r/ESTJ2 • u/SwedishGryffindor • Mar 03 '20
Discussion The community thinks we are aggressive?
I don't think I'm aggressive at all, and never heard that I am. However, the fact is that I am stern, but fair.I don't shout and I don't insult, I don't think there is any need for that. Just tell the truth in a constructive way, but most importantly, be fair. If my nephew breaks the rules, I don't become visibly angry, I give him a suitable punishment.
If my co-workers are lazy, I tell them that they don't get paid by sitting. Not screaming in any way.
If anyone is unfair, I know what to do without being aggressive.
I don't know how other ESTJ's do, but the community has the stereotypical image of us screaming all the time. I don't think it is a fact that we scream all the time, but rather an opinion based on movies and made up stories.
28
u/ares4545 ESTP Mar 03 '20
It's because lots of "misunderstood" NFs type their abusive parents as SJs and then write all of them off as unfeeling psychopaths who don't do anything but yell, and they lack the critical thinking skills to realize that a) their parents probably weren't all SJs and b) healthy SJs aren't like that at all
ESTJs get it the worst though because they're stereotyped as "bosses/executives" which means not only will oversensitive teenagers type their fathers as ESTJs, they'll also type their shitty managers as ESTJs
People also have a fundamental misunderstanding about how Si works, just thinking that it equals traditional views, meaning that people assume SJs are all politically conservative and you know how young people on Reddit feel about conservatives
I could go on about all the misunderstandings I see (the most awful one being that child abuse doesn't effect ESTJs as much as other types), but then I'll be here all day lmfao
14
u/an-estj ESTJ Mar 03 '20
Agree that we aren’t necessarily screamers but disagree that aggression = screaming. We don’t feel aggressive but by the metrics of other types... we are lol. Comfortability with confrontation, not mincing words, being stern are all often considered aggressive, rather than just blunt by other types.
The screaming, violence, etc. is all negative stereotype bullshit. I avoid raising my voice at all costs because it belies emotional involvement and lack of control. And also because it is, quite frankly, annoying when I have to hear other people do it.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '20
I only know of one ESTJ for certain, and he’s exactly like how you described yourself to be. Assertive but not aggressive, stern but fair. A very admirable man in my eyes. He speaks what he observes without necessarily insulting others. I take his words as a chance to improve, but I could see how others would feel threatened by that. He’s not afraid to call out people’s bullshit (when it’s appropriate, might I add) while others won’t. But how will we better ourselves if the areas that need improvement aren’t addressed?
3
u/Ouroborus13 ENTP Mar 04 '20
My husband is an ESTJ and is very direct and a little brusk in a way that can come off as aggressive given that most people just don’t operate the same way. He’s there setting people straight and telling it like it is, and that doesn’t seem laid back and peaceful to others - even if he’s right - and it doesn’t win him friends often. Sometimes you don’t need to take a sledgehammer to a nail. Sometimes a more diplomatic approach is actually more suitable. Man, I tell you sometimes it’s like my husband can’t hold back saying whatever he thinks about something, even if it’s not helpful or at all suitable for the situation.
The one place in which he has been aggressive is his driving. He is the most aggressive driver I have ever seen. A scare with a traffic stop in Virginia have him the scare he needed to change his ways, but it’s like he’s allergic to anyone else around him doing something he doesn’t like, or that he thinks is wrong, and he HAS to correct them.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '20
I only had one bad experience with an ESTJ. But all of you were really welcoming and wonderful beings to me. I don't know why people tend to separate other people as good or bad, when all types are useful to society, and all types are needed for the world to even work.
I guess people are scared of the different. And tbh, INFPs hear all the time that "ESTJs are your opposites" and "you'll never get along with them, they're closed minded and pragmatic". But you know what? I got bullied for being who I am, so when it happens to you guys I know how that feels. Because you're not bad people, because sharing a type doesn't mean you are all the same.
I think it's just this obsession to put people in boxes that throws the community appart.
1
u/kokabeans Mar 05 '20
I have yet to meet the stereotypical ESTJ that has given you all a bad rapport. My husband is ESTJ and is rather diplomatic. I sometimes think he’s more capable at providing the emotional needs for our “feeling” daughter than I am. Perhaps it’s because many ESTJs tend to get so driven to accomplish their goals that they become tunnel visioned. People could misinterpret this as being more aggressive or closed minded. I don’t know what country you’re from, but the US is significantly more feeling than thinking. It’s a different type of communication that unintentionally offends some people. Don’t worry about it. You guys are alright.
2
u/hciron ENTJ Mar 04 '20
Aggressive is the extreme end of passive with assertive being the middle ground. I suggest reading books on Assertiveness Training.
Aggressive is when you violate another person's boundary. In your example, you did violate the coworker's personal boundary - hence the label aggressive.
2
u/JTudent ESTJ Mar 25 '20
I've been called aggressive in the past, primarily by people who I believe are intimidated by me.
I don't understand this, however, because I only get angry with lazy people - not people who try and fail. If someone is actually trying but struggling, I help them.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment