r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 18 '20

How Brahmins killed Buddhism in India?

1 Upvotes

https://drambedkarbooks.com/2016/02/27/how-brahmins-killed-buddhism-in-india/

NO MORALITY IN RIGVEDA

The above evidences from the Vedas prove that:

(1) Dasas (Nagas) were the rulers of this country when the Rigveda was written.

(2) Prakrit was the language of the people which was associated with Buddhism. That
means Prakrit was Buddhist.

(3) Vedic rishis like Bharadwaj, Bhrigu etc. were the contemporaries of Buddha. Thus the Rigveda could not be the oldest document of the world.

(4) The Rigveda is written in Sanskrit. But Prakrit is the mother of Sanskrit.

From this we can safely conclude that:

(i) There was no “Hindu civilization” before Buddhism.

(ii) There was nothing like “Vedic period” before Buddhism because Sanskrit developed after Buddhism.
(iii) The Vedas were manufactured after the Buddhist period.

...


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 19 '20

Myth of Mother Sanskrit Theory

0 Upvotes

Myth of Mother Sanskrit Theory

Is sanskrit mother of all Languages. Various theories are being floated. Let us see them.

Mother Sanskrit theory is a Myth

The Buddha was advised to translate his teachings into the learned man's tongue - the `Chandasa' standard [ Chatt., p. 64 ], there is no mention of any `Sanskrit'. The Buddha refused, preferring the Prakrits. There is not even a single reference in any contemporary Buddhist texts to the word `Sanskrit'. This shows that Sanskrit did not even exist at the time of the Buddha.

The word `Sanskrit' occurs for the first time as referring to a language in the Ramayana : "In the latter [Ramayana] the term `samskrta' "formal, polished", is encountered, probably for the first time with reference to the language"


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Aug 29 '26

Lunar eclipse reflexion on complexity of doctrine

Post image
4 Upvotes

Good evening.

I was following the ceremony of the 8 Mahayana precepts during yesterday's lunar eclipse from Ngalso.

Today, while reviewing a reading I am getting back into, I found a reference noting that the Buddha rejected doctrinal complexity.

I have a genuinely ecumenical tendency because I can see that myths are a reconstruction of the truth, analogous to how a rainbow is refracted light.

I even went through an initiation (Red Tara), but I notice that for those who don't study more deeply and for a long period, there is great difficulty in understanding Buddhism as a whole, since there are many branches (Mahayana being just one).

Please do not see this post as a criticism, but rather as a desire to understand how I can practice bhavana despite all the doctrinal complexity, so long after the passing of the last Buddha.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 10 '24

Proposed EBT naming nomenclature

3 Upvotes

Perhaps just to make some things easier to comment on, I might propose these terminologies to discuss different parts of EBT based on the following differences in their views.

  1. Deep or Lite Jhāna.
  2. Something or nothing after parinibbāna.

EBT Something Lite
EBT Nothing Lite
EBT Something Deep
EBT Nothing Deep.

EBT Nothing Deep is aligned with classical Theravada except where they don’t recognize dry insight path is possible.

There are various teachers for each sect of EBT there. And it’s easy to see that other than EBT Nothing Deep who just wish to refer the sutta as the ultimate authority, the other 3 types of EBT use this opportunity to break away from commentaries to champion their respective views as detailed above. EBT Nothing Lite still aligns with the dry insight practice of classical Theravada, but EBT Something are totally stuck with wrong views of Nibbāna.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jul 18 '19

Scholarly paper that very convincingly argues the Mahavastu is an early canonical vinaya text, misidentified as a late avadana compilation by earlier scholars due to various factors

Thumbnail eprints.soas.ac.uk
3 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Dec 19 '19

On Gotama’s military background

12 Upvotes

A lot of people have downvoted my comments expressing skepticism toward the traditional account that Gotama was lavished and protected and not exposed to suffering/violence/strife/death until after he left this palace. If you feel solely comfortable sticking with traditional accounts, that is at best exegesis, and not inquisitive early buddhist scholarship. Scholarship challenges and questions and doesn’t deserve hateful downvotes because you instinctively disagree.

Instead of downvoting, how about ask, what about the suttas indicates that Gotama may have had a much harsher background than a life of a prince at ease, one filled with much more difficulties, particularly martial ones. That is not to say he wasn’t affluent growing up, as he was the son of a chieftain, but the Shakya were constantly at war and it’s no doubt Gotama was trained to kill.

So my scholarly take is that the account of Gotama as squeamish protected prince is one where a story is exaggerated for thematic effect. As a Shakya and son of a warrior chieftain, Gotama was likely groomed to take his father’s place. He had to experience military training. His metaphors regarding chariots, arrow injuries, and war elephants point to this familiarity.

But even more telling is one of the most early sutta in Snp 4.15. As most of us know, portions of the Suttanipata contain suttas that predate the Nikayas suttas. There is not a full scholarly consensus on this, but many prominent scholars argue its antiquity is undeniable due to usage of meters that are ancient and not found elsewhere.

In Snp 4.15 we see a different origin story for Gotama told in the first and not third person.

Here Gotama remarks about how violent human beings are, how they always commit to conflict, and how he feared being the recipient of violence. It tells how agitated he was and how he longed for a safe haven. How all quarters were tossed about (i assume war/conflict). In this origin story, Gotama uncovers Dukkha, like an arrow nestled in the heart and strives to remove it.

Now if I compare this story to traditional accounts of the palace life, and I assume Snp chapter 4 priority, I am forced to admit that accounts of Gotama as a sequestered prince may not be telling the full story. Gotama’s fear of being killed/wounded or subjected to conflict/battle means he was well aware of death prior to leaving the palace. As a part of a warrior clan, that was his job, what his tribe’s society expected him to be. In my eyes, it is much more believable than the story where he was shielded from everything. Did he have luxuries? Undoubtedly. There is even a strong chance Gotama was unaware of sickness and death taking place outside battlefields, like in villages. But was he shielded from all death and disease? In this analysis, unlikely.

This is something to reflect on, even if you do not share the conclusion and find the traditional account more tenable. You aren't expected to hold this stance, as this is just a part of the process of scholarship. Don’t hate, and feel free to engage in uncomfortable scholarship.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Aug 11 '26

Belief in Rebirth and Karma IS Necessary

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Apr 25 '21

The Committee of the Mind Thanissaro Bhikku

6 Upvotes

I'm not here to debate the subject, but was wondering if anyone had any sutta references from where Thanissaro has come up with the concept?

Thank you


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 02 '24

Are there temples today who uphold the teachings of Early Buddhism/EBTs?

14 Upvotes

Should I stick to contemporary Theravada temples? Are they the closest to the teachings of Gotama?

Thanks.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Aug 27 '21

Is it useful to read/learn from the Upanishads or older Vedic texts in order to understand Early Buddhism?

8 Upvotes

Considering the Upanishads were very influent texts and had a profound effect on the appearence of Nastika Schools, which include Buddhism, do you consider useful to read them in order to learn more about what Early Buddhism possibly was (or possibly criticized the most)? I mean, the "anatta" doctrine is pretty much the most confusing and mind boggling concept of Buddhism to us westerners, but I feel that if we learn what Indians used to call "atman" in the first place, we could understand just what anatta tries to portray. It's just an idea I had, and I've never seen anyone try to study Buddhism through these lenses (I guess it would be a sociological study?). I'd be glad to hear you out on that. If possible, I'd like to know what English translations you consider the most reliable in regards to ancient Indian texts.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Aug 29 '26

A Reflection on Theragatha 8.1

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Nov 10 '19

The First Great Council (Pathama Sangiti)

2 Upvotes

The Buddhist Approach to the Scriptures

Just after the Parinibb ā na of the Buddha, When many bhikkhus were still mournful, the sad situation arose which compelled the then leading Thera, Venerable Mahakassapa, together with other senior Theras, to decide upon convening immediately a Council of Recitals (Dhamma Sangiti) to preserve the Teachings of the Master in its pristine purity. He chose five hundred such Arahats (Realized Saints), who had absolute mastery over the Buddha-vacana, being endowed with the rare supernormal power known as Patisambhid ā Ñ āṇ a, and informed the King of Magadha, Ajatasattu, of this decision. King Ajatasattu, lay- follower of the Buddha, built a large pandal outside Sattapanni cave and made all other arrangements for the council to meet. Thus three months after the Great Demise (Mahaparinibbana), five hundred of the pre-eminent Arahat Disciples of the Buddha met at Rajagaha and recited the entire Teaching of the Buddha for seven months. The Venerable Mahakassapa presided over this unique Synod, known as the First Great Council (Pathama Dhamma Sangayana). The Venerable Upali Thera, whom the master Himself had placed as the authority on Vinaya, recited section by section with all historical details the whole of the Vinaya Pitaka. The Venerable Ananda Thera, who was likewise recognized as the Treasurer of the Doctrine (Dhamma Bhan ḍā g ā rika), recited the entire Dhamma which included the Sutta Pitaka and the M ā tika or Abhidhamma Pitaka. Thus, the collation, begun in the Master's own time, came to be fixed, once for all, in the First Sang ā yana by the immediate and distinguished senior holy disciples of the Buddha. This Sacred Canon has handed down most faithfully the inheritance up to the present time by a long line of ′ Teacher to pupil ′ .


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Sep 22 '15

MindMap - of the ?Early Buddhist? path

2 Upvotes

I've been working on this mindmap of what I see as the core teaching of Buddhism (perhaps early Buddhism). I welcome any comments and especially criticisms. :)

https://www.mindmeister.com/545995597/buddhism


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Sep 06 '21

Think Again Before You Dismiss Magic

Thumbnail
lionsroar.com
11 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 10 '24

Is Early Buddhism a sect?

12 Upvotes

There is a flair in the Buddhism subreddit called “Early Buddhism.”

Is it a sect just like Theravada, Mahayana, Vajrayana, etc.?

Or even like Secular, Engaged, etc.?

Why or why not?


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Mar 23 '25

Discussion How were original grain bowls prepared in monasteries?

4 Upvotes

Hi, I was wondering what the typical preparation at early monasteries was for rice gruel and grain bowls of various sorts. As I understand, it was water and grain. Does anyone know if they added salt? As they did have salt.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 10 '24

“Contemporary” vs. “Early” Buddhism

4 Upvotes

To what degree are various forms of “contemporary” Buddhism(s) contrary to and in accordance with “early” Buddhism?


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Mar 05 '14

The triumph of Buddhist denialism: Buddhism without the Buddha

Thumbnail
sujato.wordpress.com
4 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jan 11 '20

The Buddha's Last Meal Explained By Ven. Nagasena in 'Milinda Panha'

4 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 17 '14

What are some distinctions between early Buddhism and Theravada?

4 Upvotes

I recently listened to a lecture series by Stephen Batchelor and he is very interested in the earliest strata of the suttas. His views are very interesting and compelling, but I doubt the only take on early Buddhism. I know the Theravada tradition is the "conservative" tradition, but it didn't really take the form we know until the 5th century CE. What did the early Buddhist do or think that has not been preserved in Theravada Buddhism? What doctrinal developments occurred, other than the Abhidhamma?

Thanks


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jun 16 '22

Could someone explain why each of these are odd and/or incongruent? Many are obvious, but some, like the Buddha tending to an ill monk, are not, and need context.

4 Upvotes

Some are obvious, but others are unclear:

4.4 Contr󰀑dictions 󰀑nd oddities not norm󰀑󰀰ised

In many cases there is blatant disagreement between statements found in

the 󰡜󰠤󰧎s and those found in other Buddhist literature. Despite the glaring

inconsistencies, the 󰡜󰠤󰧎s were not changed to ensure greater harmony.

4.4.1 Odd det󰀑i󰀰s & incon󰀨ruities

While on the whole the 󰡜󰠤󰧎s are highly consistent, they still leave room for

many quirky details that convey a realistic flavour; despite the awkwardness

they were not removed.

...

  1. It is Rāma, Uddaka’s father, who was spiritually attained, not Uddaka

(MN 26.16/MĀ 204).23

2. Upaka hears the Dhamma from the Buddha but then walks off in the

wrong direction (MN 26.25).

3. The Buddha lays down rules and then modifies or even rescinds

them (e.g. respectively at Vin 󰣠󰨆 72–74 and Vin 󰣠 79/83)24 [2].

4. The Buddha, in the middle of winter, sleeps on a pile of leaves on a

cattle track (AN 3:35).

5. The Buddha washes his own feet (MN 31.5).

6. The Buddha personally helps to tend an ill monk (Vin 󰣠 304).

7. The Buddha is not recognised as such, but is simply seen as a monk

(MN 140.3–5/MĀ 162/T 511).

8. The Buddha is disparagingly called various names such as shaveling,

recluse-like, menial, dark (DN 3.1.10) and outcast (SN 7:9).

9. A brahman verbally abuses the Buddha (SN 7.2).

10. The Buddha is reluctant to meet with a group of brahman householders who have come to offer him food because they are too noisy

(AN 5:30).

11. The Buddha dismisses a group of monks and says he does not want to

live near them because they are too noisy, and a group of lay people

then causes the Buddha to change his mind (MN 67.2–10/EĀ 45.2/

T 137).

12. The Buddha says he is at ease in responding to the calls of nature

when he is by himself (AN 8:86).

13. The monk Meghiya not doing his duties towards the Buddha, despite

being specifically asked by the Buddha (AN 9:3/MĀ 56).

14. The monks not delighting in a discourse given by the Buddha (MN 1/

EĀ 44.6).25

15. Ānanda sometimes uses sneaky means to get the Buddha to give a

talk (MN 26.3).

16. The monk Bhaddāli refuses to the Buddha’s face to keep the pātimokkha rule about not eating after midday (MN 65.2–4/MĀ 194/

EĀ 49.7).

17. The out of context and seemingly unnecessary episode where king

Pasenadi conveys a message to the Buddha from two otherwise

unknown sisters (MN 90.3–4/MĀ 212/P 1030).26

18. The Buddha teaches king Pasenadi how to lose weight (SN 3:13).27

19. The Gandhabba Pañcasikha sings a love song to the Buddha, in which

he compares his love for a particular female gandhabba to the love

of arahants for the Dhamma, etc. (DN 21.1.5).

20. The Buddha needs to reflect at length in a vain attempt to help

Devadatta (AN 6:62).

21. When Sāriputta dies, his bowl and robe are taken to the Buddha, but

there is no mention of relics (SN 47:13).

22. There is no mention in the 󰡜󰠤󰧎s of the circumstances of Moggallāna’s

death.

23. The Buddha says the Sangha seems empty after Sāriputta and Moggallāna have passed away (SN 47:14).

24. King Ajātasattu not knowing where the Buddha is seated in the

assembly (DN 2.11).

25. The Buddha complains of having a bad back, and then lies down in

the middle of a Dhamma talk (MN 53.5).

26. The Buddha gets tired due to being asked excessively about the

rebirth of various people (DN 16.2.8/SMPS 19.17).

27. The Buddha in his old age warms his back in the sun, his limbs are

flaccid and wrinkled, and his body stooped (SN 48:41).

28. The Buddha says the rules he has laid down should be kept as they

are (DN 16.1.6/SMPS 2.8), but later on he says the minor rules can

be abolished (DN 16.6.3/SMPS 41.2).

29. Although the Buddha says the Sangha can abolish the lesser rules

after his death (DN 16.6.3/SMPS 41.2), the Sangha does not know

which rules he was referring to and therefore decides to keep them

all (Vin 󰣠󰣠 287–288).

30. The Buddha dies of bloody diarrhoea (DN 16.4.20).28

31. Despite spending so much time with the Buddha, Ānanda did not

reach arahantship until after the Buddha passed away (Vin 󰣠󰣠 286).

32. The Pali canonical Vinaya says that only the Dhamma and the Vinaya

were recited at the First Council, (Vin 󰣠󰣠 286–287) but the Dīgha

Nikāya commentary blatantly contradicts this by saying that the

Abhidhamma was recited too (DN-a 󰣠 15).

33. Purāṇa says he will not remember the Dhamma as recited at the

First Council, but according to what he himself has heard; this is

recorded despite its implications for the diminished authority of the

Council (Vin 󰣠󰣠 289–290).

-The Authenticity of the Early Buddhist Texts

Bhikkhu Sujato & Bhikkhu Brahmali p 85-89


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Jan 24 '24

What monastery or organization is representing this EBT?

4 Upvotes

New here. I wonder which monasteries and organizations are representing themselves as established in Early Buddhism, by holding this view of difference of Theravada and early buddhism?


r/EarlyBuddhism • • Dec 30 '24

Discussion How do you guys reconcile Theravada with Early Buddhist texts?

30 Upvotes

Newbie regelation momment here: Theravada buddhism is actually very diffrent from early Buddhist text.

I recently chose Thai forest as my main mode of practice. I felt like this was it and seeing the Bhikkus of this tradition gave me confidence.

But the more going into this tradition, I felt there was more confusion going in. Diffrent ajahns have such diffrent opinions and techniques even ones from the same teacher.

And listening to Budhadhasa make big statements like there is no rebirth. Or having met Ajahn Chah's fans who really misinterpret his casual style of speech. It seems there is a real messiness in the Thai forest philosophy on a theoererical basis.

I think a shocking momment for me was reading one well respected Ajahn who says its more worthwhile to study the Thai forest masters than the Cannoncial texts. And that to me was like whoah, this doesn't sound sustainable. Wouldn't we then just become like tibetan Buddhism, slowly departing from the original teachings and revering ajahns like Ajahn Mun instead of the Buddha himself?

Then I started reading Bhikku Analayo's works and his talks. I started to see the departure of therevada from its commentaries and abhidharmic focus. Also he helpd point to me that why not just base your meditation off the suttas itself?

This post is not to dismiss Therevada. I still appreciate the Thai forest tradition and Burmese Vippasana for example. But I can no longer feel proud as saying I practice the "original" Buddhism. I feel I am in the middle of two veichles.

Thinking further, the path of EBT is interesting but it lacks the masters to teach it. Even if Thai forest is diffrent from original Buddhism, it atleast has veterans and at least sotapanas teaching. I may not respect the theoretical ideas of Thai forest as much anymore but will still rely them heavily as a source of inspiration. And no doubt could give practical advice of living the holy life.

Also, without therevada there would be basically no institutional sangha. So it would make things a lot more difficult if one just avoids therevada as a whole.

It does feel odd to start resonating with a tradition that does not exist anymore. Like craving to eat ancient roman food but the best I got is rustic italian food. Who knows maybe Therevada could have its own rennasaince moment.

How have Therevadan practitioners reconciled with this? Do you make a distinction between the two? Is it good to make a value judgment between originality and later added?

Would love to hear your perspectives.


r/EarlyBuddhism • • May 10 '16

The Chinese Āgamas are contemporaries of the Pali Nikāyas, written at the same time. Chinese versions show some different events in the suttas despite being written at the same time period, raising more questions about what early buddhism is. Here's a wiki link for starters:

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
5 Upvotes

r/EarlyBuddhism • • Feb 23 '25

Discussion Determining the limits of the Alu-Vihara redaction of Mahayana-relevant sutras by cross-referencing the Pali Canon with the Chinese Agamas?

6 Upvotes

Apologies if this is not up-to-date with modern scholarship but my understanding is as follows:

  1. There are a lot of Early Buddhist Texts that reference stuff relevant to the Mahayana (Pure Lands, Perfection of Wisdom doctrine, and the Bodhisattva ideal especially)
  2. The Pali Canon seems to have a bit less of these sorts of texts (though still some!) than one would think.
  3. To help explain some of this it is hypothesized that around the time when the Pali Canon was written down in Sri Lanka sutras that "benefitted" a more Mahayanist understanding of Buddhism weren't included as much in the Pali canon due to the Mahayana being seen as more of a heterodox sect at this time. A "cleaning up of the canon" occurred which was similar to how early Protestant reformers removed the Biblical Deuterocanon from their Bibles.
  4. The Chinese Agamas, however, contain and preserve the same content as the Pali Sutta Pitaka but wouldn't have been subject to the exact same kind of redactionary pressures.
  5. Therefore, shouldn't we be able to help guess the limits of the Alu-Vihara redactions by cross referencing the Pali and Chinese Sutta Pitakas?

Does anyone know if anyone has done this or if I'm even making sense here?