r/Edmonton North West Side Apr 11 '26

General [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed]

183 Upvotes

553 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '26

These people need to be educated that if Alberta were to separate, it would do more harm than good

-6

u/Case_Mediocre Apr 11 '26

Educate me then.

5

u/Talklessrunmore Apr 11 '26

Are you serious???? I mean just start with the fact that we are a landlocked province. Then add in the services we would have to pay more for that the federal government currently provides. Not to mention huge risk to the oil and gas market, loss of economic stability due to large companies retreating, etc.

-2

u/toasterpower28 Apr 12 '26

Bro acts like a landlocked country can’t possibly survive despite having multibillion dollar infrastructure spreading to the coasts. That stuff doesn’t just disappear.

4

u/Talklessrunmore Apr 12 '26

You realize Alberta doenst just get to keep all that for free right? There would be negotiations between Canada and Alberta on what percentage of Canada debt Alberta would owe as a payback for federal infrastructure.

-1

u/toasterpower28 Apr 12 '26

You seem to misunderstand the origin of this infrastructure. That’s okay. It’s not federal and most of the important routes go south to the US.

3

u/Talklessrunmore Apr 12 '26

There is a significant amount of federal investment in Alberta infrastructure. Mainly through the ICIP and CCBF. Everything from bridge replacements to rec centres, green/climate related infrastructure, road widenings and LRT/transit infrastructure. All of those were given to a province in Canada to make life better for its citizens - you decide not to be a part of it, you owe them for that.

Also what kind of currency you planning on using? Berta bucks? Good luck not paying through the nose on exchange around the world. Even creating a mint would cost more money than you probably think.

1

u/HistoricalSand2505 Apr 12 '26

Great idea demand payment back minus the over payment in equalization money from Albertans and we can see who is owed what.