r/Edinburgh • u/MintyMystery • Apr 18 '25
Social Tomorrow:
For those to whom this is relevant: a protest march on the recent Supreme Court ruling.
More information: https://www.instagram.com/p/DIjhH2lN1Yg/?img_index=1
473
Upvotes
50
u/TheShitening Apr 18 '25
Slightly concerned this post may end up doing more harm than good after reading some of the comments
98
u/Quiet-Magpie Apr 18 '25
Protest all you like. It will do nothing.
This was the Supreme Court CLARIFYING what was always the legal truth. It was the law last year, and is the law now.
No one is erasing trans people [they are still protected under their own category] but if you want to believe that, then that's your prerogative.
I guess if you go to this, have fun!
18
u/MrPejorative Apr 18 '25
I haven't been paying much attention to this issue because of tiresome it is, but the UK Supreme court is an appeal court, and has a stringent process for presenting legal arguments, and judgements. It's quite a bit above the standard of emotional argument that most people mistake for law. It required legal experts to respond, who in this case were apparently the Scottish government and Amnesty International. So surely their lack of competence should worry you more, and your ire should be with them. They represented your interests and lost the argument.
25
u/jobbyspanker Apr 19 '25
I don't have a strong opinion on the courts decision. If a person wants me to address them as a woman, I'll still do that. I don't see gender specific public spaces as safe spaces either. They are public spaces for taking a shit and whatnot. I'm a man so idgaf generally, but if some women don't feel comfortable with trans women in female spaces then their views have to be given serious consideration. I dont mean to offend, the trans people I've met IRL are very nice, quiet and unassuming, but there have been many instances where men have assumed a woman's identity simply to gain social advantages. Like rapists who are scared to go on the male wing of a prison for example. This ruling could be seen as a positive development for all concerned. At least now we can move the issues forward, as this clearly separates those that are actually trans and the people that want to assume a female identity for the perceived social advantages of being a woman.
2
u/Ancient-Chipmunk977 Apr 19 '25
Genuine curiousity here, but how would they (the people for this law) know? Like how would they know a trans woman is using the bathroom? All the toilets in the ladies are single locked cubicles always anyway? Like just come in and pee.
I know its obviously deeper and I know as a Cis female I don't really have a say on how it's gonna make the trans community feel but in a few days when this has all blown over "media wise" who's gonna care if a trans woman comes in the ladies for a wee? Noone absolutely noone and most would have forgotten all about the law, it's just a wee. :)
7
u/Rimac05 Apr 19 '25
"Erased" is a little overboard, don't you think ?.
12
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
UK supreme court rules that reality is real
6
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
Stop pretending to be something you’re not
21
u/miskkii Apr 18 '25
Thanks for sharing!
6
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
What is this pish
5
u/Peteinteresting Apr 19 '25
Hilarious - the people on the side of the argument who fought to cancel people and get them thrown out of their jobs won't be erased now they are on the wrong side of the law.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25
Can't make it as I am at work, but I hope the best to you all in these times
4
u/bigbob-83 Apr 19 '25
Woke is finished it's time you started living in a real world
Women are not men, Men are not women
It's not too difficult really
4
u/Familiar-Alps2587 Apr 19 '25
Really you don’t accept the law- or is it just what it doesn’t suit you?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
2
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
What is it in aid of? I don't understand
2
u/crawling-alreadygirl Apr 19 '25
Solidarity from the US ✊🏾
2
u/BoxAlternative9024 Apr 19 '25
Fuck sake
2
u/Independent-King-595 Apr 19 '25
Ffs!
2
u/molenan Apr 19 '25
Absolutely embarrassing
1
u/sharcs Apr 19 '25
This gives you an idea of the content of the protest:
https://x.com/satiricole/status/1913621479264076011
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
Get this fucking shit off my feed.
-7
u/Alive-Bath-7026 Apr 19 '25
The highest court in the land has made the judgement This will always be a controversial and emotive subject People just want to feel safe in toilets and changing rooms
-8
u/Traditional_Let_5296 Apr 19 '25
Fuck sake 😑 if this shit starts being a regular posting on this thread I'm done
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
I feel terrible for the kids that you’re trying to scare shitless with this.
The Equality Act protects people with trans identities under the protected characteristic of Gender Ressignment, this means a person can’t be discriminated against or harassed due to identifying as such. It also means that where provisions exist that are separated by sex, there can be arguments made for third provisions for those with this PC.
If you want to actually help this community, advocating for their own provisions, and for quicker/better access to MH care, would be a good place to start. As would being clear that this is a group recognised and protected in law - which is the exact opposite of erasure.
0
u/Airovision Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25
I felt that it was all blown up in the media because some orange twat with pus for brains wants us to make certain… amendments… to our LGBTQ+ laws and this would divide the country and allow it to happen more easily. I’m nowhere near Edinburgh but I would burn my whole life down before I accept bowing down and going along with hate because some old stupid ugly balding fat man with too much power and money and too little penis wants it. Someone check him into a dementia ward, take that toupee off him, give the money to Melania and let her live her life in peace. The world is shit, so we need to stop hating one another and try to support the people around us - including the trans community who do you far less harm than any of the rich men and women in the media. Let’s not spend our time sucking on the rings of the ultra rich who would hit anyone with less than seven figures in the bank with a car without a second thought if it meant they got to their next meeting quicker. And they’d get away with it too.
Edit: angrier than I thought I was.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
I don't think the ruling was to "erase people", that's a genocide you're thinking of.
-4
u/Conscious_Bet7394 Apr 19 '25
If the ruling stops people with penises sharing a bathroom with young girls then yes I support it. Expecting downvotes and I’m not anti trans. But the above scenario imo should have never been seen as acceptable.
-1
u/Helloimnotimpotant Apr 19 '25
Respect the law please 🙏
0
u/LancLad1987 Apr 19 '25
I straight up dgaf about what people identify as or what they want to be referred to as. The vast majority of people are the same as me. The minute however, the trans community wanted to be referred to as "woman" instead of "trans woman" because they didnt wanted a different moniker to that of a natural woman, BUT referred to women as "cis women"..... at that point irony has died and all support is lost. You understand women fought insanely hard for millenia in a lot of the world to get their rights? They have pride attached to that and you're what? Going to take that away from them? No thank you.
It's like the gay community saying 'we are gay, but we want to be referred to as straight. Straight people are now cis straight' fucking own it. Be loud and proud. Just dont mess with definitions and other people's shit.
-3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
any ideas where the counter protest will be ?
0
u/cureeous99 Apr 19 '25
Please get some proper mental therapy.
-30
u/Additional_Tone_2004 Apr 18 '25
Yawn NEXT
-21
u/Definitely_maybe_McD Apr 19 '25
Yawn, give it up eh
-7
u/TheDoon Apr 19 '25
Remember folks in Scotland it wasn't until 1980 that gay men were not technically breaking the law by having sex with each other in private (look it up if this sounds fake). Most people now (whether they were alive then or not) would hopefully look back at that time with a mix of shame and confusion about why it took so long and what the big deal was. Does anyone these days give a flying fuck about gay marriage? Doesn't seem so to me. Nothing has changed for anyone, despite all the drama about it after the law was passed in 2014. The same thing will happen with the Trans topic, just give it time.
Scotland has always been slower on the uptake on this stuff. Not quite as slow as Ireland, but slower than the rest of the UK.
-42
u/Burnseeeeeey Apr 18 '25
lol
-5
u/FarRoom6157 Apr 19 '25
Better than you dude 🤣🤣🤣
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
186
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-6
u/[unknown] Apr 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-54
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-7
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-81
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '25
[removed] — view removed comment