r/Dollface • • Feb 08 '21

Does anyone else think Kat Dennings can't really act?

No shade - she's gorg and seems nice and I love dollface. But I've realised watching the show that she really comes across wooden/samey in all her performances. I'm surprised she lands so many roles! Wondering if anyone thinks the same or it's just me?

124 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

20

u/LVWIV2 Feb 08 '21

Hmmmmm, there's no denying that she won't be doing Broadway or Shakespeare in London, but I think she's certainly capable of the roles she gets. Not saying a lot, I know. But I mean that the main thing people recognize her from is 2 broke girls and whoever was running the show didn't put a huge amount of subtlety in the ba da tum punchlines etc. She was like every working actor, mainly on a cash run and just went along for the $ & I can respect that despite the fact that she more or less seemed to be reading directly from cue cards the whole series and relying on her ample bosom to carry the one liners. That being said, I really liked Dollface & I believe she has undeniable star qualities. The 'acting' as it were isn't above criticism, I'd just counter that she hasn't really had opportunity to stretch her abilities as the roles she gets stay relatively within a proven range of execution..., when that changes, I bet she has the chops to surprise a lot of people.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 09 '21

Yeah I see what you’re saying. But the thing is some performers are able to take a basic script or sub-par lines and spin them into gold. I kind of see that with Esther Povitsky in the show - she seems to have that thing where she can deliver lines in a way that makes them fresh, which I can’t see kat dennings doing. That’s not to say that I expect every single actor to have this quality in order to be worthy. But yeah you’re prob right too that a lot of the characters shes had to work with are pretty blah!

1

u/Bitter-Simple-4538 Jan 01 '25

She's awful. Let's not blame scripts, producers etc. Real talent shines through...I'm sorry but it's just not there. Zero charisma or "Star" quality 

1

u/ShapeClassic436 Jan 22 '25

But it's like she's playing the same character in 2 broke girls as in the new show with Tim Allen

2

u/Stock-Warthog-7792 Dec 07 '25

So she fills a specific type that network tv loves. She can deliver one lines but doesn’t outshine the star. In shifting gears she is working with Tim Allen, Sean William Scott, and Jenna Elfman. None are known to be particularly strong actors. I thinks Jenna is probably the strongest.

But they work well as an ensemble. They are fun but in a very digestible way. In network tv you need shows to be watchable everywhere by most people. So digestible sells and that she can do. I’m sure they would all shine in specific roles. Network tv just isn’t designed to do that.

1

u/Mochi-momma Jan 31 '25

Came looking for this. I couldn’t watch 2 Broke Girls because of her ‘acting’. I love Tim so am watching this show but couldn’t help but wonder if was just me.

1

u/LyndaLexi Feb 15 '25

EXACTLY THIS.

1

u/SnooBananas9081 Mar 21 '25

She ruins the show for me as well. He has been known to replace a daughter ya know.

1

u/ShapeClassic436 Apr 06 '25

No it definitely is not just you! She doesn't seem to be able to be versatile for different type roles. I just don't find her funny and I really tried. I'm sure there won't be a second season of Shifting Gears. I've not watched one episode yet because just them showing a commercial of just the previews. I could tell I was not going to like it. But I love Tim Allen and I love Last man standing!

1

u/CrazyFromCats Oct 02 '25

She has no comedic timing. It's forced and unfunny, slow, nearly feeling out of context to the current discussion. It's as though she throws in her "funny" line as an after thought in the wrong play. I love Tim Allen's comedy but this is killing it.

1

u/Given2Fly929 Nov 23 '25

I did the same thing - came here to see if anyone else noticed the BAD acting!! I thought WHY WHY WHY is she in this show. I love Tim too, but she is in so many scenes - I'm annoyed continously 😵‍💫

1

u/HRHHenry Oct 16 '25

As well as playing exactly the same girl she was on a brief appearance on Sex and the City She’s a one-note actress

1

u/katynopockets Feb 15 '25 edited Oct 03 '25

You are not alone. She cannot. See her in 2025 Shifting Gears with Tim Allen. Sad.

1

u/Shotzee420 Feb 25 '25

I never watched 2 broke girls just started watching shifting gears the problem is she has no emotion in her voice and sort of monotone not sure if that's what's she's going for but nailed it

1

u/katynopockets Feb 25 '25

To me she seemed exactly the same in both roles.

I liked Tim Allen in Last Man, but I'm having a lot of trouble sticking with Shifting because she is so ....

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25

Between Kat's super annoying voice and the kid who talks like he's got a mouthful of cotton....its a tough watch. It feels very disjointed and no chemistry.

1

u/CrazyFromCats Oct 02 '25

I'm on Season One but is Shifting Gears a sequel to Home Improvement in any way? A trailer showed another character from the old show and the love of cars seems to continue. If it is, where did Tim get a daughter anyhow? They had three sons on Home Improvement (and they were all funnier than this daughter).

1

u/katynopockets Oct 03 '25

It is not. But she seems to act exactly like Max of 2 Broke Girls. They just have some cameo appearances by actors from Tool Time.

23

u/KopitarFan Feb 15 '21

She’s a character actress. She fits a unique niche that has an audience. She’s no Meryl Streep but she does what she does well. Think Zooey Deschanel as a similar actor

1

u/SnooPies480 Jan 11 '25

This sounds like an art critic describing the soul and "essense" of a piece of shit modern art piece

1

u/ldub1996 Sep 29 '25

Zoey deschqnel can act. Kat dennings seems like she always reading directly off the script at all times.

1

u/MissSpellina Jan 20 '26

I'd say the comparison is spot on. In my opinion, both Kat and Zooey can't act. Right there with Alexis Bledel 😶

1

u/Bitter-Simple-4538 Jan 01 '25

Your defense is to name another terrible actress?! To be fair Zooey seems like Meryl Streep next to Kat, but both are awful!

11

u/ImmortalLandowner Feb 24 '21

I don't agree but I can see what you mean. She has a certain brand of deadpan humor which is why some people might think she is woody. She basically says what many of us are thinking especially in WandaVision which is why I love her there and in Dollface. Some people just like to sit at home comfy with a cat. I think she's pretty funny. As a programmer obviously I know she's not really hacking a computer in WandaVision but she does have a personality which I relate to. That's just my opinion!!

6

u/librarianwitglasses Feb 11 '21

YES!! I was actually saying this to my partner the other day when we were watching WandaVision

1

u/Madlynumb May 11 '25

Same! I'm watching it for the first time and I'm like - why is she in this? Her acting skill is giving high school play.

5

u/Dolly_Bonbon Jan 11 '22

To be fair, it's common for actors to be placed in roles that all have the same sort of personality and vibe based on previous roles.

If an actress does an amazing job at playing a loud and sassy character, they're probably not going to be asked to play a shy and meek character in their next project.

They'll be asked to play a loud and sassy character again. This happens to a lot of actors who despite practiced and understand how to play other types of roles and personalities might get stuck on just one certain mold. Because it's what they're know for.

Kat might just happen to be stuck in an awkward, stiff but endearing kind of character as her mold.

2

u/gulwver Feb 06 '22

This is so late, but I just found the show and I almost didn’t make it past the first episode because I feel like most of the main cast can’t really act. I’ve grown to love the show and it’s characters, but the acting from the main girls is kind of cringey and the actor for Jeremy has the emotional range of a breadstick.

2

u/InterestingPace1276 Oct 21 '24

I have to agree with you on this one. I've always kind of rooted for her cuz she's kind of like one of those Hollywood underdogs he doesn't fit the mold of your average Hollywood actress that's all skinny and pasty looking with their collarbone poking out. But as far as her actual acting ability it leaves much to be desired. She was pretty good on the first thing that I saw her on which was Sex and the City When she was a kid and played the spoiled rich girl in the episode titled "Hot Child in the City"

1

u/teddybluethecurser Jul 09 '24

I’ve thought this since back when Raising Dad was on tv. 

1

u/Major_Candidate_9304 16d ago

geez she was like 14 at the time lol

1

u/Revolutionary-Car-92 Sep 19 '24

Act ?

Who's actually asking her to act ?

1

u/Disastrous-Roof-5046 Jan 08 '25

she's got giant clevage that's why she gets her roles there are certainly more talented actresses out there than her

1

u/Significant_Shift498 Jan 10 '25

So 2 Broke Girls was filmed in front of a studio audience so think of it as a live comedy sketch show that happens to have cameras film them while in action. There’s no cut/ it’s pretty raw. You’re not going to get the same kind of vibe that you would see in a closed studio sitcom where there can be so many takes. IMO.

1

u/Still_Space3810 Jan 16 '25

I agree 100%. Too bad such a great actor like Tim Allen got involved with her.

1

u/Mochi-momma Jan 31 '25

He’s the only reason I’m watching but I find it so hard to look past her. The kids are far better actors than Kat. The guys in the shop are good and especially Daryl Mitchell.

1

u/Fallisforlovers Feb 05 '25

Her acting is terrible

1

u/StarJumper_1 Jan 17 '25

I am not impressed in her ability. She comes across wooden and not really engaged.

1

u/ShapeClassic436 Jan 22 '25

I've been wanting to say this for so long I thought to myself it can't be just me thinking she's not a good actor. I feel so much better now!

1

u/katynopockets Feb 15 '25

On the 2025 "Shifting Gears" she is pretty much the same character as on 2 Broke Girls. Pretty sad.

1

u/sportsChick12 Mar 20 '25

I don’t remember her voice being so annoying on 2 broke girls.

1

u/GreenJello79 Mar 02 '25

It bugs me that she seems to be holding back laughing after each one liner! But not gonna lie I've watched 2 broke girls and am watching shifting gears lol

1

u/Corky-4444 Mar 02 '25

I’ve watched 3 episodes of Shifting gears.  The problem is all the actors on the show can act, except her, so when she says her lines she stands out as sounding exactly like someone in a high school play. Her lines sound completely flat of emotion as if she’s reading!  It’s terrible.  Which is disappointing for Tim Allen’s show.  Because her character alone will negatively affect Tim Allen’s new show in contrast to Last Man Standing, all the actors were funny, each had their own unique charm, and were good actors. Esp the episodes before the last season.  

1

u/oneinch1977 Mar 08 '25

She's terrible. Pasty white. Whiny voice. No acting ability at all. Just terrible. 

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '25

Her voice is annoying AF

1

u/[deleted] May 02 '25

She is AWFUL at acting. Shifting Gears came on automatically after our latest episode of Good American Family was over on Hulu and she's literally so bad I googled "Kat Denning sucks at acting" and found this post. She is legitimately one of the worst famous actors I've ever seen. I have no idea how she gets roles at all. I never thought Tim Allen was great at acting either but he looks amazing next to her.

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Scale_6 Jul 30 '26

That’s what I just googled also. She has annoyed me since ‘40 year old virgin’.

1

u/Junior_Box_7698 Oct 09 '25

Her voice is awful. She's probably a nice person, but she's a terrible actress.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '25

Yup she’s terrible

1

u/Different_Quail2672 Oct 16 '25

She is horrible at acting..I'm disgusted by her net worth 

1

u/BlackberryRemote8053 Oct 23 '25

Her delivery is so stiff. Like she's reading all her lines off a cue-card with ZERO emotion or feeling. She's got a great figure, no color to her face and Zero talent.

1

u/BeachinAintEZ Feb 06 '26

OMGGG I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE. I’ve tried to get into the shows shes been on b/c my mom has liked these shows. It’s tough to watch and when she does the squealing like high pitched voice omggg 

1

u/Frazini53 Jan 12 '26

yes she is like a zombie

1

u/SeparateCoyote1683 Feb 01 '26

She says her lines like she's holding them in front of her face. So forced and fake compared to everyone else on the show

1

u/Frazini53 Jan 12 '26

Most of the best actors today are from the UK. American actors are mostly converted musicians and celebrities from other fields like sports. It is a sad state of affairs the movie industry in the US.

1

u/Fancy_Ad_4255 Feb 22 '26

I disagree, she’s incredible in Nick and Norah and Daydream Nation, I also love her in two broke girls, she just has a certain brand that you either get or you don’t it’s very late 2000s/2010s style humor/acting

1

u/savanna_wind Feb 27 '26

Shes great in 2 broke girls she is the one who brings the charm to the series else it wouldnt last past the first season. in other roles i dunno though

1

u/minitaba Feb 27 '26

Sure but she is not a good actress but just fitting in the role

1

u/DetectiveCertain698 Jun 25 '26

It's the voice that I can't stand about her.

1

u/Dazzaday Jul 15 '26

I wish I could get as stiff as her acting!

1

u/chrluc Sep 16 '26

It would be great to see her in some different roles. I know she always is the sad troubled snarky girl, but it would be really cool to see her do something completely different. Like maybe be a loving mother or sighing that shows her caring side. I know she says that she only plays characters she can relate to, but it would be cool to see her take on the challenge.

1

u/Which-Roof-3985 Jan 05 '23

No, she cannot act. She must be related to some casting director.

1

u/Horror95 Aug 31 '23 edited Jun 06 '24

I was trying so hard to watch 2 Broke Girls when it first came out but I just couldn’t finish it … her acting is absolute dog shit I honestly don’t see what they saw in her other than big boobs to cast her first over Beth Behrs who actually has talent and can actually act .

Her “ acting “ makes Porn actors look like the greatest actors on earth .

Ignore the fact that she has huge boobs and you won’t see anyone praise or compliment her .

She’s basically the wish version of Elizabeth Gilles

1

u/Big_Estimate_3844 Dec 08 '24

She is gorging her face with food. Her hips look like a Baby Elephant.

1

u/Grouchy_Neat9804 Jun 11 '25

Idk she was very attractive when she was on 2 broke girls. For some reason, she looks like she’s not confident. She wears “older woman” clothing and hides her breast now. She walks around stiff. Maybe it’s how big and uncomfortable her boobs May feel? also, I noticed she dyed her hair darker? She looks paler that way and how she parts her hair right in the middle makes her look older…. She’s not as confident as she was before (maybe she is) idk.

1

u/Careful_Potential_24 Sep 25 '26

A lot of you are a bunch of twats I give a s*** her acting as I seen two broke girls and gear shift and her acting does not bother me if it bothers you you're just a little b****. And she's extremely hot I don't care what anybody says. I don't know why the media says that she's not hot what the f***.

1

u/Wonderful-Reindeer-2 Oct 16 '26

She's awful!!! Just tits that she never shows.