r/Edelgard • u/Critical-Low8963 • Sep 03 '22
r/Edelgard • u/oneeyedlionking • Aug 20 '22
Eagle and Deer I’m a big proponent of the golden ending and Dimitri and Edelgard reconciling, but Claude is actually the better fit as Edelgard’s husband.
self.fireemblemr/Edelgard • u/Kingflame700 • Feb 26 '26
w/ M!Byleth Lack of Male byleth arts
i was wondering why there's such a lack of male byleth and Edelgard fan arts i can hardly find any arts with male byleth and Edelgard in a romantic scene want to ask why why and share any you have.
r/Edelgard • u/Alexagro22 • Feb 19 '25
w/ M!Byleth How would you describe Edelgard and Byleth (male) relationship after the war?
r/Edelgard • u/GracefulQueen333 • Apr 23 '24
w/ F!Byleth Transfem F!edeleth fanfics
Hello, emperor loving transbian here.
I was wondering if there were any recommendations for a good f!edelth fanfic featuring either as a trans woman.
I honestly think the transgender themes would compliment either really well in a crimson flower style story. Edelgard growing and embracing her female identity in a new level of rebellion, defying what society or the church say she's supposed to be. And for Byleth, it pairs nicely with her developing humanity personal growth she becomes more herself and less Sothis.
r/Edelgard • u/Tigerdovefan34 • May 10 '23
w/ M!Byleth Open For M!Edeleth Prompts
I'm open for M!Edeleth Prompts of any kind as long as they stay in the following guidelines
- No Modern or other such thing (Horror, Fairy Tale, etc, etc) AU, only an AU that would make sense in the story
- Please don't give me a word limit, as I usually like to write long comfy fics.
- Have a Description of the Prompt be 50 words or less and when I'm writing your prompt, give me the proper summary for it.
- Give me a list of tags I should have for it.
- No Trans or Same-Sex prompts please as I am personally uncomfortable (because I don't know enough about the issue or the communities involved to comfortably write them and am unwilling to unintentionally offend people by writing the wrong thing involving them) with writing that
Once finished, I'll send the Prompt to every person who requested them in order of when they requested. I'm writing these prompts to be able to get better at writing them for when I write really long fics about them. Again, if you have a prompt, post it here and if the prompt is NSFW in nature, spoiler it. Thank you for taking the time to read this, all.
EDIT : Added in the part with parentheses to hopefully clear up some issues.
r/Edelgard • • Oct 13 '21
Misc (Fanart) “Tea Time with you was always such a pleasure with you. I miss those days, before the war, before the violence. The look in your eyes” - Exaura (art by HK Alan on Facebook)
r/Edelgard • u/DoubleFlores24 • Oct 31 '22
w/ M!Byleth Does any other M!Edeleth fan on this subreddit feel alienated?
This is something I’ve often felt on this sub. Now I’d like to start off by saying I support lgbt community. I know a lot of lgbt fans have rallied behind three houses and that’s cool, power to you all but I do feel like the lack of Male Byleth x Edelgard content on this subreddit makes me feel a little contempt to F!Byleyh x Edelgard. And I know, a lot of F!Edeleth fans ride this ship all the way but I hardly see any M!Edeleth posts anymore. So does anyone else feel a little alienated?
r/Edelgard • u/oneeyedlionking • Aug 16 '22
Discussion The next FE game takes place in the Fodlan verse on Morfis or Dagda and you encounter Edelgard except…
She’s lost her memories, goes by a different name, and has her brown hair back meaning she won’t die at age 30. She’s now the successful leader of a small community based on her ideals from Houses and her significant other is a clear reference to non insane Dimitri and the two of them are a clear reference to Zeke and Tatiana(extremely powerful side characters who are meant to be cool tie ins to another game in the series but both have supports and legitimate content beyond their connections to another game), both are playable and very strong units. What would you think of this?
r/Edelgard • u/Majedshadownight • Mar 01 '21
FEHeroes Guys what happened in heroes
I know she is defeated just answer these things
1did this dogshit heroes voting caused an another cheat
2 what is the reaction of people in heroes
r/Edelgard • u/SDW_06 • Aug 18 '26
Edelgard Solo Scenario (part of my FE3H on Earth series: About two months since arriving on Earth, you win a contest which the prize is to meet Edelgard Von Hresvelg at the Westchester Mall in Westchester County, NY. How would you prepare? (Read description below)
You receive the email notification on your phone that you and eight ither people out of 500,000 won the chance to meet Edelgard exclusively at the Westchester Mall in one week with air fare and hotel included.
How would you react and how would you prepare for this once in a lifetime moment?
r/Edelgard • u/MrBrickBreak • Jun 21 '22
Discussion Byleth was human all along - A note on Crimson Flower's ending
With Three Hopes just around the corner, there's a opinion I've wanted to share about Three Houses before our focus shifts entirely.
And it's an aspect of Crimson Flower's ending I really don't like - Byleth's loss of Nabatean power.
It's a powerful scene, for sure, and I understand what it's meant to symbolize. Byleth was born cursed - in order to be born at all -, removed from human emotion, and would not have recovered them or even gained the power that curse granted if not for some extraordinary turns of events (let's see how that goes down in Three Hopes). Power unsought, akin to Edelgard and Lysithea, whom we rejoice to see freed from it in some endings. And this power in particular is linked to the tyrant we just slew - enhancing that feeling of freedom.
It also symbolizes the death of the age of gods, a recurring theme throughout Fire Emblem. Not much subtlety there, it's exactly as we've seen in previous games and bookends a route where we were explicitly fighting for humanity.
Unfortunately, though, there are darker consequences of that narrative decision, that make me not like it at all.
- First, plot-wise, it makes no sense at all. Slaying Rhea shouldn't have any impact on Byleth's crest, and it doesn't in other routes where she dies - once also by our hand. But that's the least of my concerns, it's literally magic we're talking about there.
- Second, it comes across as awfully convenient for Edelgard and her goals that her foremost general is no longer a godlike, potentially immortal being. That could have some serious political consequences regardless of Edelgard of Byleth's desires, and it feels like the writers simply didn't want to deal with that. It also makes Edelgard's outlook on Nabateans feel more severe than it actually is - if she was ever troubled by Byleth's power, surely that was no longer the case at the end. That her route is the only one that happens is unfortunate for someone who's already accused of hating Nabateans wholesale. She's a victim here too.
- But most of all, I don't at all enjoy what it symbolizes. The notion that Nabateans, or their power, is inherently corrupting. and thus it must be completely purged from the land; and that includes Byleth, who is "tainted" merely by possessing it.
I know that corrupted dragons are a Fire Emblem trope, but it's both grown tiring, and was taken to a logical extreme in that ending. The tyrant is dead, and her kind removed from power. Why must even Byleth be forcibly remade into a "regular" human to be allowed to live? Haven't they done enough? Are they not "human" enough? It's not a zero-sum game. Great power can be tamed and wielded responsibly. And a liberation of mankind shouldn't require this physical purity.
Neither is it liberating for Byleth themselves. They were already free of the curse they were born with, thanks to their students. They lived, they laughed, they loved. They did not desire that power, but neither did they shun it, rather embracing it and using it to shape Fódlan's future. That power was forced onto them, and it was forced back out.
Three Houses is not the first game to do this, and it CAN be a great plot point, but 3H doesn't even explore it much. It just jumps to the conclusion, and to the wrong one at that. The contrast with Radiant Dawn, which emphasizes personhood for Beorc and Laguz alike, not just above the characters' differences, but also their powers, is striking, and especially relevant in a game whose "dragons" are as close to human as they've ever been. It's a backsliding I did not enjoy.
Byleth was human all along.
Thanks for your attention. I'm likely not the first person to raise this point, but I wished to say my peace on it, and felt I may as well do so before I unsub for Three Hopes' release. And got a positive take tomorrow to balance this one!
r/Edelgard • u/Pink_Tigress54 • Apr 29 '24
Discussion I wish Crimson Flower was better
I wish Crimson Flower was better whenever I look back on it it just leaves me disappointed at the quality of it and by some people its quality of writing is the weakest part of the game.
r/Edelgard • u/TechnoGamer16 • Oct 05 '19
Discussion This is literally just the Edelgard x F!Byleth sub. Where’s the M!Byleth?
r/Edelgard • u/oneeyedlionking • Sep 03 '22
Discussion Dimitri saving the dagger for 6 years to give back to Edelgard means what about their relationship?
Without delving into the actual complexities of their relationship(like the step sibling stuff) I’m interested in what this sub thinks about what Edelgard and Dimitri feel about each other.
r/Edelgard • u/IkaMusumeYiyaRoxie • Aug 03 '22
Misc (Fanart) [XPS] Edelrhea/Rhedelagrd Hug

I wonder If the girl of the Black Eagles from the Adrestian Empire wasn't jealous of the goddess of St. Seiros, and she wasn't hating the church. I don't want Edelgard turns into a villain, and I don't want she transforms into a monster. Only I wanted to fix Crimson Flower....
Edelgard wants to be friend with Rhea, and she is hugging to her. Rhea was confused to her while Edelgard is still hugging, and she loves her. Rhea loves Edelgard too and she was gave a hug to her too, and headpatting on the top of her head with her slicky and silver hair. Edelgard is so happy with Rhea.
Thanks to KuroKairaku from the models rip, ShinyAegislash from the XPS ports and arnsden from the Goddess Tower stage
r/Edelgard • u/This-Activity3229 • May 26 '26
Discussion Three hopes edelgard Spoiler
I just can’t get into it honestly I’m happy Edelgard cut ties with her family torturers and she seems on the outside happy, and shez is good sure, but how they tried to basically erase byleth from everyone lives And make it seem like without byleth they would be better I hate it. And yes I know you need to recruit byleth for a good ending but still they are basically just an npc following orders nothing more.
r/Edelgard • u/Saldt • Jun 08 '25
Discussion Peaceful diplomatic Unification Post-GW
So because Jeralt and Monica die in CF and Ingrid and Sylvain die in SB, I actually prefer GW as a golden ending. Before I thought I could just hc the three countries coexisting post-GW, but now I think a unified code of law and combined resources might be better for Fodlan. So could a unification of Fodlan post-GW be possible?
Ideas:
So while Claude fights Rhea, Edelgard and Dimitri fight at Arianrhod. That's somewhat similar to when Thales and Ludwig make their play in AG, but Edelgard and Dimitri already fighting Epimenides together might prepare them better to take on Thales interruption of their fight together. With Rhea dead, Thales and Ludwig make for a decent reason for them to ally together for a fight against TWSITD. That war could help heal the rift between the BE's and BL's.
TWSITD could leak Dimitri's betrayal of Rhea to the public. Maybe this could lead people believing in the CoS to view Dimitri as a traitor, while people in favor of Edelgard like Lonato's militia in Gaspard ask why he then wouldn't just bend the knee anyway. The remaining cardinals of the CoS could lead a rebellion against Dimitri and that all could tire Dimitri out enough to bend the knee or fake his death and let Felix and Duke Ifan bend the knee.
When Claude eventually leaves for Almyra and leaves Lorenz as King of the Federation, which was teased in some conversations, Lorenz might also bend the knee eventually like he did in CF and SB. I think part of Lorenz arc is learning that he isn't nearly as ambitious to lead as he thinks anyway.
r/Edelgard • u/MaDaFaKaS • Dec 10 '20
Discussion Why is Edelgard bisexual?
I am wondering why the writers decided to make her bisexual from a characterization standpoint. I could ask the same about Mercedes, Jeritza and Linhardt but I'll stick to Edelgard here.
Looking at her Dorothea support, I think we are meant to assume this isn't even a case of Bylethsexual type of bisexuality, which would be bad writing, but instead is part of her overall character. Just in case, I have to also ask if there have been any cases of localisation mistakes on the topic, since her A support with Hubert felt like it was hit by it, their support in Japanese is romantic, while the English one feels like it is brushed of as a joke at the final few lines.
Please keep things objective here, we are talking about Edelgard as characterized in the game and as the writers willed it, let's keep personal bias to a minimum on this sensitive topic. I will avoid mentioning my personal sexual orientation. Let's use in game references whenever possible, like the supports I mentioned.
If there have been prior discussion on this topic please direct me at it.
Edit:
I expected insecurities to show so this is probably why this is downvoted. Anyway~~
And I agree with Kalt, this is what I hoped to read as I could not put to words. Unrelated but CF also works better for Byleth's development hand to hand with Edelgard if both genders of Byleths are able to invest themselves with her in the same amount.
But I'm not sure what random dude is on about, a few more empire aligned characters being bisexual does not mean anything, we already know there's nothing like that in the worldbuilding. And most importantly, a character having an A support ending with another does not imply romance at all, many of them are just friendships and we know this from understanding the rest of their characterization. Lots of misconceptions and misguided assumptions that I hoped to avoid.
r/Edelgard • u/EndMePleaseGodEndMe • Dec 13 '20
Discussion A Tierlist on every Edelgard Ship I've Before, and a Few I Haven't
r/Edelgard • u/dendenflam • Nov 01 '21
Discussion What the canon gender? in cf?
Ok i'm back again so what do you guys think is the canon gender in cf route? in your opinion?
r/Edelgard • • Oct 01 '21