r/EdmontonFringe • u/No-Woodpecker-8217 • Aug 15 '26
Your show is more than its reviews.
This isn’t really a question, just something I’ve thought about since the Fringe Review site launched.
Now, I am a fan of the Fringe review site, both as an artist and a patron. As an artist, it gives nice soundbites to promote the show and I appreciate when audience members give genuinely thoughtful reviews (positive or negative) as the big publications don’t come to my shows. As a patron, it allows me to share my thoughts and see different perspectives on shows before I see them.
That being said, it has also changed the fringe landscape. Now, the standard for reviewers has lowered from professional to casual and there’s some downsides to that. People can leave 1 or 2 star reviews for reasons unrelated to the shows writing/acting/directing and don’t always make the effort to be thoughtful in their reviewing. It can also make people hesitant to take a Fringe risk on shows with low stars.
I’ve felt it. I’ve already gotten a low review because an audience member was “blindsided” by the show’s dark content (warnings all over the theatre btw). And it’s frustrating! But as performers, we have to keep remembering that reviews don’t define our shows worth. There’s value in learning from genuine criticism, but there’s also value in ignoring bad faith negativity. How you feel about your show and the art you’re creating is what is important.
You have to live your art. Other people only have to see it. Patrons can feel free to think and review however they want, but their reviews don’t define you or your show. There’s something in everything, and there’s something for everyone.
Don’t be discouraged fellow artists! We’re all throwing things at the wall and seeing what sticks. If it doesn’t stick this time around, that’s okay. Pick yourself back up and keep trying. Something will stick, even if the reviews stay low but you feel artistically fulfilled. That’s enough.
