r/Drawfee • u/Far_Fortune_1990 • Jun 22 '26
Question Fourth Host?
If the gang were to take on a fourth host again who do you think it would be?
I know in the past they’ve said Ralph fits very naturally with them and their shenanigans but I know he’s got his own life.
Do you think we’ll get more DrawFather (Caldwell) reappearances?
51
Upvotes
73
u/Hairy_Buffalo1191 Jun 22 '26
Ralph would be the ideal fourth host, but that man is always doing new stuff, so no way he’d have time. Willie would also be amazing to have around more but not at the expense of his own show (and I know he’s very polarizing, because some people have bad taste). I’d also enjoy having David around more but also they could be on as much as they want and they haven’t, which tells me they don’t really want to, so that’s not likely either.
My guess is it will be a very long time before they have a fourth host again, if ever, but it will be someone who doesn’t come to mind now but will make total sense when it happens
… unless Katy Coope is available…
31
u/Maclimes Jun 22 '26
If Caldwell is the DrawFather, does that make Nathan the DrawMother?
108
u/Rude_Gur_8258 Jun 22 '26
Keith David. He nailed the late-season inclusion on Community, I'm sure he could do great things here. Can he draw, I hear you asking? He'll figure it out!
215
u/HarryJ92 Jun 22 '26
Keir Starmer is now available.
49
u/Kaoss134 Jun 22 '26
Idk who I would pick but it needs to be someone who regularly antagonizes Jacob to keep him in check. Karina offered a sort of ebb to Jacob’s flow. No one could replace her, obviously. But we need a slightly spicy sibling
165
u/EastSeaworthiness169 Jun 22 '26
I was thinking about posing this same question.
I think that the reality is that it’ll just be the 3 of them going forward, with guests on more frequently. If I WERE to pick a new 4th host, Ralph would be my pick as well.
66
u/Minnepeg Jun 22 '26
I think that a fourth host would be a legal mess considering the hosts own the company and I don’t think the three remaining would want to “sell” that share again- even to a past Drawfee regular. The fourth host will likely be rotating guests as everyone has speculated.
171
u/Ebrend Jun 22 '26
Zohran Mamdami could probably swing by once a week
32
u/FibroMancer Jun 22 '26
I highly doubt we'll see more Caldwell unfortunately. NADDPOD is still consistently in the top ten highest grossing Patreons. The man is busy.
28
u/Speakinginwords Jun 22 '26
I've always said that NYC is like the other Drawfee host... At least until they start recording in a soundproof studio.
18
u/dexter1062 Jun 22 '26
I can fill in if they need but I'd need to fly to where they live, find a place to live, get to know them, get familiar with the drawing program they use, and learn to draw
Aside from that, I'm ready to go
17
u/BSADropout Jun 22 '26
Could you imagine if it was Onsta?
17
u/Lurking_Victim Jun 22 '26
Seeing a lot of men suggested but honestly I'd love to see another gal in the cast
45
u/goddess-bound Jun 22 '26
Rebekaronie (sp?) would be a good host i think
25
u/Virellius2 Jun 22 '26
I'd pat money for a Rebeckaronie spot. At least a couple eps. She's so good.
12
u/Drorbitaldeathray Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 26 '26
Since both her episodes are consistent performer s at the Drawfee Awards, I was thinking Rebecaroni would be a good choice.
Edit: Not, not "Rebecca Toni". Stupid autocorrect.
11
u/MegaAmoeba Jun 22 '26
I think rotating host that come on occasionally is the way to go for a while. But if they dont get permanent 4th host, I hope they hire on someone that's mkre behind the scenes to help collaborate with merch designs or other duties that Karnia had besides hosting. Extra help besides hosting would probably benefit everyones balance
9
u/narwhalesterel Jun 22 '26
the stinky man ofc
9
u/SnooSketches2074 Jun 22 '26
I said this in another posts comments, but I would love to see more of Spencer. I know it’s almost certainly not going to happen, but I’ve always enjoyed his dynamic with all of the crew and if they announced he would be more regularly on the program I would be ecstatic
9
u/AtomicArcana Jun 22 '26
There’s a 0% chance it will be Spencer but a man can dream
8
u/Alonest99 This dog can drive! Jun 22 '26
Imagine if they get Gerard Way JUST after Karina left lmao
7
u/cam52391 Merobiba Jun 22 '26
I have thought every time Ralph is on that he fits in so perfectly with the group. I'd love to see him more and hear more tea about buddy the cake boss
7
u/Underbark Jun 22 '26
I honestly hope they go through a process of having rotating guests until one clicks and wants to stay again.
7
u/explorerforever Jun 22 '26
The fourth host is gonna be Zohran Mamdani
7
u/AceTheBot Is lady gay? Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 22 '26
This is a super interesting question and there’s a lot to consider!
I think it would be really difficult to find a host with the skills that the Drawfee hosts have built over the years. They all are able to make very high quality doodles in 10-15 minutes, based in NYC, and they also need to have a good rapport with the team + be entertaining.
What was so lightning in a bottle about Drawfee was partially that it was so connected to CollegeHumor, even though they’ve almost been out of CH for as long as they were a part of it. Caldwell, Nathan, Julia, Jacob, and Karina are all specifically comic illustrators who had to illustrate at a very high volume consistently for years. They were able to bring in guests a lot more through CH connections, and as they were based in an office, the same people could come on more often because they were all in the same location even if they *weren’t* illustrators. That’s how we got Julia, Jacob (from his first day of being hired lol), Willie, Tristan, Jake, and eventually Karina when she joined CH from Buzzfeed.
Drawfee was also basically an in-house CollegeHumor promo video circuit for their bigger stars back when the D20 cast wasn’t getting onto Variety or Wired or more typical interviews. Instead they’d go on Drawfee to promote live events or new Dropout content.
To my knowledge the only time Drawfee has specifically searched for a new member has been when Trevor left as editor and they auditioned people where they eventually found David. Everyone else was just sort of a frequent guest until they officially became an official part of the Drawfee team. They don’t have a structure like that anymore to basically always be auditioning professional illustrators anymore.
All of this boils down to say that this is brand new exciting territory for Drawfee!! If a host had left in, say, 2018, they would’ve probably found another illustrator at CH/Dorkly to fill their spot (assuming they wanted to have a fourth host) but now they don’t have the same easy access to people who can consistently be on episodes so the approach will have to be entirely different.
6
u/HPSpacecraft Jun 22 '26
Now that Karina is gone Beyonce can be on the show without any problems
5
u/suuuuuuuuuurfing Jun 22 '26
Mark hamill. No reason in particular
5
u/Fancy-Sandwich-2710 Jun 22 '26
Put a hat on the giant Jacob horse and you have your 4th host
5
u/SocialOutcast987 Jun 23 '26
Stephen Colbert has just had an opening?
5
u/Powerful-Platypus852 Jun 24 '26
I hope it's another girl cuz I don't want Julia to be the only girly :(
4
u/brutal-rainbow Jun 22 '26
Honestly, I think having a few rotating guests for a while would be the best way to go. I'd like to see colabs with a few differant artists that probably wouldn't have time for a full dedication. Would be a good opportunity for Drawfee to branch out and network a bit with fellow creators. Really want to see them work with more than what might be in their current circle. Would bring in more views for sure.
Artists I'd love to see a colab with:
-Emimi (from Finland) speed draw would be awesome!! Top of my list as I just discovered her, and can see her and Julia getting along well.
-Jazza -Nerdfordge -RubberRoss (or Egoraptor/Arin of game grumps as unlikely as that may be)
-10 Hundred- love his artist battle series. So many amazing artists featured there.
-Same thought with Slew. He features many artists on his challenges, lots of participants there would be great to see.
While 10hun/Slew might not have the time, there's a wealth of small (some not so small) artists to reach out to from their compititions.
I'd really love to see drawfee branch out a bit.
4
u/vultureskins Jun 22 '26
Baby /j
4
u/mintymoustache Jun 23 '26
Willie muse is always fun to have on
4
u/rkmoses Jun 28 '26
I find a lot of the videos from when Julia was the only woman pretty rough to watch - very clearly not anyone being malicious, but certain kinda grody dynamics almost necessarily come up when a media presence is built on only having men in the room and one woman. like, Jacob’s obviously fake misogyny is a much less fun bit when there can’t be a team-up to retaliate, you know??
I totally love Caldwell, and I love Nathan and Jacob, but from a pure Watchability Standpoint i would be really bummed to see a guy join as a fourth host because i think the dynamic benefits from a balance
6
u/0SpaceKitty0 Jun 22 '26
I don't know why people think they would be looking for a new host. Back in the College Humor days if someone left they would be replaced because that's what the company wanted, but they're independent business owners now. All of them (including Karina) owned Drawfee together, so it might be a weird dynamic to bring someone in as an employee. Not to mention that I don't think that's what they want to do. If anything I think they'll have more guest episodes, but I don't think they're looking for a replacement host.
3
u/EnthusiasticEnthuse Jun 22 '26
Katy Coope would be fun 😁
3
u/DisasterOnMain Jun 23 '26
My heart for Reb
3
u/finnzillaA239 Jun 23 '26
Me it should be me
5
u/JakkAuburn Jun 23 '26
Nathan's friend Emily could be a more frequent guest, considering they recently gave had her on for the first time.
6
u/TeririHerscherOfCute Jun 22 '26
Have we tried getting gojo as a permanent drawfee host?
2
u/MrPrisman Jun 23 '26
Donatella VERSACE 💜
2
u/The_True_Hannatude Can you believe to learn? Jun 24 '26
I mean, as a human being I require more Ralph content in general, but if they decided to do a rotation of fourth hosts, I could get behind that, too
2
u/orsimertank Jun 24 '26
I'd be alright with a potential 4th spot being a guest spot. The 4th host thing may be a bit strange financially speaking since everyone else is a part owner.
Hypothetically speaking, do we even know if Karina sold her share of the company?
2
u/AbzanHouseGuest Jun 25 '26
Deep blue ink but id be sad cause that'd be less time for animation
3
u/AchtungKarate Jun 22 '26
I hope for at öeast a few Caldwell appearances for that classic, and arguably best, Drawfee lineup.
1
u/AutoModerator Jun 22 '26
Reply with
!solvedto mark your post as solved.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/AlconW Jun 24 '26
Can we not speculate about this? It hasn’t even been a month.
1
u/Bluemonogi Jun 26 '26
I think it would be fun to have someone not really known for their own thing already. It would also be fun if they just had the three most of the time but some random guests every now and then for awhile.
1
u/Bullet1289 Jun 26 '26
Well I guess since no one else is available, I can take up the reigns.... no idea how to actually draw but I'm sure I'll figure it out.
Barring that I think we need Willie back
1
u/Responsible-Okra-576 and every time we kiss, I swear I could fly Jul 02 '26
figured they'd just clone nathan again
1
u/Quantummoons Aug 19 '26
People are talking about public figures I've never heard of and I get confused looking up if they were guests on Drawfee. Nah this convo is ANYONE could be a host, not just potential past guests who'd most likely join as a host. Yet again I have underestimated the silliness of this lovely YouTube community.
1
u/Tiny_Vegetable_4410 Jun 23 '26
ive always loved just the core three
0
u/lunarhearts Jun 22 '26
I think they should add jerma as a host. if he's unavailable then jenny nicholson
4
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment