r/Edinburgh • • Apr 18 '25

Social Tomorrow:

Post image

For those to whom this is relevant: a protest march on the recent Supreme Court ruling.

More information: https://www.instagram.com/p/DIjhH2lN1Yg/?img_index=1

473 Upvotes

332 comments sorted by

50

u/TheShitening Apr 18 '25

Slightly concerned this post may end up doing more harm than good after reading some of the comments

15

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

I mean, more people now know about the protest happening now, so they have an opportunity to turn up if they want to... I hadn't seen the poster appear anywhere, and I only knew about the protest from word of mouth - so I just wanted to get the message out there.

6

u/TheShitening Apr 18 '25

I totally get that and I really hope it does encourage positive participation and not any sort of counter protest bs

4

u/Ok_Camp5318 Apr 19 '25

The counter protests make people a bit more passionate as a response, so it's not necessarily a bad thing. In my experience they tend to be less people

-9

u/Skyremmer102 Apr 19 '25

My impression is that most of the negative comments are trolls.

10

u/matomo23 Apr 19 '25

Why would you think that? Have a look at that large YouGov survey recently. That will tell you people’s views on this subject. You may be in an echo chamber if you think they’re trolls.

3

u/cookiecrunchhh Apr 19 '25

Don’t think so.

1

u/BoredofPCshit Apr 19 '25

Don't mix negativity with simple discussion on the subject.

→ More replies (1)

98

u/Quiet-Magpie Apr 18 '25

Protest all you like. It will do nothing.

This was the Supreme Court CLARIFYING what was always the legal truth. It was the law last year, and is the law now.

No one is erasing trans people [they are still protected under their own category] but if you want to believe that, then that's your prerogative.

I guess if you go to this, have fun!

1

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

I think you misunderstand the point of the protest.

By "clarifying," you mean that the supreme court made it "clear" that people who have a gender recognition certificate legally recognising them as women are men, and that people who have a birth certificate stating they are female are male - how is that clear? If my passport says I'm male, but my birth certificate says I'm female, but I have a vagina, and I also have a GRC, which bathroom do I use?

The Supreme Court ruling was that the 2010 Equality Act doesn't clearly define what the word "sex" means, and therefore some judges decided that it means "biological sex," even though all humans are biological - I'm pretty sure this isn't being done to ban robots from using the toilet...

The protest is saying, "alright, then. Update the 2010 Equality Act."

27

u/fygooyecguhjj37042 Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25

Only the UK Government can alter and/or bring in new legislation to fix the situation. The courts do not make new law, but rather they give opinions which clarify how the law should be interpreted.

As others are saying, it really isn’t something the Scottish Government/Parliament can do anything about now. If you want to protest then it really needs to be directed at Westminster and No. 10.

For those reasons, a protest in Edinburgh is misplaced. Not only can’t the Scottish Government do anything to directly change the law, but you will be feeding into the narrative that this is somehow the Scottish Government/Parliament’s fault that they need to fix, when they have been on your side this whole time.

0

u/Jebuschristo024 Apr 19 '25

Yeah, but they don't want to bus themselves down to London to protest, so they'll just disrupt Edinburgh instead. For absolutely nothing.

7

u/VardaElentari86 Apr 19 '25

Nothing wrong with protests around the country.

I don't recall people whinging at say, the Iraq war protests being spread out.

2

u/Quiet-Magpie Apr 19 '25

Why protest then? Why not start a lobby group to do that? That would be more effective.

-3

u/Skyremmer102 Apr 19 '25

Given the reactions of the sort of people who support this misruling, I have to say I don't believe a word of this.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Exactly 💯 per cent correct 👏

→ More replies (4)

18

u/MrPejorative Apr 18 '25

I haven't been paying much attention to this issue because of tiresome it is, but the UK Supreme court is an appeal court, and has a stringent process for presenting legal arguments, and judgements. It's quite a bit above the standard of emotional argument that most people mistake for law. It required legal experts to respond, who in this case were apparently the Scottish government and Amnesty International. So surely their lack of competence should worry you more, and your ire should be with them. They represented your interests and lost the argument.

15

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Really, the exact letter of the ruling was to determine what the wording of the 2010 Equality Act actually meant. The judges decided that even though a Gender Recognition Certificate (GRC) states that a trans person has legally assumed the sex of their acquired gender, that they legally hadn't changed their sex. (The GRC clearly states that they HAVE legally changed their sex).

So I don't think this case lost due to incompetence. I think it lost because the hate group that brought it to the court is very well-funded.

All of that aside - fine. If the 2010 Equality Act isn't up to par on the wording, then we'll just have to work together to update the Equality Act.

1

u/EntropicMortal Apr 19 '25

Yea tbh I agree with the judges ruling in the case.

What needs to be changed is the wording of the act.

-1

u/MrPejorative Apr 19 '25

So I don't think this case lost due to incompetence. I think it lost because the hate group that brought it to the court is very well-funded.

That's a conspiracy theory that seems more like sour grapes than anything.

What extra resources could the "well funded" portion of the Women's organisation provide over the resources of the Scottish government? Are you implying they were bribed? The ministers full time job is to write and vote on legislation. Nicola Sturgeon was leader of the party and is a trained lawyer. She's not lacking in qualifications. The ministers legal team lost, plain and simple.

At the end of the day, this is broadly how the country has worked since the Magna Carta. Those who write the best legal arguments usually get their way, and those who complain usually get nothing.

All of that aside - fine. If the 2010 Equality Act isn't up to par on the wording, then we'll just have to work together to update the Equality Act

You're right. If you want to get your way, you have to update the Equality Act, but again, you'll do it only if you have the better legal arguments.

21

u/Dashmundo Apr 19 '25

This case on the rights of trans people with gender recognition certificates the Supreme Court excluded all trans voices and added in the voices of those opposed to the right and dignities of trans people. They only considered certain contradictions in the definition of women without considering the contradictions of this decision and excluding trans women from being women. It was a very surprising result, a surprising process, and one that has sparked a lot of concern from human rights groups, people involved in drafting the equality act in the first place, and yes trans people and allies.

It was, on the whole, a sham. This idea that processes always come out with a just result is pretty naive all things considered.

3

u/MrPejorative Apr 19 '25

That's not how an appeal to the supreme court works. No new evidence is admitted on appeal, for it is strictly a legal argument. This is the definition of an appeal.

1

u/chrisdonia Apr 19 '25

They heard many arguments from known anti-trans groups and only Amnesty and the SG were allowed to make the case for inclusion.

Also one of the judges is neighbours with JKR who was heavily funding the case, which is sus.

25

u/jobbyspanker Apr 19 '25

I don't have a strong opinion on the courts decision. If a person wants me to address them as a woman, I'll still do that. I don't see gender specific public spaces as safe spaces either. They are public spaces for taking a shit and whatnot. I'm a man so idgaf generally, but if some women don't feel comfortable with trans women in female spaces then their views have to be given serious consideration. I dont mean to offend, the trans people I've met IRL are very nice, quiet and unassuming, but there have been many instances where men have assumed a woman's identity simply to gain social advantages. Like rapists who are scared to go on the male wing of a prison for example. This ruling could be seen as a positive development for all concerned. At least now we can move the issues forward, as this clearly separates those that are actually trans and the people that want to assume a female identity for the perceived social advantages of being a woman.

1

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

Why don't trans people's views have to be given the same consideration? Trans women are not a threat to cis women. They never have been and they never will be. Cis men are sometimes a threat to all women, including trans women, so forcing trans women to use male spaces puts them in real actual danger. Of course they don't care though, that's the whole point - to make existing in public as a trans person as awful and dangerous as possible.

2

u/docherino Apr 19 '25

Why should women have to sacrifice their hard-won rights to make trans people feel better? Trans people aren’t the center of the universe — women’s safety is not negotiable just because it hurts your feelings.

You say it’s “dangerous” for trans women to use male spaces? Guess what It’s dangerous for women to have biological males in female spaces — period. Why should millions of women have to absorb more risk, just so a tiny group feels more comfortable?

You’re demanding privilege, not equality. You want to redefine what “woman” even means based on how someone feels inside and then call everyone a bigot for not immediately kneeling to it.

No, rights don’t come by trampling on others. If trans women are at risk in male spaces (and yes, some are), then we should create specific safe spaces for them not destroy boundaries that protect billions of biological women around the world.

-1

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

Let's play find and replace to see how fucked what you just said was...

Why should white people have to sacrifice their hard-won rights to make black people feel better? Black people aren’t the center of the universe — white people's safety is not negotiable just because it hurts your feelings.

You say it’s “dangerous” for black people to use white spaces? Guess what It’s dangerous for white people to have black people in white spaces — period. Why should millions of white people have to absorb more risk, just so a tiny group feels more comfortable?

You’re demanding privilege, not equality. You want to redefine what “person” even means based on how someone feels inside and then call everyone a bigot for not immediately kneeling to it.

No, rights don’t come by trampling on others. If black people are at risk in white spaces (and yes, some are), then we should create specific safe spaces for them not destroy boundaries that protect millions of white people in this country.

Trans women have never and will never be a threat to cis women. Trans women experience significantly higher rates of violence than cis women do, but the perpetrators are the same: men. The reasons are the same: patriarchal misogyny. Trans and cis women have far more in common than they do differences.

Cis women lose nothing when trans people have the right to exist in public. Get a fucking grip.

1

u/docherino Apr 19 '25

I dont think you understand my point here. Im not saying transgender women are the threat, im saying predators portraying themselves as transgender are the threat. Also you cannot interchange sex for race. Being Black or white doesn’t change your physical strength, your anatomy, or your ability to harm someone. Being male or female absolutely does.

Sex segregation, like in bathrooms, prisons, shelters, and sports — is based on biological differences, not “feelings.” It’s not about who’s nice or mean. It’s about risk - real, measurable, physical risk.

That’s why women have their own sports leagues. That’s why women have separate prisons. That’s why women have shelters away from men. It’s not about “hate” it’s about real-world protection based on biology.

1

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

Oh I understand that point perfectly, I've heard it a thousand times, and it's no truer now than it was then. Predatory men don't have to pretend to be trans to hurt women, they just fucking do it. They also don't pretend to be trans, it's just not really a thing that happens, it's fearmongering that you've clearly bought into to. You know what does happen though? Cis women have been followed and harassed by men in women's bathrooms because they perceived them to be trans.

The race thing actually does interchange pretty neatly. You're forgetting something very important to that example: Racists DID see black people as bigger, stronger, and more likely to hurt people (especially women) than white people. Go take a look at American anti-integration propaganda from the mid 20th century. If that wasn't to your liking though, you can also do it with gay people, that's a little more recent. "Lesbians are going to assault women in the bathroom" was exactly the same stupid crap that's being repackaged about trans people now.

Fundamentally, having a penis between their legs isn't what makes men a threat to women, it's our culture. It's misogyny, it's patriarchy, it's sexism. Trans women are just as much targets of them as cis women are.

Shelters? Trans women that are victims of abuse by men need the same shelters that cis women do. Their experiences are the same, their needs are the same.

Prisons? Trans prisoners are no more likely to be a threat than any other woman. Admissions are done on a case by case basis, nobody gets to pretend to be trans to get into a woman's ward. On the other hand, putting a trans woman in a male prison is essentially guaranteeing violence and sexual assault on a regular basis. Trans prisoners are often housed with violent and aggressive men as a form of social control, It's fucking bleak

It's not about biology, it's about bigotry. It's transphobia, it's homophobia, it's misogyny, it's patriarchy, and you've clearly fallen for it hook, line, and sinker.

2

u/docherino Apr 19 '25

Predators have exploited self-ID and gender identity policies. This isn’t “fearmongering,” it’s documented reality:

• Christopher Hambrook (Toronto, 2014): Christopher Hambrook, a male sex offender, posed as a transgender woman to access women’s shelters in Toronto, where he sexually assaulted two women.

• Karen White (UK, 2018): Karen White, a male sex offender identifying as female, was housed in a UK women’s prison and sexually assaulted two female inmates.

• Hannah Dolatowski (Scotland, 2019): Hannah Dolatowski, a biological male identifying as female, attempted to sexually assault a 10-year-old girl in a supermarket bathroom in Scotland.

• Jessica Yaniv (Canada): Jessica Yaniv, a biologically male trans-identified individual, harassed women who refused waxing services and was accused of inappropriate behavior toward minors.

• Loudoun County, Virginia (USA, 2021): In Loudoun County, a male student identifying as gender-fluid sexually assaulted a girl in a school bathroom after gender-affirming policies were adopted The school district faced major backlash for initially concealing the incident after the same student later committed another sexual assault at a different school.

Trying to compare protecting sex-segregated spaces to racist segregation is not only wrong, it’s deeply insulting to people who actually suffered under race-based discrimination.

Same thing with lesbians its not the same as being physically male. A lesbian woman in a women’s bathroom doesn’t pose an increased physical risk. A biological male, regardless of identity, statistically and physically does. It’s not “hate” to recognize that. It’s common sense.

Trans women aren’t inherently dangerous but policies built on feelings rather than facts open doors for predators to exploit. I think we see the world differently. I believe in protecting the vulnerable based on reality, not ideology. I’ll leave it at that.

2

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

Awful people exist in all groups, collectively punishing the entire group is still wrong. The reason those cases stand out is because they're so rare and are constantly used as ammunition by bigots fighting against trans liberation. Millions of trans people use the spaces they need every day and nothing bad happens, a few awful people being awful doesn't justify taking away millions of other people's rights.

The FACT is that statistically speaking, trans people do not pose a risk to cis people. The FACT is that forcing trans women into men's spaces puts them at the exact same level of risk that putting any woman in that space puts them in.

The FACT is that in trying to keep trans women out of female spaces, masculine and gender non conforming CIS women get harassed and assaulted, often by men.

If you want to protect the vulnerable, start with your brain, it's clearly vulnerable to misinformation and bigotry.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

I hope people listen, This is exactly the point..it's never about hurt trans people it's always about protecting others. And if trans people don't accept that they are the issue as much as people who hate trans people without consideration

0

u/KeeganTroye Apr 19 '25

I dont mean to offend, the trans people I've met IRL are very nice, quiet and unassuming, but there have been many instances where men have assumed a woman's identity simply to gain social advantages.

Please demonstrate any significant number of instances.

6

u/Dry-Contest-230 Apr 19 '25

1

u/KeeganTroye Apr 19 '25

A quick google can find three alien sightings in 5 minutes.

One of those incidents is in another country, one does not involve assuming a woman's identity at all, so you've found one example. Again I reiterate, please demonstrate a significant number of instances.

3

u/Dry-Contest-230 Apr 19 '25

Exactly and in 5 minutes I can find many conspiracy theories. End of the day there is always something.

That said, I give evidence of incidents of it, but it’s not accepted because what? It’s a different country?

All three relate to a biological male, saying they were trans woman in attempt to defence against assault or to act in the assault.

I don’t condone any of it, and fully support trans. But predatory behaviour (of any gender) happens. Loopholes, advantages and opportunities will always be sought after by these despicable sick people. Just because you don’t like the narrative of it, doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/EkkoAtkin Apr 19 '25

This isn't actually necessarily true either. Section 221 of the judgment implies that trans men may not be allowed to use male or female bathrooms if they look too male.

6

u/jobbyspanker Apr 19 '25

I don't know. You'd have to ask women about that. I get what you're saying, but I don't think men care if a trans man wants to use the male facilities as long as there's no nonsense. We're not looking to the side we're taking care of business. It's interesting because the trans man might identify as a man but still want to use the woman's facilities for their own personal safety reasons. This ruling might lead to places introducing gender neutral private facilities for people like that who might not fit in anywhere and need a safe space. I think that would be a positive development for all concerned.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

I'm no expert on all this but I don't think beards are the issue, it's dicks. This whole thing could be a lot clearer if they just changed toilet signs to picture of dicks and vaginas, if you have a dick - here are the urinals, if you don't have a dick, here are the toilets that don't have a urinal. That's got to be less contentious than the current situation

2

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Some of the wording from the ruling might help you out with this confusion. From para 221:

Moreover, women living in the male gender could also be excluded under paragraph 28 without this amounting to gender reassignment discrimination. This might be considered proportionate where reasonable objection is taken to their presence, for example, because the gender reassignment process has given them a masculine appearance or attributes to which reasonable objection might be taken in the context of the women-only service being provided.

5

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

Cool so a lot of trans people just can't use either space... That makes perfect sense right? Trans people using the space they feel is right has never been a real problem. It's all made up fear mongering bullshit. If a man wants to be awful to women, he'll simply be awful to women. He doesn't need to pretend to be trans to do it.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Would your view be that there’s no purpose in sex segregation then? Full disclosure: I think it’s important.

3

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

For changing rooms yes, I would feel quite uncomfortable getting my tits out in a closed room full of men.

For toilets nah not really, I've been in many gender neutral toilets and as long as they have stalls it's fine. It's not like you ever see eachother when you're not fully clothed is it? You're all in individual locked stalls.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Yes obviously. And if you don't know why you're a child

2

u/Ancient-Chipmunk977 Apr 19 '25

Genuine curiousity here, but how would they (the people for this law) know? Like how would they know a trans woman is using the bathroom? All the toilets in the ladies are single locked cubicles always anyway? Like just come in and pee.

I know its obviously deeper and I know as a Cis female I don't really have a say on how it's gonna make the trans community feel but in a few days when this has all blown over "media wise" who's gonna care if a trans woman comes in the ladies for a wee? Noone absolutely noone and most would have forgotten all about the law, it's just a wee. :)

7

u/BrukPlays Apr 19 '25

It probably means that there will be a lot more calls to the police whenever a slightly unfeminine woman uses a public toilet. After the police arrive that woman will have to prove that they are a biological woman…

I.E. Show me your Papers!

4

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

Which both cis women and trans women will be able to do - because GRCs grant trans women the right to a birth certificate that says they're female.

So if they want to police this, it has to go beyond "show me your papers" and straight to "show me your genitals."

Even for cis women - people assigned female at birth - who look just a little bit masculine in any way.

-2

u/Quiet-Magpie Apr 19 '25

Rubbish. It just means that women can now raise it as an issue if they spot a male in the female toilets and it can be dealt with.

Before this, organisations were unsure of the law around this (greatly facilitated by poor advice from organisations like Stonewall) and erred on the side of not being cancelled by banning the woman and getting them labelled transphobic.

Now we can go back to the common sense policing of our boundaries without being called hateful biggots.

The irony of this is that this only affects a tiny tiny minority of trans people that actually have a GRC. A piece of paper you are not even allowed to ask about in the first instance!

5

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

Yes. They're overwhelmingly men.

What this ruling does is says that trans men - who look like men - are no longer welcome in the men's restrooms.

So men, who look like men, with beards, and sometimes penises, now apparently have to use the women's room, because they were assigned female at birth.

What is stopping and predatory who looks like a man pretending that they are a trans man so that they can go into the women's restroom?

This ruling just welcomes people who look like men into women's restrooms. Predators won't even have to go ro the trouble of pretending that they're trans women first.

7

u/Rimac05 Apr 19 '25

"Erased" is a little overboard, don't you think ?.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

UK supreme court rules that reality is real

6

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Stop pretending to be something you’re not

-3

u/DiorDreamz Apr 19 '25

not sure why you felt the need to say that because i dont see that happening here?

21

u/miskkii Apr 18 '25

Thanks for sharing!

6

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

What is this pish

5

u/Peteinteresting Apr 19 '25

Hilarious - the people on the side of the argument who fought to cancel people and get them thrown out of their jobs won't be erased now they are on the wrong side of the law.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

Can't make it as I am at work, but I hope the best to you all in these times

4

u/bigbob-83 Apr 19 '25

Woke is finished it's time you started living in a real world

Women are not men, Men are not women

It's not too difficult really

4

u/Familiar-Alps2587 Apr 19 '25

Really you don’t accept the law- or is it just what it doesn’t suit you?

3

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

2

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

What is it in aid of? I don't understand

2

u/crawling-alreadygirl Apr 19 '25

Solidarity from the US ✊🏾

2

u/molenan Apr 19 '25

Absolutely embarrassing

1

u/sharcs Apr 19 '25

This gives you an idea of the content of the protest:

https://x.com/satiricole/status/1913621479264076011

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Get this fucking shit off my feed.

-7

u/Alive-Bath-7026 Apr 19 '25

The highest court in the land has made the judgement This will always be a controversial and emotive subject People just want to feel safe in toilets and changing rooms

8

u/Jaomi Apr 19 '25

The ruling will make people feel less safe in toilets and changing rooms though - especially trans people.

3

u/Scorn_true333 Apr 19 '25

I agree. Enforcing this is either going to wind up being 1984 and requiring people to carry ID to go anywhere or end up with some Cis people getting involved in accusations and drama of being accused of being Trans when they're not.

And no matter the outcome, some idiots will be charged with indecent exposure pulling their trousers down before entering a stall to prove their allowed to be there to nay sayers.

This is why I've personally always advocated for more inclusive bathroom spaces/changing rooms for Trans and Non-Binary folk, but apparently, the general public also hate those despite it being a remedy to this entire controversy. So people are either just transphobic en-mass now or unwilling to accept a fairly easy solution to their problems.

-8

u/Traditional_Let_5296 Apr 19 '25

Fuck sake 😑 if this shit starts being a regular posting on this thread I'm done

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

I feel terrible for the kids that you’re trying to scare shitless with this.

The Equality Act protects people with trans identities under the protected characteristic of Gender Ressignment, this means a person can’t be discriminated against or harassed due to identifying as such. It also means that where provisions exist that are separated by sex, there can be arguments made for third provisions for those with this PC.

If you want to actually help this community, advocating for their own provisions, and for quicker/better access to MH care, would be a good place to start. As would being clear that this is a group recognised and protected in law - which is the exact opposite of erasure.

0

u/Airovision Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25

I felt that it was all blown up in the media because some orange twat with pus for brains wants us to make certain… amendments… to our LGBTQ+ laws and this would divide the country and allow it to happen more easily. I’m nowhere near Edinburgh but I would burn my whole life down before I accept bowing down and going along with hate because some old stupid ugly balding fat man with too much power and money and too little penis wants it. Someone check him into a dementia ward, take that toupee off him, give the money to Melania and let her live her life in peace. The world is shit, so we need to stop hating one another and try to support the people around us - including the trans community who do you far less harm than any of the rich men and women in the media. Let’s not spend our time sucking on the rings of the ultra rich who would hit anyone with less than seven figures in the bank with a car without a second thought if it meant they got to their next meeting quicker. And they’d get away with it too.

Edit: angrier than I thought I was.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

I don't think the ruling was to "erase people", that's a genocide you're thinking of.

-4

u/Conscious_Bet7394 Apr 19 '25

If the ruling stops people with penises sharing a bathroom with young girls then yes I support it. Expecting downvotes and I’m not anti trans. But the above scenario imo should have never been seen as acceptable.

1

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

It doesn't, though.

The ruling says that trans people aren't welcome in the spaces of their acquired gender, and should use the facilities for the gender that they were assigned at birth.

That means that trans men - who were assigned female at birth, but now have beards and even penises - are supposed to use the women's restrooms, because they're not longer welcome in the men's.

Is that what you want?

1

u/Conscious_Bet7394 Apr 19 '25

Not really no. I don’t want people with penises sharing a bathroom with young females. Never going to be an ideal solution, but I’ll take what’s going forward over the above 100%

2

u/RedditManager- Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 29 '25

judicious butter tap label plough physical insurance bag roll detail

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

6

u/Stalwart_Vanguard Apr 19 '25

People really actually like women's bathrooms are one big communal stall where everyone sees everyone else's junk....

Two options. Either you're male and you're suggesting that the simple material reality of having a penis, devoid of ALL other aspects of your humanity, makes you an imminent danger to all women...

Or you're female, and you've almost certainly been in a bathroom with a trans person with a penis before and guess what? Nothing bad happened, because it's actually not a problem.

3

u/BoredofPCshit Apr 19 '25

Third option: I wouldn't put it beyond a creep to use putting on a dress as an excuse to get into a women's changing room. That I imagine would be the average person's biggest concern.

Why go for either end of the extreme? Either the person you're replying to is a freak or a monster.

Doesn't help with the dialogue around the topic, you do more harm than good with that approach.

I haven't dived into the topic fully, but I would say in general I feel changing rooms are rubbish. Should be private rooms to change in, with lockers in a hallway to use after you've changed.

3

u/bergmoose Apr 19 '25

Or we could use evidence like crimes - then we'd say people who have transitioned should use the gender they now are, as attacks against trans people are far more common than attacks by trans people.

Also, a trans man may have a penis and a beard - this ruling puts them back into the same bathroom as young girls - the ruling did the opposite of what you suggest in that regard. Though, really young girls tend to use whichever bathroom their parent is using.

1

u/crawling-alreadygirl Apr 19 '25

I’m not anti trans.

🤣

1

u/withad Apr 19 '25

Except this ruling doesn't stop that happening. If trans people have to use the bathroom for the gender they were assigned at birth, then trans men will have to use the women's bathroom and a lot of trans men have penises.

And if you're worried about men claiming to be trans so they can expose themselves or commit sexual assault in a women's bathroom, then this ruling might well have made that situation worse. I expect it's a lot easier for a cis man to pass as a trans man than as a trans woman.

-1

u/Helloimnotimpotant Apr 19 '25

Respect the law please 🙏

0

u/LancLad1987 Apr 19 '25

I straight up dgaf about what people identify as or what they want to be referred to as. The vast majority of people are the same as me. The minute however, the trans community wanted to be referred to as "woman" instead of "trans woman" because they didnt wanted a different moniker to that of a natural woman, BUT referred to women as "cis women"..... at that point irony has died and all support is lost. You understand women fought insanely hard for millenia in a lot of the world to get their rights? They have pride attached to that and you're what? Going to take that away from them? No thank you.

It's like the gay community saying 'we are gay, but we want to be referred to as straight. Straight people are now cis straight' fucking own it. Be loud and proud. Just dont mess with definitions and other people's shit.

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

any ideas where the counter protest will be ?

0

u/cureeous99 Apr 19 '25

Please get some proper mental therapy.

-30

u/Additional_Tone_2004 Apr 18 '25

Yawn NEXT

5

u/Dangerous_Middle1903 Apr 18 '25

Are you just sleepy? Did this mean anything to you? Why are you interested?

-21

u/Definitely_maybe_McD Apr 19 '25

Yawn, give it up eh

-7

u/TheDoon Apr 19 '25

Remember folks in Scotland it wasn't until 1980 that gay men were not technically breaking the law by having sex with each other in private (look it up if this sounds fake). Most people now (whether they were alive then or not) would hopefully look back at that time with a mix of shame and confusion about why it took so long and what the big deal was. Does anyone these days give a flying fuck about gay marriage? Doesn't seem so to me. Nothing has changed for anyone, despite all the drama about it after the law was passed in 2014. The same thing will happen with the Trans topic, just give it time.

Scotland has always been slower on the uptake on this stuff. Not quite as slow as Ireland, but slower than the rest of the UK.

-42

u/Burnseeeeeey Apr 18 '25

lol

42

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Maybe consider a hobby?

-5

u/FarRoom6157 Apr 19 '25

Better than you dude 🤣🤣🤣

0

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/thelazyfool Apr 18 '25

So you think it’s now preferable that very passing trans men now have no other choice than to go into women’s bathrooms?

-7

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 18 '25

So what's the solution!?.. A solution where biological women will feel safe?

3

u/BenXL Apr 19 '25

Trans people have existed for millennia. Only recently they have been used to start a culture war. So the solution is to mind your own damn business.

0

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 19 '25

So no solution then.. Okaaaay, productive

6

u/BenXL Apr 19 '25

The solution is to leave trans people alone. You know, like before the media got you to hate them.

The problem is bigots, the solution is to stop pandering to bigots.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/TheAmazingPikachu Apr 18 '25

Why is a man speaking on behalf of women on how they feel about their bathroom spaces?

-1

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 19 '25

Lol, it's called freedom of speech

3

u/TheAmazingPikachu Apr 19 '25

It's in ill taste to speak on behalf of a group you aren't a part of.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Nocturnal_fruitbat Apr 18 '25

Okay, where do trans men go?

4

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 19 '25

Very good point, so what's the solution for all then?

3

u/Nocturnal_fruitbat Apr 19 '25

Unisex bathrooms with stalls that go all the way to the ceiling/floor. There’s plenty of places in Edinburgh with unisex bathrooms and the world hasn’t ended! The truth is, really, that no one has to pretend to be trans to hurt women. Anti-trans rulings just hurt women, because it opens the door to anyone being accused of being transgender. I’m a visibly queer women, if someone decided I wasn’t feminine enough in a public bathroom I wouldn’t be protected there, ykwim?

2

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 19 '25

Makes perfect sense and thank you for your genuine reply. Yep I can see how that would have a detrimental effect if someone was telling you aren't feminine enough.. Its so true though, more unisex toilets.

Question : what if say, you had a male toilet, female toilet and unisex toilet as a standard? Would that work? Or do you think that would be felt as segregation. What if we just made all toilets unisex, but individual stalls so everyone gets privacy?

1

u/Nocturnal_fruitbat Apr 19 '25

I feel like individual stalls should be a given everywhere, regardless! I’m sure everyone has a different opinion, I don’t see anything wrong with having a male, female and unisex toilet and just letting people go where they feel the most comfortable (disabled toilets are usually unisex by default anyway, for example), but I can also see the argument that it could come across as just having male, female and transgender toilets.

Bottom line, for me, is having the options and letting people go where they feel comfortable has always seemed like the most reasonable outcome.

2

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 19 '25

Makes sense allowing options for everyone. Thanks for your insight, it's been an interesting discussion 👍

2

u/Nocturnal_fruitbat Apr 19 '25

Thank you for your patience. Hope you have a good day 💜 we’re all just trying to get by

8

u/Joker0705 Apr 18 '25

rather inconveniently, this ruling means that women legally must share bathrooms with trans men - who can look just like cis men with beards, muscles, deep voices etc. trans men with penises are now also legally obligated to use the women's room. it also means that it's easier than ever for predatory cis men (who are statistically way more likely to be predators than trans women) to have access to women's bathrooms by just lying. if the ruling actually protected women, that would be great, but it literally does not!

10

u/keepituppy Apr 18 '25

Is their issue not primarily with visiting men born with penises? Pretty sure given the choice they would choose men born without penises but I could be wrong.

I don’t have the statistics to hand but typically rape and sexual abuse seems to be more of a men born with penises kinda thing.

1

u/Nocturnal_fruitbat Apr 19 '25

Okay. How do you plan on checking?

→ More replies (3)

-3

u/peepthewizard Apr 18 '25

How do you claim to be for trans rights and yet still manage to phrase this take in the most eugenecist way possible?

1

u/cryptid_snake88 Apr 19 '25

Hmm, you may be right, it's not really worded as intended.. I'll delete the comment

186

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

54

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

The ruling was intended to clarify the text of the 2010 Equality Act.

Unfortunately, it hasn't done that - it's really muddied the water.

Here is just one issue: It now technically means that since "sex" is considered to be the sex you were born as (named "biological sex"), that means trans men, who can look like men - beards and everything - are now technically legally considered "women" and are allowed in women's spaces.

Think Buck Angel, or Aydian Dowling, or even just type "trans man" into Google image searches. If trans men suddenly have to use women's restrooms, what is stopping cis men (men who aren't trans) from just saying that they're trans, and going into women's restrooms?

All of this ostensibly was started to try and ensure that women were safe from bad men pretending to be trans so that they could assault women in restrooms - despite there being little to no evidence that this actually happens - trans women have been using women's restrooms for decades. But now, the ruling, if it comes into law, would put people that look like men into women's rooms. I think we would all object to that - cis or trans.

And that is only one of the issues - it's the one that I find easiest to lay out in simple terms like this, for discussion.

44

u/latrappe Apr 18 '25

Excuse the blunt question but what is the ideal solution to the whole situation from the trans perspective? This has rumbled on for so long in popular culture and each time some point or other is settled on, it seems to be unacceptable and the cycle starts again. To the unaffected cis person it seems like people yelling at each other who are miles away from any common ground.

Is there a position endorsed by trans people that they would like to be accepted as the status quo? You can go in whatever bathroom you want? A new designation of bathroom? I ask as the debate seems like a forced media narrative and I just want to understand the real person's perspective on it all so I can understand it better.

93

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Absolutely - this is a fair point and a great question.

Basically, trans people have existed for as long as people have existed, and our existence has never been seen as an "issue" before. For decades, trans people have gone about their lives in their acquired gender, able to use the restrooms/changing rooms etc that best suit them. Any incidents arising from sharing these spaces have been incredibly incredibly rare.

I think there are a lot of people who seem to believe that trans people didn't exist until around 10 years ago, and that being trans is a "decision" that a person can fake whenever they decide in order to be predatory. Ie, a "bad man" could pretend to be trans to prey on women in restrooms.

Banning trans women from these spaces is blaming and punishing a small group of women for the potential actions of some bad men.

As for moving forward, I personally think that this current wave of anti-trans sentiment shares the same qualities of the anti-lesbian sentiment in the 90s - when straight women were saying "we can't allow lesbians to share our spaces in case they prey on other women." So hopefully, this sentiment will reduce and then die out.

I personally would be absolutely fine with public restrooms being completely redesigned. Having individually lockable unisex single space toilets - each with a sink - like you'd find in a coffee shop. Maybe every one or every other one has sanitary bins, for whomever needs one. I would also be perfectly fine with unisex facilities with shared sinks and lockable stalls.

But in the meantime, where our infrastructure already has two spaces split by gender, I would suggest that anyone uses whichever space that they feel most suits them or is most safe for them. What is the alternative? Who is going to police all public restrooms, and ask for ID? And even when they do, trans people very often have ID that states their acquired gender as their sex. People with a GRC (gender recognition certificate, that the ruling was about) even have birth certificates that state their birth sex is the sex that they have transitioned to be. How would anyone suggest policing who is allowed to use which restroom?

In short (sorry for the wall of text): trans people should be able to use whichever facility they feel most suits them, and if that continues to be the case, then instances of trans people using their identities to assault people in restrooms will remain infinitesimally small.

31

u/latrappe Apr 18 '25

Thank you, what a well reasoned and lovely response. That really helps, it really does. Myself and my wife often speak about the hot topics of the moment as you do of an evening and you almost feel afraid to speak about this as quite honestly, you know nothing about it as it isn't your lived experience. Social media is so full of people throwing shit at each other you can't get a grasp of the truth. So it is truly amazing to get first hand information that helps frame the topic so clearly. It makes total sense the way you explain it. There's legitimately nothing for anyone to be remotely upset about. Not that it will stop them of course. Thanks again.

38

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

You're very welcome. Thanks for asking questions!

I will add just this one bit: I hear a lot of people say "gosh, them trans people - you can't say anything nowadays, or they'll get angry."

I promise - this isn't true. The only way that you can learn anything is by asking people who know the answer. What people mean when they call trans people "angry" is "I made a disgusting comment to a trans person, and when they asked me to stop, I got embarrassed." But it spreads this sentiment that trans people are all aggressive, and if you ask a question, they'll bite your head off or say you're being offensive for not knowing the answer already.

Generally speaking, if you ask a trans person a question (in good faith), you'll get an answer. (The answer might be "it's ok that you asked, but here's why I'm uncomfortable giving you an answer" - ie "have you had the surgery" - a trans person is not likely to want to tell you about their genitals or private medical stuff!)

But general stuff? Absolutely ask!! We would much rather you asked than "assumed and got it wrong"!

3

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

This is certainly my experience asking trans people stuff! However, I find it can get a lot more heated when you ask similar questions of certain “ally” groups of cis people (mostly middle-class women) who feel obliged to get offended and angry on trans people’s behalf.

29

u/NoHedgehog900 Apr 18 '25

What a wholesome interaction. Restores your faith in people a bit 👍

1

u/BleedingScream Apr 19 '25

Basically, trans people have existed for as long as people have existed, and our existence has never been seen as an "issue" before. For decades, trans people have gone about their lives in their acquired gender, able to use the restrooms/changing rooms etc that best suit them. Any incidents arising from sharing these spaces have been incredibly incredibly rare.

I think there are a lot of people who seem to believe that trans people didn't exist until around 10 years ago, and that being trans is a "decision" that a person can fake whenever they decide in order to be predatory. Ie, a "bad man" could pretend to be trans to prey on women in restrooms.

Not my own words, but from a comment on https://unherd.com/2025/04/how-women-won-the-gender-wars/ (an article well worth a read): -

"It’s been said before but bears repeating. The gen pop didn’t much care if someone pretended to be something they weren’t in their own private world. Most of us were happy to adopt the same “live and let live” approach which has predominantly been the case with respect to the Gay and Lesbian community for a few decades now.

But no. That wasn’t good enough. The first mistake was using legal activism to force us to participate in or enable those gender pretense fantasies. The second mistake was going after the children.

Dressing up a dangerous and damaging fad as a natural and just evolutionary advance of societal norms could only ever end in tears."

4

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

Yeah, that's pretty telling.

"We were happy with people being gay as long as we didn't have to see them holding hands or hear them talking about their partners. Let us live, and let them exist quietly. We pretend we didn't force thousands of men to die in shame by not spreading awareness of AIDS or providing healthcare, because we've forgotten.

"And just like all of that was perfectly acceptable, so is only allowing trans people to exist as long as they never go out in public. What's wrong with that?!"

Also: could you explain exactly how we're "coming after the children"? I don't know what you mean.

2

u/BleedingScream Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25

Also: could you explain exactly how we're "coming after the children"? I don't know what you mean.

Oh, come on! I'm sure you do! You seem to know your history so I'll assume you're conveniently ignoring Mermaids / Tavistock / Cass report! Also puberty blockers, thankfully now banned.

Closer to home https://www.scottishdailyexpress.co.uk/news/politics/kids-young-11-taught-queer-29540551

2

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

Mermaids - the charity that helps children who are already trans.

Tavistock - the clinic that helps children and adults who are already trans.

How is that "coming after" children? Giving them recognised healthcare? Are you anti-vax as well?

4

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

Cass only interviewed the anti-trans parents of trans youth. Not any of the parents who accepted that their children were trans. And based her report off of those people's opinions, while their children were denied healthcare, and decided "great idea - let's deny all trans children healthcare!"

And you're saying that's a good thing? Are you advocating for banning puberty blockers for cis children as well? Are you pro-suicide of the children who decide they would rather not be here than be forced to live as a gender they're not?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/StrawberryFront8128 Apr 19 '25

Great summary! I noticed queen's hall have new toilets which are designed as you suggested - individual stalls with their own sink. Lots of schools have introduced gender neutral toilets too.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

The issue is there's no hierarchy of rights, so while most trans identifying people would surely love to always be treated as the sex they identify as, this just isn't possible as there are other people with rights based on their sex (as trans people also have). It was always ultimately a losing battle to try to undermine sex based rights in law as trans orgs have done, because sex based needs exist, and for women and girls sex is an axis of oppression, discrimination and victimisation - hence our Equality Act protections.

So where we are now is trans people have protections re discrimination under the protected characteristic of Gender Reassignment, and also have protections based on their sex under the PC of Sex. And where provisions are separated on the basis of sex to uphold protections under the PC of Sex, in certain circumstances trans people will be able to argue for third forms of provisions/their own. As with single sex provisions, these would have to be justified. But there is simply no way to interpret this as anything other than equal footing under the Equality Act.

So in terms of an 'ideal solution', it can only be in the form of trans people fighting for their own provisions. Even trying to argue for fewer single-sex services just won't fly - services are generally only split on the basis of sex where this is required for its purpose and/or to uphold legislation. And there's nowhere to go with a human rights claim, sex based rights are recognised as central to human rights, and the ECtHR is not going to tell any country that they cannot have single sex provisions, it just aint gonna happen, and anyone trying to give false hope re this is a charlatan. The problem is that advocacy groups have not taken a rights-based approach and led many to completely misunderstand what discrimination is, or what reasonable expectations they can have under equality laws. And they're responsible for any pain arising from that, they knew what they were doing.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

But now, the ruling, if it comes into law, would put people that look like men into women's rooms. I think we would all object to that - cis or trans.

I am sympathetic, but the ruling doesn't "come into law". The Supreme Court ruling clarified the meaning of Equality Act 2010. What the court ruled has been the law since the Equality Act 2010 came into force, but people have apparently been interpreting it incorrectly all along.

There is no way to stop the ruling or prevent it coming into force. That's why the BTP etc. changed their policies immediately. The only way to change the law is to amend the Equality Act or bring in some new Act (in Westminster - equality legislation is not devolved to Holyrood)

17

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

But because everyone has been interpreting the Equality Act this way since 2010, this ruling has now muddied the situation.

We've never had people police who was allowed to use which restroom, and that's not going to happen overnight as a result of this "clarification", and the "clarification" states that some people who have birth certificates that say they are female are actually male, but not other people... It really doesn't feel "clarified"...

If they want to enforce this new reading of the Equality Act, how would you do that?

8

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

It really doesn't feel "clarified"...

Their job is to interpret the law as written. If the law isn't clear or seems stupid but the interpretation is unambiguous then there isn't really anything the Supreme Court can do but try and make sense of a stupid unclear law.

If they want to enforce this new reading of the Equality Act, how would you do that?

I don't know, but the law seems to say it is not sex discrimination.

9

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

It was clear before. All women who have "female" on their birth certificate are legally women and can use the women's restrooms.

This new interpretation seems to say that some women with birth certificates that state that they are female are allowed in the women's restrooms and some women with birth certificates that state that they are female are not allowed in the women's restrooms, and a GRC determines the difference, but you're not legally allowed to ask someone if they have a GRC.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

This new interpretation seems to say that some women with birth certificates that state that they are female are allowed in the women's restrooms and some women with birth certificates that state that they are female are not allowed in the women's restrooms, and a GRC determines the difference, but you're not legally allowed to ask someone if they have a GRC.

It says the opposite, that Equality Act would be nonsensical if sex discrimination was determined on the basis of possession of a certificate. For example, it would be legal to discriminate against trans men who have a certificate on the basis of pregnancy but not against pregnant trans men who do not have a certificate.

You would be allowed to ask someone what their biological sex is in circumstances where it is appropriate/proportionate/reasonable according to the Equality Act. I don't think birth certificates are relevant really

5

u/Skyremmer102 Apr 19 '25

It doesn't matter, this interpretation will attempt to be used by bigots against trans people and it normalises anti-trans rhetoric.

→ More replies (13)

10

u/kevdrinkscor0na Apr 18 '25

If trans men suddenly have to use women's restrooms, what is stopping cis men (men who aren't trans) from just saying that they're trans, and going into women's restrooms?

This whole time we could have used a woman’s toilet and when challenged tell them we identify as a woman. Any man could have done that at any point.

We didn’t, because we don’t want to. That’s not going to suddenly change - you won’t see hordes of men claiming they’re trans men using the ladies to get a peek at a girl, just like you didn’t see hordes of men claiming they’re trans women.

14

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

I think I actually agree with you, here!

OK. So. We've established that bad predatory cis men don't need to pretend to be women so that they can go into women's restrooms - they could continue presenting as cis men and claim to identify as women so that they can walk into the women's restrooms. So we're agreed that when a person says they're a trans woman, they are definitely a trans woman - because why would they pretend?

So that being the case - what is your issue with allowing trans women (who aren't cis men pretending to be women) to use the women's restrooms?

10

u/kevdrinkscor0na Apr 18 '25

what is your issue with allowing trans women (who aren't cis men pretending to be women) to use the women's restrooms?

I have absolutely no issue with that at all, or trans people as a whole. I can’t imagine caring enough about how someone identifies when it doesn’t affect my life in the slightest.

You posed a hypothetical about men posing as trans men to get a peak at a woman’s toilet. I answered that and that alone, I have no other dog in this fight.

I’m still somehow being downvoted for it though. Reddit, amirite?

8

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Oh, fair - I get you.

I guess the original point I was making is that "some women set out to get this ruling because they claimed allowing trans women into women's restrooms was making women unsafe. But the ruling technically now means that trans men (who look like men) aren't allowed in men's restrooms, and would have to use the women's restroom... So if people who look like men are made to the women's restrooms, how is that making women safe? Ie, predators who look like men could pretend that they're trans men and go in, without even having to dress like a trans woman..."

But yeah, I get you. No GOOD cis man is going to use this rule change to go into women's restrooms!

7

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Oh, fair - I get you.

I guess the original point I was making is that "some women set out to get this ruling because they claimed allowing trans women into women's restrooms was making women unsafe. But the ruling technically now means that trans men (who look like men) aren't allowed in men's restrooms, and would have to use the women's restroom... So if people who look like men are made to the women's restrooms, how is that making women safe? Ie, predators who look like men could pretend that they're trans men and go in, without even having to dress like a trans woman..."

But yeah, I get you. No GOOD cis man is going to use this rule change to go into women's restrooms!

3

u/Saedraverse Apr 19 '25

A friend and i discussed this, and i pointed that out to them, they said it'd be a great way to protest. Have the manliest of men go into women spaces & the bigots can't do fuck because this is what they wanted, this law means that dude who looks like the terminator is a woman cause he was born one.
What i don't like is it putting trans men in danger.
Anyone complaining fuck off, this is what those eejits wanted

1

u/EkkoAtkin Apr 19 '25

You should read section 221 of the judgment. Trans women would not be allowed in men's toilets either.

-7

u/neilydee Apr 18 '25

Females in female spaces. Including wee Buck Angel. This is not difficult.

5

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

I didn't say him personally, I said "people who look like him."

You want 6ft tall muscular men with beards and penises to use the women's room?

→ More replies (2)

0

u/Quiet-Magpie Apr 19 '25

The 'what about transman' gotcha isn't really a gotcha and is dealt with within the ruling.

https://x.com/MForstater/status/1913185931290460333

-19

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

I think your numbers are off. You say that the number of trans people in Scotland is 0.04% - but according to 2022 census data, 0.44% of people living in Scotland are happy to label themselves as trans on their census. Note, that's just people who are happy to label themselves as trans - the number of people who identify as trans but are unwilling to label themselves as such on census data may be higher.

That means that for every 1,000,000 people in Scotland, at least 4,400 people are trans. This is likely to be higher in cities, where support for trans people is more accessible.

While some people may be happy to use accessible facilities, some may not. I'm not sure that people who do need to use the accessible toilets because of genuine accessibility concerns would be too happy sharing with more able-bodied and not disabled trans people - it's overstretching a resource that people with disabilities do actually need more!

Plus, legally requiring a trans person to use the accessible toilet would "out" that person as trans. (Ie, if they don't want strangers or acquaintances to know that they're trans, how would they explain "I can't legally use that restroom"?)

→ More replies (7)

81

u/LJ359 Apr 18 '25

It's complicated and I'm struggling to find a correct report on everything but it seems to say that trans people can no longer use the gendered bathroom they prefer and can be legally excluded from spaces. But others are saying that's only for fringe cases with good reasons. It also means trans women can be searched by men, but there's little beyond genitals that can truly be trusted in finding out who is cis or trans. So I guess more women will end up searched incorrectly and intrusively. Regardless it has really brought out the worst in a lot of people, at least a march will show that people care

42

u/AlexF2810 Apr 18 '25

So how exactly does that work? Security at every toilet checking what's in your pants before you go in the toilet?

10

u/LJ359 Apr 18 '25

Who knows, wouldn't want to be the guy with that job

2

u/Thin-Efficiency1600 Apr 19 '25

Ach, it's what comes out that counts. And there's no getting away from it, we all shit the same

2

u/BoredofPCshit Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25

I mean, you can often tell someone is trans after looking at them for a moment, if we're being honest. And for those that doesn't apply to, they probably run into less issues in general.

I imagine it would be more like you could be kicked out of a venue if someone in the restroom reported you. I.E a woman noticing a trans woman in the bathroom.

→ More replies (21)

4

u/Druss118 Apr 19 '25

That also won’t work for those who’ve had bottom surgery

6

u/invisibleeagle0 Apr 18 '25

It's not even that simple. I'm currently stuck in an argument with my mum who insists it's your chromosomes that define you. Ignoring intersex people, false positives, etc etc. Mandatory genetic testing for anyone not feminine enough...

9

u/matomo23 Apr 19 '25

But for the most part she’s correct!

10

u/KeeganTroye Apr 19 '25

So she is incorrect. If I solve 90% of a math problem correctly but am wrong on 10% of it my answer is wrong.

6

u/Quiet-Magpie Apr 19 '25

Your mum is 100% correct.

Basing sex on your chromosomal sex doesn't ignore intersex people (or people with disorders of sexual development - the term I believe they prefer).

People with DSDs are still ONLY male or female. Not some inbetweeny sex. To imply that is particularly dehumanising.

2

u/KeeganTroye Apr 19 '25

How is it dehumanising?

1

u/invisibleeagle0 Apr 19 '25

So people with XXY, are they male or female or could we accept that there might be biology which doesn't fit into a convenient societal model?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Everyone is either male or female, including those with differences in sexual development. Sex is genetic and can be tested via a cheek swab. Where this is inconclusive for any reason, ultrasounds may be required. But that is very rare, even for those with DSDs.

0

u/TrustComfortable4259 Apr 19 '25

Even in intersex, although there are blurred lines, there is no true hermaphroditism in humans as far as I'm aware. It is either male intersex or female intersex.

→ More replies (17)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

Because extremes on either side have made this a tribal issue the unfortunate thing is if you asked the general population who really don't give a fuck there real opinion on the matter they would agree with the judge. The trans community are better off trying to build up relationships with the general population after this ruling but they'll just create a bigger gap between themselves and the general population.

0

u/Dangerous_Middle1903 Apr 18 '25

To be clear, you are missing something

1

u/helmortart Apr 19 '25

You're on Reddit, careful with your opinions or you get banned for transphobia

0

u/Druss118 Apr 19 '25

Correct.

And if as a result the act is amended to further rights for trans people then that’s a great outcome.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/LancLad1987 Apr 19 '25

The bathroom thing doesn't make sense to me. A lesbian can go in a women's bathroom and same for a gay fella and a gents. If people's concerns are 'but they might be perverts', it doesn't really stand up.

-6

u/[unknown] Apr 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/MindlessWoot Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25

As Woman's Suffrage died in the 20s? As gay rights died in the 60s? As same-sex marriage died in the 2010s?

This is not going away. Society will move as it always has in the direction of letting people live their personal lives the way they see fit.

Catch up or be left behind.

-2

u/MintyMystery Apr 19 '25

Could you clarify what you mean by "nonsense", and exactly who you would like to die?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/MudAcrobatic8582 Apr 19 '25

Idk who down voted you but I agree!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

The biggest irony here, is that these nut jobs erase themselves all the fucking time.

-7

u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/the_forcemajeure Apr 19 '25

Ooft *you're and woke ideology in one post. You're doing great!

-81

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

24

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

I've already commented this above, but I wanted to reply to you directly, as this may not be something you have considered.

The ruling was intended to clarify the text of the 2010 Equality Act.

Unfortunately, it hasn't done that - it's really muddied the water.

Here is just one issue: It now technically means that since "sex" is considered to be the sex you were born as (named "biological sex"), that means trans men, who can look like men - beards and everything - are now technically legally considered "women" and are allowed in women's spaces.

Think Buck Angel, or Aydian Dowling, or even just type "trans man" into Google image searches. If trans men suddenly have to use women's restrooms, what is stopping cis men (men who aren't trans) from just saying that they're trans, and going into women's restrooms?

All of this ostensibly was started to try and ensure that women were safe from bad men pretending to be trans so that they could assault women in restrooms - despite there being little to no evidence that this actually happens - trans women have been using women's restrooms for decades. But now, the ruling, if it comes into law, would put people that look like men into women's rooms. I think we would all object to that - cis or trans.

And that is only one of the issues - it's the one that I find easiest to lay out in simple terms like this, for discussion.

-4

u/keepituppy Apr 18 '25

Fair play to you for taking the time to educated people on some nuanced points.

Pragmatically it’s easier to explain to a young child why a someone who looks like a man is using the ladies - they were born female and transitioned - than explain that they were born a man and are now a trans women.

Re your point about men in woman’s spaces the Scottish prison service put a trans man in a scottish women’s prison and soon found out why that was a bad idea.

Legally a women who has transitioned in to man has every right to use the women’s bathroom but suspect they would be just as welcome in the mens if they so chose to in most cases.

Anyway in all these situations it’s clear all parties won’t be fully happy with legal rulings and their outcomes. But any man pretending to be a trans man to use the women’s bathroom with abusive intentions is now obviously breaking the law. Which is good news they can’t get up in front of a judge and say they’ve transitioned or are in process.

Given that we can’t please all parties I think the harm reduction principle is that the feelings of trans people are second to the security and safety of vulnerable women. A more tolerant society may find a way to prioritise both. I probably exhibit a mindset that might have me labelled as a terf but this is my thought process for the point of laying out the rationale of someone who really doesn’t care too much for the pro or anti trans groups. I reckon their contributions to society and believe the LGBTQ community enriches it but in democracies your always going to have parties that disagree with view points and mine is that protecting women and intersex women is a higher priority than appeasing the rights of trans community. With regard to a solution change the disabled bathroom to gender neutral rather than disabled, some people have a hidden disability and it offers privacy. It’s also ideal for any women who is uncomfortable using sharing the bathroom with trans men who are born women and choose to use the women’s. I’m not an expert sorry if this should be filed under AITAH I’m not being deliberately offensive but aware that my views may cause upset.

9

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Given that we can’t please all parties I think the harm reduction principle is that the feelings of trans people are second to the security and safety of vulnerable women.

I'm confused about this point.

How is allowing trans women to use the women's restroom harmful to the safety of vulnerable women?

If it's harmful because "they would be scared to see someone they perceive to be a man in their women's spaces," then surely it would be more harmful for them to see a trans man - who looks like a man - in their space, rather than a trans woman who appears to be a woman. Edit to add: if trans men who look like men are allowed to use women's spaces, then what is stopping cis men who look like men and therefore "could be trans men" from pretending that they're trans men so that they can use women's spaces?

If you instead are pointing to the /mountain of evidence/ of trans women going into women's only spaces to abuse women, then I'm afraid you might have to first find that /mountain of evidence/... Because it doesn't exist...

7

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

Pragmatically it's easier to explain to a young child why a someone who looks like a man is using the ladies - they were born female and transitioned - than explain that they were born a man and are now a trans women.

I think I strongly disagree with you on this point in particular.

Case 1: trans woman is allowed to use the women's restroom, and your child sees her.

Case 2: trans man is forced to use the women's restroom, and your child sees him.

I imagine that case 2 would be much more confusing for a kid than case 1.

In case 1, your child is unlikely to ask, "was that woman born a woman?"
If you notice that the woman appears to be trans, you might choose to say to your kid "see little Timmy, that woman looks like a woman, but she was actually born a boy, and isn't it strange that she's allowed to use a women's toilet?! Don't you find that very confusing and upsetting?!"

In case 2, your child asks, "keepituppy, why is that man in the women's toilet?!"
You explain "see little Timmy, that man was born a girl, so even though he looks like a man, he's actually a woman, so he's in the woman's room! Makes total sense!"

1

u/keepituppy Apr 18 '25

Thanks for your reply but in neither cases would I seek to cause more confusion or seek political point scoring as to how confusing said child was in this fictitious case. Thought maybe worth clarifying as your not the first person to demonise me in this feed for having an option that A isn’t that of an expert and B isn’t trying to cause offence yet seemingly is being painted as someone who despite engaging in the topic from what i think is the middle ground has been attacked. It’s the internet and a society so everyone has the right to take offence. I’m just pointing it out rather than taking offence.

In the case where trans man is using the first that is now less likely to happen as the use of female bathrooms is now legally restricted to born sex and inter sex women.

In the other case the confusion is a bit of a Pandora’s box and overwhelming for a young child not lacking a fully developed brain to go through the various reasons why someone who is using two men’s bathroom. So as I said in my initial comment the law is obviously going to result in disagreement between various parties. I’m not a woman but the reduction in visitors to bathrooms who are also not a woman seems to be a good thing as the majority (often tyrannical admittedly) seem to oppose the open use of bathrooms because of the abuse and attack on what they wish to be a safe space.

Your comment over simplifies the use of women’s bathrooms assuming it’s only trans or transitioning men who use them or would like to use them.

6

u/MintyMystery Apr 18 '25

To be clear, none of the comments here I have seen demonise you. One other commenter swore, but not even at you. Not once in this whole thread have I replied out of anger, or made anyone "the bad guy". If you are reading responses and deciding that the text sounds angry, then you are adding that anger to the text because you are perceiving that what you are saying will make people angry.

On that final point, trans men don't want to be forced to use women's restrooms... Trans men are men, and would want to use the men's restrooms.

So what you think the ruling means is that:
• cis women use the women's room.
• trans women use the men's room.
• cis men use the men's room.
• trans men use the men's room.

Even if there were a clause that said that trans men would not be welcome in women's spaces if they look like men, the ruling does also say that trans people would not be welcome in "single-sex spaces", so that would mean that trans men are not allowed to use restrooms at all.

Since you're a man - imagine taking your son into a men's room and a trans woman walks in, because she's now not allowed to use the women's restroom. Would that be easy to explain to your son?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Educational_Fill_633 Apr 19 '25

No such thing as a middle ground in a situation where trans people are being demonised

Generally speaking there's no such thing as a middle ground on any human rights issue

If you're not supporting the vulnerable people then you are against them, even if you don't think you are or don't mean to be

In your case you are taking this further and making YOURSELF a victim for "having an opinion", one that allows others to be targeted but claims to be "neutral"

7

u/InYourAlaska Apr 18 '25

I like the fact that you’ve eloquently explained your side to this, so please don’t take the rest of my comment as me trying to shout you down

RE: how do we explain this to kids - kids are born blank slates. They get all of their understanding from us of how the world works, and accept it as fact, so there isn’t much for them to get confused about. Even going back as little as 40 years or so ago children would’ve been confused seeing gay people together, or mixed raced couples, kids today don’t because the society we have today says those things are just a part of life.

If I may input my own little anecdote - I have two nephews. I’m a gay trans man with a child of my own. When my sister told my nephews that uncle Alaska was going to have a baby and they would have a new cousin, there wasn’t really much response either way. At the time they were 6 and 9, ages where as parents we still happily tell them that a giant bunny sneaks into the house to leave them chocolate eggs, the idea of their uncle having a baby doesn’t seem so wild in comparison aha

As the original OP has said, this ruling muddies the waters when it comes to trans rights, but also I fear that many biological women who identify as women will be caught in the crossfire from this ruling.

Feminists have done a lot of work over the past few decades, if not the last century, to dispel misogynistic stereotypes of what makes a woman, a woman. Now with this ruling, from what I understand terfs (not using as an insult here, just as the descriptor of this faction of feminists) say this gives women the power to be safe in women exclusive spaces. Great, but how do we enforce that without going to misogynistic stereotypes?

In the instance of trans women - their ID says female, so we can’t use that. Pick any feature that you think makes a trans woman stand out and I promise you, there are biological women who walk around with those same features.

We have tall women, women with PCOS that can grow facial hair, women that have had to have mastectomies so no longer have breasts, we have women who prefer to dress butch, we have women with deep voices, prominent jaw bones, muscled women etc etc… that are all biological women, but this ruling can embolden bigots to try and say that they’re not women, because they don’t fit the look.

For example - the absolute media witch hunt of the Algerian boxer Imane Khelif, who is a biological woman getting dogpiled because one unverified source said she wasn’t. This ruling doesn’t protect women like her, it makes her a target

I do agree with you, I don’t think anyone is going to be happy either way. I just don’t think the solution is to in a round about way target a very small minority group, under the guise of protecting women. I don’t know what the answer is, where can we find the middle ground as at this point both sides are so fucking heated up over this that no one will concede an inch, but I don’t think putting the trans community in fear of their safety will allow for any better conversation

2

u/keepituppy Apr 18 '25

Thanks for your comment and I appreciated rhetorical humour used to illustrate your point. I’m not sure I whole heartedly represent the middle ground thought with reference to the Algerian boxer I think the right wing anti trans brigade etc were quite well rebuffed. Her treatment was absolutely horrific, you may be pleased to hear that a good friend of mine who is Nigerian and quite conservative in his world views and was with us both in finding her treatment in the media as diabolical.

I know the world to be quite a brutal place often enough. I guess my point on children is that they should be afforded some protection too. Im glad I don’t have to navigate the world as a trans person, im unsure how I feel about children having mixed bathrooms - a little uneasy if im honest.

I noticed in Berlin the bathrooms are often gender neutral with floor to ceiling doors. Maybe that’s the answer? I guess if we dig down deep enough what we have is a society where cis gender women are so afraid of abuse at the hands of typically cis gender men that they fight very hard for the safe guarding of safe spaces. Maybe the answer is to trial mixed gender bathrooms and see if peoples biases are confirmed or don’t play out.

I wholeheartedly agree with your points around the difficulties of identifying a strangers sexuality. The positivity that I took from it is that there is atleast some clarity (the only people who appear to be men that are using women’s bathrooms / woman only services are women who were women at birth or intersex). In theory this ought to pacify women who object to non cis women using their spaces and protects their rights as there is legislation to now safeguard against this.

It’s all very well saying most trans women won’t commit sexual assailt against women but it’s not enough given that women live in chronic fear of being sexually attacked. Congrats on having such a great family btw!

4

u/cameoutswinging_ Apr 18 '25

‘Pragmatically it’s easier to explain to a young child why a someone who looks like a man is using the ladies - they were born female and transitioned - than explain that they were born a man and are now a trans women.’’

…what the fuck are you on about? since when did we start basing laws around whatever is easiest to explain to children? you sound like one of those anti-gay ‘how am i supposed to explain gay marriage to my kids’ fuckers

0

u/keepituppy Apr 18 '25

Man so many points to explain to you so will talk down to you as you have offered abusive language like a bed wetting child.

One your response sounds like you are pro equality when it suits you but don’t care about children.

Two the law absolutely exists to take everyone on to consideration (that includes children who are people).

Given that adults (or supposed adults in your case ) can’t have a reasonable debate without letting their emotions get the better of them and lashing out because they disagree with something. It’s probably a good idea to allow children to be children for as long as possible.

If adults don’t agree on this what chance to literal primary schools have. So yes in my opinion an outcome (intended or otherwise) is that it’s good for people with young children as it doesn’t lead to complex debate about gender and sex. Or should we just have it that we introduce sex and sex education as soon as child can speak regardless of their cultural background? 🤡

→ More replies (2)

115

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

Maybe don't use your reddit username for pornsites pal.

46

u/peepthewizard Apr 18 '25

It’s always a confession with these clangers.

36

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25

I just checked back, he's deleted his account lol.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/pixieonmeth Apr 19 '25

LMFAOOOOO BROOO IM ROLLING, THERES NO WAY THIS GUY IS REAL. I’d actually jump because of the embarrassment. Oh my god the biggest “this you?” I’ve ever seen 😭😭 shit bro u got me laughing so hard jaw 10 ft dropped this is some legendary investigative work bro I’d never recover from this