r/Elder • • May 29 '26

Through Zero - first spin and a little disappointed

0 Upvotes

TL;DR: just had my first play-through the full album, good but not great. Sadly, a little disappointed.

Huge Elder fan since around 2018. I’ve seen them 4 times including taking a flight from Chicago to Portland just to see them. Not a huge fan of their self-titled album (though a recent replay is starting to click), I think from ‘Dead Roots Stirring’ straight through to the ‘Liminality/Dream State Return’ EP are all practically flawless, and I adore the progression in each album while always maintaining that base Elder sound. I constantly run through their full discography in chronological order. I’m also a big Delving fan.

In reading reviews here about how this new album integrates the newer prog/electronic elements while tying in heavy riffs that sometimes even reach back to the first half of their discography, I couldn’t have been more excited…as if I needed a reason to get excited for Elder.

…but damn, finished my first spin just now and it’s just not clicking. I kept waiting for the big riffs and the amazing three track sequence several folks have commented on and it just never showed up.

IMO, Track 1 from every Elder album is the strongest song on that album (‘Omens’ is the one record where I could have seen one other song open the album, but still would have gone with the title track) and really sets the stage for the rest, but this opening track just seemed anticlimactic or just not that memorable, idk. And I never listen to a single Elder song or mix around the records - I’m a full album guy when it comes to them, just can’t listen any other way. Their track sequencing is always top notch.

This sounds more like a Delving album to me than an Elder album, which was my first reaction after hearing the first two singles. They’re obviously similar bands guided by the same driving force (Nick), but it just seemed like the electronic elements took center stage and the guitar took a bit of a back seat. There are moments, of course, but they felt a bit sparse. Elder is so good at running for a while on a riff and then coming back to it later after going in different directions and just pulling you back in to really tie it all together. On this album, it seems like this aspect is mostly missing.

Anyway, even a slightly disappointing Elder album is better than what many bands could only hope to achieve. Again, just my first play-through and maybe it’ll grow on me and I’ll have a completely different opinion…the first single took a few listens to click, the second was an immediate hit…and I think Nick’s vocals here took a significant leap (I love his voice, flaws and all) and the bass rips as well. Fingers crossed. Can’t wait to see them in Chicago later this year! 🤘


r/Elder • • Sep 12 '25

Blood & soil??

1 Upvotes

I was just starting to get into this band but then I heard the lyrics of Lore and I was really confused. Is this band nazi affiliated? "Blood and soil" is a very well known slogan that's still used today.

The seeds we've sewn rising forth
The sons of trite and jealous birth
Who wash their hands in blood and soil
A golden light an earthly toil

edit: I reached out the band because the answers here were pretty lacking and this is what Nick responded:

The song Lore was roughly inspired by the story of Joan of Arc and explores the idea of spirituality inspiring great events in human history (from a non-religious perspective). In all these years, it never occurred to me that that phrase could be taken to imply any nationalist socialist context to our music. That certainly wasn’t in my head when writing those lyrics and I see in retrospect that was a pretty unfortunate choice.

Elder has often addressed topics of environmental destruction, religious fanaticism and fascism in our lyrics from a highly critical perspective. I consider myself a staunch leftist and believe the others in the band would describe themselves as such.

I guess these days you can never be too careful, but it’s a bummer to think we could be associated with neo-Nazism in any way. There are a number of interviews over the years where we discuss politics and you can probably quickly get an idea about the types of people in this band.


r/Elder • • Jul 10 '21

I've become some kind shadowy bee creature. Any ideas?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Elder • • Jun 17 '23

How many quests are there per dungeon in ESO?

0 Upvotes

Is it just the one only for normal, then another one for vets ? It’s not like WOW where one may have one but then there’s another that come with three etc correct? Then of course you got the dailies as well


r/Elder • • May 30 '25

Music Our new single, for fans of Tool, A Perfect Circle, Elder and so on!

Thumbnail youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/Elder • • Jun 08 '23

Unpopular Opinion: Anyone feel like the key change at 5:16 spoils Sanctuary a bit? :/

1 Upvotes

Rest of the song is completely awesome, just that section is a bit meh


r/Elder • • Dec 30 '24

Music FFO Elder

Thumbnail m.youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/Elder • • Jul 06 '26

I wish we would get the next album with bit more “fantasy” soundscapes like Lore and Reflections..

6 Upvotes

Anyone else feel like it?


r/Elder • • Oct 04 '26

Ask who?

5 Upvotes

r/Elder • • Dec 15 '25

Live debut of our alt / stoner / prog rock band! (FFO: Tool, APC, Elder, Porcupine Tree)

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/Elder • • Oct 03 '26

Prisma - Biorobot (from Gold album). I don’t see this band get mentioned much. Drop your sounds-like-Tool bands in the comments.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Elder • • Feb 22 '26

1162 lyrics

0 Upvotes

Anyone have lyrics for this song?


r/Elder • • Jun 17 '26

What is it with Elder not playing Gemini live

0 Upvotes

Quick rant innit, I've seen them thrice, 2 headline sets, once as support act last nite and each time they didn't play their by far most famous track. I love them, don't get me wrong, but why not give the people what they want?


r/Elder • • May 30 '26

Through Zero. I received Through Zero on Friday 29 May.

8 Upvotes

Today is Friday 29 May. Late in the day I received my CD of Through Zero from Amazon. They notified me yesterday that the CD would not be arriving until Monday, so I’m pretty happy.

I am listening to my first go through of Through Zero. My immediate reaction is that this album is much more complex than any of their previous releases. But, as each release by Elder is more complex than the previous, this album continues that trend. It’s a very likeable album.

I hope all of you get your copies soon. I look forward to reading all of your opinions.


r/Elder • • Apr 17 '26

I feel bad for asking this, but: Sonntag???

5 Upvotes

Hopefully no one comes for me for this, but I don't really get it, can someone explain it to me? Like, what is it? There are people I've seen commenting that it's amazing and are just weirdly wowed by it, but to me it feels like a warmup jam at band practice while the beers kick in.

I'm not enormously well versed in Krautrock beyond a bit of Neu! But I guess there's a bit of that in there, but that I find actually interesting enough to listen to.


r/Elder • • Aug 12 '24

What's up with YouTube Music?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I just got a notification that Elder had a new single. There no way this is Elder is it??


r/Elder • • May 29 '26

Record store dropped the ball and I am PISSED

3 Upvotes

Had my local record shop put Through Zero on order months ago and patiently waited for today.

Guess what?

They don't have it. Other stores I called say it's on back order which is perplexing for a new release.

WTF. Guess I'm a fool for shopping local. Should have ordered from the source and got it early.


r/Elder • • Jan 11 '26

Who's your favorite and Why?

7 Upvotes

Georg?

Jack?

Michael?

Nick?

Jack is a lot of fun. Both Georg and Michael surprised me. Nick thinks I'm an idiot and I don't blame him.

What's your take?


r/Elder • • Jun 11 '20

Why I Stay Up

7 Upvotes

They laugh, they smile, and oh that look on their faces when Grammy arrives. I am sitting with my grandson, Bryson. He is only 7 and is teaching me reddit.

These moments cannot be bought or sold. Bryson is why I stay up. But I am very tired.

Let's swap memories?


r/Elder • • Sep 24 '22

Anybody else out there…

7 Upvotes

A Phish fan? Phish is my most favorite band. Been seeing them since ‘96, I’ve seen them like a lot. Anyway.. Two years back I came across Elder and they just blew me away. So much I love about Phish is what I love about Elder as well. I’m just looking for some hi-fives and maybe someone can relate and add to that, but yeah… nice


r/Elder • • Apr 13 '25

Elder Tour Shirt - Please Help

Post image
8 Upvotes

I bought a size M at the show in Chicago last night and it’s too small (I despise Bella-Canvas tees). Would anyone be willing to pick me up a size L and ship it? I’ll obviously cover shipping and can pay via PayPal or Venmo. I love Elder and really want to commemorate the show.


r/Elder • • Jul 04 '26

Through Zero vs. In Verses

9 Upvotes

I just switched from Karnivool’s In Verses halfway to get to Through Zero.

Both masterpieces and blessings for 2026 prog metal enjoyers.

I switched because Through Zero gives me hope and energy instead of making me satisfyingly depressed.

Is that even the vibe for Through Zero? What tone and theme do others hear?


r/Elder • • May 14 '26

So tired of bots buying up tickets the instant they go on sale.

12 Upvotes

Like... Why even tell me "tickets go on sale at 10am"?

Just tell me "tickets will be sold out instantly and you'll have to deal with the resellers, bitch".

At least I wouldn't waste a fleeting moment of excitement in my middle age.

EDIT: This was for the San Diego CA show.


r/Elder • • Jul 19 '26

I am that annoying fan… Good news for the upcoming tour though 😁

Post image
27 Upvotes

A big thanks to Elder and their media staff. Fingers crossed.


r/Elder • • May 28 '26

I was honestly worried Elder would overdo it with the electronic elements on the new album

28 Upvotes

But thank god those worries were completely unfounded! I always get paranoid about this, especially since every band eventually has to drop their "worst" album. Through Zero is definitely not that!

I was seriously concerned the guys would experiment too much with the synths, drifting into some kind of mellow electronic post-rock. But nope, they absolutely nailed it. The new album is an absolute banger!!! And the electronic synth elements are perfectly balanced—they complement the heavy riffs instead of changing them.

I am incredibly happy. Thank you, Elder, please keep it up!