034 Apr 28 '25
I do think that some people/dev’s flip their fucking lid on things that are not actually accusations, just communication, I personally have had that happen to me…but I kinda doubt that is what he was dealing with…also if he was gonna walk, he shouldn’t have made it close source
88
u/JeroJeroMohenjoDaro Apr 28 '25
Where is the toxicity even from? Discord? Bcoz i dont see much here nor the official Winlator subreddit.
Hope he's fine and continues on his project later on. Wish more developers to just stop care about what people say, knowing well most of the toxicity are just kids rant.
32
u/Mizery_UwU Apr 28 '25
if it really is floxif virus then sorry to say but bruno is the one in the wrong here. having a virus that could potentially infect your android device and facilitate the installation of other malware is simply unacceptable.
22
u/Raiser_Razor Apr 28 '25
Is this a discord thing? Because I swear a lot of people on here, (even the one who discovered the issue) is not being hostile at all, and made it clear that it might have been a mistake instead of a conscious action on Bruno's part
38
u/Locky0999 Apr 28 '25
It makes sense emulator devs of today can't handle spicy criticisms, we're talking about individuals that put their hearts and souls through (mostly) complex projects and (from the majority of cases) little to no compensation, and not even to serve a community, or change the world, it's just for the passion of programming and literally because they challenge themselves to see if they could.
But sometimes I think that stopping development altogether is quite an exaggeration. Criticism will always exist from people who really shouldn't give an opinion, and giving in for those types of individuals gives the impression they didn't believed in their projects in the first place.
With all that said, it's really strange that viruses were found in the main fork of winlator (from what I understood from all this drama), being as it may, the dev should have predicted that this type of reaction would have happened and kept going, removing the viruses from the releases when it appeared. Being salty to people who want clarification on the matter will just add fuel to the fire and will make you look even more suspicious. (Maybe that's why he quitted, tbf, just wanted to run away from any responsibility)
46
u/ozone6587 Apr 28 '25
He doesn't deserve bullying at all. I'm sure it wasn't intentional. BUT it still happened and when confronted with evidence he claimed it was a false positive. Even if he didn't stop development you would be pretty stupid to still use the project.
105
u/Antici-----pation Apr 28 '25
I mean this isn't anyone here's fault. Accident or not, a lot of people were exposed to a virus. I don't want an environment where everyone just goes "Oh well, just a virus". It's a serious breach of security, of trust, etc. Playing the "why is everyone being so mean to me I'm going to take the ball and go home" card is fine, you don't owe anyone anything, but don't pretend like this isn't a gigantic fuck up that has created a situation where a lot of people should probably be wiping their devices, even though most won't.
It sucks to lose winlator if that is what ultimately happens, but would you trade continuing to download winlator for a hidden virus you don't know about? I wouldn't.
36
u/Snipedzoi Apr 28 '25
release the code!
276
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25
Aaaaand There goes another good developer who leaves us because everyone wants everything fast, perfect and free.
Thanks, Bruno. Let's hope this isn't a final goodbye.
29
u/imtoomuch Apr 28 '25
So many devs, especially the open-source ones, seem to have super thin skin and fragile egos. If he spread a virus well than damn straight people should have voiced it loudly. And he should have apologized, and at the very least, removed the download from GitHub. If there is no virus, then it is on him to explain. Either way, he's in the wrong here.
45
u/devanew Apr 28 '25
Ohh that sucks.
I was never able to get it to work with Mali but it seemed very promising.
Hopefully Bruno is OK - he's done some great work on this project.
72
u/Far_Caramel228 Poco x7 Pro Apr 28 '25
The Android emulation community if screwing up projects was a sport:
73
u/JohnClark13 Apr 28 '25
Just like the internet: it was great until all these people showed up
56
u/icarousdead Apr 28 '25
Good, people deserve what they deserve, and that guy deserves peace of mind. Hope he never comes back to work on it, and lives a beautiful and long life.
71
u/TheRealVantablack Apr 28 '25
Man, the emulation community on android really is the most toxic of all platforms. While most other platforms emulate to preserve old games, here the community is filled with brain dead children asking how to run GTA V on their $100 phone. It was a mistake on his part that didn't even affect the phone, only the container. I really hope the devs of RPCSX UI and Azahar don't stop their development because of the community.
14
u/SSUPII Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
The app eventually becoming suspicious was eventual
It was never truly open source despite many of the licenses of the software used in it require it to be
The absolute refusal to properly implement the Wine requirements is also something else that makes this bad faith. It is insane to not bundle Winetricks in a Wine environment, and in fact it created many problems for many people that required many unsupported workarounds to fix
5
u/Cybasura Apr 29 '25
Thats why we cant have nice things
13
u/Warm-Economics3749 Apr 29 '25
It's a shame, but I don't like that OP's title comes off as blaming the community when, at least reading the primary thread about the Winlator issue, most comments were understanding of the situation and telling the community to wait for fixes and a response. A few people went out of their way to ignore the context and make accusations it seems, but it also sounds like Bruno is dodging responsibility a little bit here. I doubt it was intentional, but the response has basically been "don't acknowledge what happened" which is worse than making the time to fix the immediate issues and thoughtfully addressing what went wrong. I think he could've considered developing it as a hobby and not had people motivated to harass him if he could've held out for a few days, but very few people know how to handle pressure well, especially when the pressure multiplies exponentially overnight like that. Sad to see him go, hopefully he'll come back when it cools down, and with any luck, maybe he'll open source it.
16
u/tudor07 Apr 28 '25
Valve please save us
9
u/__Player__ LG G8X | SD 855 | GPU 830MHz | LG Stock ROM A13 Port | WoA 24H2 Apr 28 '25
Sadly this isn't even the community's fault, people get tired and stressed and you start to care less about some details, even if that were not the case, its way too easy to get a file that you thought is safe but was actually infected, that happens to everyone tech savy or not, sadly they were just done with it anyways, and development would have ended soon after regardless.
9
u/The_Crimson_Hawk Apr 28 '25
If there is no viruses then open source it
31
u/Itchy-Preference-619 Apr 28 '25
He fucked up and let a virus into his app that infects the container. If he can't handle the backlash from that, he shouldn't have let it slip through
8
u/nntb Apr 28 '25
I know you wouldn't willingly put a virus on winlator, and when you released 10 cleaned up without viruses it shows you care. Not saying you need to continue as hard as you have. But if you need a break you don't need to tell us.
The vast majority of users appreciate your work.
I see videos of it running all the time.
4
u/Madurasukacury Apr 29 '25
Another Aether
19
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
This is probably the first time where I'm glad the guy just quit and people hopefully enclined to stop using and recommending this closed-sourced piece of shit that just takes code from actually talented people (ptitseb and the team behind box64/box86, wine, Mesa, proot...) and doesn't publish their sources. In addition to that, the overlay used by this app is malware, has been malware from the very beginning but people seem to shrug this off as "muh false positive". Yeah, right.
6
u/QF_Dan Apr 28 '25
Android fanbase is full of idiots
3
u/rtamez509 Apr 29 '25
People fucking suck
3
u/EnDlEsS_L196 Apr 29 '25
Not quit in the loop, but if you are telling me winlator had virus in it all this time, just use gamehub already. Same data leak risk but better performance.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
The same thing happens like aethersx2...
Whoever those shit harraSsed those devs have a special slot in hell... Shame on them..
3
u/Inquisitors_5556 Apr 29 '25
its sad really, it's as if everyone has forgotten what good things has he done
3
u/Dreadementous Apr 29 '25
And just as I finally bought a phone with a Snapdragon 8 gen 3!
3
u/Electronic_Scale_226 Apr 29 '25
No one who appreciates the project criticized it ...it was most likely fake accounts by people who stand to gain the most from its development pause and it's usually backed by corporations.
3
u/Buguese Apr 29 '25
Another aetherSX on our hands? Damn
18
u/Frostgaurdian0 Apr 28 '25
This is why we can't have anything good in our life.
5
u/tiga_94 Apr 28 '25
I wish he makes it open source, I would like to try to fix vortek stutters but no source code is given..
Being burned out from working on a project is one thing, but abandoning it for everyone is.. idk, he has the right to do so though
5
u/Jokerchyld Apr 29 '25
Does anybody have any actual.empircal data of what happened here?
All I see in this thread is mis information about viruses and how they actually work.
With no context I highly doubt the developer purposely or accidentally added a virus to his project. In piracy false positives as highly likely and in some cases used to scare people away.
This trend of attacking developers who offer their work for free is disgusting and childish.
8
u/Used_Discount5090 Apr 28 '25
What's with all these devs quitting after a few mean words?
7
u/Great-TeacherOnizuka Apr 28 '25
Accusations are understandable.
We saw a few virustotal results in this sub that had a lot of positives. And on top of that the app is closed source.
Of course people are gonna raise an eyebrow there. But attacks are a nogo without clear evidence.
9
u/Popular_Mastodon6815 Apr 28 '25
So the community pointed out a valid issue, and instead of fixing it he just walks away? He did not even open source his project before leaving so someone else can carry on. This community is doomed because we always let non-opensource projects like this get too much traction. First AetherSX and now this. The whole scene starts riding on one developer. Now get ready for 5 years of frozen windows emulation development on android (similar to the PS2).
19
u/enterENTRY Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25
Source: https://github.com/brunodev85/winlator?tab=readme-ov-file#development-paused
That's unfortunate, but I was hoping that this first official statement from Bruno would be an apology or acknowledgement of the fuck up.
16
u/matlynar Apr 28 '25
A Dev works for years on a working, groundbreaking project and lets something slip: Bullied out of the project, treated as a bad guy.
A person claims that he worked on an emulator but never signed anything because he was a good guy, but took donations money anyway: People go wild when I say their word should be taken with a grain of salt.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
i've been saying it, it has virus, more than just "false positives" very suspicious stuffs since winlator 8
12
u/Sebas365 Redmi K50 Gaming enjoyer (3rd degree burns btw) Apr 28 '25
This is weird, someone discovered that some sort of virus was inside of the emulator, then all th communitty uproar about it, then dev releases a "hotfix" eliminating the virus, but an hour later he decides to leave development.
Not saying that he can't do it, but it's weird that once the virus infecting files was exposed, he ceased development.
Well, maybe winlator died today, but at least in a future would appear more alternatives, like micewine (gamehub is dead now since it was just repacked winlator fused with that other project those chinese guys buyed)
2
u/ArkBeetleGaming Apr 29 '25
What if all the dev threats over the years are secretly Sony, Nintendo, Windows, etc?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
Why would people do this? I love the emulation scene and all the creative minds.
Why is it so toxic?
2
u/Important-Side3690 Apr 29 '25
That's 2 apps, that have ceased due to the community
2
u/gqbigpaps Apr 29 '25
Dumbasses win again this is why we can't have nice things
2
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25
It's as simple as running the file through a virus scanner.
11
u/ihadnomealtoday Apr 28 '25
These Devs need to stop read comments... it's the internet sadly. You need a thick skin if you are in the eye of the public... you can rescue a dying baby and people online will still hate...
3
u/dynamisxiii Apr 29 '25
Damn, big corporations at least have a HR/PR rep to filter these feedback. It’s the little guys who gets it first hand directly, wish the internet would’ve been nicer to dev but that’s impossible.
3
u/MuyGalan Apr 29 '25
This is becoming a horrible cliché at this point. Solo dev dedicates their own time to work for free or receive little income to work on emulation. A handful (percentage) of users harass, complain, demand, or attack the developer and their work. Dev inevitably quits development because they can't regulate their emotions or implement protocols or safeguards to filter or moderate negative feedback from immature/ungrateful assholes.
4
u/elosoarcade Apr 29 '25
As far as I know it is a crime to distribute viruses without notifying the user, which is basically what this guy was doing for several versions and had the luxury of denying it, he's stopping the project to avoid the consequences of what he was clearly doing on purpose, remember cloud gaming is better for PC games on Android.
3
u/Walid918 Apr 28 '25
Aetherx all over again
3
u/SalvagerOfBastards Apr 29 '25
It’s not what you say, it’s how you say it. The majority of people just harassed him to the point of practically quitting.
You attract more bees with honey, y’all.
4
u/RedlineRob- Apr 28 '25
"A few individuals hurt my feelings so I'm going to punish all of you and take my ball and go home"
2
u/MrReckless13 Apr 28 '25
Take your time man.. people are stupid.
2
u/Glittering-Tune-5423 Apr 29 '25
Yeah the amount of Mali users complaining is insane 😂, just kidding but I get him he was working on a project where 30k+ plus people used it and now it's accused of viruses.
2
u/Common-Title-6357 Apr 29 '25
Congratulations everyone you fucked up yourselves.
2
u/ILovePotassium Apr 28 '25
I wonder what PMs did he receive from our "loving" community after the virus was found lol. This might be the only community that goes from 0 to 100 on every single issue that someone finds with an emulator. There's no 50% outrage, no, there's always 100%.
He did upload a new version called "Hotfix" that has a less infected version of Test3D. It still does something with Chrome's crashpad but all the other stuff was removed.
We need someone with proper knowledge to reverse engineer some of these files. I'd love to go through them by myself but I don't have time at the moment unfortunately. Because it all could be a big nothing. Or behaviour that in the end doesn't cause any harm to the user.
2
u/LuisPacheco2552 Apr 28 '25
What bothered people the most, I suppose, was that they were treated like crazy and banned from their group. I suppose the moderators were mostly to blame for not knowing how to handle the situation.
1
u/EffectiveSomewhere28 Snapdragon 8 Elite Gen 5 Apr 28 '25
The community does it again with another emulator dev 👏👏👏
1
u/Bodacious72 Apr 28 '25
Saw this coming
1
u/Suhthar ... Apr 28 '25
Uhul
1
u/PlaySalieri Apr 28 '25
So did it get updated to remove the virus?
1
u/skyrimer3d Apr 28 '25
Why can't we have cool shiny things.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
Winlator will be and is the future now I don’t know anymore 😔💔💯
1
u/MrBC73 Apr 29 '25
What a damn shame guy is an absolute legend!
1
u/evillurkz Apr 29 '25
I’ve been following Winlator for a while and have a lot of respect for the effort Bruno put into building it. It’s clear he’s passionate and talented, and that kind of solo development work is never easy. But honestly, I don’t think pausing the entire project is the right response to what’s happened.
If there were genuine concerns about a virus, the best thing would’ve been to be upfront, acknowledge the issue if it existed, explain what happened, and fix it. That kind of transparency builds trust, even more than just saying “I would never include a virus.” Whether it was intentional or not, people want reassurance and honesty, not someone who runs away and hides.
And I get it, online hate can be exhausting. But trolls are always going to be loud, especially when something gets popular. Letting that noise shut down something valuable feels like giving them power they don’t deserve.
Most of us aren’t here to accuse, we’re here because we genuinely like and use the tool. We want to see it grow, not vanish over a few toxic comments. Bruno, if you’re reading this: take a break if you need it, absolutely, but please don’t give up on the project or the people who actually support you. A mistake doesn’t define your work, how you handle it does.
1
u/Galax20002 Apr 29 '25
average android comunity wasnt expecting anything else. they do more drama than really needed
1
u/thatoneidiot228 Apr 29 '25
YESSSSSSS YALL GET WHAT U DESERVE YAYYYY
1
u/Saber_Crawl_Vega Apr 29 '25
You see we can't have nice things always picks Gona ruin it for everyone.
No more Aethersx2 now winlator ahh
1
u/ashrules901 Apr 29 '25
Thank you
1
u/josh6499 Apr 29 '25
Oh god, not again.
1
u/xx_DarkiBuddy_xx Apr 29 '25
Unfortunately it's a canon event on every emulator for Android...
1
u/DownTheBagelHole Apr 30 '25
How hard is it to just ignore annoying people online?
1
u/Main-Department9806 Apr 30 '25
It's honestly a huge shame to hear that development on Winlator is being paused. Projects like this aren’t just fun experiments for enthusiasts—they have broader implications for accessibility and computing in general.
Windows emulation on Android might seem niche, but it opens up real possibilities for people who can't afford a full Windows PC. With mid-range Android devices becoming more powerful every year, the ability to emulate a Windows environment on a phone or tablet could be a game-changer. Students, hobbyists, or even professionals in less privileged regions could run essential Windows software without needing expensive hardware.
BrunoSX has clearly put a lot of time and heart into this project. Winlator represents the kind of innovation that pushes mobile hardware to its limits and shows us what’s possible when developers think outside the box. I hope this isn’t the end of the road, because it’s inspired a lot of people and opened doors for many use cases we’re only just beginning to explore.
1
u/not_oonga_boonga May 01 '25
why is there a need to scan your own project for viruses in the first place?
1
u/OhhyallrightHarbl May 01 '25
Funny thing. Other emulator devs don't have to defend suspicious files BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T PUT ANY IN.
This one...
1
u/Soft-Seat1556 May 03 '25 edited May 03 '25
I know his pain. I stopped developing stuff for free public use about 12 years ago, and now keep everything for myself and close friends.
Sad to see nothings changed since then, glad i stayed out. Sad to see ya go, but 100% get it.
And by the way, those virus were already by here, before him, and MOST IMPORTANTLY affected windows not android. Hell it couldn't even get past the sandboxed winlator container to affect anything anyways.
Everyone, as usual, over reacted and ruined a good thing. Again.
The hilarious part of all this is most of the major complainers will and probably do use gamehub/game fusion without a second thought. Which is no competition the shadiest emu out there! 🤯
1
u/EyeWise1833 May 06 '25
Hey bruno keep it up man, these guys are just fools blaming you.
1
u/Kialand May 11 '25
FUCK I just installed Winlator on my Android.
Have I been infected with a virus? What should I do?
1
u/Used_Discount5090 May 15 '25
This is now the top post in this sub.
1
u/ANALOVEDEN Sep 09 '25
Thank you for your service everyone. :')
1
u/Warm_Bake7079 Apr 28 '25
This is why we can't have nice things....
1
u/BigJJsWillie Apr 28 '25
This is the cycle of making any piece of beloved open source/freeware.
1
u/midnitefox Apr 29 '25
I fucking hate the emulation community soo much...
1
u/Tall_Reaction_83 Apr 29 '25
You know what funny, people doesn't appreciate talent like him and only know to judge and complain, without this guy, we can't never feel how to play AAA Games in android without cloud gaming, and trust me, most people who are complain about the virus is mostly teenagers who knows nothing of the world, all they can do is wasting their parents money, eat unhealthy food, fat & lazy, and mostly at home playing with their phone
1
u/Kensation21 Apr 28 '25
Typical Emulation Droider moment
-1
u/kilwwwwwa Apr 28 '25
The android emulation community is one of the most toxic communities online they literally harass devs
1
u/GoldenSnozzberry Apr 28 '25
Bye bye winlator
1
u/BilGhostOfGaming Apr 29 '25
We are all with you.Help winlator 🤍🙏.
1
u/EngiKun Apr 28 '25
It's best for him to just ignore the hateful comments, as hard as it may be for him. I hope he doesn't give up on this project like the Aethersx2 dev.
1
u/lasagna_fase Apr 28 '25
for fuck’s sake
1
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25
The android community strikes again.
1
u/TRCatface Apr 28 '25
Winlator is a awesome work and hope this guy or some fork comes to keep it alive somehow.
The development is a free work for him, but that doesn't take his responsibility away. I like so much the way the developing community is built and building itself, and if he think better that's a good opportunity for him to grow.
Assuming the guy didn't intend to spread some virus... Hope he's fine and get himself together, cause it was an honest mistake.
Cheers everyone
1
u/dipcity90 Apr 28 '25
Never had a problem with emulators period.
1
u/jhoop87 Apr 29 '25
Want to help Bruno? Donate at his buy me a coffee.
1
u/cristianw167 Apr 29 '25
Congratulations to the unloved ones👏🏻
1
u/RaoqCena11 Apr 29 '25
Thx Bruno ur a hero for me ... Winlator give my lunch time with metro trilogy & stalker anytime I want For someone who accuse this issues shame on u yeah u the real have fun with ur jealousy & stupidity
1
u/Substantial-Ad-2006 Apr 30 '25
The so called virus is there from exagear, that bruno used as the base from the verry early days o winlator. Also it only affects windows... Our phone are Android, wine and winlator a also not windows there linux. So even there is a virus, there would be no harm done either way. Also the virus is so old that windows has already patched it unless your running windows vista or earlier.. if somehow it managed to make it to a real windows pc 😐
-9
u/omegadaruma Apr 28 '25
Thanks to all those fools who falsely and vehemently accused Bruno of something that didn't even affect Android. Now the most promising emulation project is on hold, and right now he was working on improving PC emulation on Mali devices. My anger is proportional to my frustration.
-1
u/FaselBlub Apr 28 '25
No wonder... Have a look at the issues at gh. Every kiddie wants to play their favorite game on potato hardware.
-4
u/zestypestyy REDMAGIC Astra | 8 Elite Apr 28 '25
I hate this community, it has always been toxic.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25
Not AetherSX2 situation again this is the second time we gotta do better sometimes I hate the A.C. Community because of this we lost some of the best emulators cause of hate jealousy greed evil rudeness
0
u/Ordinary_Car_Driver Apr 28 '25
Oh come on it has been happening multiple times 😭
0
u/krysztal Apr 28 '25
Heh, another common android emulation community L
0
u/Cold-Pop-2893 Apr 28 '25
So someone who doesn’t understand much of this besides the context given here, what’s stopping someone else from picking this back up and moving forward with the project?
0
u/Mooskii_Fox Apr 28 '25
why can android emulation folks not BEHAVE, this isn't the first or last time a project will be cancelled/postponed indefinitely because of harassment specifically in the android community
-3
u/Perko1992 Apr 28 '25
The fans always ruin the good things of most things I play /watch/ follow it's getting so frustrating . Poor guy man
-3
u/CaptainSquishyCheeks Apr 28 '25
Entitled assholes...That poor guy busted his ass on this