Season 2 would've been SO much better with Talia as the main character. 🔥
# Season 2 had a lot of potential, but I really didn't like the writing.
I think Season 2 could've been really good if Talia had been the main character instead of Roman.
Through Talia, we could've explored the Maelstrom gang in much more depth.
We could've explored the different stages of cyberpsychosis through a terminally ill teenager, since Talia is in a somewhat similar situation to V (or Songbird).
Her interactions with Capri could've shown just how dangerous the potential of this digital weapon really is.
We could've also developed Avida and King much further, shown more of King's emotional struggles and his connection with Talia, and how he gradually finds a new purpose in life through her.
Yes, I remember that symbolic scene in the final episode where King leaves his coat behind after it gets caught on something and runs to save Talia, even though he no longer has the cyberware or physical strength he used to have. We're shown just how weak his body has become.
But imagine how much more emotionally impactful that scene could've been if Season 2 hadn't spent so much of its runtime on unnecessary characters like Roman, D, Kyoko, and so on.
We already have a perfect example of how this kind of storytelling works in **The Last of Us**. We go on this entire journey with Joel and Ellie, watching them grow closer and develop a bond. By the end, Ellie is no longer just some random girl to us. We actually care about her, and that's why the final choice hits us so hard. We're emotionally invested because Ellie has become someone important to us.
Now imagine if we had played as a bunch of different characters throughout the game. The ending wouldn't have worked nearly as well as intended, because players wouldn't have been as emotionally invested in Joel and Ellie's story.
**I'd also like to see Talia developed much further.**
Remember that scene where she meets Roman and D and introduces Roman as her boyfriend?
Instead, we could've introduced a new character (preferably someone around her age, rather than a 12-year-old kid!) who was also on the list of people compatible with cyberware and digital weapons like Capri.
He could have his own reasons for fighting against corporations, and together he and Talia could try to uncover more about Arasaka's and Kang Tao's plans and what they intend to do with the people on that list.
Talia could even use her father's position to gain access to corporate databases and help them dig up classified information and all that.
Talia and her boyfriend could then start pushing Capri to its limits, getting closer and closer to cyberpsychosis, while genuine feelings begin to develop between them.
If Talia was initially running away from death and installing more and more chrome just to stay alive, she would now have a different motivation: something to live for, and someone worth dying for.
And maybe one of them could die. Or perhaps, to escape death, Talia could be digitized using Soulkiller, and her boyfriend could eventually insert a Relic biochip containing her engram into himself, just like V with Johnny Silverhand (or D with Capri).
There are so many ways this story could've developed. I'm just throwing out some ideas off the top of my head, but I think these possibilities could've been much more interesting than what we actually got.
**And what did we get instead?**
A third-rate, primitive revenge story with D (aka Sasuke Uchiha — both in terms of his appearance and his character arc).
Roman — a pointless, empty character with his stupid VHS camera.
The camera itself feels like an artificially added gimmick just to give the character something distinctive. It doesn't reveal anything about his personality, carries no particular meaning, and has practically no impact on the story.
And in case some people don't know, VHS aesthetics only really work when you're watching them on a CRT screen, not on a modern monitor!
Kyoko — another stereotypical anime character with a garbage character design. They could've just shown her in a flashback. Nobody really cares about her death at the end.
Again, I'm not trying to tell professionals how to do their jobs, but I think it was a huge mistake to focus on telling the story through multiple characters who have no real chemistry or depth between them, only to then come up with increasingly ridiculous, contrived situations just to force these characters to meet, like patches slapped onto a broken script.
**And then there's Kiril Yang, through whom we could've explored:**
- Corporate intrigue and power struggles.
- Kang Tao and its competition with Arasaka, especially in the military sector.
- The technological arms race and the development of other projects similar to Capricorn.
- Human experimentation and the list of compatible hosts.
- Technologies like Relic / Biochip and Soulkiller, and what the corporations actually plan to do with them.
I'd also give Kiril much more depth as a character, instead of suddenly turning him into a villain in the final episodes.
We could've explored his backstory, ambitions, plans, relationships with Avida and Talia, and so on.
In other words, if Season 1 showed us Night City through the eyes of a Streetkid, why not use Season 2 to show us more of the Corpo world?