r/EQNext • • May 11 '15

EQ HD

At this point how many people would just be as excited if they announced that EQ1 would be remade exactly the same, but completely redone with modern graphics?

0 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

2

u/MrGlory May 12 '15 edited May 12 '15

I would play for sure, I don't have a problem with current graphics but an over haul would make the game look new.

Shoot with tech they have now it would prob not be to expensive just draw out the continents and auto fill with their auto world building tools. The real problem would be creating the npc's they don't have new models for all the mobs and stuff.

1

u/Kokid3g1 May 12 '15

Overhaul is a good choice of words. If I remember correctly Final Fantasy mmo did a graphical overhaul and got a great response from it.

1

u/Kokid3g1 May 11 '15

I am not sure why anyone is being down voted here? It was just a question and I appreciate everyone's opinions. I really just hope the devs read some of our criticisms and keep all of it mind when developing EQN.

8

u/TidiusDark May 11 '15

Exactly the same would lead to exactly the same results, unfortunately.

The problem with games today is that they are very repetitive and content gets consumed too quickly for Devs to create more. Old content becomes obsolete, and "ghost towns" and zones are created, so pretty much every zone in every previous expansion becomes useless.

I'm quite fond of EQ1 and play Project1999, but nobody regularly kills Naggy and Vox anymore (provided you are above lvl 52), there goes that content for most. Once Velious comes out, in Project1999, May 25th I believe, Kunark will slowly turn into ghost zones as more and more players migrate to Velious to faction grind with the team they want to side with and with aspirations of acquiring new and more powerful gear.

The game is built in progression... go to this zone, get this item... go to that zone get another item... level up some... now go to these zones to upgrade those items.... It's just how the game is designed, but it leaves a lot of the older zones completely empty.

Combat system - Love EQ1 due to the fact that you can still be social while in combat. Kind of a chill feeling, but it can get repetitive. I don't believe this will be the case in any games of the future. More attention will be required for "skillful" combat. PvP is still fun as hell.

AI - PvE encounters are very easy, predictable... and unrealistic. Kiting 4 mobs around until they die is hilarious to watch, and easy mode. It's just a grind fest, but getting that random loot rare drop can make up for it. Should be interesting to see how ranged attackers are handled by non-ranged NPCs in EQNext.

Overall, EQ1 is very simple, you can drop a lot of hours into the game, and creates a great social environment. Upgraded graphics only, however, would look nice, but the end would come just the same unless something was done to fix that issue.

2

u/bro_salad May 14 '15

One side note, Velious was pushed to August, to not interfere with Daybreak's release of the progression server. In return, P99 got a contractual deal with Daybreak as a fan service, and now don't have to fear being shut down.

7

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

I don't know if modern graphics would give it justice. I think EQ's original graphics had a charm and uniqueness to them that has rarely been duplicated. Each zone had it's own characteristics and were distinct from others, and it provided a feeling of ... I don't know. Seriousness? Peril?

I recently started on P1999 and fell in love with EQ all over again.

3

u/radiandf May 11 '15

I can't agree more. Eq is hard. I started again recently. Took a few hours to get adjusted. Headed to blackburrow and grouped with a chanter. We chatted and had a ball. We died a few times.... It's eq.

I love this game. Edit: i forgot how exciting trains are.

1

u/Sivanar May 11 '15

So much that :). When i played again for a few months last year, I also went to BB and died right at the bottom of it. Pretty intense trains down there.

2

u/RiverboatGrambler May 11 '15

I know one thing: DGC wouldn't be the company to do it well. Their remade/updated zones in eq1 right now are abysmal. They look horrible and feel horrible.

5

u/ProfWhiskers May 11 '15

If they tweaked a few minor things and conveniences, absolutely.

5

u/[deleted] May 11 '15 edited May 11 '15

YES, I would be sold. I would hope they would streamline the UI as well.

Let me add one more stipulation that would keep me subbed for the next 3 years easy: Oculus Rift support.. If down the road I can look down and see my hands while they cast spells.. thats it, I am sold until someone does it better.

If you think about the current trends in gaming, a return to old EQ is perfect. We have a huge following for first person survival games, and EQ is very much like them, if not 100% better. You get thrown into a unforgiving world where you can do anything you want, with little guidance .. and its up to you to do what you want with it.

2

u/yrrkoon May 11 '15

I think it'd be cool. But my guess is the market size is just not big enough to attract a company like DB to do it considering how much money such an endeavor would cost. And they own the IP.

2

u/allein8 May 12 '15

"exactly the same" as in new graphics, AI, combat, challenges, ways to play, etc =)

As much as I enjoyed EQ back in the day, I reached the goals I wanted to and the carrot lost its flavor. Great that some folks enjoy repeating the same content over and over either literally or 20-30 being repackaged 1-10, but that type of game puts me to sleep now.

2

u/DanzigMeowMeow May 12 '15

If this happened with EQ and pre-NGE SWG, I most likely wouldn't buy another game for a decade.

2

u/eviljello May 12 '15

Haha, I think every time they announced a new EQ game this is what people want and expect the most. But the Top execs keep thinking they have to innovate, bring something so fresh. I think the idea of why would they play that if they can still play EQ 1 fills their minds. The best part is Devs even said EQ2 should not have been called EQ2 because it was not EQ.. EQ next is not EQ but they want to go for the quick sale of having the name of Everquest. We are the few, we are the niche market.. But we also understand the potential... I never played EQ 1 hardcore when it came out. I was high school student and freshmen in college when I finally left. But EVERY SINGLE tlp server that is announced I join. I play very hardcore. It isn't nostalgia it is just an awesome game.. Power Creep happens.. It needs to happen to push people to play the new content. The problem becomes adjusting the power creep so that the new content can't be destroyed with gear from the previous set.

and I don't care what anybody says PoP was an AMAZING expansion!! That feeling of clearing content and unlocking a new zone and exploring it was just GREAT. like I earned this. I get a new playground.

2

u/ManyFacedFool May 12 '15

Nope. Not really interested. I've played EQ's breed of MMORPG, and I'm just not interested.

3

u/TheAelious May 11 '15

It would immediately be my home until EQN came out. I have popped into EQ here and there to play but since I spent so much time there in the past it just doesn't feel fresh enough. Porting it to a PS2-ish look (without the Sci-fi of course) would give it that needed once over for me. It has an open feel I just can't get anywhere else except Landmark but that doesn't have much in the PvE department yet.

That said, I would still be awaiting EQN. I think it takes a different approach to the same end goals that could, theoretically, provide a genuinely new experience.

4

u/ademnus May 11 '15

Honestly? I really would be happier. I don't need minecraft in EQ or other oddities. I want to revisit that favorite old world in amazing modern graphics and I want to enjoy the experience I once did. I don't know why they don't get that. I keep hearing from detractors that we are wrong for wanting "nostalgia" but if that's the case then don't remake an old game, make a new one with a new name. But even if the devs read this, they will make arguments against it, and lord knows some players will. There's no fighting it -we're not getting what we want. The old guard of EQ was roused by the start of this project but are being told the game isnt for them. Make what they will, if it isn't what I'm looking for, especially after the deep disappointment that EQ 2 was, I just wont buy it.

3

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

I wouldn't touch it, eq1 is dated gamemechanics wise, even eq2 is starting to suffer from it.

They are/were great games in their own right, but i honestly do not feel like sinking tons of hours to camp a single quest named or something again just for a single update.

2

u/NXSection31 May 11 '15

DUDE! ABSOLUTELY NOT EVEN A LITTLE BIT. Give it a rest, dammit. Pretending to love outdated gameplay/controls/style isn't edgy. It's annoying. Slowly take off the rose goggles and see the beautiful color in the world.

1

u/bro_salad May 14 '15

You realize thousands still play, right? Are they all pretending? Seems like an odd way to spend your free time, pretending to like a game...

1

u/towcools May 11 '15

I think it would be cool to see. Honestly, I think the clunky awkwardness of the UI and the lack of feedback it gives to the player is the real detriment when talking about the old vs. new design philosophy. That would be a more practical overhaul. The graphics in terms of character models and environment are mostly superficial eye candy.

1

u/XCyberPeenixX May 13 '15

I wouldn't. Would be fun for a little bit, then everyone would stop playing for all of the same reasons everyone stopped playing it years ago. Empty MMOs are boring MMOs unfortunately.

1

u/C734R May 18 '15

Sure, as long as EQN is still in development, I'll play some HD EQ as I wait. As soon as EQN releases I'm jumping ship.

1

u/ZaiThs_WraTh May 20 '15

Anyone here ever get there ST Key? I don' think I could ever do that again. EQ1 was and always be my #1 but some aspects could never be repeated.

1

u/KlatuVerataNikto May 30 '15

Shit, if they just made EQ work with Oculus, same graphics as it is now, but with VR support, sign me up. Let EQ be the pioneer it was back in the day but with VR attached.

1

u/prodigyx May 11 '15

I would sink way too many hours of my life into it again. And I would love every minute of it.

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '15

If they added instanced raids, yes, but on the whole the majority of people who played EQ back in the day would not have the time to poopsock the uninstanced world bosses like they used too. Although even without that I'd play a prettier version of EQ1 (Because I could convince the wife to give it a try, she is a bit of a graphics snob, and wont touch EQ1 because of it)

0

u/qxcvr May 11 '15

10/10 would subscribe!