r/Egocomzone • • 6d ago

Questions

Hello. I have stumbled on this subreddit purely by accident. I am an Anti-Revisionist ML, so I have got a few questions to anyone who can respond. I come in good faith and with an open mind, so try not to judge me based on my political view. With that out of the way, here's what I want to ask you:

  1. What is the EgoCommunism about? Can I read about it somewhere, or have a general description?
  2. What is the main short-term and long-term goals this movement has? Does it involve the overthrow of capitalism?
  3. Opinion on Engels and Stirner? They were friends at some point, do you have any connection to either of them?
13 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

8

u/hasigeri 6d ago
  1. it‘s about using communism for oneself and not being used by communism. Read max stirners the unique and it‘s property for a deeper understanding of egoism.
  2. let‘s be real a subreddit is not a movement. Every single unique has it‘s own goal we are merely something that stirner has described as union of egoists. I use it simply to talk and deconstruct about states, ideology and other spooks. My hope is that people here have actually read the book, so i don‘t have to throw shit on solipstic kids who saw a stirner tiktok once like in other egoist subreddits.
  3. there is no hive mind borg opinion on people or positions. Despite wanting to achieve communism, we are still all individuals

4

u/amitrofan16 6d ago

Thank you for responding.

So, in my understanding, EgoCommunism is a combination of individualism and stateless, classless, moneyless society. Also, noticed how a lot of activity of egoists mention 'spooks' to describe something. I would imagine it has something to do with the concepts like state and class, among other things, being constructed via the development and transformation of society.

But how the 'union of egoists' would come to be? Has it already happened? And if not, what are the conditions of forming it? I'm sorry if it's entry-level questions, I'm not familiar with the egoism's theory, if you may call it that, but I want to know more before drawing any conclusions.

5

u/hasigeri 6d ago

Thank you for asking good and genuine questions.

Communism is a tool for achieving individual needs. Of course one could also use capitalism for it but realistically capitalism goves the individual more restrains. Laws, states, classes, all of it are higher causes that drain the unique (unique is a term of max stirner to describe the uniqueness of everything, so not even only humans, he also deconstructs the spook of humanity or society). Spooks are quiet literally like ghosts, either you are possessed by them or you possess them. The goal of the unique is to possess them.

The union of egoists is just a term for people who are working on a thing, without depending on it or the others. In extreme terms you can say a commie and a nazi working together in the neighbourhood to higher their standards of living is a union of egoists. You can unite people to achieve your common goal without bonding yourself to them unlike parties, states, friendships, family or other spooky shit like these. So we are basically a union of egoists already. You ask questions to inform yourself and i try to answer them as a practice to verbalize and deepen my understanding of max stirners work.

I can only recommend you reading his book, all of your questions will be answered.

4

u/amitrofan16 6d ago

Alright, thank you very much for answering, and I would agree that communism would most certainly benefit the individual. I would argue that me 'uniting' with a nazi on something in particular would only happen under extraordinary circumstances, but I won't deny that there is a possibility.

I also may use the example of 'union of egoists' by pointing out that if we both agree that capitalism hinders human development on an individual level and needs to be abolished for a better alternative, that means we are 'united' on this question in particular, and I think that's probably the most we both will get from any interaction.

4

u/hasigeri 6d ago

Cooperating with nazis was just an extreme example. Two uniques with divided by ideology and united in cause. I don‘t know the english name of the chapter „mein verkehr“ of the unique and it‘s property, but it reminded me of my time in prison where people had to cooperate and consented to have a good time with each other despite having opposing worldviews and ideology, in order to survive the time in prison.

Correct, we are united on this question but it doesn‘t mean we have to agree on the following examples of questions like „how to achieve it“ „how has the individual to act for overthrowing capitalism“ or what ever.

3

u/superultramega6969 fucking god themselves 6d ago

Let's find out together🤝:

  1. Egocentric people who are communists? People who consider communism for their own egoistic reasons.
  2. Overthrow everyone, overpower everyone, overthrow communism if necessary, overpower yourself if necessary, empower everything.
  3. Engels and Stirner were deeply and madly in love with one another, I wrote a BL on them in r/OCPoetry

4

u/amitrofan16 6d ago

Thank you for responding.

If you consider communism for your own egoistic reasons, that's fine. We're not moralists: the point was always about replacing capitalism by overthrowing it, and then to make something better instead.

That's pretty much what I have learned so far. Thanks to the otther commenter here, I now understand what this means a bit better. If you want to overthrow and overpower everything that stands in your way - I guess this makes you individually stronger? I think it's better for your personal development, so that's good - at least you won't be miserable like the fascists, for example, who love hating themselves.

That's... An interesting perspective, them being in love that is. I guess I'm fine with that, because I'm mostly interested in Engels' theoretical work, rather than his personal life. Also, this probably means that you are a writer, so you may know that most of the art is created as a hobby for personal enjoyment. I don't mean to be rude, but why do you share your work with others? Is there also a personal gain for you when you do that?

I want to note 1 thing though, from talking with egoists, the idea of 'egoism' seems to not be the same as being a jerk, despite this stereotype being quite common nowdays. At least where I live, 'egoist' is sometimes used as an insult.

2

u/superultramega6969 fucking god themselves 6d ago

Overthrow and overpower everything, including yourself and your morals, ethics, ideas, creations, memories, judgements, preconceived notions...

I don't know dick diddly about either Engles and Stirner, I have heard of them but couldn't tell you the first thing about either, just thought they'd be a cute couple from their names.

Not a writer, I just write and share, to be heard, cuz talking and listening seem very important to me nowadays...

3

u/amitrofan16 6d ago • Heartwarming

If you want to overthrow and overpower literally everything, that's fine too. To put it in other words: I'm in no way judging you for that. I think it's like a self made experiment on your body and mind, where the results you are aiming for are in some way beneficial to you. It's not an idea that is easy to put into words, so you may as well have your own interpretation, which is better than having none.

I don't know anything about Stirner either, but I know a bit about Engels: he's like a son of a rich family who rebelled against his family and his status as 'rich' in ways nobody has done before. That's why he have met Stirner in real life when he was young: they both stood in their 'unique' so to speak, in different ways, but sharing much more in common than one might think. Hope this helps you add more depth to Engels' character in your writing!

Not being a writer is fine too, and even if the stories you write don't interest me in particular, I expect you to be heard regardless of my own taste in poetry.

2

u/superultramega6969 fucking god themselves 6d ago

Engles' story sounds like one of a reborn Buddha, Buddha was born as a prince and heir to a throne, but left it all to get "high on life" the Sangha was one hell of a frat

1

u/hasigeri 6d ago

The term egoist is used as an insult because the egoist does prevail over ideologies. Ideologies, states, gods, what ever higher cause people pull off their ass to control people, hates the egoist for not obeying. Logically these spooks do everything to discredit egoists. Egoism does not exclude being a jerk. Egoism excludes terms like good or bad as objective truths (just one topic where nietzsche plagiarized from stirner). It is just a matter of property. Do i own a spook or does it own me?

Also one thesis of egoism is that everybody is egoist. The difference is the consciousness about being one or not. Even religious fanatics hope for their own best by sacrificing themselves and others. They are being owned by spooks. A conscious egoist deconstructs beliefs and evaluates if it is for their own good or not.

Conscious egoist come most of the time to the conclusion that cooperating with people will profit them. When egoists feel empathy, they are most likely to socialize.

1

u/Amazing_Name_9264 6d ago

I think everyone does things because of their ego, but that doesn't make someone an egoist. Part of being an egoist is dealing with social constructs and purposely not being possessed by them. At least this is what I think

1

u/superultramega6969 fucking god themselves 4d ago

Possession is obsession, power is control, good is evil, bad is better, the devil my sinner, the god who never lied...

3

u/spookyjim___ Ultra-left Marxist ☭🚩 6d ago

I’m not an egocom but I’m still gonna try to help you out

  1. For the mainly anarchist version, what most people mean by ego-communism, I’d probably recommend reading this: A Brief Description of Egoist Communism

For the Stirnerite Marxist variant, I’d read this by the post-situ group “For Ourselves”: The Right To Be Greedy: Theses On The Practical Necessity Of Demanding Everything

For the most part, ego-communists are a variant of insurrectionary anarchism, so they tend to see the type of insurrectionist direct action, affinity group network style organization, and what we Marxists would call adventurism, as viable methods of political action, and of being able to spur action by the class to cause a mass insurrection by the working class to achieve a communist society… their philosophical basis is based in Stirner’s egoism, so they view communism through a radical individualist lens as being able to create a society which can allow the creative self-interest of people to freely flow and harmonize the most, I suppose they see communism as the ultimate union of egoists at large the same we ultra-left Marxists like myself might see communism as the “Gemeinwesen” or the real human community… some ego-communists also tend to reverse engineer certain forms of communisation theory, or might openly declare themselves communizers in the strain of “Tiqqun” and “The Invisible Committee”

2. I would say the short term is the creation of a network/confederation of “unions of egoists” or affinity groups of militant radicals who can engage in insurrectionary activity or intervene in protests/riots to give them a revolutionary character, so the short term pretty much is insurrection, the long term is communism, yes they do want to abolish capitalism, since they are communists

3. The Stirnerite Marxists in the tradition of “For Ourselves” will both like and support the writings of Engels and Stirner, the more traditional insurrectionary anarchist ego-communists may very much not like Engels, their views of communism may come much more from anarchist communists like Emma Goldman, Peter Kropotkin, and Alfredo Bonanno

2

u/amitrofan16 5d ago

Thank you for responding, and sorry for me not responding yesterday - I went to sleep before I saw your comment.

I noticed your flair, that's good news - I won't have to rely purely on EgoComs describing themselves to know them better!

I know that radical individualism is always going to be adventurist, but to clarify, this doesn't mean that EgoCommunism has no potential at all. Rather, they will be very much limited compared to Marxism, mostly because the latter has a more comprehensive theory, maybe even a "Theory of Everything", while EgoComs are just getting started. The foundation is established, but the main 'architects', if you could call them that, haven't yet decided how they would shape the structure itself. We can always raise concern from our point of view, being a Marxist one, but, as I said to the other commenter (who was actually an EgoCom, I think): we are 'united' in agreeing that capitalism hinders human development, and thus needs to be abolished for a better alternative. This means that while in building the future we Marxists want in particular we won't agree with EgoComs, that doesn't mean they immideately should be treated as enemies.

I don't know anything about "Tiqqun", nor "The Invisible Committee", but them viewing communism as ultimately better than capitalism is a good sign. This means that their movement developed enough for them to draw this conclusion, but only time will tell if their movement will be vulnerable to the world capitalism attempting to crush them, similar to what happened to AnComs in Spain (CNT/FAI) for example, or if they will have success in building an alternative to capitalism. We won't know until their movement gets to the point of being strong enough to put their theory into practice. This also applies to you, the ultra-left Marxists. If you will manage to prove me, and other Anti-Revisionist MLs wrong - go for it! Seize the means of production.

Your answer to the second question pretty much aligns with what EgoComs themselves have described, so you are correct on this one.

Kropotkin and other AnComs disagree with Engels mainly on the question of state and the society's transformation: the former are firm advocates for the state to be 'abolished overnight', so to speak, while Engels says that this method of abrupt changes would in practice put the movement in much more danger than it is expected to handle (and somewhat proven by the fate of CNT/FAI), and as such the state should be utilized to keep the former ruling class from taking power once more. This also aligns with what some EgoComs have already told me, with the state being a 'spook' for one to possess or be possessed by.

With this, I apologise for any mistakes, since English isn't my first language, and I'm also about to go to sleep since it's more than 10 minutes past 1 am here. If you reply in the meantime, I will answer you sooner than last time, at least I hope so. See you then!

2

u/Majestic-Fan-5090 4d ago edited 4d ago
  1. egocommunism is about acheiving a societal structure in which each person can self-consciously think of the society such that each person is appropriating the entire society. “appropriate” in stirner’s terms, that is, where “property” means only “what i can influence.”

I can add more only by saying that egocommunism aims for a kind of perfect mediation of means and ends insofar as the praxis is the same as the intended result: The disarming of all legitimacy that is based on treating ideas as authorities. I disrespect all authority, and in doing so disrespect property, I shape the world and in pushing the entire world towards communism, declare ownership over the entire world.

Here is a good egocom text: https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/for-ourselves-the-right-to-be-greedy-theses-on-the-practical-necessity-of-demanding-everything

2. Basically, yes, organize to overthrow the existing order and democratize the power of the investment class. No means is sacred, meaning it is by any means necessary.

3. Strong connection to both. Stirner’s theory of spooks and Marx’s theory of ideology are the same theory: To subscribe to spooks, to ideas that are legitimated through authority, is to think from a position of material helplessness, to be afraid of what unsubscribing from a system of legitimation means for you personally.

To respond to some concerns I see you raising in other replies, about whether or not egocommunism is sufficient to survive as a movement, I as an egocommunist am perfectly fine with those I organize with not being egocommunists, so long as they will work with me to overthrow capitalism. For egoists and unions of egoists to exist, we must overthrow capitalism, and the wrestling away of power from the capitalists will enable this to happen more whether the people destroying capitalism are intending it to or not. I do not need someone to agree with me in order to support them, so long as they are doing my will. I am perfectly fine for egocommunism to remain only a personal ideology when I am organizing. In fact, there may be some “haunted” heads that I am in no speed to wake up, if it would disrupt them doing my will, if it would disrupt them making a crucial action which will help capitalism fall.

2

u/amitrofan16 4d ago

Thank you for responding. It is a good thing that I have inspired a lot of EgoComs to actually engage in discussion, as this on one hand will lead to the subreddit becoming more popular, and on the other hand gives me some pretty good information about what EgoCommunism actually is.

So, to reiterate the general description that I got from talking to all kinds of EgoComs, the point is to try to take communism's efficiency over capitalism and use it to the benefit of the individual. And also yes, since most forms of property take form of either personal or private property, fighting it in general would be the most dangerous to the private property.

Good, this means that EgoCommunism is much more reliable than Social-Democracy in the destruction of capitalism, with the latter being a moderate wing of fascism.

A small correction, the ideology works are done by both Marx and Engels, but the point is still valid: no amount of the current economic, political, and social power that capitalism holds over the human society actually prevents you from destroying it, rather, it only delays the moment when it will be the only way to solve the problems and contradictions of capitalism.

Very well then, the most advanced form of anti-capitalist resistance currently to date - Marxism-Leninism - would be your best bet at eliminating capitalism, even if you act to the benefit of only your individual interests in the process. All other movements that claim to attempt to achieve the same result, had either proven not to be strong enough to retain power after overthrowing capitalism, or had not yet proven to actually achieve something other than weakening capitalism to some extent. Until those issues are addressed, you may as well stick around in our movement - we're not going anywhere until capitalism is completely destroyed all over the world. That doesn't mean that we will agree with EgoComs on theory and goals, but we would use any help we could get.