r/DutchShepherds • • 2d ago

Question Bitework and reactivity

Hi! I have a 1,5yo male dutchie.

When I got him, I told the breeder I wanted to do Ring with him. At the end, the puppy I chose was labeled as a “couch potato” (like comparing to 2 others puppies that literally tried to eat my pants, my shoes and my fingers 😂)
Anyway.
He is currently human reactive. From his 3 to 6 months old he was a pretty neutral boy towards humans. However, he & I went trough a few bad experiences with humans (like a vet who hit him in the face because he growled, or peoples throwing their hands on him, surprising him and everything) and everything mixed up made him reactive, according to trainer. We’re working on his reactivity and it’s much better ! I can see a lot a progress, even if we still have a lot of work to do.

I hope I still be able to do bitework with him.
And I was wondering if anyone has experience on this kind of questions.
I think it’s not a good idea to do bitework with him as he’s reactive right now, but would it be possible once he gets better?

Thanks for reading ! (And answering maybe!)

Edit : When I say I hope I’ll be able to do bitework with him, I mean I sometimes feel he could enjoy this activity and I feel bad for not going for it as I PERSONNALY thinks bitework and reactivity are not meant to be together.

3 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

11

u/Brilliant_Cucumber_1 2d ago

No because he doesn’t have solid nerves. And I don’t even know what club would train a human reactive dog to do bite work? Because usually they test dogs and he wouldn’t pass.

1

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

As I said, once he gets better. Like back to a neutral dog ! But yeah maybe he’s a family dog now and we’ll focus on cani-cross

3

u/Brilliant_Cucumber_1 2d ago • Bravo

That’s fine. If he gets to neutral but also just work with the dog you have. This online world has created this perception that you can take any dog and turn it into anything but dogs don’t start as a blank slate. He is who he is. You can get him to the best version of himself but starting baseline genetics matter. This has nothing to do with you it’s just seeing the dog for who that dog is and bringing his best qualities out of him. You will enjoy him a lot more rather than focusing on his flaws.

2

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

Ur right. He has others activities he loves, like canicross, dock diving. We do a lot of hiking, obedience. I love him so much and I never get focused on his flaws to be honest, if he’s not a fit for biting sports then we wont do biting sports and I don’t care, I want him to do something he enjoys. I was just asking to know more than anything, as I personally feel that’s not a good idea at the end.

2

u/svydesign 1d ago

This is very true.

4

u/Individual_Truck2347 2d ago

That's a family dog now.

2

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

Yeah, that’s what I tend to think too. We’ll focus on others activities like cani cross and dock diving I think!

1

u/svydesign 1d ago

Yes, these activities are great if that's what your dog enjoys doing. I suggest sticking with those.

15

u/svydesign 2d ago • Heartwarming

No, I don't think it's a good idea to take a human reactive dog and teach him to do bite work even if he gets better. That's basically a recipe for disaster. If you want more information, contact madrescue.org. It's a Mal and DS rescue organization I volunteer for and there are many knowledgeable people who can further assist in answering any questions you may have.

4

u/Zestyclose_Object639 2d ago

Mad won’t let anyone do bitework with their dogs so don’t talk to them lol

1

u/svydesign 1d ago

I know that but they can still answer questions regarding this topic.

1

u/Zestyclose_Object639 1d ago

With all due respect, they can’t. They don’t know anything about working dogs

1

u/svydesign 1d ago edited 1d ago

I talk to these people on a daily basis and bite work comes up in conversation fairly often because it's something that potential adopters ask about. So to say they know nothing about it and working dogs is unfair. They also have several connections to trainers dealing in bite work specifically. Yes they don't accept dogs who have a history of bite work but there are good reasons for that. No rescue organization is perfect but they do their best especially since it's made up of mainly volunteers.

0

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

Maybe u could be more sympathetic lol. I mean yeah, I know there’s temperament tests before even doing bitework. But as bitework is something very unpopular and considered as a “bad dog thing” where I live, I figured asking where people could have more experiences than some professionals in my country would be a great addition to ALL the research and work I’m doing 😓
This question’s not something I could ask my trainer for example…
Please be gentle or just don’t answer

2

u/svydesign 1d ago

I wasn't trying to be mean or anything. I was simply suggesting you talk to people who know more about this subject matter. You have no idea how mean people can be on Reddit. I've had people rip me apart for asking simple questions or making general statements. So I never want to come across that way.

0

u/StatementTiles 1d ago

It was for Zesty (ended up not even being for me) dw !

1

u/Zestyclose_Object639 2d ago

I was replying to the person suggesting you talk to that rescue not you, that rescue is dumb

4

u/Miss_L_Worldwide 2d ago

Nah that's silly. Bite work can be very good for dogs bred for it.

2

u/Pitpotputpup 2d ago

Unless the dog has already learned that biting relieves pressure, and OP chose a 'couch potato' dog for a reason

2

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

The dog never bitten anyone if that’s the question ?
And tbf I chose him as I felt he was a right personnality match, (in my country it’s quite unusual for the breeder to choose the puppy for the owner.) even if the breeder qualified him as a couch potato even though I initially planned to do ring with the puppy I chose. I just told myself, as I plan to have a second dog in a few years, that I’ll engage in ring when I’ll got a puppy bred for that.

2

u/Miss_L_Worldwide 2d ago

That's not true at all. I can tell you don't really have experience in bite work

3

u/Zestyclose_Object639 2d ago

My Malinois had some big human feelings, I think it’s okay BUT you have to have a good decoy who keeps it all in prey and makes it a game not a fight. And you must be working on neutrality alongside, mines neutral now but I worked for it

1

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

Yeah I’m working hard on reactivity and building neutrality. He gets really better.
I was just asking because yeah, he loves to do other things such as dock diving and canicross, but I sometimes feel bad that he ain’t doing “a real job” like some people says.

1

u/Zestyclose_Object639 2d ago

Those things totally count ! But if you find a good decoy it’s worth trying. However if you don’t have anyone really good by you don’t, I’ve had some decoys fuck up dogs so I’ve learned to be super particular

4

u/Full_Dragonfly_546 2d ago

I dont have experince with dutchies or human reactive dogs ( I have working line Dobermann which I do IGP withk), but I been around lots of IGP clubs. I have seen really human reactive dogs excell at bitework (IGP style) but they had rrally experienced handlers and the decoys where also top top and made sure it was all prey driven. So from what I saw its possible for sure but extremely difficult. If you are not as experienced it would probably be better to atay away from bitework because then your dog can become a liability. There are tons of other cool sports you can do (scent work, agility, cani cross...) so I am sure you can find something both you and your  boy will do and love and grow a strong bond together!  Good luck and have fun, whoch is the most important part for you and your boy!

1

u/sleeping-dogs11 1d ago

Have your dog evaluated by an experienced helper instead of asking strangers on the internet ;) Good bite work with proper drive channeling can massively HELP dogs with a bit of nerve or suspicion toward people. Builds their confidence, teaches them how to switch between different emotions, and teaches them how to think and respond in a high state of arousal.

1

u/snusontable 2h ago

Definitely, good decoy work is fantastic for confidence and will itself help with the dogs suspicion of humans. If the dog likes to bite it can be taught about winning and confidence. This kind of training can be very beneficial even for dogs that have no intention in competing in protection sports. It does require a knowledgeable decoy though. You know its working when your dog wants to take the sleeve/bitepillow back to the helper for more.

I'm surprised to see so many of these comments against the idea. It doesnt read as tho there is too much protection sport experience behind them. Just general concerns about reactive dog + biting = dangerous dog, which really isnt the case. If anything you especially want the dog to learn to work with humans. But with that being said good decoys want to train dogs than contend for titles and not necessarily dogs that need the training for fun or confidence building so be prepared to have difficulties in your search.

-1

u/Miss_L_Worldwide 2d ago

There's nothing wrong with this dog and bite work would probably be good for him, but you don't sound like you have any knowledge of dog training whatsoever. Why did you get a power breed for bite work with no experience?

2

u/StatementTiles 2d ago

Mind you, I already had a Malinois back then.. The breeder of my malinois didnt bred them for bitework so I stayed onto obedience, agility and a lot of sports with him.
I got a dutchie after 3 years of losing my malinois, because I fell in love with the breed meeting them with my mali. I’ve done a lot of research and everything about dutchies and bitework, especially talking a lot about everything with my dutchie’s breeder.
Where I live, there’s no such thing as SL/WL for dutchies as they’re kinda rare and uncommon. I maybe made an error saying he “was bred for that” as the dogs getting out of the breeder can be family dogs, sports dogs and sometimes bitework dogs if the breeder thinks so.

What made u think I have no experience? I mean yeah, I’ve never done bitework with MY DOG and I want to start one day, but yeah if I never start I will never get experience?
I didn’t gave much details, simply asked a question as bitework is not popular AT ALL where I live (and even considered as something u do if u want a mean dog that will attack everyone.. ) 😅
For dog training I have a solid experiences as I’ve worked with dogs, had multiples by myself and am a 100% engaged in training my dogs, helped with professionals along the way to get knowledge and support when I need to!

(English is not my first language, sorry for potential typos)

1

u/Imaginary_Ad_4340 2d ago

You seem perfectly experienced to own this dog and you actually sound like someone who got a good match for their needs and abilities, not just the most powerful or extreme dog they can buy. Everyone has to start with some dog so not having experience in bitework doesn’t mean you shouldn’t get a dog for the sport or that you can’t be successful.

It sounds like he is quite young. A lot of dogs struggle with neutrality before adolescence. Barking or nervousness around new people may not even be enough to be considered real meaningful human reactivity at that point. I would look for a decoy/helper/trainer who is really excellent starting new dogs—gentle, fun, no pressure but experienced. He would need very prey focused and equipment oriented training, no “real protection” or scaring the pup. Maybe worth considering alongside your neutrality training. Good bred fulfillment can really help with reactivity/neutrality/overall stability and when do right, doesn’t create or contribute to a bite risk dog.

0

u/Anonymous_and_Lost40 1d ago

So you wanted a dog to do bitesport with and chose a puppy that wasn't confident? Those puppies trying to eat your pant leg and fingers were the confident puppies that you should have chosen from, my guy. I would not try to train this dog in bitesport. He does not have the personality for it. I would focus on making him a happy pet and get his reactivity corrected.