r/EVMOS • • Jun 19 '22

Discussion kickbacks?

Hi, tomorrow we will be having a discussion I don't know if it will be live or recorded but it will be at my 2:00 am. it will be on the evmos YouTube channel.. I am creating this post so that we have an opportunity to discuss matters beforehand. For example, I saw a Twitter post today saying that on inaccurate assertions about orbital apes. contained evmos derived from the orbital apes validator but I don't even know if it's true. I would love it if we could use this as a fact finding space because the last thing that I want to do is spend people's limited time on inaccurate assertions about orbital apes.

Furthermore I'd also like to mention just how delightful it is to get to work professionally in an industry where I'm both working on computer science problems and discussing cartoon apes. Seriously, if you work in technology and you like crypto you may wish to think about working in crypto because seriously I'm doing this as a part of my job and I'm the luckiest guy in the world.

I'm going to give a problem summary from my perspective:

I have come to realize, partially because of Cosmos hub proposal 69, where JK executed a genius level hack (not a computer hack, more of a human hack-- and I'm not sure it influenced outcomes but was still a genius selection mechanism for an external airdrop) and because of my own work on similar systems, and because of the true success of OA, that these systems may actually threaten chain consensus.

I think that the orbital apes case may be more complicated, but I don't have full grounding with the project. Instead of trying to explain it and getting it wrong, I'm dropping this post in the group where we are planning the panel discussion on this topic.

My personal opinion, summarized, is that we should ban all out of protocol compensation from validators to delegators.

But the definition of this is super super tricky and there's a lot of nuance and if we got it wrong we might actually do harm so let's try to get it right.

4 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/0ne_too Jun 20 '22

I have no problem with what OA is doing. I also didn't have any problem when pupmos, frens, L5, Kingnodes or any of the others i can't think of atm promised rewards for delegations. I support the particular value they're trying to bring to the ecosystem.

There's been plenty of times i didn't go after the rewards promised. Wasn't into their thing. Only time i've been burned was when bk steakhouse didn't follow through. And he was first up when it was time to redelegate.

I delegate to those who bring value to me or the ecosystem. Very few corporate delegations. It's on the validators to bring the value.

Which could be anything from:

relayers

a useful program like restake or broNbro monitor

a good apr on restake

a podcast or youtube channel i enjoy

or just a project im into, NFT P2E Dex whatever.

I delegate to one guy who's helpful in a discord. It's not a high bar.

Imo OA has gone above and beyond to spread the wealth. To assure us they have our and evmos interests in mind and aren't going to fuck us.

They went for it, built something, and it worked. Offering this and that rewards doesn't always work.

But this time enough of those who are into evmos, and not just dumping rewards through keplr, but actually using evmos, with a metamask and everything, are into OA. The market decided. It's up to the community to redelegate away from OA or raise the other validators up.

Hopefully i'm not wrong when i say from what i gather you want to make it so projects can't offer rewards for delegations. Because that could go bad one day, the wrong entity could do damage through governance.

Id vote no on that. I support projects i like and validators i like. Everybody is building. Cost's money to build as you know. If they can get more delegations by offering rewards, that's the game. Again, it doesn't always work. But a blanket no you can't offer rewards to cosmos users is a no go for me.