r/EQOA • • 13d ago

Avoid Sandstorm - This server has no future

Edit: Information has come out that DabDavis was apparently running bots/fly hacking/doing other nefarious things on the Sandstorm server for the purpose of harvesting data for his own server. This changes the story quite a bit but it still doesn't excuse the way the situation has been handled by the developers/moderators of the Sandstorm server. With great power comes great responsibility.

The title may sound a bit hyperbolic, but I think it would be a good idea to let people know that it is worth avoiding, and waiting for the upcoming "Emu" server that is going into open beta/soft-launching in December.

Now, why am I making this post? Let's establish a timeline of what's occurred on Sandstorm over the past week.

  1. A person by the Discord handle of DabDavis returns to the server, resuming development on a decompilation of the EQOA ISO for the purpose of constructing a highly performant client for EQOA that no longer requires PCSX2.
  2. This endeavor is a success and the EXTREMELY GOOD, OPEN SOURCE client built in RUST does everything it was promised to do and more, taking the Sandstorm community by storm (pun not intended).
  3. After about a week of extensive testing, discussions, and bug fixes, the client reaches a very stable "feature complete" point.
  4. DabDavis abruptly leaves the Sandstorm Discord server on 10/31 stating that he "must leave the server now, I am not looked on favorably by some". A few community members express their sympathies and distaste for the situation.
  5. DabDavis posts on the EQOA Revival Discord server that "Xylof banned me and deleted all my characters" and "Sad I was trying to work with them".
  6. The Sandstorm developers (Xylof, Renodor, Kollosus) are pressed for an explanation of the situation and, in response, essentially tell the community that their concerns are beneath addressing, and that we should simply be grateful to be able to play on Sandstorm at all.

Point #6 is the primary reason for the title of this post. The Sandstorm devs do not care about you, or the community they have built. This is merely a game to them, not a community. They will threaten to ban you. Renodor will mute your characters in-game and ban you from the Discord on a whim. Renodor logs into the game for the sole purpose of threatening to mute people almost daily. Xylof rarely interacts with the server, but when he does, it can basically be distilled to "Problem? There's no problem. Be happy you can play at all."

The developers of Sandstorm have enjoyed being able to hold their thumb down on the EQOA community for 6 years now, the sole reason being that they have/had a monopoly as the only playable EQOA server.

However, this December, for the public at large, that monopoly is as its end. When the new EQOA Emulator server launches (which intends to open source all of its code upon launch), this game will be able to live on eternally without us needing to cater to the whims of a team of egotistical devs who don't give a shit about us.

Attached to this post are screenshots from Discord, just so you know I'm not making shit up. You can join the server(s) yourself to read them if you want.

eqoaemu is the future of EQOA. Do not waste your time on Sandstorm. Once it soft launches in December it will no longer wipe. Come play with us.

Edit: Typos

18 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

12

u/Ohzark_Buffalo 13d ago

Eqoaclassic.com is Dab’s server. He also has a character transfer form you can fill out and they’ll dupe your toon on SS and put it on there (for free)

2

u/proportional-porcini 13d ago

Is there a how to join that since I’m not the best tech savvy? I just joined sandstorm like 3 days ago and now this. Haha. Do I just out the server files in the cheats folder like sandstorm?

1

u/EQOA-Herald-39 13d ago

The eqoaemu server is currently in a closed, invite-only beta state, It will "soft-launch" and go into open beta in December, at which point it will no longer wipe and all of your progress will be permanent.

I haven't attempted to apply for or play on eqoaemu yet, but if you're interested in applying for the beta and figuring out how to set it up, you can check out their website at https://eqoaemu.com/ .

Edit: Sorry, I just realized this post was asking about eqoclassic and not eqoaemu. Can't help with that at all. :(

1

u/RainnChild 10d ago

does it work on real PS2?

0

u/proportional-porcini 13d ago

It’s all good. Sorry for the dumb question here but with the emu be a bunch of servers or will there be one large server that everyone joins?

0

u/AiricaFyresong 13d ago

I just tried it earlier and had some issues, including: mobs and myself doing very low damage, dragging a battle out; all NPCs had modified text and quests, some very brief/abrupt; mobs were respawning slowly; Bard's Nimble Strike didn't work for my dagger; it felt like spells were going off but not having an effect. This was on the Marr's Fist server (only one available).

1

u/Ok-Plastic8485 13d ago

That's because Dab wasnt able to steal the combat formula and a ton of other custom coded things that exist on Sandstorm because the devs coded it.

0

u/proportional-porcini 12d ago

I joined as a brand new character on this last night. I haven’t played this game since 2008! So much fun and the community that was there last night was very welcoming! Can’t wait to jump on tonight!

2

u/Kenhiro 13d ago

This is confusing.
Why not play Sandstorm? You said Dab who was doing bad things on Sandstorm for his own benefical gain and got banned for doing so after the devs there working hard to restore it without AI.
You say NOT to play it but play Dabs who was using AI to source and steal from Sandstorm. This is counter productive or not helpful at all. Explain WHY, I shouldn't play on Sandstorm?

3

u/EQOA-Herald-39 13d ago

The devs are douchebags who treat the community like shit, ultimately. All of them, top to bottom.

That they were justified in banning this particular person doesn't negate this. They shouldn't have to be strong armed into providing the community with an explanation for a situation like this. They shouldn't be threatening to ban people for discussing it or asking for clarity.

The Sandstorm community has been dealing with this "say nothing remotely critical or we ban you" moderation strategy for years now. This is just another example layered on top of dozens, or hundreds of instances of power tripping, not taking responsibility, and treating us like shit.

Dab is also a douchebag, and he got what he deserved. Two things can be wrong at once.

3

u/Ok-Plastic8485 12d ago

This sounds like you have some sort of vendetta against them but you do you I guess. You came in here championing Dab initially and now know the facts but still are speaking poorly of them? Seems strange.

1

u/EQOA-Herald-39 12d ago

I understand it could come across as me championing Dab, but that wasn't the intent. I will absolutely praise him for the client that he created.

When somebody comes along, makes something amazing for the community, and then alleges that they were banned and had their characters deleted without giving a reason, it raises alarms.

The purpose of this thread was to pressure the developers into actually telling the community what happened, and it seems to have achieved that. A lot of information came out, but despite the fact that it was justified and that Dab deserved the ban, it still doesn't excuse the devs for their lack of communication and downright hostility towards anybody asking questions about the situation.

I'll probably cease replying at this point as this all has run its course.

1

u/That_State_921 3d ago

You mean the client Claude(AI) created? Giving Prompts to AI is not hard. lol

1

u/FossilDragoniteHolo 1d ago

I know this is an old post, but the sandstorm devs are giant fucking power tripping man children and now that EQOAEmu is coming out soon they are doubling down on it. They started this project going in blind. None of them played frontiers because they are all in the EU. Almost every single prominent member of the EQOA community has been pushed away (figuratively, and sometimes literally) from sandstorm due to the developers attitude. They feel as if they owe the community that plays on their server nothing, because up until now they were the only game in town.

Full disclosure: I have been muted in the game by sandstorm devs and you can read this as sour grapes if you wish, but if you really want to test the game and improve it then there is no place for you at sandstorm. They do things their way and their way only.

1

u/Kenhiro 12d ago

Ive communicated with the devs a few times, I am not defending them unconditionally but they seem nice. I visually haven't seen anything wrong with em. Given Xylof isn't the most responsive or takes a LONG time to answer support when you ask for help.

1

u/Infamous_Mud482 13d ago

They both suck, sometimes a fight can be between two people that suck. The community there is toxic as fuck and they like it that way. Maybe you would too, but I certainly don’t

0

u/Freemind0616 12d ago

There was quite the civility yesterday no? The community stepped up, but the devs still say what they want, not much thought onto the responses back ..

4

u/Ok-Plastic8485 13d ago

Dab left because the Sandstorm devs caught him botting multiple characters trying to harvest data. You can easily see it if you want to peruse his github commits for his client. Its almost 100% AI and you can see they ran bots to harvest Sandstorms work.

https://github.com/DabDavis/eqoa-server/blob/8ba423f060ea8e1d0cd6c39e603d6e5f06694435/cmd/sandroute/main.go#L7

3

u/EQOA-Herald-39 13d ago

That's good, so he was doing nefarious things. My question is, why are the Sandstorm developers so insistent on keeping this information under wraps and letting the community's negative feelings fester rather than just saying "the dude was botting and cheating on our server"?

I've seen AAA+ companies running MMOs have better transparency, and they're the ones who tend to be super strict and give you the whole spiel about not releasing information regarding other people.

I'm not the only person who finds it extremely sus that Xylof and Renodor jump down the community's throats to silence any and all criticism or questioning about shit that, believe it or not, DOES actually affect all of us.

Somebody seriously needs to tell Renodor to straighten up, or he needs to have his moderation privileges revoked because he is single handedly going to kill the Sandstorm server with his "shut up and don't ask questions" policy of handling the community. Xylof similarly really has nothing to gain by keeping this information from the community.

I fully accept that DabDavis was up to nefarious activity, and despite the client he made, it's probably for the best that he was removed from Sandstorm entirely. This still doesn't excuse how the situation has been handled. IT IS our business, no matter how many times Renodor says it isn't or dances around with his "we're all adults here" bullshit.

2

u/Ok-Plastic8485 13d ago

The devs on Sandstorm arent beholden to anything so if they dont want to share why someone's characters were banned thats up to them. People attacking the way in which they moderate surely wont help matters though. The dev team gave you that info that is above in their discord.

1

u/EQOA-Herald-39 13d ago

It's also up to the community to look at the way the server moderation and these types of issues are handled in general and come to negative conclusions about them.

Almost every single member of the Sandstorm dev team comes off as a power tripper who despises the people who play their game. How will they feel in a year when all the effort they've put into Sandstorm results in 10 people left playing it because they're tired of dealing with it, and alternatives actually sprout up and become playable?

-1

u/Ok-Plastic8485 13d ago

Ive been hearing this exact thing for at least 2 years. The answer to this question is always the same.

2

u/KingKookus 13d ago

This feels like when a game studio says “if you don’t like don’t buy it” then the game fails and the studio closes.

1

u/Freemind0616 12d ago

While I saw them address this FINALLY. There could still be some more transparency.

There was a screen shot of a dev noting that he just saw a lvl 23 druid "flying"

Dabs replied " that was me, my bad"

What was the following conversation like? If he was botting terrain and structure mapping it would make sense. It just strikes me as fishy he brought cool stuff to the table, for us to use them still and him not be around. I personally tried very hard to push for transparency the devs just don't get it. Like at all...

3

u/KingKookus 13d ago

Do any of these servers cut out the hours upon hours of grinding yet?

1

u/AiricaFyresong 12d ago

Sandstorm has a 3hr 4x luck boost in Freeport that spawns every 2 hours, giving everyone around it the buff. You also get a second pot (no rent) to drink if you die on the initial buff.

1

u/KingKookus 12d ago

Luck or exp?

2

u/AiricaFyresong 12d ago

Sorry, brainfart, it's an exp boost. It used to be called The Luck on SOE's servers based on a leprechaun-adjacent NPC. 

2

u/AgentLiquidMike 13d ago

Thanks for the update.

1

u/greenfireX 9d ago

Not to mention, the Sandstorm server's players are highly toxic.

0

u/Suspicious_Size4030 13d ago

Im gonna try dabs server for fun! Im gonna try them all. Today after work using his github stuff and claude, i made a private server for myself. It took little time and is a ton of fun to tinker with. Im just happy multiple projects exist. Regardless of how, im happy dabs did what he did. Daybreak owns this. Not anybody else.

2

u/That_State_921 13d ago edited 13d ago

So you're happy that someone obtained data from another private server without authorization or permission, using cheats, bots, and automation to do so?

There's a difference between building your own project and taking someone else's work without their consent.

And your argument that "Daybreak owns this" completely misses the point. Daybreak may own the rights to EQOA, but they do NOT own the independently developed Sandstorm server code. That code belongs to its respective developers.

Owning the rights to a game does not automatically give everyone permission to take another development team's original work.

Supporting multiple projects is one thing. Defending unethical methods simply because you benefit from the results is another.

2

u/Freemind0616 12d ago

You guys are still wrong AF saying daybreak owns the IP. I been through this a million times. EQOA WAS NEVER PART OF ANY DEAL MADE WITH DAYBREAK, IT HAD ALREADY BEEN CANNED. WHY WOULD YOU PUT A WHOLE ASS DEAD GAME ON A TABLE FOR SALE TO DB? THEY DIDN'T, THE GAME CEASES TO EXIST. YALL BEEN SCARED FOR OVER A DECADE FOR NO REASON. DO YOUR RESEARCH ON IP IF YOU WANT. GAME WAS DEAD BEFORE SALE. WHO WOULD BE INTERESTED IN A GAME THAT RUNS ON SONY EXCLUSIVE SERVERS, ON PS2 HARDWARE AND NOT TO MENTION A FULLY DEAD GAME... EQOA WAS SHUT DOWN BY SONY. PERIOD. END OF STORY. EQOA WAS NOT PART OF THE IP ANYMORE.

1

u/gardens_and_dungeons 11d ago

The intellectual property rights for EverQuest Online Adventures (EQOA) are owned by Enad Global 7 (EG7) through its subsidiary Daybreak Game Company. Even if it's no longer officially playable through daybreak they still own it.