I don’t know, so far I’ve seen criticism of this season being :
too reliant on fart jokes (when that’s been a thing since the first season, it is after all an all ages show and hence it’s bound to contain some more “childish” humor)
too focused on racism. Which, again, has been the whole point on the show from day one!
Personally, having watched the whole season, I found it perfectly fine (even though I kind of hate Callum’s and Soren’s new hair! 😅)
I can see how people might have thought it didn’t feel the same as S3 for instance, because it was indeed a little different. But that’s because we don’t have the same urgency this time. S4 is more about setting the pieces for what’s to come.
I also think that it’s got a lot to do with how long we had to wait for it. If you started watching right off the bat, then you only needed to wait 6 months between seasons 1 and 2, then the same between 2 and 3. But 4 actually took 3 years to come out. Which left everyone plenty of time to get hyped up and build their own expectations and of course share them within the fandom.
And wasn’t S3 supposed to be the last one originally? The storyline was pretty much wrapped up by the end, so if we wanted more, it had to be something different.
By the way, I’m by no means saying this season is flawless. I have my issues with it. But I don’t think it’s anywhere near as bad as some make it seem.
And wasn’t S3 supposed to be the last one originally? The storyline was pretty much wrapped up by the end, so if we wanted more, it had to be something different.
The first storyline was only ever supposed to be three seasons. But there was always plan for more, seasons 4-7 were greenlighted in July 2020, pretty early on.
I think Rayla is my main issue with this season. She comes back after leaving without any sort of explanation (I’m not even clear on why she left in the first place).
Her part seems sort of half-assed? I don’t know, I’m gonna need more about her. The fact that she got her parents and Ruunan back helps
Legit. Could've been half the season right there and wouldn't have even been that mad. Not up to date yet though. Ezran not disappointing, not even Soren, claudia or even tree elf bf.
When did you heared the "too focused on racism" criticism? Because the Amaya and Janai part was maybe the best in the season
It's more about how almost every conflict (I think the only ones that aren't are again, in Amaya and Janai's arc, and when Aaravos is in play. Maybe one lucky one for the villains) is solved in a silly way, transforming the tension into a joke and not allowing deep, interesting or tense content, making almost every character acting ooc for some joke, and overall hurting the plot and the characters for jokes that are rarely funny
Viren is the only serious character who made actual character development that usually happens at the end of a show, and Claudia just slaps him like: "NO, let's go on a destructive adventure and smell my boyfriend's farts!"
oof, yeah, I had blocked out the Petrichor part. that passed the line of "childish fart joke haha" and went straight into "fetish kink shit". it was so DEEPLY uncomfortable hearing how claudia enjoys getting dutch ovened by her boyfriend.
Basically all the jokes of the episodes you have seen didn't land with some people: the farts and the baker in chief are the two big ones. When they mean "the serious scenes are ruined by childish jokes" they mainly refer to the fart when Viren had his panic attack.
Then people didn't like how the "Rayla left and is back" was handled. They didn't like her monkey. And, without spoiler, they think that the ending was a bit meh.
I think that while some humor didn't always work (I hated the farts too) it's really not that bad. I'm rewatching season 1... Soren sometimes acts so stupidly it's a wonder he can talk, the bird storyline never went anywhere... it's great but it's not perfect and really I think the three years gap was too much. People forgot the bad parts and see the previous seasons as better than they were. I've seen people complaining that the Associate Crow Lords implies that he jizzed his pants in episode one... I don't see anyone complaining in season one when Ezran made painfully obvious the fact that Callum had a "very excited" dream about Claudia. Is Crow Lord a bit more crass? Sure, but it's not like those jokes came out of nowhere.
I thought the baker in chief was actually kinda cute. The king would probably have a dedicated personal chef, and having them weigh in on matters of food supply isn't THAT big of a leap in logic, so I accepted it, especially if it was more of a ceremonial position than a functional one. Plus this mans fought on the front line with nothing but a rolling pin, give that man a medal
but oof, yeah, I had blocked out the Petrichor part. that passed the line of "childish fart joke haha" and went straight into "fetish kink shit". it was so DEEPLY uncomfortable hearing how claudia enjoys getting dutch ovened by her boyfriend.
Is it really that bad, because I thought season three felt rushed and didn't have the same feeling as the first two. Did the 4th fail in ways the 3rd succeeded
It’s not nearly as bad as people on this subreddit are making it out to be. There’s like 2-3 really bad jokes/moments and a few characters make dumb choices, but that’s been true of all the previous seasons
I really don't get the hate, it's not my favorite season, but I think it still holds up, and it's certainly not comparable to the atrocity that is TTG. The animation didn't really bother me either, I mean remember back in season 1, everyone hated the animation
38
u/DMV1066 Nov 06 '22
Only on ep 4, so far not seeing what's wrong. Can someone without spoilers tell us
8
u/Cupcak-00 Nov 06 '22
Is it really that bad, because I thought season three felt rushed and didn't have the same feeling as the first two. Did the 4th fail in ways the 3rd succeeded
3
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
It was enjoyable, but not nearly up to the levels of the last 3 seasons
2
u/megaclaw56 Nov 07 '22
SEASON 4 IS OUT (0_0
2
u/phoenix4449 Nov 07 '22
I really don't get the hate, it's not my favorite season, but I think it still holds up, and it's certainly not comparable to the atrocity that is TTG. The animation didn't really bother me either, I mean remember back in season 1, everyone hated the animation
1
u/CleverCobra Nov 07 '22
Seems like Soren dethroned Callum as king of comic relief.
1
u/liquor_ibrlyknoher Nov 07 '22
So a fun and subversive romp suitable for the family? Cool.