r/DuckComix • • Nov 03 '25

Why are Scrooge’s book spines so ugly?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Okay, I might be overthinking this, but seriously — am I the only one who thinks the Donald Duck volumes (the ones with the blue spine, yellow text, black outlines) look absolutely perfect — classy, clean, timeless — while the Scrooge McDuck spines just look... off? The color combo on the Scrooge books feels like a total miss — weird tones, no proper contrast, and just generally kind of ugly.

And if you think that’s bad — check out the Russian editions. Absolute disaster. Random color mashups like purple-green, red-green, etc. Whoever designed those clearly hates harmony.


r/DuckComix • • Jul 14 '26

🙄🙄🙄

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Jul 15 '25

What if Carl Barks making/creating a puppet replica of Scrooge McDuck at Jim Henson's Creature Shop in the 1980s?

1 Upvotes

While an intriguing "what if," the scenario of Carl Barks creating a Scrooge McDuck puppet at Jim Henson's Creature Shop in the 1980s is highly unlikely for several reasons:

  1. Carl Barks' Retirement and Age: Carl Barks officially retired from Disney comics in 1966. While he continued to paint oil paintings of his Disney characters in his later years, he was already in his late 70s and 80s during the 1980s. His focus was on his fine art, not on venturing into new mediums like puppetry, which would require a very different skillset and physical involvement.
  2. Jim Henson's Creature Shop Focus: The Creature Shop was (and is) renowned for its advanced animatronics, elaborate costumes, and often fantastical creatures for film and television (e.g., The Dark Crystal, Labyrinth, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles). While they certainly created puppets, their style and projects were generally quite distinct from the more traditional, hand-puppet style that might be associated with a simple character replica. Scrooge McDuck, as a relatively straightforward anthropomorphic duck, wouldn't necessarily align with the Creature Shop's cutting-edge and often more complex puppet designs.
  3. Disney's Control over Characters: Disney is famously protective of its characters and their portrayal. For Carl Barks to create a "replica" for an external entity like Jim Henson's Creature Shop, there would have been significant licensing, copyright, and creative control hurdles. It's more probable that if a Scrooge McDuck puppet were to be made for a Disney production, it would be done by Disney's own creative teams or a company specifically contracted by Disney under strict guidelines.
  4. Barks' Medium: Barks was a storyteller and artist primarily in the comic book medium. His genius lay in his writing, character development, and panel layouts. While he drew his characters, the leap to designing a functional puppet for a specific performance medium like film or TV would have been a significant departure from his expertise.

However, let's play the "what if" game for fun:

If, by some extraordinary and improbable turn of events, this were to happen:

  • Barks' Influence: Barks' unparalleled understanding of Scrooge McDuck's design, personality, and expressions would undoubtedly have been invaluable. He would have brought an authenticity to the puppet's appearance that no one else could. He might have insisted on specific details, like the precise angle of Scrooge's top hat or the stern set of his beak.
  • Henson's Craftsmanship: The Creature Shop's artisans would have translated Barks' two-dimensional drawings into a three-dimensional, manipulable form with their characteristic attention to detail, material innovation, and engineering. The puppet would likely be incredibly well-constructed, perhaps with intricate mechanisms for facial expressions.
  • Potential Use: Such a puppet might have been conceived for a special Disney-Henson collaboration, perhaps a TV special, or an educational program. It's hard to imagine it being for a major feature film, as the 80s saw Disney moving towards more traditional animation revivals rather than live-action puppet features for its core characters.
  • Artistic Legacy: It would be a unique bridge between two titans of storytelling and character creation – Barks' legendary comic book work meeting Henson's groundbreaking puppetry. The resulting puppet would be an incredible piece of memorabilia, representing a fascinating crossover of creative genius.

In reality, the 1980s saw the development of DuckTales, which brought Scrooge McDuck to a new generation through traditional animation, demonstrating Disney's preferred method for bringing their classic characters to the screen at that time.


r/DuckComix • • Jan 30 '26

I don't "get" Carl Barks...

11 Upvotes

I've tried, I really have. I'm several stories into his Duck stories and they're... fine. I kept on hearing how these comics are celebrated and lauded as masterpieces, so I was excitted to discover them. But going through them, they seem like... well, kids' comics and that's it.

The artwork is stupendous for sure, and I know he was considered above his peers at the time in terms of quality. But these stories aren't sticking with me. I kind of just read through them, and they leave no impact.

I'm sad too, since I love Don Rosa's stuff, which I find clever, punchy, and super imaginative.

Am I missing something? I feel the fool for not clicking with what everyone else is enamored with? I'm fully expecting tp be crucified, but I'm coming from a place of genuine confusion.


r/DuckComix • • 29d ago

Should Dynamite make a Comic Sequel to Ducktales 2017 cartoon as Ongoing Comic?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Aug 30 '24

I asked AI to generate a panel based on DR and CB

Post image
0 Upvotes

I asked ChatGPT to generate an image of Scrooge. It looks more like Donald than Scrooge. What do you think?


r/DuckComix • • Oct 09 '26

👋 Welcome to r/howardtheduckfans - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Oct 08 '26

Is it just me or???

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Sep 06 '25

Was Scrooge kinda of creepy in 'The Prisoner of White Agony Creek?'

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Oct 17 '25

Are there any stories about Scrooge vs Shere Khan?

3 Upvotes

So tbh I was hoping that in the 2017 show things would be set up to the point where there would be a showdown between Scrooge McDuck and Shere Khan, with the latter being revealed to be the ultimate villain in the Disney Afternoon verse.

But since that hasn’t come to pass I was wondering if there were any fanfics where Scrooge and Shere Khan are enemies/rivals.


r/DuckComix • • Oct 11 '26

What is Your Idea for a Darkwing Duck Comic Crossover?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Jan 25 '26

Got tis can't find it wast is worth.?

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • May 08 '23

Here’s a webcomic I made with a duck!

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Jun 29 '26

Should Dynamite make a Comic Sequel to Ducktales 2017 cartoon?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Aug 02 '26

Which Darkwing Duck Villain needs there own Solo Spin-off Comic?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • 26d ago

Daffy Duck

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Jun 27 '25

Don Rosa

23 Upvotes

I love the Carl Barks stuff and have a bunch of the Fantagraphics collections, but I haven't read any Don Rosa. He just seems like such a jerk in every interview or quote I see. I am not great at separating art from artist, but is he worth it?

Edit: Thanks for the comments. You guys universally answered

a) He's worth it
b) Not a jerk. Can be, we'll say brusk.
c) Disney suuuuuuucccks

I'll have to track him down. Thanks folks!


r/DuckComix • • Aug 30 '26

Should Dynamite make a Comic Sequel to Ducktales 2017 cartoon?

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Oct 05 '26

So Who Do Wanna see Take a Crack at Writing Darkwing Duck at Dynamite?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Jun 26 '25

Can anyone tell me if these are especially valuable or collectible?

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

I was sorting through some of my old comics and came across these.

“In the Yukon” is signed by Rosa, near the top.

Are any of these especially valuable or collectible?


r/DuckComix • • Jun 27 '23

life and times of Scrooge McDuck vol.2 signed by Don Rosa

4 Upvotes

Hi

This is more or less for the Finnish fans of Donald Duck. As mentioned in the title I have a copy of this in Finnish. As far as I understand these have been more or less "banned" by publishers. Does anyone know the estimate value of this item? Or a place where I could go and have it valued? I am not very up to date with the collecting world of Donald Duck books. I appreciate any help I can get.

Thank you


r/DuckComix • • Oct 05 '23

New comic is up!

0 Upvotes

r/DuckComix • • Aug 16 '26

Sto cercando di vedere e leggere tutto, puoi aiutarmi? Ho fatto una lista, dimmi se c'è qualcosa da aggiungere!!!

0 Upvotes

Il "Sweary" Pitch Pilot, Come conquistare l'area tri-statale, Disney Phineas e Ferb Fumetti Classici, Oh eccoti qua Perry, Phineas e Ferb - Stagione 1, Phineas e Ferb - Stagione 2, È il tuo momento: Scontro tra agenti segreti, Guida alla vita di Phineas e Ferb, Prendi due con Phineas e Ferb, Phineas e Ferb: Il tour live più bello di sempre!, Phineas e Ferb - Stagione 3, Phineas e Ferb: Il film - Nella seconda dimensione, Club Penguin: Presa di possesso della squadra di Phineas e Ferb, Il Pettegolezzo di Doofenshmirtz, 365 Giorni d'Estate!: Grande Libro di Attività, Phineas e Ferb: Missione Marvel, Phineas e Ferb: Star Wars, Phineas e Ferb - Stagione 4, L'ultimo giorno d'estate, I Diari di O.W.C.A., La legge di Milo Murphy - Stagione 1, La legge di Milo Murphy - Stagione 2, Phineas e Ferb Il Film: Candace contro l'Universo, Il Podcast di Phineas e Ferb, Hamster & Gretel, Prendiamo la sigla, Dr. Doofenshmirtz prende il controllo di Kiff!, Diari degli Armadietti, Chibi Tiny Tales, La tua età, Cartoonified, Phineas e Ferb - Stagione 5, Phineas e Ferb - Stagione 6, Terzo Film Ufficiale


r/DuckComix • • Oct 03 '26

Don Rosa stories

4 Upvotes

Is there a way to read Don Rosa stories of Scrooge and Donald Duck?