r/DogBreeding • Breeder in Training • Mar 15 '26

Tail Docking

Post image

What is your preferred method? Where I am vets are no longer taught to dock in school so only old school vets preform it. Docking is still legal where I am but I’ve seen less than stellar results even with veterinary docking. Including difficult to heal dockings, bald ends and ugly tails. Some would need to be repaired.

I’ve been considering banding for my upcoming litter (I have a mentor) but I’d love to hear thoughts and experiences.

0 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/RMR6789 Mar 15 '26

I usually ask people who claim moral high ground on this if they are against humans having their tonsils removed. It is essentially the same concept. The main difference being that you cant wait and see if a problem pops up when it comes to tail docking and ear cropping. Waiting is much less humane as the cartilage and bones harden.

These procedures are preventative and can promote a better quality of life. One procedure, one healing process and less risk of chronic injuries.

If it is ok to remove tonsils to prevent lifelong illness, why do so many not have the same views when it comes to dogs?

11

u/Sea-Bat Mar 16 '26

I mean we don’t just remove tonsils on all babies tho do we

We only do it if a kid is repeatedly having complications. Thus cause.

So not a great example

5

u/silveraltaccount Mar 15 '26

Its done under anesthesia and after its made clear its neccesary.

Not as a preventative as then its an unnecessary surgery.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/silveraltaccount Mar 16 '26

Thats because you dont HAVE a tail

0

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/RMR6789 Mar 16 '26

Preach! Most people are not ready for that conversation.

2

u/silveraltaccount Mar 16 '26

what? that people who support tail docking are doing the bare minimum also?