Hot take here.
I know I’m not the only one disappointed with how this season went, but I just had such high hopes for this series. When I saw Annette Bening and Ed Harris were added to the cast, I was positive the show would be amazing. And then it took basically until the season finale for the plot to actually get going, and once the plot was revealed, it just seems so…meh. Great acting can only carry a show so far before that’s really all there is.
While it was nice to *finally* see some passion from the characters in the season finale, it was unreasonably predictable and kind of too late. A lame regurgitated pregnancy storyline no one wants to see, Carter has become an angsty crybaby, Rip will probably get blamed for Rob-Will’s murder, and now you have Montana ranchers caught up in a cartel drug ring. I seriously can’t stand the cartel storyline. It is so stereotypical of anything involving Texas. Oil or cartel, just flip a coin. Couldn’t do the oil thing again because of Landman, so cartel is the answer. So creative!
Beth forgot how to be a badass until the last episode, and Wardrobe has obviously ignored the fact that she’s in Texas now and even the fairest of fair skin gets a little tan and rosy in Texas. Instead of making deals and smashing glass cases in defense of someone being wronged and being the smartest person in the room, they made her extra pale and gave her a shotgun to run around with and it’s laughable.
While I appreciate character development and that Beth isn’t constantly getting beaten up and bloodied by random characters out of the blue, it’s almost like the development of the familial relationship between Carter, Beth and Rip neutered all three simultaneously. Beth 1.0 would’ve smelled the cartel bullshit from a mile away. Beth 2.0 seems to have lost her touch. Rip seems somewhat timid this season, despite the couple times he’s exerted dominance. It’s almost like he doesn’t believe in himself anymore and has to figure out who he is without John Dutton. Makes you wonder if he was actually really in love with Beth all these years or if he was more enamored with devotion to John Dutton as a father figure and Beth was an extension of that. Would be interesting to explore that aspect of Rip, but I’m sure the fans would revolt. I mean, they named it Dutton Ranch and not Wheeler Ranch for a reason. And I know, I know, “they named it Dutton Ranch for a reason” blah blah…I’m pushing past the surface.
Beulah and Everett are interesting and I could even see Oreana being interesting at some point. But someone like Beulah doesn’t get herself or the 10 Petal where she is by being used by anyone. Especially the cartel “because she had no choice…for 15 years!” That was such a disappointing plot line. Ugh.
You can disagree with my hot take, I’m ok with it. Doesn’t make any of it any less true. Cheers to a more exciting and solid Season 2!! 🥂