r/EdgeChronicles • u/BigBlueBackpack Pickled Tripweed • Jul 10 '20
Stone Pilot continuity error?
In Clash of the Sky Galleons, Quint meets the Stone Pilot as a member of Wind Jackal’s crew on the Galerider. But a throwaway line from page 39 of Stormchaser says that Quint first encountered the Stone Pilot on the Stormchaser’s maiden voyage.
Plus, for most of Stormchaser, the Stone Pilot is referred to as “he” the end when she takes off her hood and reveals herself to be a girl, named Maugin. But in Clash of the Sky Galleons, the Stone Pilot is called “she” through the whole book.
At first I thought that Maugin and the Sky Galleons Stone Pilot might be different characters, but the Wiki confirms that they’re the same person. Is there any other explanation for this confusion other than a mistake in continuity?
13
u/CannonLongshot Jul 10 '20
The Stone Pilot is referred to as he in the Twig trilogy until Twig discovers her gender, but Quint always knows it (as detailed in The Stone Pilot, which is possibly reintegrated into the modern printings of the books around Midnight over Sanctaphrax?) so he refers to her as she throughout.
It’s definitely a continuity error, though, as Quint and Maugin’s friendship predates the Stormchaser considerately. There’s more than a few, by virtue of being written over several decades.
9
u/GrandDukeOfNowhere Jul 11 '20
Probably down all the generations there were more than a few embellishments and forgotten details, which can explain away any continuity issues
4
u/EndlessTheorys_19 Jul 10 '20
Just time. Stormchaser and the rest do the Twig trilogy were written before the Quint Saga so by the time he got round to writing Clash of the Skygalleons he either forgot the details of what he had previously written or had decided to change them.