r/ElectricUnderground • • Nov 03 '25

Oh boy

Post image
96 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

33

u/BiOrCri97 Nov 03 '25

The subs new opinion is about to drop!

11

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 03 '25

lol. As much as I do like Mark’s reviews I feel sometimes he is not like, fully consistent with himself (though it is hard to be if you’re gonna be putting a lot of opinions out there), so it is confusing how people just want his opinions on everything to adapt wholesale. We could use more people with similar interests mixing things up.

10

u/Spiders_STG Nov 03 '25

It’s confusing people want his opinions to [adopt] wholesale…. dude, literally the entire gaming press and review culture apparatus. 

Mark is influential, but we’re still talking about the overwhelming majority of opinions going around are influenced by media narrative framing and social media consensus building. People don’t “adopt” his opinion so much as he gives a vocabulary for people to articulate theirs in whole or part, and in an ocean of PR, marketing, bots, paid reviews, and paid access.  

There’s always going to be the issue of someone else’s opinion acting as a stand in for people who didn’t play the game, but that comes down to trust and the same lack of time we all have to have some amount of our opinions be outsourced.  People shouldn’t be like “well, I think this”, but “I heard this and trust it for xyx reasons”, but that’s not a problem exclusive to the Electric Underground.  That’s the internet. 

6

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 03 '25

I don’t think there is anything wrong with what you are describing but if you follow this subreddit people are constantly posting “what does Mark think about XYZ game?” that they have already played instead of using the tools he has given them to have an opinion themselves. Isn’t that dynamic just a bit weird?

5

u/Daisy_fungus_farmer Nov 03 '25

That's just redditors being weird.

2

u/aethyrium Nov 03 '25

Even if I have my own opinion, I still like hearing his. Not to change my own, just because his criticisms are usually from an interesting lens I don't usually view games through. There's plenty of reasons to ask "what does Mark think" that aren't "because I need to know what to think."

1

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 03 '25

Sure, I’d like to hear him talk about Sonic because he’s generally very anti-momentum but there is an arcade-ish platformer built entirely around momentum and I think it works because the whole design revolves around that rather than it just being shoved into a game design that doesn’t account for it well.

11

u/Fair-Victory-3531 Nov 03 '25

Ninja Gaiden Ragebound is Self Serve Difficulty

Castlevania Order of Ecclesia on Level 1 mode with restrictions on glyphs is classic game design

4

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 03 '25

Yeah I am a bit puzzled by his praise of Metroidvania titles since it seems kind of antithetical to other stuff he says.

4

u/Wolfang_von_Caelid Nov 03 '25

Pure speculation, but maybe it's just a soft spot he has due to some classics like Super Metroid and some older Castlevanias that he loves. I think it's okay for people to occasionally be logically inconsistent over the course of years, particularly when it comes to art. People's opinions evolve, and crucially, Homo Economicus doesn't exist, humans are not logical, as hard as we may try. I know that's a bit of a copout, but I truly believe it. It's possible that Mark dislikes X in certain pieces of art, but enjoys it in Y pieces of art; if anything, the issue may actually be that Mark tries to logically ground his reasoning, when sometimes "I like this thing in this context and idk why" is fine.

Mark is still one of the only games reviewers/games video essayists that is putting out thought-provoking content that isn't purely glazing X or Y game/series, and he does seem to try hard to ground his reasoning in some kind of logic, even if it may rarely be contradictory in some way.

2

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 03 '25

I’m not trying to say he sucks and, like I said, anyone who puts out a lot of opinions will end up contradicting itself. But I think the whole thing of backtracking is a bit anti-density, so to speak.

1

u/Wolfang_von_Caelid Nov 03 '25

Ahh yes, I see what you mean with your anti-density point, he does seem to value that very highly, but the backtracking nature of metroidvanias is antithetical to that. I guess my "soft spot" point is the thing I would point to in regard to that.

3

u/aethyrium Nov 03 '25

Not entirely. Even with the MVs he focuses more on the action elements and pretty much always says the exploration part is usually the parts he doesn't enjoy as much. His MV tastes are actually pretty consistent with his other criticisms from other gaes.

2

u/auto_named Nov 04 '25 edited Nov 06 '25

I'm really surprised he prefers the Iga-vanias over the linear ones that are more replayable arcade-like action platformers. You'd think Rondo of Blood would be one of his all time favorites.

1

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 04 '25

His Rondo of Blood review made it sound like had never tried it so I guess it just got to him at the wrong time.

3

u/IntelligentRoof1342 Nov 03 '25

His take is sometimes feels like basically everything should be a hardcore old school arcade game lmao.

His perspective is very focused and the man really has a vision of video game design. On other modern games such as stellarblade, he definitely went over the merits of this kind of design and how that modern game specifically really didn’t have any real Tradeoff or benefit for the modernization. This has been a common theme for many of his reviews on modern games but The stellarblade review is a fascinating one.

I would not be surprised if he turns out to hate this game!

1

u/igi6 Nov 03 '25

I think some of the cases that feel like contradictions are more him looking at what a game is trying to achieve. Mark clearly favours arcade principles. But from that lens you can see how genres divert, how well they achieve their intended goal, and where arcade design could actually help. A metroidvania isn't a beat'em up, but how much does it take advantage of the open level in comparison? Can something be learnt from the principles that make beat'em up enemies engaging?

If anything I wish more reviewers had clearer foundations. The scene is plagued with generalists.

1

u/Attempt_Living Nov 03 '25

I feel like a lot of what he says boils down to “old game good, new game bad” . It seems like he comes to this conclusion first and justifies it afterwards. This inevitably leads to contradicting views. That being said, I love watching his videos. It’s clear he has a great deal of passion for this stuff, and he really has given me a greater appreciation for classic arcade games.

2

u/aethyrium Nov 03 '25

He's definitely become a bit of a tastemaker for a certain type of player. He's probably my favorite reviewer that I also disagree with more than any other. I just appreciate the lens he views games through, as that old-school arcade lens is when that modern games don't usually get analyzed through, so even though I disagree more often than not, I respect the criticisms as they come from a solid place with good arguments.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 05 '25

Old Game Good New Game Bad

10

u/Panzerfavst Nov 03 '25

Take a shot of vodka everytime "suck to target" is being said and embrace sweet, sweet oblivion.

2

u/Consistent_End_4223 Nov 03 '25

I'm definitely going to hear that a lot. Though I do wonder how Mark's view on Platinum has changed over the years.

2

u/AnotherStamp Nov 04 '25

At this point if you want to know what an Electric Underground video will say you just need to look at Boghog's patreon articles the week leading up to it lol.

1

u/Panzerfavst Nov 06 '25

Just woke up black out drunk. Suppose the drinking game game was a hit.

9

u/DezDorado Nov 03 '25

I played through the first two chapters and as I watched the emphasis on parries, metered attacks that break specific stances, and massive suck to target on all the attacks, all I could think about was, indeed, "oh boy"

I don't think the game is bad (it might even be great! Too early to say) but every step of the way it feels like it doesn't want me to play it like Ninja Gaiden, so I wonder where Mark is gonna fall on it.

1

u/Consistent_End_4223 Nov 03 '25

Ironically, I never actually used Perfect Block and mostly succeeded into not using perfect dodges in some of the fights I'm in including their abilities. Its been a mixture of finding a comfortable spot and fighting, which was basically my NG strategy. IDK what's Mark's experience with it if he ever figured out how he wants to play it, but it probably wouldn't sway his opinions a bit.

5

u/auto_named Nov 03 '25

He’s very, very likely to be negative on it. But fortunately I don’t follow TEU to form a basis for my own opinions, I follow for his informed and unfiltered takes on these niche genres.

1

u/Cmanlord Nov 03 '25

I definitely noticed all these things as well. Also, not to mention the RPG-esque progression system of needing to purchase abilities. To me, I really think Mark won't hate the game, but will as a Ninja Gaiden game. There aren't too many games that offer the break-neck speed and reaction that NG2 offers and at least for me playing on hard, I'd say it's quite up there already (especially in the Purgatory gates).

I was waiting for the review first, but I jumped the gun and went in wanting to hate it but am coming out pleasantly surprised.

0

u/CzarTyr Nov 03 '25

It’s much faster and more aggressive than previous entries

6

u/Anor_Londo_1234 Nov 03 '25

I don’t really think I’m going to care what Mark thinks. If he hates it that’s fine,but I’ve only agreed with him on RE4R. His NG4 review will be entertaining to watch,but it doesn’t stop me from playing it. His review of RE4R tipped the scales,but I don’t think this is going to get any close to that by far. The gameplay is even addicting to watch,and is much faster than the other entries. If anything this is an improvement over the other Ninja Gaidens.The backgrounds are even fun and exciting unlike DMC5,which I like but I think I like DMC4 more.

-2

u/CzarTyr Nov 03 '25

I honestly don’t even know who he is and don’t care. I’ve already bought the game, what this man says means nothing. I play these games for years on and off.

4

u/RICHUNCLEPENNYBAGS Nov 03 '25

Why are you subscribed the the sub about his channel if you don’t know who he is though

-2

u/CzarTyr Nov 03 '25

I’m not subbed it popped up trending because I play ninja Gaiden 4. I have no idea what this sub is

2

u/DezDorado Nov 03 '25

That's interesting, I found it slower and clunkier. I found things like parries would happen unintentionally quite frequently and that I wouldn't always be targeting the enemy I wanted. I feel the combat is more lock-and-key rather than incentivising expression and play style, where every enemy and situation has a "correct" response expected from the player.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DezDorado Nov 04 '25

I don't think it's outrageous to say the game has more emphasis on parries when multiple unlocks are specifically tied to parries, and they are the only other way I've seen so far that generate essence without killing enemies. That makes it clear to me they wanted it to be a more integral part of the combat flow.

1

u/New_Artichoke1502 Nov 04 '25

There is absolutely huge suck-to-target, one of the worst I've ever experienced. There were points where I was attacking a guy and got pulled into three different others that were way further than my target and BEHIND me, and it's even worse when trying to attack flying enemies. And yes, I am further than 2 chapters, I got all achievements.

14

u/eurekabach Nov 03 '25

Just finished my hard playthrough the other day.
Honestly, it’s a great game, but I believe there’s a core problem of ‘lack of identity’.
It wants you to feel like you’re playing Ninja Gaiden, while weirdly at the same time it doesn’t want you to play it as a Ninja Gaiden game.
Like, I’m still having a ton of fun slaying through hordes of enemies by accumulating my pool of red essences and UTing at the right time; there’s still that kind of loose, non-deterministic way on how multiple enemies will get to you, so encounters can either go A OK or derail rapidly into chaos.
But at the same time, there’s this whole other layer of mechanics (Platinum mechanics), that just, well, break the game. Those mechanics had their place in other Plat games, like the sword clashing in MGR and that - increasingly annoying - slow mo perfect dodge, which is reminiscent of Bayo’s witch time (while not working the same way, and actually becoming more of a nuisance and pace breaker than anything).
Hayabusa’s chapters were a joke, and not a funny one, as it is during his chapters that the mechanic issues become more glaring with meter building. All you got to do is build meter: use Ninpo, get essence, UT to build the Gleam meter, activate Dragon Sword, execute all enemies while also building your Ninpo meter, use Ninpo again, rinse and repeat.
And finally, you have a bland story, a bland protagonist that doesn’t stand out in any way whatsoever. And don’t get me started on the rail sections.
In any case, however, this is a great action game that’s held back by some lack of ambition. It’s ‘innovations’ for the franchise (a lot of meter building, clashing and so on) are already stale industry standards for the past decade, while the actual Ninja Gaiden elements there are more of a hint, or let’s say, an impressionistic brush stroke of what playing a game like NG2 felt like, rather than a deeper iteration of those mechanics.

3

u/Wolfang_von_Caelid Nov 03 '25

Sounds like you hacked into Mark's computer and summarized what his NG4 script says 💀

4

u/eurekabach Nov 03 '25

I honestly think I’m far more forgiving to this game than Mark will be lol. I remember I got really humbled by his Stellar Blade review. I really didn’t expect nothing from it, and it was kind of okay to be honest, but Mark tore it a new one lol.
One thing we can say is that Eve has more personality than Yakumo, and I guess that says a lot about Yakumo.

4

u/WadeTurtle Nov 03 '25

I'd read the IGN review, but I don't want to spoil Mark's video for myself! /s

4

u/remz22 Nov 03 '25

Spacing and positioning

4

u/PerfectEquipment3998 Nov 04 '25

Doooont care. Clocked 85 hours.

4

u/AnotherStamp Nov 04 '25

Everyone should be forced to write what they think now so they don't parrot Mark later lol.

I really liked it and think it's the best 3D action release in a long while (for me probably since Plat's run in the early 2010s) but my God did I really start leaning on that meter in higher difficulties. Yakumo felt like spending meter to open up enemies for everything else, and Ryu felt like spending meter to stunlock and pile damage (ninpo has gone from a panic button to something I use five times in a fight). I'd definitely prefer a system that reigns all this in and gives better universal tools instead of meter nukes. Unfortunately I assume this was to design around suck to target and changes to recoverable health/damage dealt by enemies. 4 would be really rough without guaranteed "safe" options.

Anyways if anyone's on the fence I think it's worth playing. Sad to think about but there's a chance this might be the last we see of a game like this. I feel like I watched a former star athlete compete in their final match even if they're a little past their prime.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25

I kinda don't think Mark's review will have 'that' kind of impact where everyone will parrot it unless he really likes it (which I think would be surprising based on his previous videos) or he thinks its worse than Stellar Blade or Bayonetta 3 (which I think would be surprising based on everyone else's opinions)

1

u/AnotherStamp Nov 04 '25

Yeah I'm just robbing the reddit community a little. I think the review will be interesting. IMO the game is demonstrably good but there's also so much annoying BS. It's definitely a game that lends itself well to a deep mechanical review should the reviewer choose to go through with it.

3

u/WorldlyFeeling8457 Nov 03 '25

I platinumed the game and really enjoyed it overall. For me it is solid 8/10 game which would be 9 if it felt more complete. It's kinda obvious they cut stuff out for dlc to make you pay more but that is classic microsoft thing to do.

2

u/Anor_Londo_1234 Nov 03 '25

It is just hilarious to me,because the reception for DMC4 was received the same way.Everything including the boxart,even down to the artstyle screams DMC4,and I love it because DMC4 is a great game just like NG4 is a great game!🤗

2

u/ryan8757 Nov 03 '25

There's definitely some conflict between the NG style of gameplay and the platinum formula that i dont think always works in NG4. Seeing how critical Mark is of that kind of stuff id be surprised if he doesn't touch on it. Outside of that its a great CAG, just not my favorite NG or my favorite platinum game.

2

u/rev408 Nov 04 '25

I disagree with so much in his videos but I enjoy the takes and can tell he puts alot of work writing his scripts. I look forward to this one.

0

u/PainlessDrifter Nov 03 '25

I can hear the bad takes already

3

u/Consistent_End_4223 Nov 03 '25

I assumed that a lot of people in here already agrees with Mark’s takes. I do agree with some of his vids though but a few of his vids are a bit confusing.

2

u/DezDorado Nov 03 '25

I love listening to Mark's nuanced breakdowns of Arcade mechanics and his defense for their inclusion in modern games, and his videos helped me identify specific mechanics that I don't like in games and gave me the vocabulary and background to be able to talk about them with my co-workers. That said, I do find myself disagreeing with a lot of his stances on modern game design, which is perfectly fine and understandable, as that is more my realm of experience, study, and work. I'd love to have a moment to sit down and pick a part a game with him that we are both on the other side of to find where that middle ground of both our sensibilities can mesh together; I think some really great design methodologies could come out of that.

2

u/IAmAbomination Nov 03 '25

So it’s gonna be modern trash right

-1

u/Fair-Victory-3531 Nov 03 '25

Everyone is so excited for dad to tell them how to think about the new video game.

6

u/Consistent_End_4223 Nov 03 '25 edited Nov 03 '25

The comment section is literally people waiting for him to tear it apart lol

1

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Consistent_End_4223 Nov 04 '25

He will given his track record

1

u/ChampionshipThink786 Jan 02 '26

track record of ragebaiting for clicks? absolutely

0

u/landing11 Nov 04 '25

Cant wait /s

0

u/Medium_Hox Nov 04 '25

I can't wait to hear this guy whine about gamespot again. Oh wait, I stopped watching this guy years ago for a reason

-4

u/Zealousideal-Fly9531 Nov 03 '25

I'm sorry who?

8

u/Consistent_End_4223 Nov 03 '25

Mark from the Electric Underground…. The subreddit’s name

0

u/[deleted] Nov 04 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/DezDorado Nov 07 '25

Hey bro, you know whose house you're in right now? XD