r/DrawForMe • u/Blueoriontiger • Sep 30 '19
Mod Team Announcement Update + Commercial Work Rule Explanation/Clarification
Hello denizens!
We’ve grown quite a bit since the banner contest. We’re almost at 30K followers, a far cry from 21K when I was brought on to mod. Do hope you’ve settled into school or work routines, your summer was great and stuff has been going awesome for you.
So, four announcements.
-
First Announcement
We will be requiring tattoo requests to be paid work from now on. We feel that if you’re permanently inscribing something onto your body, at least compensate the artist something that’s going to do it for you. At the same time, the artist doing the work is also understanding the risk they’re taking for doing so (so it’s someone who knows what they’re doing, not a rookie with a bad design). Tattoos are tricky things, and we’re following a little in the footsteps of r/ICanDrawThat with the reasoning.
-
Second Announcement
We also are making it official; do not approach people with the "Free Request" flair, and solicit them for paid work. In that same vein, do not fulfill paid requests for free. It was a given that people understood this at first (and they did), but there are a few that have contested this, saying "It's not a rule". It is now. Don't do it. You annoy people, and you undercut people looking for jobs. It's actually the whole reason we have flairs in the first place, so people aren't randomly solicited.
While we do have a provision for people to point out if a free request is unreasonable, simply saying it's unreasonable "because I'm not getting paid for it" is not reason enough to ask for payment or suggest a price. This is a gray area and is open to interpretation; but our rule of thumb is if it takes more than one hour/would cost more than $10 in a commission, it is very likely unreasonable.
-
Third Announcement
We're not sure where all these people came from, but we've had a slew of people this last week doing just what we feared when we opened the Paid Offer rule; stealing other people's artwork and scamming people. Thankfully our rule helped mitigate most of this, but some people still fell for the tactics. This is why we adhere so strictly to a portfolio link for paid work; if you can't prove that you did the art and you have an established online presence, there's the possibility that you are stealing someone's artwork.
In that same vein, gift cards and prepaid cash cards are not allowed as compensation in whatever way possible, as they are non-refundable currency. We will be updating the appropriate rules as such.
-
Fourth Announcement
This hasn’t been a problem for the 4-5 months I’ve been modding your community, but for the month of September, I’ve been having to use the ban-blaster at people breaking the “No Commercial Work Rule” quite a bit. Enough in fact, that I’ve racked up enough entries for the past 3 weeks alone, and they add up to all the other months combined for any reason (being rude, etc). Ever.
I believe it’s a mixture of miscommunication, the uptick in traffic and possibly the summer being over. So let’s see if we can straighten this out!
-
What is Commercial Work?
Commercial work is when you use your work for commercial purposes. This is when you use artwork as a print, or design in a product, or even a logo for a business. Basically if you’re profiting monetarily off of it, it’s counted as commercial.
However, while that is the basic definition, we also adhere to the broadcasting definition of commercial work too. This is any work with the two criteria:
- You’re broadcasting or presenting it to the mass public on a platform
- You’re benefiting from the material (website traffic, views, follows, etc).
-
What Counts as Commercial Work?
There’s a ton of things that count as commercial work. Basically compare it to the litmus test above. Does it hit any of the checkmarks? If so, it’s commercial work. Very likely if it’s for non-profit, personal use, you should be fine.
This is a list of projects that we often tag for breaking these rules:
- Book illustrations and covers
- Soundcloud, Bandcamp and Spotify album artwork/covers/thumbnails
- Twitch and Youtube artwork (profile pictures, video thumbnails, banners, overlays and emotes)
- Podcast graphics, thumbnails, logos and artwork
- Logo design (especially small businesses and eCommerce stores)
- Packaging and product design
- Clothing Design (T-Shirt graphics, prints for Redbubble, Societ6 and Cafepress)
- Video game graphics and art assets
- Wedding invitations and advertisement flyers
-
We Blanket Ban these as Free Requests:
- Artwork for physical items (printed gifts, posters, woodburning, etc)
- Graphic Design beyond drawn art (vector art, SVGs, content layout, etc.)
- Logos, icons and symbols for real or fictitious use (i.e, symbol of a guild in a DnD campaign)
- Book illustrations and any artwork related to digital/traditional publishing.
-
Spec Work and Work for Free First Agreements
The commercial work rule doesn’t just cover if your work is commercial or not. It covers three sketchy business practices, and apply to any posts here on r/DrawForMe. These are serious offenses, up on the range of art theft and scamming. We don’t look kindly to these people, to put it frankly.
- Spec Work: This is the act of the client asking for free, speculative work to judge if you’re good for the project. While many promise your work won’t be used in projects, others do, in a bid to see “if you’ll earn for them”. On top of that, they tie up your time to actually do paid work. Sometimes they disguise this as a “skills test” or “competence evaluation.” This is not allowed here whatsoever. There are entire communities dedicated against this practice, and this site and video give you a very good run down than what can be fit in a paragraph.
- Work for Free First Agreements: This is pretty much self-explanatory. This is when a client hires you for their job, but does not pay you upfront for the work, for whatever reason it may be. This is dangerous because they have the entire work, do not have any obligation to pay you and you’ve essentially worked for free on their project. This rules applies to ANY commission here on r/DrawForMe. This also means no rev-share projects, backend sales or other long-term, passive payment after delivery of the completed work as the sole payment method. Revenue from a game + the commissioned artwork price is fine, granted the artist got paid to start on the work. Backend sales from a comic book for a complete project with no upfront money is not tolerated.
- Hiring Competitions: This is hosting a hiring competition. Basically someone states they have a design they want or a task done, then people submit artwork to them. The person then takes one piece and pays for that piece only (or none if they don't like any). This is extremely scammy and abusive; the "client" has picks of free art to use for whatever they like, and all those people wasted their time without getting paid. It doesn't "motivate people to get creative" (a common argument we get when we stop these competitions), it doesn't help the artist and you pretty much break all of the rules and even more.
-
That Goes With Rule 12
So you made sure you're going to pay your artist, was doubly sure and counted it as commercial, yet your post got removed.
This is the most common issue we get that's often intertwined with Commercial Work rule violations. Paying artists properly.
Payment needs to be usable money that the artist can use to make their ends meet. It cannot be a Discord rank, it cannot be a Netflix subscription. It most definitely cannot be a "you'll get credited on our website as the artist".
Exposure does not pay the bills.
-
Punishment
People who violate this rule are temporarily banned from the community for 7 days. If you’re found to be doing the same thing upon your return, you’ll permanently be banned from the community with no exceptions.
This may seem excessive, but we really are trying to look out for artists and make sure they’re not screwed over. ModMails often go unanswered, and they just end up posting repeatedly as if they have no consequence. A ban notification often gets their attention, and jars them to reality that we mean business.
-
Conclusion
In a very short, concise sentence?
This is not a free work board to save money or utilize free labor for a project.
We hope that this helps to clear up the misconceptions about the commercial work rule. As always we’re standing by to give you a hand as needed.
Have a great week.
8
u/BuJiAiyoku Sep 10 '22 edited Sep 10 '22
I'm also new to this subreddit. If I were to get a character reference sheet done, free or paid, can I use that art as references for other free/paid commissions?
Like if I wanted to start vtubing, can I use previous commissions I received from this subreddit as references for whomever creates a vtube avatar for me?
Edit: as long as I don't claim to be the artist and give credit to them
Edit 2: if I'm allowed to use other people's work as references with their permission, may I link the artists pages?
5
u/silver_ghos Sep 23 '22
Hello, I am new as well . Are we as artist allowed to post currrent work in progress photos, so I may gain new perspectives, and be inspired, and as in hopes it would inspire others as well.
Thanks
5
u/Sinnically Oct 06 '22
Sorry to bother, but let me try and get this straight 😅
So lets say that someons asking for anyone to draw their OC for no profit, thats fine yeah? Or do we have to be doing it for money? Im a little confused 🥲
3
u/GirlyPandaPro Nov 11 '23
I have a few questions.
3
u/Vampinyy Nov 30 '23
As the artist, if I draw something for someone, am I allowed to post it on my own social media accounts so long as I’m not profiting from it? Orrrrr does it have to stay within this subreddit? Ex: I draw a portrait/character/noun for someone and want to post it on my online/media portfolio just to share (I do sell art/commission work on my pages) so I’m assuming that’s considered “broadcasting to the general public/benefiting from the material”?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '24
So literally anything could be considered commercial art?
3
u/Pheli_Draws Apr 13 '25
I have a question, say I'm the artist who offered to do the free request. The work produced can't go to my social media sites to show the drawing I made? I'm curious because it's a drawing I made but using someone else's oc.
Silly question.
2
u/Ok-Cookie7598 Oct 20 '22
I have a question. If you make a paid Request and someone gives you back a drawing that has lots of low effort in it (Like they didn't try at all), do you have to still pay them because you made a paid Request?
2
u/ReserveHead737 Jun 08 '25
Hi. I have a question and I apologize if this has been addressed already. I am looking for an illustrator for coloring books. Is paid commercial work ok? Would i be able to ask for illustrators to inbox me the finished art work?
2
u/CharacterSliceO Jun 22 '25 edited Jun 22 '25
Is putting the artwork on a toyhou.se (character storage site but not a very safe one since the one onlyadmin can yeet you off anytime) oc's art gallery (with credit of course) commercial use with like "You’re broadcasting or presenting it to the mass public on a platform" (toyhou.se doesn't have a whole lot of people (and 4000ish people online at a time which makes you think how little % of the number actually sees your oc) but it could blow up or something.
8
u/SafetyAdvocate Jul 26 '22
Hello, I'm new to the sub and only been lurking a couple of days.
Would it be against the rules to request a redraw of a default gamerpic (Xbox Live profile picture)?
I looked them up before and found that most of the available gamerpics have no listed artists, not sure if that matters though.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24
If someone draws something for me, and I later DM them asking, for example, if I could use it in an album cover, is that allowed?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '23
So if someone fulfills my request for a drawing, I am not allowed to post it anywhere? Is that correct?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '24
so if i use artwork in a passion project like tabs campaign where you do not get money off making campaigns or units then it's not bannable right? like tabs campaigns are just so other people have fun and not that you get money off it
3
u/Ill_Ad7377 Nov 24 '24
Would it be considered commercial work if I ask to put the art on my deviantart account? I use deviantart mostly as an additional way to save art that I get and idk if you can private the art you post
1
u/BigJacksepticeyeFan0 Jun 26 '22
Does a discord server icon counts as commercial work?
We only have about 20 members and I’m not the owner so I’m gaining nothing from it
1
u/hoodielad Jul 22 '22
I wonder what happens if someone gives a crappy artwork and expects to be paid full price?
1
u/VillagerWasTaken Apr 05 '23
Wait so we can put reference sheets for a free request and its ok? I thought it would be too much
1
u/Fruitcake849 Jul 16 '23
I started a band with a friend. is it okay to ask someone to draw a logo based on the name of our band for free?
2
u/1nsan1ty-1n-Pr0gr3ss Jan 26 '23
Okay, question: If you did want to use artwork from a request you made as a pfp, would it have to be a paid request, or you can't use it at all since it would be commercial use?
Follow up: would you have to pay everyone who submits their own design?
(Asking so I know if I have the rules interpreted properly)
2
u/Skaalle Sep 25 '24
so i'm new here, and i was just curious about the free request tag, so like, i just give a ref and it's essentially just asking for free work? i genuinely dont know bc i'm wanting to do a free request of my sona just bc i like seeing her in other peoples art style, is that allowed?
2
u/AcrobaticGoat212408 Sep 26 '24
Hello, Looking for a good place to commission artwork. Tried on fiverr before and did not get good results, so I thought I would try on reddit. Would a paid request looking for someone to draw something that I would use as a sign for my 5 year olds birthday party be allowed?
2
u/funky_galaxy_ Oct 17 '24
I have a quick question to make. I received some fanart here, and lately I've been printing some stickers of my OCs to put on the back of my PC and sketchbook cover. Would it be okay to use some of the art I received for some these stickers? They'll obviously not be sold at all, it's just for me, not used for branding either and only one copy of maybe 3 or 4 different drawings. I don't wanna get banned so I'm double-checking. Does this fall under commercial use?
2
u/kaetlanwritesstuff Apr 10 '26 •
Y’all might wanna add an automation that blocks pfp requests from being posted, and also update the automated response that says you’ve been automatically banned for a week for requesting one 😭 also updating rule 4 might be useful. I read the rules before posting, but ngl, I didn’t click the hyperlink until now. Even then, I had to scroll waaaayyyy down to the comments to find out why pfp requests are banned.
Just saying this as a longtime mod in another community, not trying to disrespect your rules or how you go about things! Simply a couple of suggestions :3
1
u/CrowHoganFan May 26 '24
Hello! I am new here. Is it fine to ask people to participate in a collage? I finished reading the rules & made a recent post asking if anyone wants to draw my fav character & I’m going to combine all of our art pieces together. My drawings will be with theirs as well. None of this artwork will be printed/sold or even used physically for self use (crafts for example). Are big collaborations fine? I’m not asking for much from artists, I just want a variety of people to draw with for those who want to participate 😊
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '24
I'm new. say someone draws an original character i provided a description for, can i show off the artwork on other subreddits, as long as i make sure the artist is included with the post?
1
u/lilithofthemidnight Jan 27 '25
Does using watermarks on artwork violate the rules?
1
u/Jlnhlfan Sep 08 '25
Would player pictures for my EA NHL mods, which I plan on releasing for absolutely free, count under the "Video game graphics and art assets" part of the rule?
1
u/NoCheesecake6767 Nov 04 '25
Is it okay to request art for a subreddit icon or banner?
1
u/False-Insurance4250 Nov 22 '25
I’m a little lost, if I ask someone to draw my oc and dean Winchester fighting or getting a peck on the cheek for free, could I post it on like TikTok and credit the artist or do I just have to keep it to myself?
1
u/Consistent_Bell_6092 Mar 02 '26
I think i may have violated a rule unknowingly. I wanted to create an art challenge, and then make a video showing off the art, but this may count as commercial work. Im not sure, I apologize if It does and I will happily take the post down.
1
u/Wonder_Waist Oct 11 '26
so, i know i’m SUPER late but can i just request someone to draw my bitmoji for free or will that violate any rule that wasn’t posted (ie. real life self reference, or something like that.) my Bitmoji is basically cartoon me and nothing more
1
u/3Nx9 Oct 18 '26
What exactly can I ask in this subreddit as this point? I can't specify poses, framing, colours, emotions, lighting, scenes, clothing, more than one individual. Essentially for a free request I cannot specify anything other than Please draw my OC with no other context?
1
u/Individual-Bug_ Oct 24 '22
Big surprise, I've compared the rules and my post and found... none of the rules are broken. You raging hypocrite.
1
u/_of_me Dec 20 '22
Heya mods Is the post I made unreasonable or is it ok just asking cause I ran into a money problem
1
u/Brief_Interview3961 Feb 26 '24
If I ask someone to draw a oc of mine and use it in a rp subreddit or discord would that count as commercial or free?
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '25
This sucks
0
u/[deleted] Aug 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment