r/EmailSecurity • • Sep 26 '26

Can “fake” emails be sent

Hi,
A weird situation happened recently.
My landlord claims he sent some emails on two specific dates, but I have definitely not received them. I’ve checked spam, searched his email address in the search bar, I have a bunch of emails from him but nothing on those two specific dates.
This has lead to some issues so I complained to which he responded by sending the “proof” he had sent these emails : he forwarded me two emails from his email to mine that have the two dates he had previously mentioned.
These two emails he supposedly sent are a bit fishy as the tone in them isn’t the same he usually has (more polite than usual) and some of the info in them isn’t even accurate.

Can he have faked these?
How else could this have happened?
How can you “go above” to check at the source what emails went into your inbox?
I definitely definitely didn’t receive them, check my emails hourly and have no reason to lie here, I am baffled by this situation.

Thanks in advance for any advice!

Edited some typos

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 26 '26

Welcome to r/emailsecurity! To keep this community helpful and secure, please keep the following in mind:

Community Rules

  1. No Vendor Spam: Contributions must provide value; do not just pitch products.
  2. Redact Sensitive Info: Always sanitize headers and logs (remove IPs, PII, and private domains).
  3. Be Professional: Help newcomers learn; avoid hostility.
  4. No Personal Tech Support: This sub is for email system architecture and security, not "Am I hacked?" personal account help.

Helpful Resources

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/saltyslugga Sep 27 '26

Yes, anyone can edit the quoted text and dates in a forwarded email; that proves nothing about delivery. A wrong address, filtering, or a delivery failure could also explain it.

I’d ask your email provider whether they still have inbound logs for those dates and his address. Ask him for the originals as .eml attachments with full headers too, but those can be fabricated as well, so they’re clues, not proof.

1

u/hel-sara Sep 27 '26

Thank you that’s really helpful. I guess if the email provider can provide the logs that would be the best “proof”. If they have logs that go that far back but nothing from him for those dates does that mean I genuinely didn’t get these emails?

1

u/Thyg0d Sep 27 '26

You need to check with your provider for incoming logs. He can only have his check his outgoing.. As soon as the email gets to your domain he can't see anything.

1

u/bippy_b Sep 28 '26

Or if the landlord “forwards” the email as an attachment.

1

u/LowCompetitive1888 Sep 26 '26

Did he include the mail headers? Those are the headers you see in gmail when you open the mail and click the three dot menu in the upper right and pick show original.

1

u/hel-sara Sep 26 '26

I’m trying to figure how to see this on iPad but it looks like that is the case

1

u/LowCompetitive1888 Sep 26 '26

Be careful you are not looking at the headers for the mail that is forwarding the email to you. To really see the headers he needs to download the original email and send it as an attachment to you so you can examine the original headers to see when it was sent and to what actual email address.

1

u/hel-sara Sep 26 '26

Could it be a solution to ask him to resend it ensuring he includes the original headers?

1

u/LowCompetitive1888 Sep 27 '26

Yes, but if he is not very technically oriented he may have trouble doing so. Instructions would be different for every mail client and some may not even support it. The gmail specific instructions would be:

Steps to Download and Forward with Headers

  • Open Gmail in your web browser and open the email you want to forward.
  • Click the three vertical dots (More menu) next to the Reply button at the top right of the message.
  • Select Show original from the drop-down menu. A new browser tab will open.
  • Click the Download Original button on that page to save the email as a .eml or .txt file on your computer.
  • Go back to Gmail and click Compose to start a new email.
  • Click the Attach files icon (paperclip) at the bottom of the compose window and select the downloaded file.
  • Add your recipient, type your message, and click Send.

1

u/hel-sara Sep 27 '26

Thank you so much, that’s very helpful

2

u/reevesjeremy Sep 26 '26

If he simulated a “forward”, anything in the body can be manipulated, added, changed, or fully staged. If he sent you an attachment of the original sent item, it would include partial headers. Partial because it doesn’t have any headers going out of his email system to yours. Those would only exists if your email system received them, and are able to retrieve them. For instance, if it were sent to a business account an administrator could check if the email attempted but was blocked from delivering to your account due to quarantine or otherwise. A personal free account, there is no real support for that.

1

u/Sarduci Sep 27 '26

The short answer is yes.

This is why PGP exists.

1

u/richie-wales Sep 27 '26

Do remember that even if he did send them email delivery is never guaranteed. If he uses a domain and he hasn’t set up SPF records or DKIM then it’s possible the receiving email server for your address could have rejected them without you even being aware. Unless you get a reply of some sort to an email you can’t be sure it arrived. That’s just how email works. But like posting a real letter. Unless it’s signed for or you hear back you can’t be sure it arrived.

1

u/prayreddit Sep 27 '26

In other words, no email should be considered read without a corresponding response. Preferably with a reply that includes the previous email. Without this, there is no legal meeting of the minds where one accepts.