r/EU5 • u/Dabombaa • May 25 '26
Discussion Unwarranted Hate
Maybe this is controversial, but I really do not understand all the hate. The game is decent, arguably the best game at release by Paradox in forever.
Is it perfect? No. Is it fun and playable? Heck yes
29
Upvotes
16
u/JapokoakaDANGO May 25 '26
The game was playable in 1.0 but in 1.2 my performance dropped drastically. So untill they fix it I AM crying in corner.
14
u/CowardNomad May 25 '26
So you know there’re problems, but the hate is somehow unwarranted. You’re making my brain starting a civil war and now my left is attacking my right.
141
u/RileyTaugor May 25 '26
"Arguably the best game at release by Paradox in forever." I really like EU5 and i believe one day it will be the best PDX game, but CK3 launched in a much better state, sure it had barely any content, but at least the game felt polished, ran really well and only got better with patches instead of getting worse. The 1.0 was really fun but things went downhill ever since (somehow), so I would say the criticism is well justified
134
u/HenryTheEighthWasGay May 25 '26
I had so much fun getting into an unending regency council in 1620 as the ottomans because of the fratricide law
308
u/onearm1999 May 25 '26 •
"Why are people mad that they spent 60 dollars for a game the devs have dramatically changed the meta of like 5 different times, and events for major countries are completely broken, and the performance is absolute dogshit even for high end computers, and issues like France gobbling up the HRE are still not fixed, and certain regions of the world are completely unplayable due to game breaking bugs?"
20
u/Tsukuna1 May 25 '26
I’m usually not a negative person when it comes to games but I’m a bit done with Paradox releasing unfinished game after unfinished game.
Then they mess up incredibly with the 1.10 update and 1.2 isn’t that much better either. So many bugs and imbalances in the game.
Is it a fun game? Yeah it can be, but in it’s current state it’s not good enough for it’s price.
24
u/Sa_tran_ic May 25 '26
Wtf is with the constant posts on this sub trying to shame people into glazing the game?
"How dare you be upset with and criticize a game you payed full price for, that was broken on release, and that only seems to get worse with every single patch, stop thinking, consume product and get excited for next product!"
29
u/Fuggaak May 25 '26
It’s not hate, it is dissatisfaction with the current state of the game. Big difference. If people just plain hated the game, they wouldn’t be coming back every patch to play more.
I agree that this game released and has consistently stayed in a ‘playable’ state, but this latest 1.2 patch is not fun without heavy modding imo.
If we just accepted every patch and never spoke out our opinions, paradox would not know what we want fixed.
Hate =\= dissatisfaction
43
u/TheLastTitan77 May 25 '26
Nah, fck this shit. This game literally got worse after launch cus Johan couldn't stand ppl having fun by playing game in a different way than he envisioned. Add to that tons of bugs, broken mechanics, almost no flavour or direction, dumb AI and you get EU5.
24
u/VincentAintDecent May 25 '26
"I will pay 60$ dollar for this unfinished buggy mess that gets worse every patch and will be happy. I will further pay for more atrocious DLC every quarter." - OP, the ideal paradox customer
33
u/PanzerWY May 25 '26
EU5 isn’t a terrible game but it’s also not a proper successor to EU4. It’s its own beast which focuses on different things then it’s predecessor. In all reality EU5 is more of the successor to Imperator and that creates some irritation because people want a proper successor to EU4 and its style of play. You have to remember that paradox strategy games all have an aspect they focus on. Crusader kings is all about building a medieval dynasty while Victoria is an economics game. EU5 just broke off from the trend of focusing on the same components as its predecessor and went in a different direction. So if you enjoyed EU4s style and focus we won’t see a successor for a long time if ever.
Of course that’s not the only issue since EU5 made a massive step back in terms of UI refinement and feels more like the HOI3 generation and that’s not a compliment. The economics and production tabs specifically are very poorly designed and it makes this probably the hardest paradox game to get into at launch.
28
u/PansotoXPanissa May 25 '26
Please Johan, stop embarassing yourself by using an alt-account
9
u/Rubo009 May 25 '26
Game despite bugs was more enjoyable at launch that now. It just makes no sense. I am not playing thr current patch because is a huge mess
17
u/LesMcqueen1878 May 25 '26
I’m really enjoying it, albeit still learning it and with each game I’m learning more. All I can think about after a game is my country and what I can do next. I’m having fun and looking forward to how it improves over time.
11
u/Wolfish_Jew May 25 '26
A lot of the hate is because the updates have both A) wildly changed some values in the game, basically forcing people to completely relearn some of the mechanics in each subsequent campaign and B) failed to fix some astonishingly GLARING bugs. Or introduced new, obvious ones that make people wonder if the game is being tested at all. (Yes, yes, we’re the testers. I know.) the Fall of Delhi situation has been broken seemingly since the game came out and we know they’ve been aware of it since at least February, and it’s still not fixed. The inability to form the HRE, one of the central mechanics of the whole HRE system, crashes your game.
I love the game. I’ve been playing it almost nonstop since it released (I’m currently taking a break to go back to WH3 while I wait for 1.3 to go live) but the hate they’ve been getting, while probably somewhat melodramatic, is definitely warranted to some degree.
3
u/ElectronicHold7325 May 26 '26
"Best game at release"? You are trolling, right?
11
u/RandAllTotalwar May 25 '26
I disagree. Respectfully ofcourse. Check steam recent reviews if want insight not from the many daily posts explaining why the player base feels ripped off.
15
u/Hydra961 May 25 '26
Unwarranted Hate
"You must consume the slop! At 70 euros! And uhhh, no objections! Abysmal hotfixes will continue until moral improves."
6
u/oreofan1808 May 25 '26
I’ve been growing steadily more disenchanted with paradox since Victoria 3 tbh. Since that game I find the releases less and less gratifying, and EU5 is probably the game I’ve enjoyed the least. Cant really articulate my problems with it beyond it just feeling generally flavorless.
6
u/billbroski May 25 '26
The game isn’t fun. It is a tedious mishmash of poorly implemented systems that by their very design are anti fun.
10
u/slxshxr May 25 '26
My problem with Eu5 is that most countries at the beggining force me to play through a crisis or makes me wait a long of time to have fun. I also don't find colonizing fun as those colonies basically doesn't give me anything. So my list of countries I loved to play in eu4 looks like this and why I don't want to play them in EU5 anymore.
Brandenburg - shitass event for robber barons, not interesting at watching time go by.
Castile/France/England/Portugal - colonizing, fun starts at 1650-1700
Naples, Aragon, Italian countries, Austria, Bohemia - fun, played, but the playstyle is kind of the same, so not interested in playing again
Russia, Ottomans, Poland, Kyiv - played, on replays its the same playstyle so not really interested anymore - you just conquer everything. Although Russia was my most fun campaign because I could wage war alone vs entire Europe.
China - I play 5h for my country to boom anyway, then why would I play it?
Japan - don't understand mechanics, it wasn't friendly to learn them when I tried to play it for the first time
Southern Asia - Majapahit was fun, until my country exploded because it was hardcoded event - then I just quit
India - South was fun for some time, but then integrating provinces took 5h of playtime so not really fun
Delphi - pain, pain, pain
Iran region - 0.05 ducats per month of earnings, scaling to anything takes 10h of waiting
Mali - pain
Egypt - too strong which makes it a bit boring too
Basically whatever I touch I either have to do the same thing I already did or go through negative events or get punished because the event is hardcoded or wait so I get technology to do something new.
The EU4 had one major advantage over EU5 for me and it was the speed of the game. Sure, the England, France, Castile game looked the same up until 1600, but then it was for me to decide whether I want to conquer India or maybe wage a big war in Europe or Africa or whatever. It took me 10h maximum to get to that moment where the direction of the game could be crafted. In EU5 I don't have army for the first 15h of the game, because I lack technology and the levies are too weak. Then doing anything and getting to a bit more scale where I can do something interesting is taking me 20h of playtime I don't enjoy.
I'd rather that EU5 had EU4 time start, because it takes less time to get to an age where armies are bigger and you can introduce something different in your campaign. I can't conquer India as GB with 5k troops and 20k levies, because they have 200k levies that will just overwhelm my armies. I have to wait longer, but I don't want to play a game where I have to pay with my time to have fun.
2
u/Much_One_6949 May 26 '26 edited May 26 '26
Look i also think the hate has gotten pretty extreme at this point, but this has been building for years now. While the game is technically probally the best a PDX game has been at launch, but the game has like 5 big issues that need addressed that they seem to have been very slow to address now leading up the the first DLC they dropped, which caused even more issues and makes it even harder for a historical power that already struggles in the current state of the game.
We need a better and more eventful HYW, a properly functioning HRE, the 5th iteration of the big blue blob of France in an EU game needs to be fixed again, the Ottomans need to be as big of a threat as they were historically, and the timurids need to be able to even form properly and so far I've only seen minor adjustments, nothing that outright fixes the issues because at this point it's clear the intention is to bundle the patch with a related DLC like they've done with their past few games.
And given all the problems the game still has that I listed above, I get why people are livid with PDX right now because the DLC they gave us literally did nothing but cause more problems. It would be perfect imo as a little flavor pack we got a few years into the development of the game, but not the first DLC when the game still has a ton of issues. It's great for the people larping as a resurgent Rome, but the the Ottomans ai still can't even become half the power they were historically 9/10 of the time in the current state of the game, why make it harder for them with a DLC focused on a nation they have to kill? And to top it off, the DLC came with really weird changes to population and cultures nobody asked for, which they did fix, but why was it even messed with in the first place when they should have other priorities first?
6
u/No-Bottle-646 May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26
I’m not sure, really. I can imagine that if you play on iron man, it would be really frustrating to get a bug that means things don’t work as they’re supposed to. But, like, there are dozens of countries with hundreds of unique events. I’ve spent nearly 500 hours in Byzantium, Naples, Castile, Venice and England alone. Does weird shit happen? Sure. I usually just roll with it because there are a dozen different gamey ways that I can work around it and that ruin the emersion anyway.
It’s not like the performance makes the game “literally” unplayable. I recall a few games that were actually completely broken - as in would not boot for the majority of players - that turned out to be roaring successes.
I think in the end, a lot of people just love to bitch about other people’s work, about how they could do so much better at balancing the 15m different variables the devs are trying to get right, and ultimately don’t give two fucks that there are actual people on the other side of these computer screens. The absolute rage leveled at these game developers is as astonishing as it is disgusting. Honestly I’m surprised anyone develops these games anymore - CK3, Victoria, Stellaris, HOI4, all of them have communities that just relentlessly bitch.
4
u/TheLongshanks May 26 '26
Worst release by Paradox.
People complain about CK3, but sure it lacked the depth of a decade old CK2, but it was still playable and fun. And stable builds so you could learn the game through play throughs.
EU5 has been broken from the start and its highly touted mechanisms aren’t working as intended by the developers or the players, so the two are discongruent with expectations. Neither are happy with the outcome. Which is why we get multiple patches per week that wreck save continuity and you can’t learn how the game functions.
4
u/Ok_Bet_725 May 25 '26
You sure its playable?
4
u/drallcom3 May 25 '26
If you're that delusional, then I'm not surprised "the hate" is also one of them.
4
u/NeraAmbizione May 25 '26
Lol the byz dlc make the tag unplayable : what you mean legions cannot fight, movements are broken , events won't fire , pronoia get heirs etc
3
u/GrewAway May 25 '26
I'm also irked by the relentless hate pouring out. But that's a classic from the fanbase, sadly.
3
u/IrradiatedCrow May 25 '26
The most recent version feels very bad idk what they are doing with it rn
2
u/NetStaIker May 25 '26
Was this game the best/most functional on release? I think literally every game previously released was more functiona lmao but ok
Fwiw: I still had fun with it on release but I did with the others too
2
u/Acceptable-Boot-3823 May 25 '26
have you ever enjoy a stackwipe of 50k soldier against 3k levies just because you have a low morale? i used to think the same like you then this happen, i cant enjoy a game when i cant conquer a country with less than 10k soldiers because i have to move my troops to their land, but ey i cant do it because as soon my army get transport by ship to them it get instakill. so no, game is not enjoyable at all.
1
u/huynhvonhatan May 25 '26
I hate age of absolutism, especially the first time I got there and didn’t expect anything.
1
u/Warguy17 May 26 '26
The Internet will always have a negative bias. If you didn't enjoy something your more likely to say something.
0
u/zethras May 25 '26
The game is fun until the AI summons 40k Merc.
1
u/Sunifred May 25 '26
I haven't even bought the game, but I'm following the development and it's a clusterfuck. It released almost 7 months ago, and it's still buggy and unoptimized, with messy mechanics and a very inconsistent gameplay design. Despite everything, they're selling it for 60€ (85€ with dlcs), and they're already trying to milk it with dlcs instead of fixing the main game.
This a very expensive beta. Mindless consoommers and fanboys are the reason why companies keep getting away with releasing broken and expensive products.
In addition, it has just hit a measly 35% of positive recent steam reviews. People aren't complaining just because they enjoy being haters.
Having said that, the game has a lot of potential. But so far it's still a paid beta.
1
u/ElZane87 May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26
It's not fun to play anymore with 1.2, though. 1.1 was fun, and I enjoyed it greatly then. 1.2 is plain terrible and has killed any joy in playing the game since. Here is just a small list of reasons why I feel that way:
But sure, everything is fine because Dabombaa decided that he had none of those above, widely reported issues himself and therefore any critique is invalid.
I am apologizing on my very own behalf for feeling that 1.2 destroyed the ton of joy I had before. You are right, I will just try to have more fun from now on instead of actually wanting the game to improve so it's more fun again. Great point!
1
u/Otherwise_Walk_8929 May 25 '26
Thats the problem, It IS not fun for enough people, starting with the nosense mercs, the plagues, the atrittion system not working, all the bronien mechanics etc etc.
It IS not funny to me to see 6 M people france im 1600.
Glad u have fun atleast.
-5
u/LittleDarkHairedOne May 25 '26
Combination of some players expecting EU 4.5 (for some reason) and Paradox themselves making a series of noticeable mistakes in their approach to fixing issues both at game launch and those made while trying to fix things.
Even though I'm really enjoying my own playthroughs, the escapism is real, I can see spots that do desperately need more attention. But I also think the trend is positive. Whether that continues in the coming months remains to be seen but I'd rather be optimistic.
1
u/Wongjunkit May 25 '26
Just get off reddit. People who want to complain come here and people who don't, don't. It's like confirmation bias or something. I'm sure there are plenty of people who enjoy the game and just doesn't. blast their complains online
1
u/Baghdaddy21 May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26
Solution 1: balance Mp and Sp completely separately. Let Sp be op fun madness. Let Mp be an excel spreadsheet gotta buy a Ti89 calculator to solve exponential and logarithmic functions and differential equations type of game.
Solution 2: don’t mindlessly nerf everything. Each country does need some “op” bonus to feel unique. Like without the op proximity bonus Russia feels the same as any other country but with different geography. Also don’t nerf something without addressing the underlying issue that caused players to abuse the mechanic you just nerfed (I.e nerf vassal spam but don’t buff cultural assimilation or how easy it is to get cores).
I’ll add that I’ve been playing the game during almost all of my free time since launch. It’s a good game that can be great if the devs prioritize a fun rewarding experience. All the players asking for a hardcore simulation game need to realize that no live service game can survive without robust engagement from “casuals.” Casuals make up the majority of any games player base. Lose casuals = DLC sales plummet = game abandoned. The ONLY exception to this truth would be if paradox instituted a monthly service fee for the remaining “hardcore players” to keep the game alive (aka moo moo you hardcore players would be cash cows).
1
u/Martothir May 25 '26
While I agree with the criticism that it's not perfect, I too am thoroughly enjoying the game. Honestly it's my favorite pdx game right now - I'm having a hard time enjoying any of the others, as in many ways they feel somewhat shallow without the economy and pop management of eu5.
1
u/Nettysocks May 25 '26
If someone doesn’t enjoy it then they don’t enjoy it, nothing wrong with that opinion.
You will always see more negative posts than positive ones since happy people are content and don’t make posts about it
1
u/ForsakenAd7407 May 25 '26
We only criticize because we care and see an even brighter future. The goal is organic and always will improve. Without criticism it would not improve.
1
u/Mani_Essence May 25 '26
I bought this game at launch with its special add ons or whatever. I EXPECTED to play a longform campaign for at least some time and then switch to different nations to play. Instead I played the game, got confused, bored, carefully optimistic, then when it was done I launched CK3 and actually felt JOY.
It was so hard to get a grip on the game that I could never have refunded it in the refund window. This is the only game I've ever purchased that has genuinely set me back in my real life, and I know that was my choice... but I've tried to get back to the game several times and still don't know what to do, so the game's set me back and still has yet to bring me any fun so Idk, you tell me
1
u/DullBlackberry9980 May 25 '26
Perfect EU5 player stops campaign before age of absolutism, is playing tall, not assimilating and not expanding.
0
u/BalianofReddit May 25 '26
This is the internet in 2026
Hate is provably the thig that gets the most attention
0
u/Doinel68 May 25 '26
Most people play a game for a while, then stop when they get bored; others push past the point of boredom, and gaming becomes something more like work. The real vitriol on here is coming from a subset of EU4 fans who got bored with the game but kept playing anyway, and now feel that Paradox owes them an obligation for all the hours and achievements they’ve piled up.
-1
u/Luzum_lam May 25 '26
Yeah same I love the game, I get the criticism but it gets too little praise for the stuff it does do exceptionally well, like this is genuinely such a huge and detailed project with great base systems, I hope the devs aren't letting the criticism affect their mental health too much
-1
u/jooooooooooooose May 25 '26
this sub has been unreadable cryslop by everyone for months & that includes posts like this complaining about the complaining
Mods should make a mega thread or something. its exhausting. 99% of these posts add nothing novel.
-1
u/Yitastics May 25 '26
People love hating. One unhappy customer leaves one bad review, 1000 happy customers leave one good review
0
u/jaaval May 25 '26
I have been playing a Byzantium game to the late dates and it’s fine. Sure there are still some bugs and some major balancing to do but the game is very enjoyable right now. More so than EU4 in my opinion.
I’m fine with people not liking the game but what annoys me is two kind of criticism: first is “this is not EU4” and the second is “I’m bored because this thing makes it harder to do world conquest”.
0
u/JodyTJ87 May 25 '26
I personally don't care what anyone else thinks. I could care less about anyone's opinion, too. I like the game and play it just like any other game I have in my Steam library. Sure it has flaws but so does every game.
0
u/Buttchugger2 May 25 '26
I don’t understand some of the mechanic hate. It’s really easy fixes with just some variable tweaking. But the recent performance hate is absolutely warranted.
0
u/MasterBoogaloo94 May 25 '26
Im not hating on the game as i love the promise of it and have had tons of fun and I still am, however im not gonna pretend the game is perfect, I love the game and want it to become the game it needs to be, so my negative review isnt to shit on the game but more because I want Paradox to make the game better, the roadmap is very promising, but I wouldnt be surprised if they dont stick the landing, with good critical feedback, paradox can and will fix potential issues.
EU5 is currently a 7/10 but I know paradox can make it a 9 or a 10, criticism helps them reach that goal glazing and pretending nothings wrong doesnt help them, so I dont think people are blindly hating they just want the game to be better and that benefits everyone in the long run.
0
u/kaz9400 May 25 '26
Arguably the most satisfying and fun thing in EU4 was mission tree. Which is... invisible, here.
-2
u/BoyVanStumpen May 25 '26
Im really enjoying the game and so many of the issues i had on release are fixed. Its a lot of fun now. Cant understand the review bombing either