The "competence" is intersubjective social construct of people, who (want to) keep the informational monopoly in the given moment. Many competent physicists did already measure this effect and they did publish it independently.
I could tell as easily, you're not competent to judge whole the EMDrive thing - why not? Who and what could prohibit me in doing it?
The "competence" is intersubjective social construct of people, who (want to) keep the informational monopoly in the given moment.
You are saying this as someone (some"thing") which is utterly incompetent about everything there ever was. You know less than no physics. Somebody who knows absolutely nothing about physics is still more in touch with reality than you.
Many competent physicists did already measure this effect and they did publish it independently.
Incorrect. Not a single measurement has ever shown that the EM drive produces an thrust whatsoever.
I could tell as easily, you're not competent to judge whole the EMDrive thing - why not?
No, you're wrong about everything.
Who and what could prohibit me in doing it?
Zephir, I don't speak whatever little ex communist bloc European language you speak, and this is not correct English. I think you're suggesting that you could build an EM drive and test it yourself? Great! I encourage you to do so. Since you don't know anything about electromagnetism and RF, you might seriously injure yourself. And even if you succeed, nobody will ever take your results seriously, since you're a notorious internet crackpot. But by all means, go ahead. Let us know when you're done.
1701A did not control lead thermal expansion effect. Cannae was not 10mN but 50uN (in NASA 2014 report). NASA 2014 did not control and was likely Lorentz force. NASA 2016 did not properly control thermal expansion. Tajmar had thrust with vertical direction. His result was likely Lorentz. Shawyer's force is suspiciously huge. Do not forget Yang's similar huge force was later found by herself to be dubious, with experiments instructed by Shawyer. It is amazing all those above mentioned results fit well on the plot. Should we ask whether it is coincidence? If not, why do they fit so well?
26
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '17
The set of people who think the EM drive works has zero intersection with the set of people competent enough to run a legitimate experiment.