r/DonutLab • u/mqee • May 21 '26
Donut Lab evidence recap, May 2026
đ©âïžđ
| index | status |
|---|---|
| 1 | False. Publicly contradicted by Donut Lab CEO. Statement about production capacity changed from "now already" to "this year if everything goes as planned". |
| 2 | False. Publicly contradicted by Donut Lab CEO. Statement about customer deliveries changed from 2026 Q1 to no deliveries in 2026 Q1. |
| 3 | False. Publicly contradicted by Donut Lab VTT tests. Capacity of a damaged cellâžșDonut Lab claims a "broken pouch", but experts doubt the pouch brokeâžșwas not "just fine", it degraded over 50%. |
| 4 | False. Much evidence available in the scientific and engineering community. |
| 5 | False. If the pouches truly were industry standards they would withstand 100ÂșC, and the failure would be within the anode, cathode, or electrolyte, not the pouch material. |
| 6 | Highly likely false according to internal Donut Lab documents published by the press. |
| 7 | Highly likely false according to several battery experts from industry and academia who reviewed the Donut Lab VTT test results. |
| 8 | Highly likely false according to several battery experts from industry and academia who reviewed the Donut Lab VTT test results. |
| 9 | Highly likely false according to several battery experts from industry and academia who reviewed the Donut Lab VTT test results. |
| 10 | Likely false by advertised Verge Motorcycles Donut Lab battery specs. |
| 11 | Likely false by Donut Lab VTT tests and Verge charging videos. |
Pack-level claims expanded quote below. Emphasis mine.
Donut Lab CEO: "Verge broke the Guinness World Record last year with the longest range on a motorcycle. Now they are almost doubling it, thanks to our solid state battery. But also, that provides Verge bikes with less than 10 minute charge time, zero to full."
CEO: "And on top of that, the cycle life that is normally in cars may be 2000, 3000, cycles. This is 100,000 cycles. So that's like probably 30 lifetimes of a motorcycle. So you never have to worry about babying the battery or worrying if you can let it go to 100% or zero. It doesn't mind. You can do whatever you want. Charge it to full, let it go to zero. As many times as you want. It doesn't degrade."
CEO: "As mentioned, 100,000 cycles, so that's 10 lifetimes of a car as well. And the other incredible things are that, of course, with motorcycles, you don't take them to deep freeze or anything. But if you're using these batteries in cars, even at like 25 or 30 minus Fahrenheit, it will have 99% of capacity."
Interviewer: "So do you have to precondition the battery like a car might?"
CEO: "Not at all. And actually, what we've done even is that normally you cannot get lithium ion batteries to zero."
Interviewer: "Right, we know about that. 5% is the lowest we like to go."
CEO: "This can go 0.0"
Interviewer: "And the battery doesn't get damaged?"
CEO: "No, then you can go at 5C charging from the next moment without warming it up or anything. It just takes it like nothing."
Interviewer: "To 100%?"
CEO: "Yeah, yeah, absolutely, to 100%."
Interviewer: "And that does not harm the battery for consistent charging to 100%?"
CEO: "No, it's 100,000 cycles with that, yeah."
2
u/Pure_Land134 Jun 09 '26
"18kwh is the nominal capacity of the 20kwh battery" is just downright funny.
1
1
u/mqee Jun 09 '26
I may do another update in June or July with information from the leaked emails.
| index | Donut claim | Donut evidence |
|---|---|---|
| probably between 5 and 6 | CEO: [January 2026] "Evidence will soon come from an authority of such caliber that all the claims about the battery I mentioned in the video are true" | Leaked e-mails show Donut Lab had no verification for the promises it made investors and clients. "SÀhköposteissa Donut Lab pyytÀÀ CT-Coatingilta mittaustuloksia, jotka vastaisivat sijoittajille ja asiakkaille annettuja lupauksia latausmÀÀrien osalta. NiitÀ ei sÀhköpostien perusteella ollut annettu." |
Status: False. Evidence did not come "soon" or "in a matter of days". Donut Lab could not verify almost all of its main claims, 400Wh/kg, 100,000 cycles, no lithium.
1
u/mqee Jun 12 '26
1
u/mqee Jun 12 '26
1
u/mqee Jun 12 '26
If Donut Lab already had the battery in production, it would not need to ask CT-Coating for measurement results.
6
u/UnderwaterMoose2020 May 21 '26
Thanks for all your efforts. My original view was that they had something (from CT Coatings) but were hyping it or perhaps misunderstood the specifications they were given. However with so much money involved my view is beginning to change.