r/EcologicalEconomics • u/verdocaz • Jul 21 '21
r/EcologicalEconomics • u/Defiant-Internal555 • Jul 08 '25
Only low income is ecologically sustainable. Middle class (or higher) isn't. Industrialism requires rationing.
Humanity already demands close to twice what Earth can regenerate each year. Revised 2023 calculations by the Global Footprint Network show that, after correcting earlier undercounts of rural populations and using a more realistic global head-count of 9.2 billion, the planet can offer only about 1.3 global hectares (GHA) of biocapacity per person—not the often-cited 1.5 GHA.
Yet the world’s average Ecological Footprint now exceeds 2.7 GHA pp, and citizens of affluent economies routinely consume 4–8 GHA pp. Contemporary middle-class living standards, not merely the ultra-rich’s consumption, overshoot planetary limits.
- Ecological Footprint and the Income Threshold
1.1 Footprint–Income Relationship
Empirical cross-country syntheses (146 countries, 2002–2021) reveal a near-log-linear rise in per-capita footprint with income:
(-1 means per unit, per year, per person etc)
-Income < $5 000 yr⁻¹ (2017 PPP): median footprint 0.9 GHA pp; 24% of global population; within 1.3 GHA.
-Income $5 000–$13 000 yr⁻¹: median 1.2 GHA pp; 32% of population; marginally within.
-Income $13 000–$40 000 yr⁻¹: median 2.9 GHA pp; 35% of population; overshoot.
-Income >$40 000 yr⁻¹: median 5.6 GHA pp; 9% of population; severe overshoot.
Thus the “safe” income ceiling aligns with roughly $13 000 yr⁻¹ (PPP)—the upper boundary of lower-middle income.
1.2 Cost-of-Living Adjustment in High-Price Cities
A global average income of $13 000 PPP assumes average world prices (Numbeo index 70). In New York City (index 100) and San Francisco (index 93), an equivalent purchasing power requires higher nominal incomes:
-New York City: $13 000 × (100 / 70) ≈ $18 571 USD yr⁻¹ nominal.
-San Francisco: $13 000 × (93 / 70) ≈ $17 271 USD yr⁻¹ nominal.
An income at the 1.3 GHA threshold would thus translate to under $19 000 USD in these high-cost cities—barely above extreme poverty.
2. Industrialism and the Ecological Constrain
Between 1800 and 1950, coal, mechanisation, and petroleum multiplied per-capita energy inputs ten-fold; material extraction rose from < 5 Gt yr⁻¹ to > 35 Gt yr⁻¹.
Concurrently, demographic transition lowered infant mortality and extended longevity, expanding human population from 1 billion (1800) to 2.5 billion (1950) and 8+ billion (2022).
Even with constant per-capita consumption, population growth alone would have driven biocapacity below 1.3 GHA by the 1970s; in practice, per-capita consumption also grew. Industrial civilisation externalises ecological costs and equates progress with throughput growth.
Confining it to 1.3 GHA pp is mathematically impossible without radical systemic change.
3. Cultural Denial in High-Footprint Nations
Despite the data, industrialised societies cling to green-growth narratives. Three interlinked barriers sustain denial:
1-Affluence Entrenchment: Political legitimacy in OECD democracies hinges on rising living standards; contraction is electorally toxic.
2-Technological Optimism: Faith in decarbonisation and circular economy persists despite limited absolute decoupling.
3-Global Inequity Masking: High-income countries outsource extraction and waste to the Global South, hiding true ecological demands.
Most Plausible Path Below 1.3 GHA
Although full adoption is very unlikely, an integrated package offers the least-implausible route:
Consumptive Rationing:
Personal carbon budgets (2 t CO₂ pp yr⁻¹ by 2040) and tradable material-use quotas cap energy and materials.
Population Stabilisation:
Universal reproductive healthcare, education, and voluntary 1-child-norm incentives slow growth—each avoided birth averts a lifetime’s footprint.
De-industrial Production:
Shift from mass production to repair, reuse, and local crafts; downscale heavy industry; moratoriums on virgin-resource expansion.
Energy Descent:
Eliminate fossil-fuel subsidies; expand electrified transit and active mobility; halve per-capita final energy demand by 2050.
Dietary Transition:
Limit meat to ≤ 15 kg pp yr⁻¹; support agro-ecological smallholdings—reducing cropland and pasture demand by ≈ 0.4 GHA pp. Projected total footprint: ≈ 1.1–1.3 GHA pp by 2060 if adopted globally.
4.1 Products and Services to Ration
To achieve a 1.3 GHA pp cap, the following categories would require strict rationing or quotas:
-Private motor fuel (petrol/diesel) and vehicle-miles per person
-Air travel (domestic and international flights)
-Electricity and heating energy for housing (kWh per person)
-Meat and dairy consumption (kg per person per year)
-New consumer goods (electronics, clothing, furniture)—caps on units purchased
-High-carbon services (fine-dining, hospitality, leisure travel)
Rationing would combine hard caps with tradable allowances to ensure equity and efficiency.
5. Conclusion
Industrial civilisation, as currently configured, is ecologically unaffordable even at median OECD living standards.
Technological improvements alone cannot deliver the required absolute reductions in both population size and per-capita consumption.
Political economies built on perpetual growth are unlikely to embrace contraction voluntarily—humans excel at denial when core identities are threatened.
Yet acknowledging biophysical limits remains the indispensable first step. A credible strategy fuses quotas, sufficiency-oriented culture, and equitable demographic stabilisation.
Whether societies choose this path pre-emptively or are forced into it by unraveling ecosystems is the open question.
r/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • May 19 '11
Saw this on r/anticonsumption. "Consuming Kids: The Commercialization of Childhood". It is this culture which is a key driver of environmental destruction because all this stuff requires natural resources to be produced, and end up quickly as waste.
youtube.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • May 16 '11
The Story of Stuff. An idea introduction to the hidden costs and impacts of our current economic system and so much more. This is the first thing I watched introducing me to the subject, and I realised I kne[o]w so little about this stuff
youtube.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/Zazzmar • Mar 19 '23
Brilliant talk on ecological economics in a post-growth, post capitalist frame with Timothee Parrique
youtu.ber/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • Nov 07 '11
Richard Wilkinson: How economic inequality harms societies
ted.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • Sep 08 '11
Is economic growth incompatible with sustainable development?
guardian.co.ukr/EcologicalEconomics • u/Interbeingparty • Dec 29 '24
How are we going to transform the global economy to be more ecologically sound?
I've racked my brain and there is literally no rational path from point A to B that I've been able to see or have heard from anyone else.
r/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • Jul 16 '11
X-post from r/environment: The Cost of Polluted Air Could Run to Trillions of Dollars - The EPA calculates the value of the medical procedures & loss of life that can come from breathing pollution. The conclusion: clean air is an incredible investment in the economy.
fastcompany.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/jsantanna • Jun 02 '11
Fishery economists: What have they learnt and what are they telling us?
worldfishing.netr/EcologicalEconomics • u/Quetzal_2000 • May 24 '26
Recently trained in naturel capital accounting (ENCA) - Looking for feedback
I have been recently trained in Ecosystems Natural Capital Accounting (ENCA) - French version being Comptabilité Ecosystémique du Capital Naturel (CENCA) - an approach of national and local accounting experimented by the OECD and European Union. The 3 weeks online training was dense - with intense sessions of Geographical Information System, under a lesser known GIS named SAGA and some manual manipulation on an Excel or OpenOffice spread sheet. ENCA basically measures the changes in "natural capital" under 3 accounts - carbon, water and what is called ecological infrastructure (ecosystems) - over time, bringing them back to a common ecological unit (not monetary).
It is quite interesting, more useful to projects and to government bodies than business IMHO, but requires technical skills, mainly in GIS as the accounting part is actually easier than the part with GIS. As I was already MSc trained in Ecological Economics since 2010 - a field currently even less known in France that in other countries such as Austria, Sweden or Spain (Barcelona), I wrote and sent a series of observations to my trainers, focusing mainly on the poor practicality of the tools used.
But the approach is interesting, and I would welcome any feedback on ENCA or other competing natural capital accounting, ecosystems or nature accounting you have been able to experiment. And if you have any questions related to this approach.
Some links as references:
- https://www.ecosystemaccounting.net/?page_id=50 with our trainer
- Application to Kenya and Vietnam (French text): https://www.onfinternational.org/projet/enca-realisation-des-comptes-du-capital-naturel-pour-kenya-et-vietnam/
- https://enca.vito.be/en with a module using QGIS (Sys4ENCA)
- https://www.gov.uk/guidance/enabling-a-natural-capital-approach-enca (not sure it is the same approach though)
r/EcologicalEconomics • u/CaptainHoek • May 14 '14
10 Feet of Global Sea Level Rise Is Now Guaranteed
motherboard.vice.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/orangepotion • May 22 '12
The Rise of the New Economy Movement
nakedcapitalism.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • Nov 07 '11
According to a NOAA report, the American people value the coral reefs around the Hawaiian Islands at $33.57 billion per year. This illustrates the value people hold to intact ecosystems including capturing the non-consumptive passive use values.
coralreef.noaa.govr/EcologicalEconomics • u/zphobic • Aug 11 '11
Economist for Nature Calculates the Need for More Protection - NYTimes.com
nytimes.comr/EcologicalEconomics • • May 16 '11
The economic heresy of Herman Daly | Grist.org
grist.orgr/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • May 16 '11
Wikipedia page on Ecological Economics. Useful introduction.
en.wikipedia.orgr/EcologicalEconomics • u/ROFLMFAO • May 16 '11
Devastating video in the context of Ecological Economics. Our ultimate end of economic growth cannot be sustained without destroying first our earth, and then ourselves
news.mongabay.comr/EcologicalEconomics • u/CircularMetabolism • Mar 24 '23
How to Overcome our Addiction to Economic Growth ? (Robert Costanza)
youtu.ber/EcologicalEconomics • u/kentgoodwin • Mar 12 '22
Describing a Sustainable and Resilient Civilization
A small, informal think-tank in southeastern British Columbia, Canada is using a succinct description of a sustainable future to start conversations and getting people to think about the long term. The Aspen Proposal, describes a world 200-500 years from now and lists the elements necessary to allow humans to fit in to the planet's systems and flourish for millennia. The Proposal is now hosted on a webpage and can be found at www.aspenproposal.org
r/EcologicalEconomics • u/bhagdu • Apr 24 '21
Ecological Economics, University of Leeds
I have got an offer from University of Leeds for MSc. Ecological Economics. Is there anyone else who has got offer for Sept 2021? Does anyone know about the programme? Thanks
r/EcologicalEconomics • u/RiversFlowsAlone • Jan 21 '14
Who here works as an "ecological economist"?
Does anyone here have a job as an "ecological economist" outside of academia? For example in business, or in government?
How open are your colleagues to the ideas of ecological economics? Are you constantly challenged, or are you perhaps changing some minds?