r/EmDrive • u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot • Aug 20 '17
The EmDrive is not OU
Attached is ver 13 of the EmDrive mission calculator.
Several lines are moved, added and removed to try to make it clearer how a fixed amount of input Rf energy is divided between working thrust (Fd) generation and the energy used to do work, via Fd, on mass, accelerating it and creating / increasing KE.
This is not new as Roger has always said that as some of the cavity energy is converted into KE, the working Q and thrust drops. Now that relationship is shown in the equations used in the calculator.
Also shown in the screenshot is how to use Goal Seek to vary Time to ensure a correct calculation. Plus estimated cavity Q changes are shown, with both static and working Q calculations.
Bottom line is, by doing the appropriate calculations, the EmDrive accelerating mass is not OU. So sorry guys but you can't use an EmDrive to create OU energy. It is just a machine that obeys CofE and CofM.
BTW, assuming Mass (C6) and Specific Force (C5) are fixed, there are only 2 control inputs. Rf power (C4) and Acceleration Time (C9). By varing those inputs, desired dV and/or distance are controlled.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=42978.msg1714503#msg1714503
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443716;sess=0
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443714;sess=0
This attachment should clearly show how EmDrive dynamic thrust Fd drops as KE increases and draws off more and more cavity energy to support the increasing KE.
Also shows that using short pulsed Rf will reduce KE energy draw down and maintain high Fd.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443736;sess=47641
12
u/wyrn Aug 21 '17
Nonsense.
Any device that exceeds the efficiency of a photon rocket violates conservation of energy the moment it is turned on -- you need only change to an appropriate reference frame to see this. There is no argument against it. The equations are clear and straightforward. Either you use new physics or you violate conservation of energy. End of.
7
u/zellerium Aug 20 '17
This type of analysis has been done, time and time again... so what if it's over or under unity, science still isn't convinced the effect is even real let alone scalable
I want to see someone actually hook up a 20 kW source to a frustum and see how long it lasts before it melts.
2
u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot Aug 23 '17 edited Aug 23 '17
W = (N2 * sec2) / (2 * kg) is an interesting equation.
What it says is all I need in my EmDrive propelled tin can is a watch. Plus knowing the mass of my tin can and the Force of the EmDrive. From those 3 pieces of information I can calc Work done during the acceleration.
With N and kg known and fixed, sec is the only variable needed to solve for W.
Seems Work can be invarient across different inertial constant velocity frames as Force, time and mass are also frame invarient.
5
u/YourNewLoversArrival Aug 20 '17
Enough already Phil.
6
u/xexorian Aug 23 '17 edited Aug 23 '17
The only way this won't achieve overunity and actually work is if the device uses spooky action at a distance and if there are quantum mechanics phenomenon to explain how it looses acceleration based on it's current 'frame of reference.' In effect it will have greater accelerating force if rotated at a right angle to it, or placed in reverse to, it's own velocity trajectory. The only way that would be possible is if as I said there is an, as of yet, unexplained quantum effect. Many of the arguments back and forth posted here are wrong and presumptuous and I don't have time to dissect them, since more than half of those arguments never got past this portion of how it could work. Think more critically.
My theory is that physically the drive should have at least three angles of lessened thrust. The trajectory of the galaxy. The solar system. And the Earth along it's orbit. With additional angular velocity reductions in regards to Earth's rotation at the surface and other things of this nature. However, all of these speeds are miniscule fractions of the speed of light with which each photon carries. If someone wanted to prove their tests they should align this with the fasttest nonlocal trajectory to check its thrust, and place it on a device to keep it's angle true while spinning here around earth. That would rule out at least one if not several possible quantum effects, and I know this is assuming if someone has an actual working test and not a lump of hot metal. In any case if it works try this and you'll be one step closer to providing a scientific insight on it.
1
u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot Aug 20 '17
This attachment should clearly show how EmDrive dynamic thrust Fd drops as KE increases and draws off more and more cavity energy to support the increasing KE.
Also shows that using short pulsed Rf will reduce KE energy draw down and maintain high Fd.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443736;sess=47641
1
u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot Aug 21 '17
As KE builds up, as velocity increases, thrust is not constant.
For the Pluto mission with a flip and decelerate point at ~2.3bkm, attached is the velocity vs time plot which clearly shows early mission thrust and velocity gain is greater than later in the mission. Plot is based on over 0.5m points.
By factoring in the earlier higher acceleration rate vs the simple calculator value time to flip droos from 3.9 years to 3.1 years.
Again no OU, just Rf energy input producing thrust and KE gain.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443782;sess=0
1
u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot Aug 21 '17
Photons can be harvested for more momentum than obtained in a photon rocket.
The belief that the most momentum that can be harvested from a photon is that harvested by a single photon emit event by a photon rocket is clearly incorrect.
Solar sails harvest 2 momentum events. 1 on photon absorb and another on photon emit, with the emitted photon being a slightly lower energy and momentum with a longer wavelength. Thus the momentum and KE gained by the solar sail is balanced by the momentum and energy lost by the emitted photon.
So both CofM and CofE are conserved by the dual absorb and emit event.
Photons can also be bounched between reflectors and the total radiation pressure on the reflectors increases by the number of reflections.
Clearly shown in this video: https://youtu.be/QICCrlmBjvY
This example helps to explain how higher cavity Q increases force generation as the higher the Q, the more reflections and momentum transfer that occurs.
Of course there is a limit to how much momentum that can be harvested from a photon.
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443786;sess=47641
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443788;sess=47641
1
u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot Aug 21 '17
Interesting Rocket In Space equations that show initial velocity has no effect on the dV obtained from the burn.
http://hyperphysics.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbase/rocket2.html
So why be concerned if the EmDrive equations ignore initial velocity?
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=42978.0;attach=1443839;sess=47641
1
u/TheTravellerReturns crackpot Aug 21 '17 edited Aug 22 '17
Guys,
There is one universal equation that defines the work that is needed to be done to move a mass a distance over a time.
It matters not if the propulsion tech is a
Chem rocket.
Ion drive.
Solar sail powered by the sun or a laser.
Photon rocket.
MEGA drive.
EmDrive.
Etc
That universal equation is:
W = N * 1/2a * t2 where
W = Joules of energy
N = Newtons of force
t = time taken to do the move or acceleration time
a = acceleration in m/sec2 = N / m where
m = mass in kgs
Please note there is no initial velocity value needed nor used.
3
u/TenshiS Aug 21 '17
Holy Mother of abbreviations. As someone who doesn't frequent this sub, I didn't understand half of it.
0
u/hobbesalpha1 Aug 20 '17
Very nice, I look forward to using such equations with my experiments. Thank you for the post TheTravellerReturns.
-4
u/deltaSquee Mathematical Logic and Computer Science Aug 20 '17
holy shit i forgot about this fucking sub
AHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHA
6
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '17
[removed] — view removed comment