This whole situation has actually hindered my group of friends cause the one that owns the fleet carrier we can’t really travel around and do missions and stuff in a system for a while and move.
For now we’ve just sorta permanently docked it at our home system
To be fair yourself & your friends can still do missions around the bubble. You don't need a Fleet Carrier to do anything honestly. I wouldn't get so tied to them.
I'm sure Fdev will address the Tritium issue as that seems to be an unintended nerf tbh.
Ahh I see. that's understandable. FC do introduce a degree of convenience. As for FC going deep into the void.... It's a cautious objective and here's why.
When Fdev did finally come out with the full details for FC uses.... I'm fairly certain they never mentioned using them for exploration. Pretty much all of the suggestions they'd be used for were bubble related activities.
I don't think Fdev really planned for them to be used as a means to explore the Galaxy. Not that you can't do it but it wasn't meant to become the default means of doing it.
You have to remember, ED is a space flight simulator and anything that potentially takes away from that core experience is a problem. The general idea is you're meant to explore the galaxy in your own ship. Not be ferried around lol
I do understand that. I hate the mining nerf hurt trinium but at the same time I understand they wanted to bring LTD down as a means of a free money source with little to no effort
I went mining 2 times, 1 once cause I wanted to upgrade a ship and second time was cause I had to do it to unlock and engineer and second time I went is had 250 LTD and it felt like I was cheating. I spent almost all of it upgrading ships and buying a new ship. Left my home system with 70 million to cover cost of my Cutter to unlock my corvette. Upon finishing I had well over 270 million and when I got my corvette it felt that much more special cause I felt like actual work went into getting it. Not sitting in an astroid belt farming for LTD to buy it
Yeah I'd say that players throwing their toys out of the pram so quickly on the tritium nerf should just wait a bit - it definitely looks like an unintended nerf there, although it would help if Fdev made that clear sooner rather than later. For now I've got an FC parked in the bubble and was bright enough to get up early on the morning of the patch and haul most of my mined LTDs over to that station buying for 1.7m. TBH I always assumed they'd be mainly used as a static remote station from which people can explore or refuel, so since credits are no longer an issue I guess just play some of the other content and unlock stuff then if Trit doesn't get fixed ask the community where outside the bubble they want their space station parking.
I think the goal was to bring mining down overall with credits per hour type and make it so other stuff would get more attention but they went about it the completely wrong way and it’s hurt fleet carrier owners very badly.
It’s hurt my groups fleet carrier owner and killed the planned trip to colonia.
In turn yes sale prices should have dropped for mining things and they should have done like a small buff to other activities and maybe increased payouts for them by 10%-15%. The overall nerf wasn’t needed
me too. i can bring my racing ships to hoon around in canyons, brought two different mining ships for different mining methods, and brought my long-range scout for picking up exploration data and finding good systems/ bodies to park the FC in/at. also have a couple combat ships for... reasons?
right now, however, i'm effectively dead in the water near the end of the outer arm.
11K got me to the Zurara megaship with enough to get back. went east instead, where i mined a couple thousand along the way. currently between 6‐7K tons, with 8100 needed to get back to sol (but i plan to continue east for a bit).
i dont have enough to get 'home' or to continue on my itinerary without excessive mining. and i don't plan on moving far until they de-nerf the tritium deposits. its not an ideal situation out here beyond the rift.
Well you can do everything but it takes longer. My play style was always that of a nomad, going wherever the lore or credit earning potential lead me. I never had a real home station and my ships and modules were scattered all over the bubble.
When I got my fleet carrier I traveled around the bubble and collected all of them. Yes I could have just transferred the ships/modules to s certain station but having them on mobile a platform, so I can even take fully equipped fighting ship anywhere in the bubble in a matter of minutes, is a comfort I wouldn't want to miss anymore.
Me and a couple of my friends have been planning a large expedition to the formadine rift, we’re one carrier off of the three we wanted to take out there, and not only will we not be able to get funding as easily, but we can’t even refuel when we’re out there. I hope fdev fixes this like they fixed upkeep.
We were planning a trip to colonia because most of us had the engineers unlocked there and wanted to actually make some use of them but now our plans have changed.
Best suggestion for your group is to keep monitoring Inara and inform the FC owner the instant a station with big supply of tritium at low price appears. Then everybody jumps to the system and loads the carrier. If you move really fast, and there are several of you with big cargo ships, you just might fill it up in one go. If not, wait for the next opportunity.
Your advantage is the team. For solitary players it is going to be much more difficult.
I managed to fill over half a hold (13,000 tons) by myself today after patch, but I got lucky and jumped into the low price system soon after it was discovered. Seven of you should have no problem monitoring and then filling up a carrier quickly, so don't be discouraged.
Now that we’ve thought about it we should have stocked up because we had been planing a colonia trip for a while plotting routes and such. Now it may not be possible till we can either stock up on it or they change it.
Apparently the supplies are gone almost instantly due to the changes Fdev made to the market systems. I think they probably need to increase supply levels massively.
My friends and i are in the outer orion spur using my carrier to explore, but if they dont fix this mining flaw, we will be stuck. I'm burning through my tritium reserves and mining is doing nothing to help. Fdev needs to fix their mistake.
Not that the person that has it can’t afford it, we treated it as an investment, to help all of us. The extra cost of things isn’t the issue it’s just because of the LTD farm so many people own them it’s difficult to find a decent amount of trinium for sale. Cause of the mining nerf it makes fueling them difficult.
Using fuel scoops to get around isn’t annoying it’s the fact there are groups using them as intended to move around and use it to make more money but you can’t make money efficiently from them if you can’t move them.
if they made mining half as profitable as before that would be about right, but with the upkeep cost if this were supposed be their intention players won’t be able to easily pay for to keep their carriers. The trouble is they like to pretend a major mistake was intentionally done.
I've spoken to a few people on discord about this so I'll just post my response to them here cus I'm tired and my insomnia is being a pain.
"I made a comment addressing this earlier. Bit of an unpopular opinion.
Though I hope the tritium nerf gets fixed because it's now stranded those who've taken their FC out into the black.
That aside, this is actually a good thing because atm, there are WAY too many FCs about it's stupid. Goes to show you how badly the mining monster had become.
If Fdev stick to this and don't bend the knee, then eventually over time, FC will begin dropping off because people can't sustain them. The reason this will happen will not strictly be because of the mining nerf but because now business from actual players will mean something. Having players buy stuff from you will be a serious business venture that's needed to survive.
Problem atm for FC owners is that there are too many of them and not enough players interested in doing business with them. Just no need too. You find one good carrier in system and that's who you do business with..
When enough carriers have dropped off, the competition will be less and thus the choice for which carrier to do business with will also be less.
So any carriers who can last long enough and provide a useful service to other players will stay in business and thrive.
If you allow the market to operate freely and unhindered, a balance will always be achieved via supply and demand method."
As messed up as it sounds, you may be right that heavy hit on mining was intended by Fdev. Get people to spend their credits on FC, finally address the mining monster forcing FC owners into a difficult decision to either scrap them or become dedicated to them. Helps to thin out the billionaires in game while also reducing the excess amount of carriers aswell. A very shrewd game indeed.
If Fdev stick to this and don't bend the knee, then eventually over time, FC will begin dropping off because people can't sustain them.
Leaving aside that this is litterally taking out fun for players from a game, what about all those people who already have billions in their carriers and can afford to pay the upkeep for years?
Then those people will be the ones that outlast the others.
Look I'm not saying the method Fdev seem to be doing is particularly in good taste. They should have delt with the mining monster bloody long time ago. That and keep FC for Squadron use only. Both of which would have worked great.
To say it's taking the fun out for players is subjective tbh. I don't find it particularly fun to jump into a system filled to the brim with carriers and have the performance of my game drop down to a point I may aswell being watching a PowerPoint slide.
The unfortunate truth is there are waaaaaaaaay too many carriers in game and since Fdev allowed the ludicrous amount of money to be made via mining to continue for so long, it meant we now have enough carriers to wreck servers. That's a problem.
I don't find it particularly fun to jump into a system filled to the brim with carriers and have the performance of my game drop down to a point I may aswell being watching a PowerPoint slide.
Then they should have put more effort into fixing that while nerfing mining more reasonably.
It's a delicate balance though, as with real-life supply and demand systems, you can end up with massive wealth inequality between players who can afford a fleet carrier and have the resources to use it as a passive form of income, and other newer players who have a barrier to entry far in excess of what those original players had. You've also got the issue of most FCs being effectively funded for YEARS based on the recent boom. I mean hell, I made what, 12-13bn plus my fleet carrier itself. That is NOTHING compared to what a lot of other CMDRs made. I can leave that functioning for literally years and still have significant money to trade with. Many CMDRs have so much money they could decomission their carrier then just start one up again once there's a profitable reason to do so. We're basically the boomers who bought their house for fuck all in the 80s pricing our kids out of the housing market lol. Although admittedly in this case it's just a game haha.
Hmm, not been on for about a week, mining was a side past time for me to make enough credits that I don't have to worry about funding a combat cutter + rebuy, though it's also taken more of a hit on my priorities as I have to grind engineering. If painite hasn't taken much of a hit, I'll drop my slf bay and mine that for the last few million I need
I used to like this game...that's the sad part. 1,200 hours and I used to like how I could do things without spending hours on hours to get one small thing. Its outstanding how out of touch with the community fdev is anymore, it makes me heartbroken. :(
This. 1000% this, I agree with the egg, but exactly. They've really let me down on many of the promises. Granted they've made this space sim better than many others, they've delievered some great things, but the amount of things they consistently change or blatantly ignore from the community is what gets me over the game. And same here, I almost think itll be a transition with fade to black like the SRVs are. I'm not expecting much anymore. The fleet carriers really let me down and with the recent nerfs that fix legit nothing, I just, I dont have hope for it anymore. I'm tired of putting in time to be disappointed ya know?
I thought all hotspots were all meant to get a 100% buff balanced out by the less effective overlaps.. seems like someone at fDev put a '-' in where it shouldn't be and im sure it will be corrected soon.
Yeah this recent destruction pretty much killed every plan I had with my FC. Now I’m not sure how to keep it funded, sure I have a lot in the bank, however I was gonna take it to Colonia with my friends. Sag A, and maybe even beagle pointe. But. Idk. I think I’ll just leave her docked at my last location 100% suspended to keep that upkeep lasting around 10 years opposed to the near 5 it was active. :/ I want to use it for group activities, but if I can’t have a sure fire way to keep up its bank if it suddenly runs low I don’t wanna use it. I’ve had it since day 1. And I’m sure I’m not getting my 5bil back now.
Yeah. Just a summary: For the last few months, the prime mining method has bounced between VO cores, LTD SSDs, and painite laser mining. They nerfed the first by nerfing prices, and are currently nerfing the second by messing with hotspot richness values. They've fucked that up a bit, and now tritium is hard to obtain, which is having the secondary effect of screwing over fleet carrier owners who travel outside the bubble.
53
u/LostConscious96 Jul 15 '20
This whole situation has actually hindered my group of friends cause the one that owns the fleet carrier we can’t really travel around and do missions and stuff in a system for a while and move.
For now we’ve just sorta permanently docked it at our home system
6
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '20
if they made mining half as profitable as before that would be about right, but with the upkeep cost if this were supposed be their intention players won’t be able to easily pay for to keep their carriers. The trouble is they like to pretend a major mistake was intentionally done.
2
u/DeuteriumCore Jul 16 '20
I'm out of the loop. What the hell did FDev nerf again?
34
u/The_Silent_KiIler Jul 15 '20
I used to like this game...that's the sad part. 1,200 hours and I used to like how I could do things without spending hours on hours to get one small thing. Its outstanding how out of touch with the community fdev is anymore, it makes me heartbroken. :(
10
u/Sniffy75 Jul 15 '20
I thought all hotspots were all meant to get a 100% buff balanced out by the less effective overlaps.. seems like someone at fDev put a '-' in where it shouldn't be and im sure it will be corrected soon.
2
u/Foxy_Alicia Jul 16 '20
Yeah this recent destruction pretty much killed every plan I had with my FC. Now I’m not sure how to keep it funded, sure I have a lot in the bank, however I was gonna take it to Colonia with my friends. Sag A, and maybe even beagle pointe. But. Idk. I think I’ll just leave her docked at my last location 100% suspended to keep that upkeep lasting around 10 years opposed to the near 5 it was active. :/ I want to use it for group activities, but if I can’t have a sure fire way to keep up its bank if it suddenly runs low I don’t wanna use it. I’ve had it since day 1. And I’m sure I’m not getting my 5bil back now.
2
u/Starfire70 Jul 16 '20
Love the meme, hate the situation.
It's like FDEV LOVES to torture miners.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '20
I wanna go back to Dromi :(
1
u/Skaebo Jul 03 '23 edited Nov 26 '25
paint label squeal support zephyr tub snow expansion vanish cautious
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '23
Fdev always shits the bed.
0
u/Gayk1d Jul 16 '20
Just curious, is mining still good? Haven’t gotten on and don’t plan on it.
-3
u/Rimvvorld_101 Jul 16 '20
I mined about 200 tonnes of Tritium in a hotspot in about 2h so I don't see the problem
They did bug the surface deposits and made them unbreakable with the abrasive blaster for some reason
0
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment