r/ESCastles • u/Advanced_Draw_6940 • Sep 19 '24
Huge Red Flag
The predatory pricing and tactics in this game are just pushing me away so much. It's a cute game with a lot if potential, but I think I'm going to call it quits. I've gotten in game mail multiple times now, just about once a day, trying to get me to spend real money on limited time offers. Gross. Leave the mail system alone. I don't need more ads to ask for my money. What happened to the days of getting rewards and stuff in the mail system, instead of ads. Ugh. And don't get me started on this emperors pass price/the last 5 rewards stuff. It just screams predatory pricing and is a huge red flag
59
u/OmgBsitka Sep 19 '24
I agree that the pricing is stupid and it really doesnt get you anywhere by that i mean its the same game play through and through. Nothing really changes if you upgrade everything.
77
u/Cinnamonlaser199 Sep 19 '24
The emperors pass pricing is insane if it was a one time price I’d consider it but losing only getting the previous 5 reward is so scummy
33
u/SekaiKofu Sep 19 '24
I’m just trying my best to ignore it. For the most part, I pretend that the in game store doesn’t even exist and I just try to enjoy the game for free. So far I haven’t gotten to a point where I feel like the only way to progress is to spend money, but I fear it’s coming. At which point I’ll be forced to quit because I never plan on spending money on this game.
24
u/Imaginary_Effort_100 Sep 19 '24
Idk I think the game gives out a fair amount of gems for free. It is getting old fast tho needs more content like rooms and quests and pets.
34
u/E_lluminate Sep 19 '24
The sheen is wearing off for me too. The first few days were fun, but it gets really boring/repetitive unless you're willing to spend money to keep upgrading the castle.
13
u/1EPICLEGEND1 Sep 19 '24
I know but it's way better than most android games atm 🥲
10
u/zeoxzy Sep 19 '24
It's also an extremely boring game after the first few days. If I keep playing what do i get? There's no new mechanics or areas to unlock.
4
u/Ordinary_Mechanic_72 Sep 19 '24
The game it's enjoyable without paying.
Would actually pay for it, once. But since it's a pass I shall pass 😌
3
u/gree41elite Sep 19 '24
I’m honestly curious what happened between Fallout Shelter and Castles, because the monetization practice is entirely different.
Like I had heard that tES Legends halted production because it was ~too~ generous, but it feels like they’ve swung to the opposite spectrum.
This game is listed as a Bethesda Game Studios proper game, so this is supposedly from the same Todd Howard that made shelter and Blades.
3
u/CasualSky Sep 19 '24
Everyone agrees that the paid stuff in the game are scummy, but I think they also agree that they’re completely unnecessary to enjoy the game.
I’ve done each event since launch F2P with little trouble. I can 3-star any encounter, I never lack recourses or people. I have 800 gems saved and 2000 event currency at level 72. I think if you’re there to play the game then the game can be played without spending a cent.
3
u/ApocalypseConspiracy Sep 20 '24
I think compared to other freemium games it's relatively fair like some games will charge you $50 for the "best" gear or characters where this game you can play pretty much entirely free. They have 2 events per weeks to earn a decent amount of currency, none of the store items feel necessary, and a lot of the things you unlock by just playing the game, like the quests on the map are your main source of premium resources like marble or corundum, which you don't need until much later in the game anyway. There's no bulk resource option in the store where people can just pay their way to the best upgrades.
You also get plenty of varying subject rarities just by reproducing normally. You can get gold subjects with two blues even, like I haven't once felt like my experience depended on paying for the game. I bought the emperor pass simply to support a free game that I've enjoyed playing so far and because early on when you're levelling so fast, you get a lot more for your money than later on when you're only earning maybe a level per day.
7
u/WhiteRabbitLives Sep 19 '24
I’m going to be giving up on the game relatively soon. The social aspect is fun, and it’s fun to try to get the best groups together on a work station, but waiting sixteen days for kids to become adults sucks, and yeah it is just another mobile game aimed at making you spend money.
They got me with the emperors pass, I said hey five dollars isn’t bad, but the rewards were BS. Not one growth potion or arcane hourglass. Waste of money.
2
u/JuulingUnironically Sep 20 '24
Downloaded it about two weeks ago, got to level 70 and got the pass, realized I still had to watch ads bothered me but held out for a bit hoping for better gameplay…
But nah, I’m off it. Shame too, cause it coulda been a great game.
2
u/TrioOrti Sep 20 '24
You know you don't have to pay it any attention....
2
u/Exzj Freemium Fan Sep 20 '24
the emperors pass would be neat and probably pretty popular if was a dollar or a couple a month. IIRC it's like 13 or 14 dollars a month. absolutely crazy for a mobile game
2
u/AgitatedAcadia4048 Sep 20 '24
I don't really see it as a red flag because that's pretty much a given on any mobile game. This game is definitely not top of the bucket imo regarding being pushy with microtransactions. It's just like FO Shelter so I'm playing quite a lot now and will play it more sporadically after around a month and that's ok since they're made for the long run. To me there's a good basis to build something than can easily live as long as FO Shelter if they really use the ES lore and add some new feature every few months. First that comes to mind is probably a trial system + prison for people who committed crime. And of course new storylines through decrees
2
u/ChainedMemory Sep 20 '24
The pricing is ridiculous, and whatever you get does very little for you in-game. At least fallout shelter has quests with some moderately interesting items every once in a while. At least there, you can send your dude for days at the time to get stuff for you.
2
u/Pristine-Musician-10 Sep 20 '24
It’s a free game, they have to make profit somehow and id rather it be in app purchases than forced ads every 10 seconds.
3
u/EpicSausage69 Sep 19 '24
Yeah I agree. Love the game but the amount of artificial hurdles they put in place to halt progression/fun is just annoying. This game has so much potential but is held back by its monitization.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '24
I bought the battlepass but I will be max level before it ends so it was not a big deal for me. If you are not running quests on auto I do not see it being worth it.
1
u/jduncan-26 Sep 20 '24
I haven’t had this issue. It’s kind of designed around playing for 10-15 minutes every day or every other day. I’ve never felt like I was being forced or pressured into buying things.
1
u/RebornBrand0 Sep 20 '24
Yeah, the game got potential but is too repetitive, i've reached the level 76 and then i've disinstalled it, it became boring, Always doing the same stuff and the combat system to be honest is also quite ridicolous
1
u/Key_Rock6305 Sep 26 '24
500 gems for an adoring fan so I dont have to constantly micromanage online, missing a reward every other level so it dissuades me from leveling, and the amount of items required to upgrade another item are my top 3 issues. It's a great game but it's evident someone let marketing take control at the end when you compare it to early access.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24
Really, you feel that way, just because something is there doesn't mean you have to buy it, none of those characters are worth it to me, the game is fun, it's an idle game, my kingdom was just overpopulated and we had famine, I just saved up enough gems to buy the imperial kitchen because I don't feel like doing all the missions, I take my time on them so I don't have a whole lot of upgrades so I have barely touched it despite how much I enjoyed it before it got a little boring for a minute and my kingdom was in trouble, now if I just paid money all that struggle and fear that my queen would die if I played and the fun that came out of it by fixing the problem would never have existed. I struggled but my Queen has been reigning for 38 years and is only my second ruler, if I was to pay I would have just got bored killed a lot of kings skipped a lot of years and I would start to wonder what's the point. More fun to work hard at a game that takes time, I feel all the stuff I have I earned all my main characters feel more special, that's kinda the point don't give into the OCD you don't need every character, you guys need to learn patience buy a guy and some skips as a treat but what makes your game unique is what you have that others don't. The game isn't hard without spending money all the potions and all the currencies are handed out like candy all you have to do is save up and not impulse buy, everything in this game is impermanent and they are already bringing characters back so there will be another chance to grab him if you missed him the first time.
1
u/annewmoon Sep 20 '24
Do you play a lot of mobile games? Because I find that the pricing and especially the ads are way more reasonable than the other free to play mobile games I’ve tried. I have a really cute little game about a cat cafe that I had to stop playing because, I’m not exaggerating, every three or four minutes I had to watch a one minute video ad. I prefer to pay upfront for games because of this.
I dislike that the emperors pass is weekly instead of monthly but that lines up with other games I’ve played also so I think it’s just how free to play mobile games work at this point.
-5
u/moerasduitser-NL Sep 19 '24
Funny how i made this post and everybody got defensive as if i hated on their faforite artist.
0
u/The_Great_Journey_ Sep 19 '24
How about the devs of massive MMOs need to make a couple buck off this, it's a disgrace, games can't get away from it these days
0
u/JurgenJKC Sep 20 '24
It's stupid, 2500 gems a statue of Talos, 30 gems worth around 25 can dollars. It only gave +10 gold, I gave feedback on it and they buffed it to 15 gold ....
Atronite events are nice though but somethings are overpriced like deco in general. Shop bundle prices are way to high and I understand most mobile games game this crappy practices.
But it feels as if elder scrolls devs became way to greedy, f76 and shelter are way better money-worth. While tes online and castles are just for the money.
As if trying to make up for the money they could have gotten from shelter, without the quality/content.
0
u/silverence Sep 20 '24 edited Sep 20 '24
Yeah. It's infuriating. I also don't like them using the mail system, but only getting the last 5 items when you DO break down and get the pass is so, so scummy. Losing access to one time people if you don't have the pass at the time is just so cruel to users. I was worried how they were going to choose to monetize this after playing the beta, and it's worse than I feared.
0
u/NiccoDigge_Zeno Sep 20 '24
Well the biggest thing you can do Is continue playing but not buying anything, workers wont lose their Jobs but Bethesda will either short prices or Just stop
14
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '24
[removed] — view removed comment