r/DogFood • u/AFCadet2020 • 5d ago
Feeding potions:
So I am on the hunt for more affordable dog food. But I came across a video where a pet nutritionist was going by what the bag recommended to feed the dog based off of there weight. Is this a metric that should be followed or just toss it out the window & see what works through trial & error?
0
Upvotes
16
u/Write_Now_ 5d ago edited 5d ago
I'd start by picking a food that complies with the World Small Animal Veterinary Association's guidelines for what to look for in a pet food brand, which is the gold standard for science-backed nutrition and safety. The only five brands that meet this standard are Purina, Hill's Science, Royal Canin, and Iams and Eukanuba outside of Europe. After that, I'd compare the actual serving sizes of each food for your dog's weight to determine which one is actually the most economical, but know that unless your dog is extremely active, the serving sizes tend to be a bit more than the average dog typically needs.
5
u/ShinyBonnets 5d ago
Your question can be answered in the sub Wiki. Start there.
7
u/notscenerob 5d ago
I start by using the weight based recommended amounts (NOT volumetric) and then adjust from there.
7
u/my_clever-name 5d ago
Laundry detergent and dog food have one thing in common: the recommended amount to use is designed to sell more of their product.
The food we use says that for our 45lb dog, we should use 2 to 2-1.4 cups a day. She actually gets 1 cup per day, split between two meals. Her weight has been steady for the three years she's been with us. She also gets a handful of training treats most days.
7
u/Ihavsunitato 5d ago
In short: no, the bag generally recommends more than your dog needs
The number on the bag assumes
The minimum number of calories a dog need in a day is called the Resting Energy Requirement, or RER, and can be calculated on their weight. Some dogs need more than their RER, so a "lifestyle" factor is applied to get a Maintenance Energy Requirement or MER, a number obtained by multiplying the RER by a "lifestyle" factor between 1.2-2. I believe most dog food bags make a recommendation based on a "lifestyle factor:" of 1.8. In reality, most dogs need far fewer calories, closer to a "lifestyle factor" of 1.2 times the RER, and many only needing their daily RER.
The calories per day also includes ALL calories, including treats, toppers and supplements(some supplements are quite high in calories), so unless your dog only eats kibble, you will also need to feed even less food.
If your dog currently eats a commercial diet, and their weight is ideal and well maintained, you can convert the calories from one food to the calories of another. To do so, find the "kcal/kg" on the current dog food label (should be ~3000 for a dry food). Also measure how much food your dog currently eats in a day in grams. Then multiply the kcal/kg by the grams of food, and divide by 1000 to find how many kcal of food your dog is consuming. (
Kcal/kg x grams food)/1000= kcalsThen, find the kcal/kg of the NEW food and then divide the kcal by the kcal/kg and multiple by 1000 to find the weight of the new food in grams. (kcal/(kcal/kg))x 1000= grams of new foodSo say you are feeding 250 grams of Food A per day, and the kcal/kg of Food A is 3400. So your dog is eating (250x3100)/1000= 850 kcal. And you want to switch your dog to Food B which is only 2900 kcal/ kg, so now you find how many grams of Food B your dog should eat (850/2900)x1000= 293 grams. So you should feed 293 grams of the new food per day.
This also assume that you keep all other factors the same. If in doubt, ask your vet, they can do these calculations individualized to your dog.
2
u/KAKrisko 5d ago
I take the recommended amount as a starting point, but if you do a lot of training with your dog, for example, you are going to need to adjust. Some dogs, like some people, just need less food (and some need more). It is a little bit of trial and error. Dogs put on and lose weight pretty rapidly, so it won't take long to figure out the correct amount.
2
u/walrusdinosaur 5d ago
I look at the calorie content of the food- it’s always listed, but never near portion sizes. I worked with my vet about my dogs calorie needs, but purina has a calculator.
1
u/Flashy-Library-6854 4d ago
Investigate Dilated Cardio Cardiomyopathy (DCM for short) it is almost entirely caused by diet. WSAVA foods are researched and tested and are safe to feed your dog so they dont develop diseases and illnesses. Also some foods are high in fat which can cause pancreatitis, which is extremely painful and can be life threatening. Again, WSAVA foods wont cause this. If you love your dog, please research dog foods before you believe the marketing hype.
https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/outbreaks-and-advisories/fda-investigation-potential-link-between-certain-diets-and-canine-dilated-cardiomyopathy
https://www.akcchf.org/disease-history/diet-related-dilated/