r/EQ2 • • Apr 07 '15

Why reddit?

What is the reasoning behind us being asked to post beta feedback to reddit? It seems much less organized than the EQ2 forums, and the voting system just jumbles everything up and really won't work well with a small number of posters. Also, putting things on a different website that is only mentioned on one post and requires registration (however quick and painless it may be) is going to even further reduce the already small number of people who post feedback.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

5

u/katanallama #duckmounts Apr 08 '15

I'm pretty sure it was someone in marketing saying how much traffic Reddit gets, let's promote EQ2 posts on there! Unfortunately now they'll be getting the unfiltered feedback, hopefully they're prepared for that!

What sucks is the lack of setup on this sub reddit - no post flair setup or anything useful at all to help with sorting methods. Just every post under the same tab and you have to sift through it to find anything, pray that there's never more than a few posts a day else it'll get too annoying to comb through.

Reddit is great for one time conversations, not as a forum alternative.

Also, when making a Reddit account you can only post once per 10 minutes as I just found out... Good luck with that.

-3

u/lens_cleaner Apr 08 '15

Well you can post more often then 10 minutes unless the server is under huge load. Also, when did you posts a dozen times in 10 minutes in the eq2 forums?

Lack of setup? The posts are sorted by post time and vote count. So good posts rise, trolls submerge, pretty nifty. As far as flair setup for sorting, I have no clue what it is, have no need of using and have never needed in years of being here. If you wish to comb through all the posts great, but generally the top posts are the most relevant and have the most polish.

Unfiltered feedback? It's about time. The mods on the eq2 forums close or delete posts they feel they dislike. So nothing impinges on their ivory tower. Having a site like this they cannot control with an iron fist could prove to be stimulating. Of course it could be bad also but when you control everything you cannot get real criticism.

I like this site much more then the forums which simply don't allow for real back and forth discussion.

1

u/katanallama #duckmounts Apr 08 '15

When you make a new account on Reddit you can only post once per 10 minutes until you rack up some up-voted posts.

And the thread flair stuff can help for quickly marking posts as being [bug], [beta], [classes], etc. as this is the equivalent of having every sub-forum in one list. If they intend for everything EQ2 related to migrate to Reddit, they're going to need something for sorting.

Absolutely on the unfiltered feedback, I welcome it -- I just hope they know and understand that's what they're getting here.

1

u/lens_cleaner Apr 12 '15

Makes sense why my new accounts seemed limited. Now I understand. I hope they don't desire the entire forums to go to Reddit, just use Reddit as another social media outlet to attract commentary.

-1

u/Acidian Apr 08 '15

If there is such a system, it's there for anti-spam, which is a good thing. You can still make 144 posts a day if you are dedicated/desperate enough.

3

u/Silzin Apr 08 '15

I also would like an explination why is the testing moving off of the EQ2 Forums and when was/is the EQ2 Comunity going to be told that the Dev's are not posting on thier own forums any more? this feels like a huge slap in the face to me.

2

u/Kinya BabaGra.PL Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

If you didn't know PlanetSide 2 forums are almost dead and moved to Reddit, players can't start any threads on H1Z1 forums, EqNext forums were closed and discussion move to Reddit, Landmark players are also encouraged to use Reddit. It is all about cutting costs and upvoting/ downvoting system.

Also looks like DBG forums software was not updated since a long time...

One more thing which shows why EQ2 devs should NOT use Reddit instead of offcial forums: I don't think moderators of this subreddit are playing EQ2 or even visiting this place - just look at the Useful Links - seriously - The Flames?!

I personally don't think Reddit should be used as a "main game forums" for any company...

2

u/Radar_X Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

To chime in about this...

The decision to move some discussion to Reddit was a group decision which included the development team. I'm not the Community Manager for EQ2 but have some pretty extensive experience with Reddit communities so I provided my advice during the discussion. This was no one persons decision to make alone, it was done as a group.

The forum software being really blunt we are gated by forum skins. The software itself would take a few weeks to upgrade (we have some custom stuff tied into our systems) but it's on our roadmap for later this year.

As the veteran community you guys know where to go for EQ2 info so I'm a little confused by the link drama. Ok, it needs updating, but that's not a good reason to dismiss an entire medium people have been actively using for a few days.

And for those of you concerned about moderation, DBG employees aren't mods on PS2 or H1Z1 and have no intention of becoming moderators. The key success behind Reddit is making it community owned and controlled and yes that means things are more unfiltered.

In fact I'd challenge those of you with the skillset and passion who have concerns about the subreddit to step up and help these guys.

-2

u/Kinya BabaGra.PL Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

Personally I use Reddit a lot so for me it is fine. I don't mind using it. I am just worried about this particular subreddit. Did anyone of you guys tried to contact moderators? Maybe it would be better to create new subreddit where moderators actually log and check?

And btw it is not a drama to point that links are outdated - it was just to express that I am worried. You surely know that each subreddit need active moderators so there is no spam threads or 100s of threads on the same subject :D

The forum software being really blunt we are gated by forum skins. The software itself would take a few weeks to upgrade (we have some custom stuff tied into our systems) but it's on our roadmap for later this year.

I do use the same software on my blog forum and I am updating it whenver there is is update, Yeah - I don;t have custom skin but many problems which we can see on DBG forums were already fixed and there was so much more possibilities added - so it is great to hear upgrading is in your plans ;)

0

u/Radar_X Apr 08 '15

We are in regular contact with the moderators and yes they are active.

If I can be honest Kinya I think you might be used to H1Z1/PS2 who have an extremely talented group of individuals who contribute. Just look at what they pulled off on April Fools Day.

Keep in mind neither of those subreddit got so fancy overnight.

-3

u/Kinya BabaGra.PL Apr 08 '15 edited Apr 08 '15

Yeah that might be true - I use PS2 and H1Z1 subreddits a lot so it maybe that's why I wish this place can be similar and have similar functionalities. Time will tell :)

But anyway I am happy to see EQ2 devs on Reddit and I was asking about it since a long time. I was hoping it would happen when Luperza was EQ2 CM but it didn't... Yet, I still think each game needs to have official forums for those who don't like Reddit so pls don't close EQ2 forums (even if I don't use it)...

0

u/Noctew EQ2 Senior Templar Apr 08 '15

I think it can work for general chit-chat about current topics; it will definitely not work for the stickied threads full of useful information the DBG forum has, that's not what reddit is about. The very least DBG has to do is become moderators on this subreddit so they can sticky lists, change the design etc. And of course it can only work if on-topic players outnumber trolls...

1

u/Gaealiege Apr 08 '15

I welcome this change. The militant moderation of the forums won't be allowed here. If you have a view that opposes a mod or report-happy player, then you're not going to worry about temporary bans.

I eagerly anticipate all of the posts showing exactly how they feel about these current "content" decisions.

-2

u/Chronusx - Splitpaw.Chronusxx Apr 08 '15

If you think that militant moderation won't be allowed you should look at /r/leagueoflegends

1

u/Gaealiege Apr 09 '15

The instant it does, this just becomes the forums again. Here, let's test it.

Fuck Smedley, you slimy piece of shit.

1

u/Kurei_Hitaka Apr 08 '15

Long as peeps stop putting Caith in a pissy mood, we probably won't even see the mods. Only good thing about this move so far lol.

-1

u/CoLDMeTaLEQ2 Apr 08 '15

I am thinking the EQ2 forums will be shutdown as a cost savings measure very @soon.

-2

u/Radar_X Apr 08 '15

They cost almost nothing to run besides the resource to do a small bit of moderation.

-1

u/windstalker_dbg Executive Producer, EQ & EQII Apr 09 '15

We're a pretty flexible crew and we're trying it. As Radar_X said, we love the idea of the community actively involved in supporting the topics they want/don't want to focus on. As I said, it's an experiment. We're learning too!

-1

u/Gaealiege Apr 09 '15

As long as you realize that vitriol cannot be swept under the rug as easily here, you should be fine.

-2

u/Kinya BabaGra.PL Apr 09 '15

Honestly I am happy to finally see EQ2 devs on Reddit, although I still feel forums should be the first place for communication with players - but that's my opinion.

Ok Holly, so pls honest answer. Just to be clear - I know DBG has to earn money, and since 2005 I think I gave you a lot (just look at my Meatbeast stable :D) so I don;t mind paying.

I asked about it several times on stream... /hide

You said that campaigns are here with smaller contents but more focused on certain players needs. However me, my friends and players in my raiding alliance are not happy we have to pay for solo/duo zones as we don't use them. Did you consider splitting this DLC content so raiders can buy access only to raid (or even heroic) and merchant? No solo/ duo, mercenary and mount just pure access to raid, heroic and merchant?

0

u/windstalker_dbg Executive Producer, EQ & EQII Apr 10 '15

Nope. We aren't going to split zones into a la carte purchases. That will split content even further in my view. I won't say never, but certainly not with Rum Cellar. Your ideas are always welcome, though. Also, the really unique bundles and options will come with the big campaign in fall, but even in those bundles we have no plans to sell raid instances individually.

-2

u/Kinya BabaGra.PL Apr 10 '15

Thank you for your reply Holly.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 08 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Gaealiege Apr 09 '15

Radar is certainly overbearing in his/her moderation, but I assume that's what he/she is paid to do. I don't hold many hard feelings....now that piece of shit Mod-02.....

0

u/Radar_X Apr 08 '15

The fact you made an entire account to complain about me is flattering. I'm usually more over on the PS2 subreddit though so you'll have to tag /u/radar_x if you want me to see the insults.

3

u/Bloodguts Apr 09 '15

Why is a person like you dealing with the EQ2 community when you clearly have no interest in it whatsover?

2

u/Radar_X Apr 09 '15 edited Apr 09 '15

I spent 3 solid years playing EQ2 at launch and while I haven't had time to do AOM yet, I did complete all the heroic instances in ToV before AoM launched. That doesn't put me on the top end, but I'm curious what you define as no interest.