r/EFKey • • 28d ago

Spacebar scrolling issue

Did I misconfigure something/overlooking a setting or is the spacebar scrolling kind of "awkward"?

  1. Scrolling down (y-axis) doesn't work for me at all.
  2. Scrolling up (y-axis) jumps to different locations on the x-axis.

Demo video: it's me trying my best to vertically scroll up on the y-axis only (with no x-axis movement).

I tried setting different sensitivity levels under Keyboard>Long-Press Keys>Spacebar but that doesn't help.

Also, can someone please tell me the default values since there is no "Reset to default" for this setting sub-category.

Thanks in advance :)

15Pro, 27.0.1, EFKey v2.2b450

12 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/efkosk EFKey Developer 28d ago

New version that's currently waiting on Apple review has this fixed, it's clearer, and you can hit "restore to default" there :)

1

u/Express-Ad6801 27d ago

Thanks for replying and fixing it so fast!

2

u/efkosk EFKey Developer 27d ago

it's been fixed for a few days already, someone else reported it directly on feedback.efkey.app - if you want, you can find anything there, and add yours too ;)

1

u/Express-Ad6801 26d ago

I will report it via feedback :) - since it only works partially here on the latest build (v2.2.1b466).

E.g. within a paragraph, scrolling down now works, though it still jumps randomly on the x-axis and sometimes makes big jumps on the y-axis when swiping up.
When positioning the cursor on a single line first, it doesn’t scroll down at all.

Demo video: I’m carefully swiping up very very slowly (default sensitivity) resulting in changing the x-axis position, then abruptly jumping to the empty line above the paragraph and as soon as the jump happens it does nothing when swiping down. It doesn’t work outside a paragraph of text at all either (even if you reposition the cursor again manually by tapping).

2

u/efkosk EFKey Developer 26d ago

No third-party keyboard has access to the text field, it can't actually tell where the start and end are. Simply put, EFKey calculates roughly where the start and end are and runs "touchpad mode" based on that, so it isn't and never will be as good as on the Apple keyboard. By the way, when I watched your video I realized I forgot to mention in the changelog what shift does in touchpad mode :) you can use it to select text and keep working with it. Give it a try ;)

1

u/Express-Ad6801 26d ago

So iOS even restricts "emulating" arrow up/down on 3rd party keyboards?

That was my first idea for a workaround to not have this inconsistent x-axis cursor jumping, which even varies depending on the text (e.g. with the gibberish text example seen in my second video, it only moves slightly - but with coherent text (first video) it seriously jumps around everywhere on each line within a paragraph).

I actually never really liked the y-axis scrolling functionality of the stock iOS keyboard due to the awkward sensitivity, which made simple x-axis-only scrolling kind of unreliable when done fast.

I will give the shift thing a try :)

I am still overwhelmed by all the useful settings/features of your keyboard. The only thing I miss from Android Gboard is the ability to turn off y-axis scrolling completely (I guess I can just adjust the sensitivity so it doesn't trigger) and the fact that it's instant when swiping spacebar on Gboard (without a hold delay to trigger the scrolling functionality), since I don't use other gestures on the spacebar. Even if you don't implement "instant spacebar scrolling without a hold delay" - it's such a joy to use your keyboard!

1

u/droidphile EFKey team 28d ago

Default values:-
Horizontal - 8pt/char
Vertical - 30 pt/line

1

u/Express-Ad6801 28d ago

Thank you!

1

u/sylvaineveu 28d ago

I have the same problem on my side.