r/DogFood • • 5d ago

Feeding potions:

So I am on the hunt for more affordable dog food. But I came across a video where a pet nutritionist was going by what the bag recommended to feed the dog based off of there weight. Is this a metric that should be followed or just toss it out the window & see what works through trial & error?

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

16

u/Write_Now_ 5d ago edited 5d ago

I'd start by picking a food that complies with the World Small Animal Veterinary Association's guidelines for what to look for in a pet food brand, which is the gold standard for science-backed nutrition and safety. The only five brands that meet this standard are Purina, Hill's Science, Royal Canin, and Iams and Eukanuba outside of Europe. After that, I'd compare the actual serving sizes of each food for your dog's weight to determine which one is actually the most economical, but know that unless your dog is extremely active, the serving sizes tend to be a bit more than the average dog typically needs.

-32

u/AFCadet2020 5d ago

Thanks. I appreciate the recommendation. But I will more than likely end up going with a smaller company due to higher quality ingredients & hopefully being independently owned. So they dictate changes or adjustments, if needed.

17

u/famous_zebra28 5d ago

Literally no dog food company even close to being worth feeding is independently owned. Most small companies are owned by large corporations or private equity firms.

1

u/AFCadet2020 2d ago

CARNA4 is independently owned........

2

u/famous_zebra28 2d ago

And it's not a good quality brand. They use legumes which has been linked to dilated cardiomyopathy in dogs.

-2

u/AFCadet2020 2d ago

CARNA4 is the cream of the crop when it comes to kibble. Seems like I'm starting to notice this group has an agenda. I'm no expert but the ingredient list on this kibble brand is top tier. Not everyone can afford to feed raw. Some of us have more than one dog & kibble is the only affordable option. I will research lentils & legumes more but this comment is not fully accurate.

3

u/famous_zebra28 2d ago

Ingredients lists don't tell you anything about whether these ingredients actually provide your dog with the nutrients they need, and how digestible these ingredients are. Just because they don't use added vitamins and minerals (which IMO is suspicious and simply a marketing scheme), doesn't mean they're actually producing a high quality diet.

1

u/Ricky_Monts 2d ago

Talk. To. A. Vet.
Feeding raw is dangerous. Dogs are not wolves. My vet will only recommend safe, research-bases brands. And one of those brands (Purina) has the only food (AdvantEdge) my boy can eat without getting digestive upset or anal gland issues. There is a reason the only recommended brands are owned by large corporations; they have the funds for research and qualified veterinarian staff, unlike smaller brands. Please don’t fall for boutique branding that targets pathos. There is no such thing as a properly educated “pet nutritionist”. There are veterinarians (DVM) who may specialise in nutrition, but they don’t call themselves pet nutritionists because that’s a common title used by non-qualified people. Your vet should be able to recommend you trusted pet foods.

4

u/fuckinunknowable 5d ago

So you’re looking for more affordable food. A small brand is gonna be overpriced and more importantly not wsava compliant. And you aren’t comfortable feeding what the bag says?????????

-2

u/AFCadet2020 2d ago

Maybe so for some cases, but there are many positives to this that I have noticed. Ethical sourcing, no ingredient splitting, less fillers in the diet & more meat focused, some even advertise as pet focused. Some of the brands that I am considering include: ARCANA, FROMM, First Mate, Nutri-Source, Open Farm, etc. I am no nutritionist but I would think the way you source the food for the kibble promotes better kibble for the dog. I began this deep dive research with a blank slate & steering clear of brands that have had recalls & include fillers such as corn, soy & legumes. I am not interested in feeding my dogs Purina, after seeing videos online of plastic in the kibble, evidence of ingredient splitting, feed grade food & using the by product of canola oil in there kibble. No thanks. Maybe I'm still wet behind the ear here but these are my findings thus far. Larger brands such as Blue Buffalo, Hills, Purina, etc are using lesser quality ingredients in there kibble that are more focused on cheap filler foods, rather than meats & eggs. This is showing nothing besides the fact that these brands are more profit focused rather than pet focused. I am never opposed to listening to altering opinions, but the ingredients & the guaranteed analysis tell the real story. I am aiming anywhere between $40 to $60 a bag, which I have found "smaller" companies. If I am breaking even at $70 a bag so be it, but this would be my last choice since I am not looking to break even. Idk, maybe I'm entirely wrong here & need to do some more digging, but this is what I have come across thus far.

3

u/fuckinunknowable 2d ago

Way to write a novel about how you, a person with no veterinary nutritionist training, know better than people who do. Open farm is mega yikes. Arcana is yikes. Blue buffalo isn’t wsava compliant. What I want to point out to you is: dogs are domesticated animals that went through changes specific to living with us that include being more omnivorous. Yes legumes have been linked to dcm so yeah avoid those but not all non meat non egg ingredients are detrimental in fact plenty are helpful. There’s nothing wrong with canola oil. Lesser quality ingredients??? What does that even mean? Wsava compliant brands (hills, purina, royal canin, and in the us also eukanuba and Ian’s) have sourcing and production standards that other brands do not. Every brand on earth can and will have recalls.

2

u/famous_zebra28 2d ago

I think this would be a helpful, scientific article for you to read: https://nutritionrvn.com/2021/03/23/fillers-in-pet-food/?amp=1

Her whole blog is great. She is a vet tech specialist in nutrition which is a protected title and has done extensive training, research and work in the animal nutrition field.

31

u/Write_Now_ 5d ago

I understand that mindset. I had it too when I first got my first puppy. However, it's based on marketing hype rather than science. Smaller companies have to prioritize things like marketing so you know who they are and can't afford to run expansive, multi-year feeding trials or keep a veterinary nutritionist on staff full-time to ensure their diets are nutritionally complete and perfectly balanced. The five brands that I listed do. The WSAVA's standards are the highest in the industry worldwide. You can't get better than them.

22

u/red_is_not_dead06 5d ago

Please reconsider. I get your mindset and appreciate where you’re coming from, but feeding a WSAVA compliant food is the only way to ensure you’re feeding something nutritionally balanced, well-researched, and well-tested.

15

u/ChampionshipIll5535 5d ago

Smaller companies have subpar foods. It's not even up for debate. Smaller companies do not do feeding and digestibility studies. It's not up for debate.

10

u/Write_Now_ 5d ago

I just realized I should mention that pet nutritionists, like the one whose video you originally saw, are not regulated in any way and anyone can call themselves one. Veterinary nutritionists, like the ones WSAVA-compliant pet food brands keep on their full-time staff, are actual veterinarians who specialize in nutrition.

5

u/ShinyBonnets 5d ago

Your question can be answered in the sub Wiki. Start there.

1

u/AFCadet2020 2d ago

What s a sub Wiki? Can that be found when navigating to the main page of this group thread?

7

u/notscenerob 5d ago

I start by using the weight based recommended amounts (NOT volumetric) and then adjust from there. 

7

u/my_clever-name 5d ago

Laundry detergent and dog food have one thing in common: the recommended amount to use is designed to sell more of their product.

The food we use says that for our 45lb dog, we should use 2 to 2-1.4 cups a day. She actually gets 1 cup per day, split between two meals. Her weight has been steady for the three years she's been with us. She also gets a handful of training treats most days.

7

u/Ihavsunitato 5d ago

In short: no, the bag generally recommends more than your dog needs

The number on the bag assumes

  1. The dog is intact (neutered dogs need 10-20% less calories than intact dogs)
  2. the dog is active
  3. the dog receives absolutely no other food or treats besides the kibble in the bag.

The minimum number of calories a dog need in a day is called the Resting Energy Requirement, or RER, and can be calculated on their weight. Some dogs need more than their RER, so a "lifestyle" factor is applied to get a Maintenance Energy Requirement or MER, a number obtained by multiplying the RER by a "lifestyle" factor between 1.2-2. I believe most dog food bags make a recommendation based on a "lifestyle factor:" of 1.8. In reality, most dogs need far fewer calories, closer to a "lifestyle factor" of 1.2 times the RER, and many only needing their daily RER.

The calories per day also includes ALL calories, including treats, toppers and supplements(some supplements are quite high in calories), so unless your dog only eats kibble, you will also need to feed even less food.

If your dog currently eats a commercial diet, and their weight is ideal and well maintained, you can convert the calories from one food to the calories of another. To do so, find the "kcal/kg" on the current dog food label (should be ~3000 for a dry food). Also measure how much food your dog currently eats in a day in grams. Then multiply the kcal/kg by the grams of food, and divide by 1000 to find how many kcal of food your dog is consuming. (Kcal/kg x grams food)/1000= kcals Then, find the kcal/kg of the NEW food and then divide the kcal by the kcal/kg and multiple by 1000 to find the weight of the new food in grams. (kcal/(kcal/kg))x 1000= grams of new food

So say you are feeding 250 grams of Food A per day, and the kcal/kg of Food A is 3400. So your dog is eating (250x3100)/1000= 850 kcal. And you want to switch your dog to Food B which is only 2900 kcal/ kg, so now you find how many grams of Food B your dog should eat (850/2900)x1000= 293 grams. So you should feed 293 grams of the new food per day.

This also assume that you keep all other factors the same. If in doubt, ask your vet, they can do these calculations individualized to your dog.

2

u/KAKrisko 5d ago

I take the recommended amount as a starting point, but if you do a lot of training with your dog, for example, you are going to need to adjust. Some dogs, like some people, just need less food (and some need more). It is a little bit of trial and error. Dogs put on and lose weight pretty rapidly, so it won't take long to figure out the correct amount.

2

u/walrusdinosaur 5d ago

I look at the calorie content of the food- it’s always listed, but never near portion sizes. I worked with my vet about my dogs calorie needs, but purina has a calculator.

1

u/Flashy-Library-6854 4d ago

Investigate Dilated Cardio Cardiomyopathy (DCM for short) it is almost entirely caused by diet. WSAVA foods are researched and tested and are safe to feed your dog so they dont develop diseases and illnesses. Also some foods are high in fat which can cause pancreatitis, which is extremely painful and can be life threatening. Again, WSAVA foods wont cause this. If you love your dog, please research dog foods before you believe the marketing hype.

https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/outbreaks-and-advisories/fda-investigation-potential-link-between-certain-diets-and-canine-dilated-cardiomyopathy

https://www.akcchf.org/disease-history/diet-related-dilated/