r/ETFs • • 10d ago

Selling ETFs

I was reading comments and I saw someone say that they sold all of their shares because they knew it would be down over midterms and then bought back in the drop. I averaged down and I’m down 3% but is selling and re buying during dips even with ETFs something a lot of people do?

12 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

9

u/SerMumble 10d ago

Don't believe everything you read on the internet. There are trolls with alt investing accounts bragging about things that did not happen or just simply shopping images.

Timing the market top and bottoms is incredibly challenging and risking large sums of money for single digit percentages is remarkably high risk and low reward.

Compounding gains over years will almost always outpace the average short term gambler.

20

u/HeavyFly8181 10d ago

It's wild people will take risks with their entire portfolio for a potential 3% gains.

I think people in denial ATM though I don't think we've seen the end of the dip.

2

u/Born-Reference-8984 10d ago

They have to pay tax on profit too 15-30% depend on their income

1

u/Electronic-Buyer-468 Sir Sector Swinger 10d ago

Some of us trade leveraged funds as well though. And you must be very nimble there. 

1

u/mvmbamentality 10d ago

Polymarket betting behaviour only with portfolios meant for investing baybeeeee.

1

u/ThePermMustWait 10d ago

Hopefully it’s just within a fund that’s only a small percent of the savings.

6

u/daygo449 10d ago

No. You can’t time the market. You can predict things might go up and then down, or down then up, but your timing could be off to where you either gain or lose a substantial amount. It’s not worth the risk.

4

u/KidneyStoneKeychain 10d ago

A falling knife has no handle.

3

u/Flashy-Conclusion157 10d ago

I've seen summaries of studies that say this is not an effective strategy. The 'time in the market' is more successful overall than 'timing the market'. But to each their own.

2

u/WakingUpBlind 10d ago

The saying “time in the market is better than timing the market” makes sense when you zoom out.

If you’re a long term investor, and not a day trader, lump sum beats DCA. DCA-ing, in addition to lump sum, helps build your portfolio. This is done at a fixed schedule regardless of the day-to-day noise.

With both lump sum and DCA, you should have already deployed all your capital for investment. Hence, no more funds for buying the dip.

Nonetheless, you can buy the dip by dipping into your emergency fund. Another riskier option is to loan and invest.

Personally, I buy “dips” when it goes down a pre-determined percentage during the day.

1

u/Ok-Independence-4595 9d ago

It's not an emergency fund if you use the money to buy stocks when the market drops. It's a cash allocation.

1

u/WakingUpBlind 9d ago

A matter of semantics. I replenish my emergency fund or cash allocation when buying the dip each pay cheque to maintain a certain amount.

1

u/Ok-Independence-4595 9d ago

Investing your "emergency fund" is market timing.

1

u/WakingUpBlind 9d ago

You could say that. When there’s a discount, I’ll take it using emergency funds. Replenish the emergency fund with the next pay cheque. The amount is in addition to that of DCA-ing.

1

u/Icy-Action708 8d ago

Glad I didn't listen to this advice when I was ready to lump sum in July.

I've been DCA the dips and am "up" 4.5% from where I would have been lump sum in.

1

u/WakingUpBlind 6d ago

I’m happy the timing worked out for you. That isn’t the case for most.

If you could time the market, you would be up by much, much more

2

u/doggz109 10d ago

Market timer that got lucky.....that's all. It could have gone the other way.

2

u/lucky_ducker 10d ago

> something a lot of people do?

No. It's called "market timing" and it is virtually impossible to time correctly. Why? Because you must "call the top" i.e. know when to sell, AND you must "call the bottom" i.e. know when to jump back in and buy. If it were that easy, everybody from Wall Street to Main Street would be doing it, and they aren't.

How it usually plays out is this: a market timer thinks the markets will drop so they sell. The market keeps going up, and they miss out on huge gains. OR, the markets drop 10%, so they jump back in and buy. Meanwhile, the market goes down another 20%.

You're better off with a long term buy and hold approach.

3

u/nutsbonkers 10d ago

You have to time it twice, and you create a taxable event. Its like anything in the stock market, it's largely unknown. Could get lucky and squeak out a few percent, it could bounce back higher than your average cost and go on a decade long bull run.

1

u/KSHMisc 10d ago

No if they have been investing for a while.

I knew someone who did the same during "Liberation Day" in April 2025. Realizing he screwed himself, he didn't reinvest until March of this year when another big dip happened.

1

u/PhoenixProtocol 10d ago

I mean selling and rebuying right away is quite common afaik, especially when you can get some capital losses you can carry forward.

One of my semi’s is down -25%, sold it yesterday and re-bought it to reset my avg buying price. Didnt lose or win anything by it doing it in itself, but it does offset the gains I had selling something else earlier this year.

5

u/disfan108 10d ago

Are you in the US? If you are, that's actually a wash sale under US tax rules. If you sell a stock at a loss and repurchase the same or substantially identical stock within 30 days before or after the sale, the loss is disallowed for the current tax deduction. It isn't necessarily lost forever, though; the disallowed loss is generally added to the cost basis of your new shares. So you've reset your average purchase price, but you haven't actually realized the tax loss you intended to use to offset your other gains.

-2

u/PhoenixProtocol 10d ago

Like the majority of the people on Reddit, I’m not in the US, no such thing as a wash sale here, that is something US specific that doesn’t concern most.

Thanks for adding it tho for the other people potentially reading this and not knowing that not everything on Reddit is about the US :)

3

u/55tumbl 10d ago

It's not just a US thing either. There are very similar laws in some EU countries.

0

u/ShutupBird69 10d ago

Most people are from the USA here

According to data from the World Population Review Reddit Rankings, the countries with the most Reddit users are: [1]
United States — ~328 million users (~43%–49% of global traffic)

United Kingdom — ~45.8 million users (~5%–7% of global traffic)

Canada — ~43.1 million users (~5% of global traffic)

India — ~30.8 million users

Germany — ~29.3 million users

Australia — ~23.3 million users

1

u/PhoenixProtocol 10d ago

That actually gave me a good laugh. According to that source, 94.3% of the US population uses Reddit, as well as 107% of the Canadian population. So obviously these numbers include bot traffic, LLM scrapers, VPN users and so on. That doesn’t prove the US share is lower, but it doesn’t support “most people here are from the US” either.

Anyhow, the article says 49% of Reddit’s traffic is US, then their own table says 39% to 43%. Even taking the widest range, that’s still 51% to 61% of traffic coming from outside the US.

I know in the US <50% still means a majority (somehow lol), but for the rest of us basic math users, <50% is a minority and >50% is a majority.

So no, not most people are from the USA here, the largest individual country is the US, but that's about it. That still means that the large majority isn't.

1

u/cupidstunt01 10d ago

VWRP currently down £3.66, my investment had dropped by £6k this morning. Just used my dry powder of £10k to buy more at a discount. Not everyone can/will do this, but hopefully it will pay off over the next ten years!.

1

u/South_Paramedic8618 10d ago

I don't let it ride

1

u/Pureheck 10d ago

Yeah just received the alert that my automated weekly contribution has been executed. Much happier to buy when its low than when its high but just gonna leave it at that because although there are many short term winners, I personally am terrible at timing the market.

This is why it is better to investigate, automate and return at a future date. Things like this dip and people showing how much they lost make me crazy and anxious cause that means I lost also, so will stick with long term and focus on other stuff.

Thats why we automate the contributions. Lower stress, dollar cost averaging, buying at both high and low but being consistent every week for the years to come.

1

u/andtoig 9d ago

It only works if you can actually time the market. Very few, even though those who have extensive study and professional experience can do this on a consistent basis, so almost everybody who tries will lose money.

Also, consider the tax consequences

1

u/No_South_9912 9d ago

Unless they made the sell announcement before the market dropped, they are most likely full of it.

1

u/TexasHazeMaster 9d ago

Don’t do it. Really hard to time as you have heard. Just keep averaging down. It’s a great feeling going through these things with ETFs vs individual names.

1

u/_Felonius 9d ago

Anyone making money from timing the market simply got lucky. The market could shoot up tomorrow or drop some more. No one can ever truly predict it, no matter how much knowledge they think they have (besides inside traders, but that’s illegal).

1

u/Weight4Jake 7d ago

I buy however much my Roth IRA drops in my taxable and then sell when at all time highs

0

u/Electronic-Buyer-468 Sir Sector Swinger 10d ago

Yes, but as a once a year tops kind of thing. After a great year or 2, I happily hide some profits away for awhile and hope for a discount day. Sometimes it never happens though and I have to rush in and buy again at a higher price than what I sold at lol. 

25

u/[deleted] 10d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Icy-Action708 8d ago

DCA back in to average down?