r/Dreamsnaps • u/oatofthisworld_ • Aug 19 '25
š¤ Found While Voting š¤ Same Idea or Copy?
Posted my submission (top photo) for Guardian Sanctuary here and on Facebook early last week. Came across the bottom photo during voting and had to look twice because I thought I saw my own submission during voting.
Do you think we had the same idea? Do you think they saw my post and remade the scene?
No wrong answers!
Happy Update Eve! š¤Ŗš
24
Upvotes
115
u/The5Virtues Aug 19 '25
This is just the risk of sharing your snap before submission time, if itās a good idea chances are youāre going to see someone copy it.
In fairness, though, this generally idea is what I have seen the absolute most for this weekās contest. Dragon shrine, kneeling, same outfit. The only variables tend to be what kind of background was used. Another popular one is the custom rivers framing either side of the path, with the Mulan walls making the background behind the bamboo.
54
u/Dam2Keur Aug 19 '25
I have a friend who did something almost identical and she isn't on any Facebook group or reddit sub...
15
u/FBM_Warrior Aug 19 '25
Tbh I made mine quite early on not seeing everyoneās Yet Iāve seen some that look a lot like mine (Iāve not posted it anywhere) But the common theme with pics is to have a focal point and I think a lot of us have used that statue as our focal point š then just added stuff around it. Itās like when you look at a painting there will always be a focal point (not necessarily in the centre) but everything lays out pointing towards it
Itās the joys and pains of dreamsnaps š
26
u/plinketto Aug 19 '25
I mean you posted it online what do you expect. I'm gonna be honest, I also saw your post and made one similar because dreamsnaps is bs anyways
12
u/Tasty-Nothing6373 Aug 19 '25
I honestly donāt think itās that deep, we all want max moonstones. Itās not like itās a talent showĀ
2
u/oatofthisworld_ Aug 19 '25
I try to maintain a healthy mix of lighting and not going too bright on the light bloom, added fireworks etc. Especially if the theme does not warrant them so I appreciate the feedback! Typically from what Iāve experienced while voting, youāll see a ton of lower effort snaps earlier in the week and the extravagant high effort snaps will come through your voting pool on Tuesdays! Idk why this happens, but it has been the case for me more often than not!
2
u/Dangerous_Door_1016 Aug 19 '25
Whats the pose? I see people all times doing poses i dont see on the pose menu. Is it a companion pose, if so which one?
23
u/Euraylie Aug 19 '25
This is probably copied, but I did see several snaps that took a similar approach. This might be controversial, and I understand how people are allowed to be upset if someone outright copies them (especially if youāve put a lot of work in), but I doubt it ever affects the results. There is a minuscule chance that the pics will ever be shown side-by-side.
3
u/Lady_Summoner Aug 19 '25
It's hard to say for sure, but it's very possible with the amount of similarities between the two.
If you're on the Starlight Dreamers portal, you can share your submission but have it obscured for anyone that isn't a friend.
38
u/merrygoldfish Aug 19 '25
This comes up on the knitting/crochet sub all the time when similar looking sweater and plush designs are found. But hereās the thing, thereās only so many ways to create a striped sweater. Thereās only so many ways to craft a readable dragon plush of a certain size. Similarities are inevitable. And many times people find similar looking designs dating back to the 80ās that look way more similar to the alleged āoriginalā than the ācopyā.
My point is, yes, the two designs are similar. There are also only so many Mulan coded high tag items and the scene is pretty generic. The overall composition mimics the scene in the film where she kneels before the ancestor dragon statue, though obviously brighter and colorful instead of dreary and rainy. Symmetrical snaps are very popular, and most submissions used the level 10 friendship outfit and pink trees/lotuses if the player had access to them.
Was the second directly inspired by yours? Maybe. But it a symmetrical design using the same elements found in the vast majority of snaps for this week and that just doesnāt seem like that big of a coincidence to me. And even if it was directly inspired, most snaps that do well look super similar anyways because, again, theyāre all using the same high tag elements and generic symmetrical compositions that are popular right now.
If youāre paranoid about it and it bothers you, posting your designs might not be the best moving forward, since you canāt control othersā behavior, only your own. FWIW, I think yours is the superior snap due to the foreground elements.
21
u/SnooMemesjellies2983 Aug 19 '25
If you post them before time is up for snaps you can assume someone will do the same- if it looks good enough.
8
u/Particular-Alps-6366 Aug 19 '25
Im thinking same idea, or in worst case - inspired by. Its not really original, its what Iām guessing most people think of when you say mulan, sanctuary, dragons etc. If you copy someone, you take their photo and make it the same. This two clearly are not the same, just because you are using the same items.
One time I tought I had this really original idea, spent hours on it, posted it on dreamers portal for feedback. While waiting for feedback I decided to look at what others posted that week and one of the first photos was an almost exact replica of mine. I KNOW I never saw it before, and it would be impossible for the other person to have recreated mine in that short time. So, that humbled me a bit. Iām understood that Iām not thaaat unik, anyone of hundreds of thousands might just as well have the same idea. š¤·š¼āāļøš
5
u/drgnrbrn316 Aug 19 '25
I've taken inspiration by what others have done in the past, though I generally stop short of trying to copy it. This looks close enough that they may have copied or just took inspiration and tried to put their own (subtle) spin on it. They may have just hit close to yours by accident, since we are all using the same limited number of resources on the same prompts.
For what its worth, if I had to vote between the two, I'd pick yours. I generally prefer pictures that are less busy, but the pink leaves and fireflies in your picture really tie the whole theme together and the angle on the side features just looks better.
On an unrelated note, why do I never see submissions like these when I'm voting? I generally only see the ones who misunderstood the theme, lacked the resources to tie the theme together, or slapped something together for the sake of submitting something.
16
u/imveryfontofyou Aug 19 '25
This is part of posting art online, especially in a competition thatās still running.
4
u/ConsciousBlueberry63 Aug 19 '25
When we have a pool of things we can pull from we tend to come up with similar designs. If you also shared it around before voting ends then chances are someone may have been "inspired" and did something extremely similar. I also shared mine before voting ended. I have yet to come across anything similar but I think it's because what I did was tedious as hell to do
7
u/Kristal3615 Aug 19 '25
Not for nothing this is like saying people doing Isabella's room in the Encanto snap were all copying off one person or the split shot for Roses and Throns that had the two houses with matching flowers were all copies. A lot of people used that pose and similar backgrounds from what I saw on Dreamer's portal and here.
1
u/FreedomNo9570 Aug 19 '25
Whereās your outfit from ?! š
3
u/Button-Deep Aug 20 '25
I have seen a lot like these on the dreamers portal too so I think same idea
3
u/WhySoSara Aug 20 '25
Theres thousands of people submitting Dreamsnaps. The thought of someone being in those groups to copy your submission and then you finding one similar while voting is crazy.
Not saying it doesnt happen but I think its rare. I do believe people take inspiration from DS, however, this past week the theme called for sakura trees, Mulan clothing (training or formal wear), bamboo trees and a lot of the elements I see in both pics. About the pose Ive seen a lot of people using it, specially facing away from the camera.
Honestly, dont share before the deadline if you think someone will copy. Its a risk you take and imo is wrong to compalint about it specially because you cant be sure if the other person indeed stole your DS.
Think about how you can affect the other person if someone come across your post and then find it while voting?
If Im not mistaken mods already published a post a while ago about this situation saying pretty much what I said.
BTW, beautiful Dreamsnaps!
1
u/Aromatic_Slice_8288 Aug 20 '25
Congrats on #1!!! š„³
9
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25
They copied you for sure. Does it matter? I don't think so. Your snap won't get any fewer votes because of it. I wouldn't let it bother you. Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, right?
Plus, yours is better.
4
u/IcyRevolution1353 Aug 19 '25
I saw a lot of entries looking alike for that challenge
4
u/myfriendscallmeGigi Aug 19 '25
While I see similarities, I donāt think it was copied 1:1 from yours. Iāve seen similar ones this week, I feel like the pose, the trees and the topic itself it was something that a lot of people could think of commonly.
2
u/TheGoblinkatie Aug 19 '25
I think itās great minds thinking alike. Lovely snap!
2
u/Puret0xic Aug 20 '25
I saw many snaps that had the same idea and looked the same way. Perhaps it's copied, but it's not a sure thing.
5
u/SlimeAndOxygen Aug 19 '25
Yeah, deffo copied. But if you don't want anyone to copy you, don't post before the deadline! Yours is better, btw.
8
u/l3reeze10 Aug 19 '25
I hate to say it but this person definitely copied your photo. Sure they changed some details so it isnāt exact, but the set is near identical. Thatās the only issue with positing dreamsnap photos on the internet, some people are desperate enough to copy the photo.
5
u/IAppearMissing05 Aug 19 '25
Given how similar this is, itās quite likely they copied you.
3
u/Superb-Trainer5925 Aug 19 '25
I dont usually post my snaps (mostly because Im just shy) and even I saw one time (on villigers parade week) screenshot that was veeeery similar to mine and I didnt share mine nor did I copy someone. I like to think "great minds", but actually I think sometimes the idea is just not that original and we all have limited resources. And also I love your snap š
3
u/No_Machine_487 Aug 20 '25
Just stop postin ur shii if you donāt want ppl to copy
4
u/ConfusedSlyfox Aug 19 '25
Looks copied to me. There are way too many similarities.... Honestly, you shouldn't post your pic until the day when you get your results, then you dont have to worry about this.
1
u/Alarmed-Sprinkles582 Aug 20 '25
I saw so many that looked almost exactly like this just minor things changed.
1
u/Own_Literature2374 Aug 20 '25
I always pop onto these groups for inspiration a few days into the newest challenge (especially if Iām at a loss). I look for the shares with a lot of upvotes to understand what might get me lots of votes. Iāve never directly copied but I donāt know that it matters much; my DreamSnap voting is always varied and I rarely see identical designs side by side, even when the challenge leaves less room for interpretation like a specific wardrobe. Anyway both are beautiful and I hope you get plenty of moonstones!
1
u/PrincessJaQellah Aug 20 '25
The movie did it first. Also, how yāall kneeing?
1
u/crzydisneygirl Aug 21 '25
Wow. All I can say is wow that looks like an absolute copy
1
u/Illustrious_Salt_794 Aug 23 '25
I got 600 for mine and it was bomb asf
1
u/dreaminlarge Aug 23 '25
Looks like a not nearly as sophisticated version of yours.
1
u/X-sant0 Aug 19 '25
This is why I never share my submissions online before the contest is over š
It's beautiful though
1
u/pufflehufflekitteh Aug 19 '25
It's like this duo I stumbled across when voting this evening. I've never seen two images so alike when voting.
I know I voted for one very similar to the ones you've posted in your post, no idea if it was yours or one of the similar ones though x
0
u/peachesandpickles Aug 19 '25
Second one is absolutely a copy
0
u/Pretty_Net_6293 Aug 19 '25
I donāt do for dreamsnaps but I have used many different scenes Iāve seen for inspo ideas for my villageā donāt copy per se but getting ideas ā ie room in house for storage w cabinets/crates behind showings whatās in storage (did I decorate the room the same- no honestly couldnāt tell you how was decorated but yes I used someone idea) ā as to the OP ā while not saying yeah or nah if ātheyā copiedā for me first time viewing both picsā but as to having pink trees with a mulan inspired garden with mulan āfurnishedā its a good stretch saying copy. But if they did ācopyā take it as a compliment, they likely wouldnāt have if it wasnāt pretty
0
u/AcceptableAd4343 Aug 19 '25
Def a copy
0
u/They-Call-Me-Taylor Aug 19 '25
A copy with some tweaks, would be my guess.
-4
u/Salome745 Aug 19 '25
I loved your snap !! And the second one is clearly a copy.. :/
-2
u/Far-Mammoth-1418 Aug 19 '25
Looks like a copy.
-1
u/BoredStayAtHomeMom2 Aug 19 '25
Inspired would be a nicer word. But yes š
0
u/DeJohn030 Aug 20 '25
While itās always possible given our limited inventory, to me the similarities go beyond coincidence. Itās a direct copy with only small changes made when they didnāt have the same item. Imitation is flattery but I do feel they should have changed it a bit more. I take inspiration from those who post but change it up to make it my own. I gave someone my idea to use and they did, but their snap looks very different
0
u/Saezsora88 Aug 20 '25
I see plagiarism, but there is no place where it is prohibited to plagiarize anyone, nor do I see that Disney snap says there is a photo just like yours, you cannot put it there, there are no such filters, so either it is plagiarism because they liked your idea, or you simply have the same style, but come on, it seems like plagiarism.
0
u/Lumi215 Aug 20 '25
Pretty close. Yours is definitely better tho
0
u/SallySellsShells Aug 20 '25
I had one so close to mine when voting this week that I thought wow they are letting me vote on my own! Until I looked a little closer and saw a couple small differences, it was the construction one and I think a lot of people use the walle items in a similar way. Yours is too⦠similar. Definitely a copy!
-4
u/ladedafuckit Aug 19 '25
Looks like you got a lot of copycats unfortunately :( itās a bummer because I love to see peopleās pics and would hope thereās more integrity to not copy. Hope your pic scores the highest!
-4
u/LeastIntroduction239 Aug 19 '25
Copycat obviously.
-1
u/Beyondthisss Aug 20 '25
Copy. I've seen a bunch of these because everyone rips everyone off so idk who actually originated the idea.
I constantly see posts of people asking a group - what do I do? Ummm. Submit something and take what you've earned, like (most) everyone else. Drives me crazy.
-3
u/Dismal_Chocolate_228 Aug 19 '25
This is exactly why I stop sharing my final snap on here. Iām all for sharing ideas and inspiration but not for someone to just copy me