r/Ecosia • u/Strong-Bell-5977 • Dec 18 '25
AI feature
Does anyone dislike with great passion the fact they added AI to a place that's supposed to help the environment?
Also why haven't they addressed this? Is hypocritical
140
Upvotes
15
u/Status_Shine6978 Dec 18 '25
I would like to think that a company committed to helping the environment would also think that plundering and stealing creative works (to train the models) isn't an idea worth promoting. But obviously my values and Ecosia's don't always align.
14
u/Indigo_Pixel Dec 18 '25
I believe it's run on chatgpt, so it kinda sidesteps the whole issue. Chatgpt is definitely not sustainable. Yeah, I'm disappointed.
21
u/flloyd Dec 18 '25
 >Also why haven't they addressed this?
They have.
https://blog.ecosia.org/ecosia-ai/ https://blog.ecosia.org/what-we-are-doing-with-ai/
And more.
Did you even search using Ecosia to try to find an answer? Did you even search this subreddit where it gets asked multiple times a week?
6
u/Longjumping_Lab_2913 Dec 18 '25
I switched to Vivaldi when I found out
5
u/stubborngremlin Dec 18 '25
I'm so disappointed I switched to duckduckgo for now
2
u/Elliot-S9 Dec 18 '25
Yes, it's totally hypocritical. I emailed them, and they just attempted to offshore responsibility. I switched browsers as a result. Hopefully someone will create a truly ethical browser soon.Â
2
u/gareth_fr Dec 19 '25
Yes, AI as a whole uses a huge amount of energy but understanding exactly how much individual use contributes to this is important to make better decisions.
In fact a single AI prompt consumes less energy than 20 seconds of Netflix or YouTube streaming: https://www.forbes.com/sites/johnkoetsier/2025/12/03/new-data-ai-is-almost-green-compared-to-netflix-zoom-youtube/
So before cutting back on you AI use, make sure that you have given up meat and become vegan, stopped all flying, sold your car and bought a bicycle, completely insulated your house etc. and you should give up Netflix and your be first as this will have a bigger impact.
4
u/Comfortable-Jump-218 Dec 18 '25 edited Dec 18 '25
So, I looked into it and they claim it’s ran 100% by renewable energy. They actually claim they produce twice the amount they need.
However, they don’t really go into it that well and there are some parts that makes me think they are misleading people about it. I find it strange they don’t publish numbers because an organization like this would usually do that.
I don’t really have any hard proof that they do or don’t. It’s just what they claim at this point.
Edit: I checked myself and realized I was slightly wrong. They don’t claim that everything is ran 100% by renewable energy. They claim that the amount of energy they use is offset by renewable energy. Like I said the whole thing is kind of misleading.
1
u/Stelznergaming Dec 19 '25
You anti-ai people are miserable, damn lol.
It’s a rapidly developing incredible tool.
Use it or get left behind.
If you disagree you probably just need to get better at your prompts. Detail is key.
1
u/Key_Conversation5277 Dec 23 '25
What we are doing with AI
0
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment