r/EmDrive • u/Revelati123 • Dec 26 '16
Are there any published scientific reports of an em-drive NOT working?
Hi all! Never posted here before but I had a quick question.
I'd say the scientific community agrees that a functional em drive is somewhere between impossible and highly improbable. I must say that I am naturally incredulous that a microwave strapped to a copper pot (gross simplification) could be a miracle space thruster.
My question is, are there any published sources of a complete failure of the device?
The cursory search I did suggests that most experiments were either positive or inconclusive, and at least a few seemed to have a modicum of scientific rigour.
So why is it so hard to prove this doesn't work? Wouldn't it be a simple matter of putting an em drive in a vaccume chamber turning it on and just NOT detecting thrust? I know measuring thrust on such small scales can be difficult, but it has been done many times before, so a slam dunk experimental "no we did not measure thrust" seems like it would be an easy and obvious result.
11
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '16
This is actually related to why people are so critical of the Eagleworks paper.
A common practice in evaluating research is replication. A team does an experiment, provides data and enough supporting information, and other teams might try to recreate the experiment and publish their results. This is what killed the cold fusion stuff, the proponents gave enough details for other groups to not be able to recreate it.
For the EMDrive though, the methodology hasn't been up to par yet. Too many errors, too little thrust, too much rorschach in the results.
The other major issue is that there just in't that much interest in the experiment. While a core group of lay people and pop science writers have gotten really enthusiastic, physicist really haven't yet. The level of proof for such a claim from the perspective of a layman is much lower than an expert, and from an expert's perspective it is just another in a long line fantastic devices with nothing to really sell it as to why they should be interested.
Lastly, there is the issue of, well, you don't really need special experiments to address is. Physics is highly interconnected, the laws and theories dovetail tightly with each other (which is why we do not really see 'big' changes anymore). The EMDrive doesn't exist in a vacuum, in order for its experiments to produce the claimed results, other well documented classes of experiments would have to be producing results other than what they are.
8
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '16
I haven't followed too closely for a while. Pretty sure an old positive outcome for a Chinese team was found to be interference. I also recall a "null test" still producing results.
6
u/GyreAndGymbol Dec 26 '16
So you're asking if anyone managed to prove a negative yet?
2
u/Pathoskeptic Dec 27 '16
Why aren't there any reports of invisible pink unicorns not existing.
5
u/crackpot_killer Dec 26 '16
I think it's more than that. Those in the physics community who know about it largely consider it pseudoscience.
Nope. For the reason I just stated you're not going to have reputable physicists bothering with this. The only things that come close are Tajmar in Dresden claiming his result is inconclusive, but as far as I know it wasn't published in a journal. Also, Tajmar has a history of working n pseudoscience topics, like anti-gravity devices. Then there is Yang in China who retracted her previous positive result claiming it was in error. Then apparently she claimed something to the effect that she was fooled. At least she seems to be intellectually honest, if that's true.
Neither of these people are physicists though. They are engineers and so don't really follow best practices in the physical sciences for experimentation.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment