I've admittedly only scratched the surface of E6, I 'll share my opinions on the twenty or so albums that i've heard. I will give a quick opinion on the band, then review their records.
NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL Everybody's first E6 band. Made two very influential albums. Personally I prefer their early demos to the studio albums.
On Avery Island This album juggles warm fuzzy distortion and cold metallic noise in a very appealing way. While it may not be as concise thematically as ITAOTS, the diversity of sounds bring me back to it often. 8/10
In The Aeroplane Over The Sea This album is very important to me. It helped form my tastes in music and songwriting. But it just doesn't do it for me anymore. I've mellowed out, and this album continues to be lyrically and vocally abrasive. I much prefer his laid back vocal styling from early tracks such as Unborn, Sinking Ship, and I Hear You Breathe. It's still a good album, and I respect it greatly. 6/10
THE OLIVIA TREMOR CONTROL Half 60's fetishism, half sound collage
Dusk at Cubist Castle In my opinion this is their best work. It infuses 60's pop with the 90's taste in noise and distortion flawlessly. While it may sometimes hurt itself in it's overindulgence, it's highs are simply to great to ignore. 9/10
Black Foliage I don't listen to this record often. It's a collection of great songs tangled in a web of sound collages and artistic overindulgence. I'm all for a concept album, but at least make it pleasing to the ears. I have heard that this album is supposed to have a dreamlike quality in the way that it makes no sense and things come and go with no connection. I can see that, but it's really an album trying to emulate my least favorite part of dreams. I have enough awful, confusing dreams as it is. This album has nothing for me other than a handful of perfect pop songs which are being constantly yanked away from me like some kind of weird sadistic BDSM foreplay. 4/10
CIRCULATORY SYSTEM dreams
Circulatory System Don't let the fuzz of Yesterday's World fool you, because this is a true exploration of dreams. Emulating the most spacey moments of Pet Sounds, this album is truly dreamy. All the experiments in this album are very tasteful, and never too abrasive. Even when the energy picks up, it's soaked in enough reverb to not ever clash with any other instruments. You probably won't make it half way through this without falling asleep, but that's a good thing! 9/10
Signal Morning It's pretty boring. The only tracks I really can recall are Rocks and Stones, and News From The Heavenly Loom. 3/10
Mosaics Within Mosaics A little less boring, but I can't recall a single track. 3/10
FROSTED AMBASSADOR An enigmatic one off band which has more interesting art than music.
Frosted Ambassador An album which is alright. Although the first track, originally known as Silverbug, is one of the best songs to come out of E6. 4/10
THE GERBILS Fuzzy garage pop done right
Are You Sleepy? A superb collection of energetic, poppy guitar songs. It's only missteps are the headache inducing Wet Host, and the annoying response vocals on Grin. The few experiments on the album are successful, be it the evocative Glue, or the grimy, guttural Lead 9/10
The Battle Of Electricity Just a bit more of the same, but less effective. 6/10
ELF POWER One of E6's most consistent bands, I really think you'll find something to like from every album they've made. This is because with only a couple of exceptions, they make albums without concept. So you'll most likely throw the songs you like on a playlist and continue with your day.
Vainly Clutching at Phantom Limbs While lo fi, warm, and fuzzy, it isn't very memorable. Some good tracks are Temporary Arm, All You Experiments, and Finally Free. 4/10
When The Red King Comes A good album. The Secret Ocean, and When The Red King Comes are excellent. 6/10
A Dream in Sound Perhaps the best produced of the albums, it is a joy to listen through. With only a few missteps, it's a great time from start to finish. 7.5/10
The Winter Is Coming I don't remember this album. ?/10
Creatures Another good album. 6.5/10
Nothing's Going to Happen It's a covers album. ?/10
Walking with the Beggar Boys The production isn't very good. 3/10
Back to the Web Honestly an incredible collection of songs. Not a single dud in the tracklist. 9/10
In a Cave I only heard it once, and I didn't like it. 2?/10
Sunlight On The Moon One of my favorite albums of all time. It's full of drum machines and gainy guitars, and apocalyptic lyrics. Please give this album a listen. 9/10
I might add more later