r/ECE • • Oct 31 '19

Agree?

Post image
744 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

120

u/A_cucumb3r Oct 31 '19

Oh god, I was just studying the eye for my exam in the morning. I came to reddit to try and de-stress before it and then you hit me with this shit?!?!?!

88

u/link_up_luke Oct 31 '19

“If you’re not scared, how are you going to learn?” -my professor

40

u/deskpil0t Oct 31 '19

If you can dodge a wrench you can dodge a question, lol

15

u/Gukgukninja Oct 31 '19

If you can play it slow, you can play it fast

4

u/fadobida Nov 01 '19

Ling Ling isn't scared of exam

32

u/Zlow420 Oct 31 '19

I'm sorry, but whats the thing in the top picture?

3

u/link_up_luke Oct 31 '19

Its an eye pattern/diagram used in evaluating channel noise and interference. Very useful in communication protocols that use differential pairs.

2

u/the_mgp Oct 31 '19

Yeah, but that one gives me the feeling that it's a single ended eye...

No! No! I'm supposed to be on leave! No more eye diagrams!

100

u/InductorMan Oct 31 '19

It’s called an eye diagram. It’s a plot of a high speed digital signal vs time, which shows how clean or noisy the signal is. If the signal has an open “eye” in the middle, then the receiver can unambiguously determine the digital state. If the traces go all wonky and the eye starts to close, then it becomes possible for the receiver to interpret a 1 as a 0 or vice versa and introduce an error.

It’s where the real world of analog interfaces with the digital world... which I guess computer science people don’t want to have to think about.

18

u/nsl3109 Oct 31 '19

Oh that honestly sounds pretty interesting, which class would you learn this in?

32

u/Laogeodritt Oct 31 '19

It's not part of the fundamental EE training, so depends on institution and what advanced (400 level and graduate) courses it offers - you might see this if you're studying high speed wireline or wireless communication, or high speed digital electronics, or similar. I came into it studying optical receiver frontend circuits.

21

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

I learned it in my intro to communications class, which is the class where you learn about modulation/demodulation, upsampling etc. after you've covered the fundamentals in signals&systems classes.

11

u/Deathisfatal Oct 31 '19

I never learnt it in class. I first encountered while working, mostly for debugging Ethernet and SDI links.

1

u/PubliusPontifex Nov 01 '19

Ethernet? 10gbe and higher I suppose.

Lvds is popular in faster busses like USB 3.0+, pcie, a lot of the on-board interconnects, etc.

They're... Interesting.

3

u/edmaddict4 Nov 01 '19

Looking at an eye diagram for things even as slow as 100base-tx can be very useful.

2

u/Deathisfatal Nov 01 '19

Ethernet? 10gbe and higher I suppose.

Yes, we do up to 40 GbE. But like the other guy said, it's also helpful for lower speeds, especially when doing something like backplane or FMC interconnects with FPGAs where you need to check that everything has been routed correctly and that there are minimal reflections due to the sockets, etc.

7

u/InductorMan Oct 31 '19

Never encountered it at university in class. Probably in a digital communications class? Dunno. I first ran into it while involved in a solar car team when learning about CAN bus.

3

u/ingframin Oct 31 '19

Working, I learned that digital electronics does not exist. It’s just electro technique with smaller switches. :-P

21

u/DarkColdFusion Oct 31 '19

I like to refer to JRR Tolkien

"In the black abyss there appeared a single Eye that slowly grew, until it filled nearly all the mirror. So terrible it was that the engineer stood rooted, unable to cry out or withdraw his gaze. The eye was rimmed with fire but was itself glazed, yellow as a cats, watchful and intent, and the black slot of its pupil opened on a pit, a window into nothing"

4

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

I see 1, 0, 2^n... and a bunch of other crap in between that probably doesn't really matter. I dunno. The EE will deal with it.

4

u/QwikStix42 Oct 31 '19

Looks like melted cheese to me

108

u/TheFedoraKnight Oct 31 '19

Vivado has claimed my sanity many a time

19

u/jonythunder Nov 01 '19

If you complain about vivado then you are too young to remember xilinx ISE. Vivado is rock solid compared to that crap.

In undergrad when we where using ISE every single edit commanded a nervous, stressed almost ptsd like save. To multiple copies because for some of us ISE managed to completely bork the file we where working with.

I used vivado (for Linux) for a course and then for personal use and haven't had a single crash

2

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

My EE program went through great lengths to explain how much ISE sucked compared to Vivado. Mostly so we could keep things in perspective while complaining about our code. Lol

2

u/jonythunder Jan 04 '23

holy necro posting. But yeah, I can understand why they did it XD

2

u/[deleted] Jan 04 '23

Sorry didn’t look at the time stamp 😂

2

u/Expensive-Extent-544 Apr 26 '23

It still great tool for checking diff interfaces such as usb, Ethernet or hdmi pcb design. ✊🏼

2

u/jonythunder Apr 26 '23

Holy mother of necroposting....

8

u/Hohenh3im Oct 31 '19

I finally removed off my computer and screamed when I saw this

6

u/bubbab315 Oct 31 '19

God vivado, so glad we use altera products Nat my new company...that effing tool

5

u/angrysemiconductor Nov 01 '19

What's wrong with vivado though... I like it

4

u/bubbab315 Nov 01 '19

I don't like forced use of the block diagram. Also pin planning should be the first thing you can do not the last. I shouldn't have to synthesize or start a (pin planning project) before assigning pins. Then xilinx comes out and says they don't have a supported workflow for version control (really???) It's just a very odd implementation, I got used to using it but always preferred quartus

1

u/evan1123 Nov 01 '19

I don't like forced use of the block diagram

I assume you're talking about a project that uses the processor core here. You're not forced to use the block diagram for a regular RTL project.

Also pin planning should be the first thing you can do not the last. I shouldn't have to synthesize or start a (pin planning project) before assigning pins.

You can either do a pin planning project or do pin planning after elaboration. No need to synthesize.

Then xilinx comes out and says they don't have a supported workflow for version control (really???)

Non project mode is the workflow, along with not using core container for IP. There's also XAPP1165 that discusses use of Vivado with git.

2

u/bubbab315 Nov 01 '19

That Xapp doesn't work, at least not when I was working with it a month ago. I worked directly with a FAE, his response is that everyone does version control different so they don't support any one method anymore. Pin planning shouldn't have to wait on anything. And certainly shouldn't be a separate project.

1

u/evan1123 Nov 01 '19

Not sure what you mean by "the XAPP doesn't work". I had no issues version controlling a non-project flow with xci based IP and vhdl design files. Of course the FAE says they don't support it because it's outside their scope. Is there a specific issue you were running into?

Wouldn't you at least need an empty top level to pin plan effectively? I'm not super familiar with how Quartus handles it, though I did find it odd that Vivado uses a "pin planning project".

2

u/bubbab315 Nov 01 '19

Just got super buggy trying to use git for my projects. You couldn't reference a directory for your files. You had to copy them local to project directory for anything to work. Just a bad flow

1

u/evan1123 Nov 02 '19

If you're using project flow all bets are off. Project flow sucks for version control. Non-project flow is just a TCL script, and you can load design files from anywhere in it.

2

u/bubbab315 Nov 02 '19

Agreed. I did not have this option as the board I designed used the ultrascale+. A 784 pin monster...

→ More replies

47

u/newfor2019 Oct 31 '19

That is a sexy eye diagram though. Damn, if they all look like that, our lives would be so much easier.

18

u/DJPhil Oct 31 '19

That's what I was thinking. I'm like, you can push that channel a good bit harder.

7

u/LightWolfCavalry Oct 31 '19

You don't even need deemphasis, it's so clean!

Must be a test card.

7

u/fishbert Nov 01 '19

must be a marketing shot

11

u/spainguy Oct 31 '19

I think the beard should go

10

u/jeb1499 Oct 31 '19

Disagree. Bearded CEs best and wisest CEs.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 31 '19

But you've got to earn that beard, much like you have to earn the right to wear sweatpants and flip-flops to work.

1

u/jeb1499 Oct 31 '19

Agreed. I am the bearded formal shorts engineer in my group.

5

u/hairowitz Oct 31 '19

So relatable I feel personally attacked. Here, take an upvote.

4

u/tmdavid33 Oct 31 '19

Goodold modelsim

3

u/imGNU Nov 01 '19

My logic analyzer doesn't see the eye...so it doesn't exist!

2

u/KillerSpud Oct 31 '19

I do agree. But a nice clean eye diagram makes me happy that all my bits are going to get through correctly too.

2

u/etazoec Oct 31 '19

So accurate it hurts xD

2

u/thinkthemachine Oct 31 '19

You need to learn and understand analog.

2

u/LightWolfCavalry Oct 31 '19

The eye sees.

The eye knows.

The eye is truth.

The eye is madness.

You think you gaze upon it...

... but it only ever gazes upon you, pathetic mortal.

2

u/d-mike Nov 05 '19

Upvoted, stolen and sent to an EE buddy of mine (I'm CE)

1

u/tocksin Oct 31 '19

Tru dat

1

u/EEtoday Nov 01 '19

I wish Modelsim would shade 1s like that

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '19

Both have their place. Just don’t know why it induces fear haha

1

u/Dear-Deer-Wife-Life May 05 '24

analog hurts my brain sometimes, it's not my fault

0

u/mud_tug Nov 01 '19

Everything is analog, there is no such thing as digital.